*Intuition of Reality* By Sri SSS is not a digest on *brahmAkAravrutti*

[Guest guest]

Namaste Bhasker ji,

 

Humble praNAms Sri Subbu prabhuji

Hare Krishna

 

Subbu prabhuji :

 

First of all, what do you/the Swamiji mean by 'individual

intuition'? A sadhaka is an individual and he does sadhana and gets

the realization through the 'intuition'. Can it be a 'collective

intuition'? Can two or many sadhakas sit together in adhyAtma Yoga

and arrive at a 'sArvatrika anubhava'? The Bhashya is full of

mention about ' sa avagacchati'= 'He knows', 'sa vijAnAti', sa mukto

bhavati, etc. Nowhere it is mentioned that collectively some people

get realized together. The Gita and the Upanishads are also clear

about this. The Swamiji himself mentions above: '....to one who has

attained the vEdAntic intuition.' in singular.

 

bhaskar :

 

First of all prabhuji, the subject mail was intended to show you that my

swamiji's views are entirely different from what you have understood from

this book...Just to show that I had to type all those relevant portions

from book...Atleast now I think you will be in a position to understand

that what you have written as my swamiji's thoughts is entirely

wrong...that's all.... my purpose is served....

 

Secondly, with regard to *sArvatrika pUrNAnubhava*, what you have

understood as *collective intuitive experiences* of multiple sAdhaka-s is

simply rediculous...What is *anubhava* according to shankara ?? what is

vaiyuktika anubhava (individual experience) and what is sArvatrika anubhava

(universal experience)?? how Atma jnAna can not be proved by individual

experiences ?? etc. etc. have all been explained to the best of my ability

in my article *nirvikalpa samAdhi in advaita vEdAnta....So, I dont think I

have to reply to your assumptions on what constitutes *pUrNAnubhava*....

 

I shall try to share my understanding on mAndUkya maNtra 7 & shankara

bhAshya in due course...till then

 

Hari Hari Hari Bol!!!

bhaskar