Official Ramakanta vs. IRM discussion thread

[Guest guest]

Posted by Yaduraja on Nov 23, 2006:

 

Dear Ramakanta Prabhu,

PAMHO. AGTSP!

Your confusion grows ever deeper.

 

You have asked many questions in your last post in an apparent attempt to

throw up a smokescreen around your latest self-contradiction. Why are you

asking me these questions, don't you know the answers? (Does that argument

remind you of someone...Ha!)

 

It is you who is trying to challenge point c), not me. It is you who needs

to prove that physical presence is vital, even though Srila Prabhupada said

the opposite over and over and over again, and even though he never

physically met many of his disciples, and even though he did not physically

attend many initiation ceremonies, and even though he never once stated that

he must remain on earth to deliver his disciples (as you state).

 

It is you who has contradicted yourself by presenting evidence which states:

 

> "You have asked if it is true that the Spiritual Master remains in the

> material universe until all of His disciples are transferred to the

> Spiritual Sky. The answer is yes, this is the rule.”

(Letter to Jayapataka, 11 Jul, 1969)

 

And then go on to foolishly challenge this very point:

 

> Why does Srila Prabhupada have to come back to this material universe, if

> he remains within this material universe in the form of books etc. that

> are sufficient to guide all ISKCON members?

(Nov 22, 2006 - 06:13 AM Ramakanta das)

 

If Srila Prabhupada “remains within this material universe in the form of

books etc. that are sufficient to guide all ISKCON members” as you now

state, then obviously his physical presence in relation to ISKCON members is

still irrelevant, as we state, and as Srila Prabhupada states over and over

again, but which you have foolishly challenged over and over again. In which

case point c) remains unchallenged by you and you remain defeated.

 

So please decide what your position is. I do not have to defeat you if you

have already defeated yourself in relation to point c), as you have

foolishly done yet again. Once you have a chat with the other Ramakanta and

decide whether or not Srila Prabhupada must remain in the universe to

deliver his disciples please let me know and I shall respond accordingly.

 

Best wishes to both of you

Ys

Yadu