Astrology and Uncertainty

[Guest guest]

|| Sri Ramajayam ||

 

Respected Mr. Bharat,

 

I totally agree with what you have said in the

appended mail.

 

If Mr.Mohan Jyotishi can give us 3 instances of where

astrology has failed, there are so many instances (in

this group as well) where astrology has been

successful and effective in warding off dangers by

giving proper remedial steps/actions. The great Varaha

Mihira (who was quoted by Mr Jyotishi in one of his

mails) was able to very accurately predict the death

of Vikramaditya's son. Like this, there are so many

places where astrology has been successful.

 

My belief is every action/result depends on free will

and predestiny. Astrology gives us an indication of

the predestiny. There is always a free will which

ultimately determines the result; astrology is a

science which makes us aware of the predestiny and

teaches us how to exercise our free will to achieve

success in all endeavours.

 

As per the popular sloka "Phalani graha charane...",

astrology gives us only an indication of what is

expected to happen; who else but the creator, can say

with certainty, what will happen!! So that is the very

spirit of Vedic Hindu Astrology which needs to be

borne in mind before reading or giving predictions.

 

There is an unavoidable uncertainty in any

science/profession and astrology is no exception. As

you have mentioned in your mail, at times doctors make

wrong judgements and that doesn't mean practise of

medicine should be condemned.

 

So I do not think people should bring the science to

disrepute just on the basis of a few cases where it

has failed.

 

Regards,

Vijayanand.

 

---------------------

 

Namaskaar Sri Mohan

 

"If someone calls himself a Vedic Hindu and knows the

Vedas actually, he would certainly not to

predictive astrology since there are no Rasis in the

Vedas nor in the Vedanga Jyotisha or Atharva Jyotihs

nor Paitamaha sidhanta or Paulisha or Romaka Sidhanta

either! If in spite of such facts some one insists to

call himself or herself a "Vedic astrologer" it means

that he/she does not know even ABC of the Vedas!"

 

Your facts and fictions are limited by so many

assumptions that it is

simply

futile to discuss anything with you. Again, who are

you to pass a

judgment

whether or not someone has understanding of the Veda

or not? Are you

the

dwaarpal of what is Vedic and what is not. I certainly

can't discuss

matters

with people who "think from their knees".

 

1. Dr. B. V. Raman, supposed to be the "Greatest

Vedic

astrologer of the Twentieth century" had planned

astrolo8ically to deliver a lecture on "Astrology as

an aid to Medical Sciences" at Hyderabad on January 2,

1999. However, he passed away on December 20, 1998,

fourteen days prior to delivering the "astroligically

planned lecture".

 

By making this statment you have proven that you know

nothing about

astrology or about the man or about both.

 

2. Kunji Lal, the by-now-famous Jyotishis of Betul

had

planned astrologically to shed of his mortal coil on

October 18, 2005, and it had been "okayed" by a doyen

among "Vedic astrolgers" viz. Mr. K. N. Rao! All that

happened was that it gained some more bad publicity

for the already infamous "Vedic astrology".

 

Good for your "cause"!

 

 

3.Poor BJP had preponed last General Elections by

several months on the "sane advice" of "Minsters of

Vedic astrology". The result was that it had to

vaccate the seats of power before time, thanks to

"Vedic astrology" and "Vedic astrologers".

 

Oh! So they would have won, if Sh Mohan Jyotishi would

have been

consulted.

 

Three instances, which we have no proof of being true

or false, have

been

given to prove that the entire gambit of Vedic

Astrology is false. As

per

your absolutely useless logic, all doctors should be

banned from

practising

medicine :

 

1. As some make wrong judgments which seldom results

in death.

2. As some advise to others that many a times causes

more complications

3. They cannot save themselves from death!!

 

Prabhu, if I discuss anything further with you, I

would be foolish.

 

Thanks and Regards

Bharat

 

 

 

 

________

Enjoy this Diwali with Y! India Click here

http://in.promos./fabmall/index.html