Guest guest Posted August 16, 2006 Report Share Posted August 16, 2006 Dear Gurujans and Members, After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to find a simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% of the charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% of the cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth data and the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more charts. All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I have a feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also comply with the rule. I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has contributed so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing so. My collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and therefore I ask for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast astrology literature and classics. Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes conjunction)" Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I do not want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the data that is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a random set of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments positive or negative are welcome. Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage Date Vimsottari MD Lord Comments 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun-75 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus conjunct with 2nd lord Moon 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is 2nd lord 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu conjunct with 2nd lord 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect Regards, Pratap Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2006 Report Share Posted August 16, 2006 Dear Pratap, I believe the 2nd lord has to be from UL and not from Lagna. Guru Sanjayji has elaborately explained this topic in his class on UL (Audio). Moreover, pinpointing dasa of a planet is too large a period, say the shortest dasa period is of Sun (6 years) and predicting marriage even in this 6 years period will be too vague. We would need to close in with AD, PD and even SD for a clear prediction of marriage timing. Regards Ravi Nair Pratap Kaneria <pkaneria > wrote: Dear Gurujans and Members, After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to find a simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% of the charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% of the cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth data and the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more charts. All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I have a feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also comply with the rule. I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has contributed so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing so. My collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and therefore I ask for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast astrology literature and classics. Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes conjunction)" Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I do not want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the data that is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a random set of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments positive or negative are welcome. Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage Date Vimsottari MD Lord Comments 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun-75 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus conjunct with 2nd lord Moon 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is 2nd lord 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu conjunct with 2nd lord 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect Regards, Pratap How low will we go? Check out Messenger’s low PC-to-Phone call rates. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2006 Report Share Posted August 16, 2006 Dear Pratap, Good to know that someone is interested in sharing his findings with other people for their enhancement. I have not gone into deep analysis of Your details given, but the 2nd connection or the 11th connection itself are without support of seventh lord ,enough to confer marriage to the native. You may check the 11th connection participation in the cases where You may not have got results coming with reference to the second lord. Here I am not confirming Your theories or denying them but just putting what I have noticed. The second is considered to be family, and 11th is gains, or 7th as we all know for what, Any planet in Nakshatras of any of these Lords, by way of placement connection or Lord of Bhava connection, running a Mahadasha or Antar supported with a favourable Mahadasha for marriage prospects, would be enough to confer marriage on a native. But these are not Bhaskars Rules, but rules given by my Gurus. Take care, Hope to hear more from You for helping your colleagues, which is very positive step. Bhaskar. Bombay Cell-9323522663 Landline- 022-24330886 Private email - rajiventerprises (AT) hathway (DOT) com Consultations from this Astrologer are not Charged on Forum, but by Private Mail, Telephone, or any other way, would be charged. , Pratap Kaneria <pkaneria wrote: > > Dear Gurujans and Members, > > After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to find a simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% of the charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% of the cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth data and the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. > > I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more charts. All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I have a feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also