Doubt and Krishna-Consciousness (was Fall of the Jiva & OOP)

[Guest guest]

Dear Prabhu

PAMHO

AGTSP

I know for sure there is devotees that have some doubts on the jiva issue,and

we can discuss it.As far as Ramanujacarya being quoted,there is nothing wrong

with that,he is certainly a bonafide vaisnava.Yes maybe it would seem more

correct to quote Baladeva Vidyabhusana,it does not matter much.What is your

doubt in this matter?Srila Jiva Goswami has also very clearly dealt with the

fall of the jiva in his Paramatma Sandarbha,similarly the same has been done

in the Jaiva dharma by Bhaktivinoda Thakura.It is very simple also if no one

fell ,then where did the jivas come from?Obviously the answer must be

Krsna.Jivera svarupa hoya krsnera nitya dasa,if the soul is eternally a

servant of Krsna,before he was conditioned he must have been a servant

no?Otherwise the conditioning is also eternal,and it is never defined that

way.

Hope to hear from you on this issue.

YS

]Payonidhi das