Guest guest Posted February 2, 2007 Report Share Posted February 2, 2007 Namaste Vish, I hope you can clear up some confusion that has arisen in my mind. As I live at the other side of the planet from the Devi Mandir, visiting for me is quite an undertaking, not to mention the careful introduction and preparation process needed in the family circle. I am working on it, but need to plan and save and tread carefully. So I have been happy to plod along quietly, strengthened by the idea that physical distance does not matter and that Maa and Swamiji are in my heart, and so are all pilgrimage places. But now I hear that meditation cannot be taught by post or book, and I am wondering what I have been doing all this time. I understand that those who live in close proximity to the Guru receive many blessings, and although I realize there are special blessings assocciated with being actually physically near the Guru, I have always derived comfort from the thought that there are many ways of being 'near' the Guru. Have I misunderstood the importance of physical presence? with love, Henny s.com, "inspectionconnection108" <inspectionconnection108 wrote: > > Namaste Ryan: > > I talked to Swami about your questions on meditation. Swami suggested > you tune into the live Gita study class nightly at 6:30 PM Pacific > time, or watch the classes afterwards from the archives. Swami says > the Gita is full of knowledge and discussions about meditation. Also, > if you are interested in learning to meditate, visit the Devi Mandir > in person. because meditation cannot be taught by post or a book, it > is a direct transmission from teacher to student. > Visit the Devi Mandir web site at : www.shreemaa.org > > Jai Maa Jai Swami > > Vishweshwar > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 3, 2007 Report Share Posted February 3, 2007 Hennyji, Please don't let your faith be shaken by Swamiji's advice to another person. All of your experiences are true. You are pure of heart and mind and blessed with Mother's bhaava and bhava (I just know it's true). You definitely do not need to be in physical proximity to get ANYTHING from the guru - providing you are open to it. I say this from experience. Not only have Mother and Swamiji been with me from their abode in Napa, but my beloved Gurudeva once blessed me with the highest of graces, and I never saw his face in this world. I have certainly had my share of doubts. In fact, my mind sometimes overflows with them. They do nothing but create chaos. In concert with the desires one harbors toward the guru, they can become a force to throw you completely off the path. Trust your process, your sadhana, your experience. Are you growing? If the answer is yes, then trust your intuitive experience and keep growing. If you have love for them in your heart, they will not abandon you. I'm sure Vish will take this to Swamiji, and Swamiji will allay your doubts about distance, as he has with others on this forum, from time to time. In the meantime, please take my words to heart. They are true. Jai Maa! Chris , "henny_v_i" <henny_v_i wrote: > > Namaste Vish, > > I hope you can clear up some confusion that has arisen in my mind. As > I live at the other side of the planet from the Devi Mandir, visiting > for me is quite an undertaking, not to mention the careful > introduction and preparation process needed in the family circle. I am > working on it, but need to plan and save and tread carefully. > So I have been happy to plod along quietly, strengthened by the idea > that physical distance does not matter and that Maa and Swamiji are in > my heart, and so are all pilgrimage places. But now I hear that > meditation cannot be taught by post or book, and I am wondering what I > have been doing all this time. I understand that those who live in > close proximity to the Guru receive many blessings, and although I > realize there are special blessings assocciated with being actually > physically near the Guru, I have always derived comfort from the > thought that there are many ways of being 'near' the Guru. Have I > misunderstood the importance of physical presence? > > with love, > Henny > > s.com, "inspectionconnection108" <inspectionconnection108@> > wrote: > > > > Namaste Ryan: > > > > I talked to Swami about your questions on meditation. Swami > suggested > > you tune into the live Gita study class nightly at 6:30 PM Pacific > > time, or watch the classes afterwards from the archives. Swami says > > the Gita is full of knowledge and discussions about meditation. > Also, > > if you are interested in learning to meditate, visit the Devi Mandir > > in person. because meditation cannot be taught by post or a book, it > > is a direct transmission