comply with the rule. > > I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has contributed so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing so. My collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and therefore I ask for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast astrology literature and classics. > > Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: > > "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes conjunction)" > > Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I do not want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the data that is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. > > I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a random set of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments positive or negative are welcome. > > Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage > Date Vimsottari > MD Lord Comments 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun- 75 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus conjunct with 2nd lord Moon 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter > Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is 2nd lord 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu conjunct with 2nd lord 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect > > > Regards, > > Pratap > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2006 Report Share Posted August 16, 2006 Dear Bhaskarji, Thanks for your kind words. It is my pleasure to share any statistical results I come up with. If it is helpful to anyone it would double my pleasure. I am sure there are many other good and proven methods to time marriage. I did look at other houses and lords and none stands up as consistently as 2nd house connections. I am sure you have many charts with marriage dates. I would like to request you to please look at some of these charts and share the results. Regards, Pratap bhaskar_jyotish <bhaskar_jyotish (AT) (DOT) co.in> wrote: Dear Pratap, Good to know that someone is interested in sharing his findings with other people for their enhancement. I have not gone into deep analysis of Your details given, but the 2nd connection or the 11th connection itself are without support of seventh lord ,enough to confer marriage to the native. You may check the 11th connection participation in the cases where You may not have got results coming with reference to the second lord. Here I am not confirming Your theories or denying them but just putting what I have noticed. The second is considered to be family, and 11th is gains, or 7th as we all know for what, Any planet in Nakshatras of any of these Lords, by way of placement connection or Lord of Bhava connection, running a Mahadasha or Antar supported with a favourable Mahadasha for marriage prospects, would be enough to confer marriage on a native. But these are not Bhaskars Rules, but rules given by my Gurus. Take care, Hope to hear more from You for helping your colleagues, which is very positive step. Bhaskar. Bombay Cell-9323522663 Landline- 022-24330886 Private email - rajiventerprises (AT) hathway (DOT) com Consultations from this Astrologer are not Charged on Forum, but by Private Mail, Telephone, or any other way, would be charged. , Pratap Kaneria <pkaneria wrote: > > Dear Gurujans and Members, > > After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to find a simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% of the charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% of the cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth data and the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. > > I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more charts. All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I have a feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also comply with the rule. > > I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has contributed so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing so. My collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and therefore I ask for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast astrology literature and classics. > > Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: > > "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes conjunction)" > > Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I do not want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the data that is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. > > I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a random set of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments positive or negative are welcome. > > Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage > Date Vimsottari > MD Lord Comments 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun- 75 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus conjunct with 2nd lord Moon 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter > Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is 2nd lord 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu conjunct with 2nd lord 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect > > > Regards, > > Pratap > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2006 Report Share Posted August 16, 2006 Dear Gaurav, Good question, These rules (Which I have mentioned) have to be applied to Antar as mentioned in my mail, and also pratyantar to narrow down to timing the events., which at times can even give You accuracy within 2-3 days, while experts may give the exact date of event itself., using the Ruling planets as support. Regards, Bhaskar. , "Gaurav Sharma" <gauravkom wrote: > > Dear Pratap, > > The rule is more towards the Mahadasha and Mahadasha`s are normally > for a longer stretch except a few. I can understand the reason behind > the rule but did you tried to check