Guest guest Posted July 29, 2006 Report Share Posted July 29, 2006 Dear Jyothish, Female born in Virgo Rasi have arpa putra yoa? In a female horoscope if the putrakaaraka Guru in the putrasthana and natural malefic in the 5th house to the putra sthana, she may not have any issues? In a female horoscope, if the 7th is a malefic’s house aspected by malefic, she would be childless? All reply based on true life knowledge would be much appriciated. With regards, D.Sathiyanarayana Gupta. See the all-new, redesigned .com. Check it out. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 29, 2006 Report Share Posted July 29, 2006 dear friend sometime ago i furnished birth details of few of my customers who had the following combinations mentioned by you who all have had grown up children due to jupiter in 5th house. as regards other combinations mentioned by you, even though such rules do exist in some classics, there are no blind rules which come true in all cases. astrology is such a maze that there are so many overriding features, e.g. even if the worst negative yogas are found in one's chart, jupiter's benefic aspect on them would ensure that the native will not get those negative results as feared. so mere declaration of a person getting children or not based on one principle is not prudent and we shall check all overriding rules. it is hightime putrakaraka jupiter is drubbed by some as putranashaka based on some illogical rules, NOT SUPPORTED BY FACTS. if someone comes out with such a jupiter bashing theory, kindly come open and i will support the benefic putrakaraka results of jupiter supported by living charts. analysis of dead persons charts on hindsight is the most easiest job. let us give living examples. however, dictatorial practices are back in the world. modern astrologers are coming with new researches and asking their critics to prove them wrong, instead of substantiating their theories with living person's data. if any person brings living charts criticising jupiter as putranashaka, i will furnsih more number of charts than him supporting jupiter as putrakaraka with same combinations. with best wishes pandit arjun vedic astrology, Sathiyanarayana Gupta <gupta816 wrote: > > Dear Jyothish, > > Female born in Virgo Rasi have arpa putra yoa? > In a female horoscope if the putrakaaraka Guru in the putrasthana and natural malefic in the 5th house to the putra sthana, she may not have any issues? > In a female horoscope, if the 7th is a malefic's house aspected by malefic, she would be childless? > All reply based on true life knowledge would be much appriciated. > With regards, > D.Sathiyanarayana Gupta. > > > > > > See the all-new, redesigned .com. Check it out. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 29, 2006 Report Share Posted July 29, 2006 Dear Sir, My elder sister has chandra and Guru in aquarius(5th house) with Tula lagna .She has two grownup fine sons with one doing MS in Sweden and the other recently joined in job after graduation. regards srinivas Quoting panditarjun2004 : > dear friend sometime ago i furnished birth details of few of my customers who had the following combinations mentioned by you who all have had grown up children due to jupiter in 5th house. as regards other combinations mentioned by you, even though such rules do exist in some classics, there are no blind rules which come true in all cases. astrology is such a maze that there are so many overriding features, e.g. even if the worst negative yogas are found in one's chart, jupiter's benefic aspect on them would ensure that the native will not get those negative results as feared. so mere declaration of a person getting children or not based on one principle is not prudent and we shall check all overriding rules. it is hightime putrakaraka jupiter is drubbed by some as putranashaka based on some illogical rules, NOT SUPPORTED BY FACTS. if someone comes out with such a jupiter bashing theory, kindly come open and i will support the benefic putrakaraka results of jupiter supported by living charts. analysis of dead persons charts on hindsight is the most easiest job. let us give living examples. however, dictatorial practices are back in the world. modern astrologers are coming with new researches and asking their critics to prove them wrong, instead of substantiating their theories with living person's data. if any person brings living charts criticising jupiter as putranashaka, i will furnsih more number of charts than him supporting jupiter as putrakaraka with same combinations. with best wishes pandit arjun vedic astrology, Sathiyanarayana Gupta <gupta816 wrote: > > Dear Jyothish, > > Female born in Virgo Rasi have arpa putra yoa? > In a female horoscope if the putrakaaraka Guru in the putrasthana and natural malefic in the 5th house to the putra sthana, she may not have any issues? > In a female horoscope, if the 7th is a malefic's house aspected by malefic, she would be childless? > All reply based on true life knowledge would be much appriciated. > With regards, > D.Sathiyanarayana Gupta. > > > > > > See the all-new, redesigned .com. Check it out. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 30, 2006 Report Share Posted July 30, 2006 Dear Pt.Arjunji, Thank you for your kind advice. Even in these modern days of scientific advancements, there exists a belief among Hindus that the birth of a child relieves them from pitru runa. Probably this could be one of the reasons that a small percentage of the Hindus still believes in Kuta system of match making where in majority among the Kutas directed towards progeny. It was under this contingency a reference was made to the Jyothish Pundits as I did not have much readily available statistical data to stand by or against the Astrological hypothesis under question. It is not my intention to drub Jupiter or any other gragha for that matter. I thank you once again. With regards, D.Sathiyanarayana Gupta. panditarjun2004 <panditarjun2004 > wrote: dear friend sometime ago i furnished birth details of few of my customers who had the following combinations mentioned by you who all have had grown up children due to jupiter in 5th house. as regards other combinations mentioned by you, even though such rules do exist in some classics, there are no blind rules which come true in all cases. astrology is such a maze that there are so many overriding features, e.g. even if the worst negative yogas are found in one's chart, jupiter's benefic aspect on them would ensure that the native will not get those negative results as feared. so mere declaration of a person getting children or not based on one principle is not prudent and we shall check all overriding rules. it is hightime putrakaraka jupiter is drubbed by some as putranashaka based on some illogical rules, NOT SUPPORTED BY FACTS. if someone comes out with such a jupiter bashing theory, kindly come open and i will support the benefic putrakaraka results of jupiter supported by living charts. analysis of dead persons charts on hindsight is the most easiest job. let us give living examples. however, dictatorial practices are back in the world. modern astrologers are coming with new researches and asking their critics to prove them wrong, instead of substantiating their theories with living person's data. if any person brings living charts criticising jupiter as putranashaka, i will furnsih more number of charts than him supporting jupiter as putrakaraka with same combinations. with best wishes pandit arjun vedic astrology, Sathiyanarayana Gupta <gupta816 wrote: > > Dear Jyothish, > > Female born in Virgo Rasi have arpa putra yoa? > In a female horoscope if the putrakaaraka Guru in the putrasthana and natural malefic in the 5th house to the putra sthana, she may not have any issues? > In a female horoscope, if the 7th is a malefic's house aspected by malefic, she would be childless? > All reply based on true life knowledge would be much appriciated. > With regards, > D.Sathiyanarayana Gupta. > > > > > > See the all-new, redesigned .com. Check it out. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.