Which sastra says...?

[Guest guest]

>Dear Vidvan Gauranga Prabhu, Please accept my humble obeisances. All

>Glories to Srila Prabhupada.

>

>> Another point is that we have to use some common sense. When sastra says

>> that we should serve the guru in vapuh, that obviously means that we have

>> to do so as long as the guru is physically alive on the planet. That is

>> the understanding that is conveyed to us both by precept and example of

>> the previous acaryas.

>

>Notice how Vidvan has now changed the subject. First he tried to present

>*quotes* which he claimed *proved* that the Guru *must* be physically

>present for the pre-initiated aspiring disciple. Now that it has been

>pointed out that the quotes do not actually state this - Vidvan has dropped

>his evidence from actual quotes to 'common sense' & 'precept and example of

>the previous acaryas'. This is just another way of saying that he does not

>actually have any quotes from Srila Prabhupada stating the necessity for a

>physically present guru in order to take initiation from, as he originally

>claimed.

>

>Ys, Sattvik Das

 

 

Your above comment is too poor to even stand before Vidvan Gauranga pr's

solid and scholarly comment with compilation from other texts based firmly

on Sadhu sastra, guru vakya. So please do not embarrass yourself anymore by

writing something of this sort. We can easily see you are not able to

properly debate here with VG pr, DK pr and others, so please don't try to

pull on. We do understand your problem. Devotees will hopefully forgive you

for the time they may have wasted in reading your texts, but now it's

enough. You should have chosen someone from your own group to have the

debate balanced. Don't you think so? I hope you can understand this much.

Hare Krishna!

 

ys, bb