whether such a rule applies to > Antardasha or Pratyantardasha as then you will be able to narrow down > to specific months in a year. > > > Gaurav > > > > , Pratap Kaneria > <pkaneria@> wrote: > > > > Dear Gurujans and Members, > > > > After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able > to find a simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha > dasha when the marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate > a rule which I am presenting below with supporting data. It is > working with almost 95% of the charts I have examined (data presented > here is only a sample). In 5% of the cases where the rule did not > work, I have doubts about the birth data and the ascendant. If this > rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be used to rectify > the ascendant in case of married natives. > > > > I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against > more charts. All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri > ayanamsa. I have a feeling that charts prepared using other commonly > used ayanamsa may also comply with the rule. > > > > I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has > contributed so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind > me doing so. My collection and reading of astrology classics is > limited and therefore I ask for forgiveness if a similar idea has > already been proposed in vast astrology literature and classics. > > > > Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: > > > > "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd > lord or a planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi > drishti (includes conjunction)" > > > > Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule > against. I do not want to identify the natives and therefore I have > given only the data that is necessary for someone to create a chart > and verify the rule. > > > > I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a > random set of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. > Any comments positive or negative are welcome. > > > > Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage > > Date Vimsottari > > MD Lord Comments 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun- > 75 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` > 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting > 2nd lord by rasi drishti 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 > May-72 Venus Venus in 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun 13 > 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus conjunct with > 2nd lord Moon 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu > Rahu aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 16W 10/11/1965 > 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus aspecting 2nd house with > rasi drishti 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu > Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 20W 11/30/1973 > 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as > 2nd lord 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun > conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house 57 10/27/1980 > 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter > > Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 58W 5/2/1979 > 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu > and aspecting 2nd house 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov- 97 > Saturn Saturn aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 59H > 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is 2nd > lord 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu > aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect 60 3/11/1978 > 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun aspecting 2nd house by rasi > drishti 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus > in 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord 63 4/24/1950 > 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by > 7th aspect 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu > Rahu conjunct with 2nd lord 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 > 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th > aspect > > > > > > Regards, > > > > Pratap > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 16, 2006 Report Share Posted August 16, 2006 Dear Samir, Thanks for your comments. Yes. I agree with your observation about too many planets qualifying for giving marriage. I am looking for other factors that can reduce the number of qualified mahadashas. But I am still interested in cases where the rule fails. If you can find some cases where some one gets married in a mahadasha not qualified per rule, I request you to share the birthdata and the marriage date. This will help me with the research. Regards, Pratap Samir Shah <solaris.smoke > wrote: || hare räma kåñna || Dear Pratap, Namaskar I have one problem with this rule, and that is that it applies to too many planets! Take the first chart in the list (listing planets in Vimsottari dasa order): Jupiter - aspects 2nd house Saturn - is placed in 2nd house Mercury - aspects Venus - aspects (graha dristi) Sun - aspects 2nd lord Moon - 2nd lord Mars - aspects 2nd lord (graha dristi) This leaves only the nodes that do not fulfill the condition. Take the second chart: Mars - aspects 2nd lord Rahu - aspects 2nd lord Jupiter - aspects 2nd lord Saturn - aspects 2nd house Mercury - 2nd lord Ketu - aspects 2nd lord Venus - aspects 2nd house Sun - joined 2nd lord Leaving only the Moon! So, as per your rule, marriage could have occurred any time between the person's birth and 2076! Would this help in rectification? I could go on - but statistically, this condition is going to be met in most charts by a majority of the planets. This, I would suggest, is why it has worked in 95% of the charts you checked. If you could show it