Karmic Twins: do they have same challenges in life hmm...

[Guest guest]

Dear Rajesh ji,

 

This is indeed something intriguing to pursue because it speaks to the

hypothesis of astrology being based on cycles -- something that Rishi

ji has recently reminded us about, if I recall.

 

Unless there is a cyclical and repeating pattern, astrology would be

very difficult to explain and rationalize. I mean as many sceptics

remind us repeatedly, differnt individuals with sun in aries (the

appropriate zodiac, of course) must have some similarities or else how

do we figure them out. Same is true for yogas and combinations. I

realize that some of this has been a bit oversold, like poor cousin

mangal dosha and the perenneal favorites: KSY and sade sati!

 

But without the cyclical consonance there can only be random chaos and

much as half-baked sceptics may want us to march to that drum, we need

not do so, as yet!

 

I am responding to you because I think you have set the bar too high

right at the beginning. It is not that easy to meet your standards of

exclusion!

 

However, even individuals born on the same day at different times and

places tell and teach us a lot! Look at November 14, 1954 for instance.

Run the charts for different places and times on that day and you will

find some interesting things happenin'!

 

Trust me, I am not making you waste your time, if you are a serious

student of jyotish!

 

RR

 

, "rajesh" <rrgupta97 wrote:

>

> Dear Learned Members:

>

> I have pondering over an Idea for quite sometime.

>

> If two people born at different places, have same birth chart (born

in

> same lagna, on same day); will they face similar challenges in life.

> (they may have different navamsa, and other charts)

>

> If yes, will they benefit, if they communicated with each other.

>

> The concept of birth twins having same birth chart but different and

> same habits has been observed by some. Correct me on this, if so!

>

>

> Rajesh

>

[Guest guest]

Interesting postulate, Sir,there are intrinsic similarities perhaps

at the mental processes level while the bodily situations varying

with desh and patra; Kaal being nearly the same

rishi

 

, "Rohiniranjan"

<jyotish_vani wrote:

>

> Dear Rajesh ji,

>

> This is indeed something intriguing to pursue because it speaks to

the

> hypothesis of astrology being based on cycles -- something that

Rishi

> ji has recently reminded us about, if I recall.

>

> Unless there is a cyclical and repeating pattern, astrology would

be

> very difficult to explain and rationalize. I mean as many sceptics

> remind us repeatedly, differnt individuals with sun in aries (the

> appropriate zodiac, of course) must have some similarities or else

how

> do we figure them out. Same is true for yogas and combinations. I

> realize that some of this has been a bit oversold, like poor

cousin

> mangal dosha and the perenneal favorites: KSY and sade sati!

>

> But without the cyclical consonance there can only be random chaos

and

> much as half-baked sceptics may want us to march to that drum, we

need

> not do so, as yet!

>

> I am responding to you because I think you have set the bar too

high

> right at the beginning. It is not that easy to meet your standards

of

> exclusion!

>

> However, even individuals born on the same day at different times

and

> places tell and teach us a lot! Look at November 14, 1954 for

instance.

> Run the charts for different places and times on that day and you

will

> find some interesting things happenin'!

>

> Trust me, I am not making you waste your time, if you are a

serious

> student of jyotish!

>

> RR

>

> , "rajesh" <rrgupta97@>

wrote:

> >

> > Dear Learned Members:

> >

> > I have pondering over an Idea for quite sometime.

> >

> > If two people born at different places, have same birth chart

(born

> in

> > same lagna, on same day); will they face similar challenges in

life.

> > (they may have different navamsa, and other charts)

> >

> > If yes, will they benefit, if they communicated with each other.

> >

> > The concept of birth twins having same birth chart but different

and

> > same habits has been observed by some. Correct me on this, if so!

> >

> >

> > Rajesh

> >

>