Why nativities jump ship --- What is the KARAKA for astrology, really?

[Guest guest]

Dear Nandini,

 

If you ultimately came to peace with whatever the astrologer managed

to convey, maybe it was indeed what Creator wanted you to pay

attention to and BRAVO -- you cared and decided to listen!

 

The conduit, the flute, the astrologer at that point becomes almost

meaningless, just like the envelope that brought the correct

*message*, just like Hermes was meant to be! Just a messenger and not

THE message!

 

Mercury, therefore, is not the karaka of astrology! Then what is?

 

Best wishes

 

RR

 

 

, "kakan_leo" <kakan_leo

wrote:

>

> Dear RR ji,

>

> Would like to share my personal experience, which may or may not be

> typical.

>

> The experience of an astrological reading is extremely practitioner

> dependent. And also, like you mentioned, we have a pre-conceived

> idea in us about how the experience of a reading would be.

>

> When I approached an astrologer (on the internet) for the first

> time, I expected to get connected, through the astrologer, to a

> lifetime message, that is meant for me. If I may say, get connected

> to Kaal.

>

> The astrologer happened to say exactly what I wanted to hear, but

> even then, I did not have the experience that "THIS IS THE

MESSAGE".

> I am unable to explain why. There was a thirst in me that was not

> quenched. I did not have the feeling that I was connected to the

> Divine message. Something was missing. It was not the sincerity of

> the astrologer. But I had the feeling that maybe he was not after

> all passing on or tuning into THE message, if there is anything

> called that.

>

> Hence I tried again, but half heartedly this time.

>

> But I consider myself a very lucky person, in many ways. And I did

> finally find the person who gave me the tuning in that I was

looking

> for. Needless to say, it was NOT, what I wanted to hear, at that

> point of time in my life. But I was so satisfied with the

experience

> that I accepted it. After that I have not had the urge to ask

anyone

> else for any opinion on my chart.

>

> Regards,

> Nandini.

>

>

>

>

>

>

> , "Rohiniranjan"

> <jyotish_vani@> wrote:

> >

> > I will try again :-)

> > Read my original posting in this thread and you will see where

you

> > are missing the point in the briefly quoted message below from

> your

> > post:

> > , "Rajan S. Malla"

<rajan@>

> > wrote:

> > >

> > > So when people get different answers without any specific

> answers,

> > then it

> > > urges people to seek help from others expecting the next one

may

> be

> > specific

> > > and solve the problems...

> >

> > ***********************************

> >

> > Rajan, my question was: What happened after the first reading

that

> > made the person go to the second one, and third and so on!

> >

> > Your disappointment with different readings from different

> > astrologers is understandable, but the QUESTION is: WHY DID YOU

OR

> > ANYONE GO TO THE NEXT ASTROLOGER AND HOW SOON AFTER THE FIRST

> > READING? :-)

> >

> > See my point?

> >

> > RR

> >

>