working in charts where only one or two planets meet the condition, then there might be something to it. But otherwise, it seems a product of chance. Best wishes, Samir At 07:16 16/08/2006, you wrote: Dear Gurujans and Members, After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to find a simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% of the charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% of the cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth data and the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more charts. All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I have a feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also comply with the rule. I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has contributed so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing so. My collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and therefore I ask for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast astrology literature and classics. Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes conjunction)" Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I do not want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the data that is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a random set of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments positive or negative are welcome. Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage Date Vimsottari MD Lord Comments 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun-75 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus conjunct with 2nd lord Moon 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is 2nd lord 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu conjunct with 2nd lord 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect Regards, Pratap Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 17, 2006 Report Share Posted August 17, 2006 Dear Pratap, To support your work, let me say that my marriage was done in 1977, Jupiter MD. Leo Lagna and 2L Mercury is in Leo aspected by Jupiter from Aquaris. Regards Ravi Nair Pratap Kaneria <pkaneria > wrote: Dear Mr. Nair, By no means, my objective was to precisely time the marriage. I agree that MD period is quite long and one would need to find right antar and pratayantar dasa to come with a reasonable time frame. First let us see if we can confidently identify a MD. I have some idea about the way to identify antar dasa. But I do not want to focus on that right now. I am sure there are already many existing and successful methods to time the marriage. Consider this just an addition. 2. In most cases more than one MD will qualify for marriage. One has to look at the remaining qualified MD's and the age of the native. A qualified MD may not necessarily give marriage. I just saw a query where the person is not likely to get married for next 8 years because the current MD does not qualify for marriage. (of course assuming that this rule works). Thanks for your input, Regards, Pratap "A. Ravindran Nair" <rain13club > wrote: Dear Pratap, I believe the 2nd lord has to be from UL and not from Lagna. Guru Sanjayji has elaborately explained this topic in his class on UL (Audio). Moreover, pinpointing dasa of a planet is too large a period, say the shortest dasa period is of Sun (6 years) and predicting marriage even in this 6 years period will be too vague. We would need to close in with AD, PD and even SD for a clear prediction of marriage timing. Regards Ravi Nair Pratap Kaneria <pkaneria > wrote: Dear Gurujans and Members, After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to find a simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% of the charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% of the cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth data and the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more charts. All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I have a feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also comply with the rule. I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has contributed so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing so. My collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and therefore I ask for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast astrology literature and classics. Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes conjunction)" Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I do not want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the data that is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a random set of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments positive or negative are welcome. Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage Date Vimsottari MD Lord Comments 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun-75 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus conjunct with 2nd lord Moon 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is 2nd lord 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu conjunct with 2nd lord 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect Regards, Pratap How low will we go? Check out Messenger’s low PC-to-Phone call rates. Everyone is raving about the all-new Mail Beta. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 18, 2006 Report Share Posted August 18, 2006 Dear Ravi, Thanks. Please keep applying to other charts you come across. I am particularly interested in the charts that fail. Regards, Pratap "A. Ravindran Nair" <rain13club > wrote: Dear Pratap, To support your work, let me say that my marriage was done in 1977, Jupiter MD. Leo Lagna and 2L Mercury is in Leo aspected by Jupiter from Aquaris. Regards Ravi Nair Pratap Kaneria <pkaneria > wrote: Dear Mr. Nair, By no means, my objective was to precisely time the marriage. I agree that MD period is quite long and one would need to find right antar and pratayantar dasa to come with a reasonable time frame. First let us see if we can confidently identify a MD. I have some idea about the way to identify antar dasa. But I do not want to focus on that right now. I am sure there are already many existing and successful methods to time the marriage. Consider this just an addition. 