Residents of Vaikuntha have perfect qualities

[Guest guest]

On 19 Mar 1999, Payonidhi Dasa wrote:

 

> Advocating that the jiva does not fall from Vaikuntha is against GBC rules

and

> regulations,as such ideas are based on insufficient understanding of

> sastra.

 

That is yet to be proven.

 

Maybe this should not be allowed to continue to discuss this here since

> the advocaters of such ignorance,just fill up page after page,with no onter

> idea that to pollute the devotees away from the actual situation.

 

I hope no one has any doubts on my original assertion that ISKCON devotees are

discouraged from airing doubts.

 

> his pastimes.This persons here don't even want to identifie his devotee

> name???I suggest that this issue about the jiva be disallowed

> right here before we get more of this mayavadi ideas in here.

 

Mayavadi ideas... interesting. Well the Sri Vaishnavas (the followers of Sri

Raamaanuja) hold to the no-fall theory. Are they mayavadis? Would you like to

go to them and tell they are mayavadis for not believing in fall-vaada?

 

> YS

> Payonidhi das

> They don't want to learn and rectifie but to challenge the GBC and Srila

> Prabhupada's presenting the proper siddhanta on the jiva issue.

 

I think it's truly sad that the mentality of some ISKCON devotees has been so

affected by some critics of the GBC that they perceive any sort of discussion

as a challenge to GBC authority.

 

Anyway, I fail to see how someone can accuse someone else of not wanting to

learn, when that same person is the one trying to stop the discussion.

 

regards,

 

-- K