7th and 10th lord in 9th(confusion !!)

[Guest guest]

Dear RK Dash ji and other learned Guru

 

Your analysis below is detailed but has left me confused as to

whether Guru will truly be benefic or malefic. would appreciate if

greater light can be throw on the behaviour of Guru, given that it is

the owner of 7th and 10th placed in 9th and suffers from

Kendradipathi dosha . Also the fact that it is retrograde does it

have any impact

 

Thanks and Regards

Vivek

 

 

 

vedic astrology, "arkaydash" <arkaydash

wrote:

>

> Hi Vivek,

>

> There can't be a better placement for Ju, given the lordship. To my

> mind, this scores over Pisces placement of the planet.

>

> No planet fails to benfit from this hse, namely the 9th. But I

> reckon, no other planet could have benefited by way of tenacy here

as

> much as Ju does. You know it. First, Ju aspects lagna, the

summation

> of everything, and the final phaladatru linkage of the

> dharmakarmaadhipati yoga. In this chart it aspects (providing the

orb

> of influence applies) the dharmadhipati. The dharmakarmadhipati

yoga

> is not the smabandha of exchange, but ekaitara smbandha. In this

> chart even a tad more than ekaitara, because it aspects Sat (9th

> lord) and Sat aspects 10th. In this chart this yoga is very close

to

> the dharmakarmadhipati yoga of the first order. He aspects 5th hse,

> the seat of 'dhee', the mirror hse of 9th. Being at a slant, he

(this

> 10th lord) would not like obstreperous power. But the authority and

> respectability of a finer kind.

>

> In short, the lord of the mightiest kendra in mightiest kona. Add

to

> that Ju's magnitude and his benefic-ness.

>

> But, Vivek, this throws up the classic case of quandary as we chase

> logic. Is he not generating the strongest of kendradhipati dosha?

Is

> he not the 7th lord? And then, you have karakobhavanashaya, the

> significator spoiling the hse, the 9th. And how about this? Is he

not

> 12th from 9th?

>

> Where our mettle as astrologists (I am not an astrolger, who of

> course has the benefit of testing his tools, the givens)is tested.

>

> Shree Sreenadh, are you reading, sir?

>

> How about tiering the rules (the 9th-ness from lagna overrides the

> 12th-ness from 10th)?

>

> Now the sign, Aq. I read an online article which weaves a nice

li'l

> theory of why planets attain exaltation where they do. It argued,

as

> in Capricorn, the servant (Sat) quarters, Ju in Aquarius is in

> detriment. Varahmihira's words about Cancer-like status to Aq

w.r.t.

> Ju came to my mind. How is Ju placed in the sign Aq? Is it in fall

or

> is exalted (near-exalted)?

>

> Can we agree on one of these views re sign, eg, and unequivocally?

>

> Best,

> RK Dash

>

> vedic astrology, "vivekn74" <vivekn74@>

> wrote:

> >

> > Hi

> >

> > Can you please tell me the impact of 7th and 10th lord in 9th.

More

> > specifically for Gemini Ascendent where 7th and 10th lord is

Guru.

> > What happens if the Jupiter is retrograde too.Also Guru has

> > kenrdapatya dosha

> >

> > Please refer the following details

> >

> > DOB - 20.08.1974

> > TOB - 1.20 am

> > Place of Birth - New Delhi

> > Asc/1st - gemini /.Sani

> > 2nd - venus

> > 3rd - Sun/Mars/Budh(combust)

> > 4th - Moon

> > 5th -

> > 6th - Rahu

> > 7th -

> > 8th -

> > 9th - Guru®

> > 10th - mandi

> > 11th -

> > 12th - Ketu

> >

> > Regards

> > Vivek

> >

>