2. In most cases more than one MD will qualify for marriage. One has to look at the remaining qualified MD's and the age of the native. A qualified MD may not necessarily give marriage. I just saw a query where the person is not likely to get married for next 8 years because the current MD does not qualify for marriage. (of course assuming that this rule works). Thanks for your input, Regards, Pratap "A. Ravindran Nair" <rain13club > wrote: Dear Pratap, I believe the 2nd lord has to be from UL and not from Lagna. Guru Sanjayji has elaborately explained this topic in his class on UL (Audio). Moreover, pinpointing dasa of a planet is too large a period, say the shortest dasa period is of Sun (6 years) and predicting marriage even in this 6 years period will be too vague. We would need to close in with AD, PD and even SD for a clear prediction of marriage timing. Regards Ravi Nair Pratap Kaneria <pkaneria > wrote: Dear Gurujans and Members, After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to find a simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% of the charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% of the cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth data and the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more charts. All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I have a feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also comply with the rule. I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has contributed so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing so. My collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and therefore I ask for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast astrology literature and classics. Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes conjunction)" Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I do not want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the data that is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a random set of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments positive or negative are welcome. Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage Date Vimsottari MD Lord Comments 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun-75 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus conjunct with 2nd lord Moon 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is 2nd lord 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu conjunct with 2nd lord 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect Regards, Pratap How low will we go? Check out Messenger’s low PC-to-Phone call rates. Everyone is raving about the all-new Mail Beta. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 19, 2006 Report Share Posted August 19, 2006 Dear Amit, I was creating charts for the data you have given and I am finding some discrepancies. Are you using Lahiri ayanamsa or some other ? For example, in second chart, if marriage was done in 2/2005, md lord was Jupiter per chart I create and you specifiy rahu md. In fourth chart, you say there is conjunction of md lord venus with 2nd lord which I do not get. 2nd lord Su is in scorpio and venus is in libra. Also I would appreciate if you specify marriage mo/yr in all cases in addition to md so that I can be sure that the chart I am creating is same as what you see. Regards, Pratap ak_131 <agrawal.amitk > wrote: Dear Pratap ji, I have some data with me, I have tried to check it with my limited knowledge. I have few suggestions for the same. 1) MD Planet relation with D-9 Lagna 2) MD Planet relation with 2nd house 3) MD planet relation with 7th house 20 Apr 1956, 81.41 E,22.04 N , 8.15 am , Sun dasha(feb-82) , 2nd lord conjoined Sun,Sun aspects 7th house by Rashi drishti 19 Apr 1980, 73.42 E,24.30 N, 7.15 am , Rahu Dasha (feb-2005), no connections,Rahu aspects 7th by Rashi Drishti 18 Apr 1982, 72.58 E,25.22 N,19.30 ,Jupitor Dasha(feb-2005), no connections with 2nd house, Jupitor aspects 7th house 17 Nov 53, 72.50 E,25.0 N,00.10 ,Venus Dasha , conjunction with 2nd lord, Venus aspects 7th house -Rashi Drishti 7 oct 67, 76.00 E, 25.00 N,00.01.39 ,Mercury Dasha, 2nd lord saturn , no connections, mercury is 7th lord 23 Jul 1979 , 72.58 E,25.00 N, 7.45 , Saturn MD,Saturn sitting in 2nd house ,saturn is 7th lord 3 Feb 77, 79.41 E,27.29N, 17.30 , Mercury MD,Mercury no relation with 2nd house, no relation with 7th too 15 July 67, 76.34 E,27.38 N, 8.00 , Venus MD,Venus in 2nd house -aspecting 7th by Rashi Drishti 13 Nov 81, 76.34 E,27.38 N, 11.50 ,Rahu MD,Rahu aspects 2nd house by Rashi Drishti - sitting in 7th house 12 Sept 73, 78.1 E , 26.00 N, 16.55 , Saturn MD, Saturn lording 2nd house but no connections to 7th house .. Out of 10 times 4 times 2nd house fails , 2 times 7th house .. I dont have anymore data for married ppl.. Regards, Amit , "Ramesh F. Gangaramani" wrote: > > || Satyam Bruyat Priyam Bruyat || > > Dear Pratap, > Your rule works for me. I got married in Jup MD. Jup aspects (graha drishti) > 2H and 2L. > Best Wishes, > Ramesh > > > _____ > > [] On > Behalf Of Pratap Kaneria > Wednesday, August 16, 2006 12:17 AM > naastrology; ; > > [Om Krishna Guru] Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha > > > > > Dear Gurujans and Members, > > After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to find a > simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the > marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am > presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% of the > charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% of the > cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth data and > the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, it can be > used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. > > I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more charts. > All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I have a > feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also > comply with the rule. > < /DIV> > I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has contributed > so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing so. My > collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and therefore I ask > for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast > astrology literature and classics. > > Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: > > "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a > planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes > conjunction)" > > Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I do not > want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the data that > is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. > > I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a random se t > of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments > positive or negative are welcome. > > Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage > Date Vimsottari > MD Lord Comments > 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun-75 Mercury > Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` > 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter > Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti > 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in > 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun > 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus > conjunct with 2nd lord Moon > 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu > aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti > 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus > aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti > 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu > aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord > 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu > aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord > 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun > conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house > 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter > Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti > 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn > conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house > 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn > aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti > 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is > 2nd lord > 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu > aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect > 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun > aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti > 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in > 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord > 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury > Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect > 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu > conjunct with 2nd lord > 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu > aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect > > > Regards, > > Pratap > ~ om tat sat ~ Thank you for maintaining the decorum of the Achyuta Ashram. Reminders: (1) Recite the Shadakshari Mantra 'Hare Rama Krishna' (2) Try to become Vegetarian - remember Akbar the Great who said that the human stomach should not become a graveyard for animals. (3) Practise charity in thought and deed - do one free chart reading today Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 20, 2006 Report Share Posted August 20, 2006 Dear Amit, The question is why I am getting different lagna ? Please tell me which ayanamsa you are using. And is it possible to give mo/year of marriage for all charts ? Regards, Pratap ak_131 <agrawal.amitk > wrote: Dear Pratap ji, I apologise for the mistakes made by me.That time it was 3.30 AM IST , but I could not resist myself from replying. I have rechecked the horoscopes again and found somethings : For chart 2 -> Its correct that the native was running Jup MD at the time of marriage, but that too doesnt have any relation with 7th house. For Chart 4-> I am getting Leo Lagna, I think you are getting Lagna as Virgo. Regards, Amit , Pratap Kaneria wrote: > > Dear Amit, > > I was creating charts for the data you have given and I am finding some discrepancies. Are you using Lahiri ayanamsa or some other ? For example, in second chart, if marriage was done in 2/2005, md lord was Jupiter per chart I create and you specifiy rahu md. In fourth chart, you say there is conjunction of md lord venus with 2nd lord which I do not get. 2nd lord Su is in scorpio and venus is in libra. > > Also I would appreciate if you specify marriage mo/yr in all cases in addition to md so that I can be sure that the chart I am creating is same as what you see. > > Regards, > > Pratap > > ak_131 wrote: > Dear Pratap ji, > I have some data with me, I have tried to check it with my > limited knowledge. I have few suggestions for the same. > > 1) MD Planet relation with D-9 Lagna > 2) MD Planet relation with 2nd house > 3) MD planet relation with 7th house > > > 20 Apr 1956, 81.41 E,22.04 N , 8.15 am , Sun dasha(feb-82) , 2nd > lord conjoined Sun,Sun aspects 7th house by Rashi drishti > > 19 Apr 1980, 73.42 E,24.30 N, 7.15 am , Rahu Dasha (feb-2005), no > connections,Rahu aspects 7th by Rashi Drishti > > 18 Apr 1982, 72.58 E,25.22 N,19.30 ,Jupitor Dasha(feb-2005), no > connections with 2nd house, Jupitor aspects 7th house > > 17 Nov 53, 72.50 E,25.0 N,00.10 ,Venus Dasha , conjunction with > 2nd lord, Venus aspects 7th house -Rashi Drishti > > 7 oct 67, 76.00 E, 25.00 N,00.01.39 ,Mercury Dasha, 2nd lord > saturn , no connections, mercury is 7th lord > > 23 Jul 1979 , 72.58 E,25.00 N, 7.45 , Saturn MD,Saturn sitting in > 2nd house ,saturn is 7th lord > > 3 Feb 77, 79.41 E,27.29N, 17.30 , Mercury MD,Mercury no relation > with 2nd house, no relation with 7th too > > 15 July 67, 76.34 E,27.38 N, 8.00 , Venus MD,Venus in 2nd house > -aspecting 7th by Rashi Drishti > > 13 Nov 81, 76.34 E,27.38 N, 11.50 ,Rahu MD,Rahu aspects 2nd house > by Rashi Drishti - sitting in 7th house > > 12 Sept 73, 78.1 E , 26.00 N, 16.55 , Saturn MD, Saturn lording > 2nd house but no connections to 7th house .. > > Out of 10 times 4 times 2nd house fails , 2 times 7th house .. I > dont have anymore data for married ppl.. > > Regards, > Amit > > > > , "Ramesh F. Gangaramani" > wrote: > > > > || Satyam Bruyat Priyam Bruyat || > > > > Dear Pratap, > > Your rule works for me. I got married in Jup MD. Jup aspects (graha > drishti) > > 2H and 2L. > > Best Wishes, > > Ramesh > > > > > > _____ > > > > > [] On > > Behalf Of Pratap Kaneria > > Wednesday, August 16, 2006 12:17 AM > > naastrology; ; > > > > [Om Krishna Guru] Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha > > > > > > > > > > Dear Gurujans and Members, > > > > After reviewing quite a few charts with a objective of being able to > find a > > simple and unambigous method of finding a vimsottari maha dasha when the > > marriage can take place, I have been able to formulate a rule which I am > > presenting below with supporting data. It is working with almost 95% > of the > > charts I have examined (data presented here is only a sample). In 5% > of the > > cases where the rule did not work, I have doubts about the birth > data and > > the ascendant. If this rule gets approval from senior astrologers, > it can be > > used to rectify the ascendant in case of married natives. > > > > I am so excited that I could not wait to keep checking against more > charts. > > All of the charts I examined were prepared using lahiri ayanamsa. I > have a > > feeling that charts prepared using other commonly used ayanamsa may also > > comply with the rule. > > < /DIV> > > I would like to dedicate this work to Shri Sanjay Rathji who has > contributed > > so much to vedic astrology, hoping that he would not mind me doing > so. My > > collection and reading of astrology classics is limited and > therefore I ask > > for forgiveness if a similar idea has already been proposed in vast > > astrology literature and classics. > > > > Pratap's Rule for Marriage Maha Dasha: > > > > "Marriage can take place only in vimsottari maha dasha of 2nd lord or a > > planet aspecting 2nd house or 2nd lord by graha/rasi drishti (includes > > conjunction)" > > > > Listed below is a sample of data I have verified the rule against. I > do not > > want to identify the natives and therefore I have given only the > data that > > is necessary for someone to create a chart and verify the rule. > > > > I am hoping that senior astrologers will test the rule against a > random se t > > of charts in their collection and provide some feedback. Any comments > > positive or negative are welcome. > > > > Chart DOB POB TOB Marriage > > Date Vimsottari > > MD Lord Comments > > 3 12/20/1947 73E04,24N03 18:28 Jun-75 Mercury > > Mercury aspecting 2nd house by Rasi drishti ` > > 9 3/8/1967 73E04,26N17 17:40 Nov-91 Jupiter > > Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti > > 12 9/16/1943 72E37,23N02 2:22 May-72 Venus Venus in > > 2nd house with 2nd lord Sun > > 13 11/18/1944 70E27,21N44 21:07 Jul-68 Venus Venus > > conjunct with 2nd lord Moon > > 16H 2/3/1961 77E35,12N59 21:39 May-91 Rahu Rahu > > aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti > > 16W 10/11/1965 77E35,12N59 11:41 May-91 Venus Venus > > aspecting 2nd house with rasi drishti > > 20H 10/11/1969 77E43,24N34 6:31 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu > > aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord > > 20W 11/30/1973 78E50,24N44 14:48 Dec-96 Rahu Rahu > > aspecting 2nd house as well as 2nd lord > > 24 12/3/1958 77E27,21N44 16:26 Jun-85 Sun Sun > > conjunct with 2nd lord and aspecting 2nd house > > 57 10/27/1980 78E28,17N23 21:30 May-04 Jupiter > > Jupiter aspecting 2nd lord by rasi drishti > > 58W 5/2/1979 78E28,17N23 0:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn > > conjunct with 2nd lord Rahu and aspecting 2nd house > > 58H 7/22/1970 78E28,17N23 6:30 Nov-97 Saturn Saturn > > aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti > > 59H 7/3/1971 81E38,21N14 18:50 Oct-04 Saturn Saturn is > > 2nd lord > > 59H 3/22/1969 75W41,04N31 5:50 Oct-04 Rahu Rahu > > aspecting 2nd lord Ma by 9th aspect > > 60 3/11/1978 122W55,49N13 18:32 Jul-06 Sun Sun > > aspecting 2nd house by rasi drishti > > 62 5/1/1973 73E07,19:13N 4:30 Jan-96 Venus Venus in > > 2nd house and aspecting 2nd lord > > 63 4/24/1950 77E25,24N59 20:00 Jan-82 Mercury > > Mercury aspecting 2nd house by 7th aspect > > 64H 7/15/1973 78E07,09N56 4:20 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu > > conjunct with 2nd lord > > 64W 10/12/1975 78E07,09N56 16:00 Feb-05 Rahu Rahu > > aspecting 2nd house and 2nd lord by 5th aspect > > > > > > Regards, > > > > Pratap > > > > > > > > > > ~ om tat sat ~ > Thank you for maintaining the decorum of the Achyuta Ashram. > Reminders: (1) Recite the Shadakshari Mantra 'Hare Rama Krishna' > (2) Try to become Vegetarian - remember Akbar the Great who said that the human stomach should not become a graveyard for animals. > (3) Practise charity in thought and deed - do one free chart reading today > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.