from teacher to student. > > Visit the Devi Mandir web site at : www.shreemaa.org > > > > Jai Maa Jai Swami > > > > Vishweshwar > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 3, 2007 Report Share Posted February 3, 2007 Om Namah Shivaya! You need not be shaken by the words of Swamiji. They are said in a context. The love we see in a message contains joy and truth. If we find fear in a message, it is not truth for us. You can clarify the same with Swamiji and you will get the instructions based on your position. Cheers, Mahadevan venkitaraman , "henny_v_i" <henny_v_i wrote: > > Namaste Vish, > > I hope you can clear up some confusion that has arisen in my mind. As > I live at the other side of the planet from the Devi Mandir, visiting > for me is quite an undertaking, not to mention the careful > introduction and preparation process needed in the family circle. I am > working on it, but need to plan and save and tread carefully. > So I have been happy to plod along quietly, strengthened by the idea > that physical distance does not matter and that Maa and Swamiji are in > my heart, and so are all pilgrimage places. But now I hear that > meditation cannot be taught by post or book, and I am wondering what I > have been doing all this time. I understand that those who live in > close proximity to the Guru receive many blessings, and although I > realize there are special blessings assocciated with being actually > physically near the Guru, I have always derived comfort from the > thought that there are many ways of being 'near' the Guru. Have I > misunderstood the importance of physical presence? > > with love, > Henny > > s.com, "inspectionconnection108" <inspectionconnection108@> > wrote: > > > > Namaste Ryan: > > > > I talked to Swami about your questions on meditation. Swami > suggested > > you tune into the live Gita study class nightly at 6:30 PM Pacific > > time, or watch the classes afterwards from the archives. Swami says > > the Gita is full of knowledge and discussions about meditation. > Also, > > if you are interested in learning to meditate, visit the Devi Mandir > > in person. because meditation cannot be taught by post or a book, it > > is a direct transmission from teacher to student. > > Visit the Devi Mandir web site at : www.shreemaa.org > > > > Jai Maa Jai Swami > > > > Vishweshwar > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 3, 2007 Report Share Posted February 3, 2007 Dear Henny: There is a story in the Mahabharata. It goes like this. There was a young man who wanted to learn archery from the great master, but he was too far away, and too poor to receive training. He wanted to study from the great master who was teaching Arjuna, but he could not. He created an image. It was the image of the master, and everyday he practiced. He became very adept, and finally one day the master did discover him, because he was far more skilled than even Arjuna. Of course the last part of the story is not so inspiring at least for me. The guru decided that for payment he would take this young man's right hand. Weird story, but anyway, the moral here is, take the guru's teaching to heart. Distance would then not be an issue. Peace, Shankari Kali Mahadevan venkitaraman , "henny_v_i" <henny_v_i wrote: > > Namaste Vish, > > I hope you can clear up some confusion that has arisen in my mind. As > I live at the other side of the planet from the Devi Mandir, visiting > for me is quite an undertaking, not to mention the careful > introduction and preparation process needed in the family circle. I am > working on it, but need to plan and save and tread carefully. > So I have been happy to plod along quietly, strengthened by the idea > that physical distance does not matter and that Maa and Swamiji are in > my heart, and so are all pilgrimage places. But now I hear that > meditation cannot be taught by post or book, and I am wondering what I > have been doing all this time. I understand that those who live in > close proximity to the Guru receive many blessings, and although I > realize there are special blessings assocciated with being actually > physically near the Guru, I have always derived comfort from the > thought that there are many ways of being 'near' the Guru. Have I > misunderstood the importance of physical presence? > > with love, > Henny > Now that's room service! Choose from over 150,000 hotels in 45,000 destinations on Travel to find your fit. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 3, 2007 Report Share Posted February 3, 2007 Guru Drohna took the thumb of the right hand of the student, as payment because the student was originally rejected by Drona. Drona had said that Arjuna would be the best in the world, so he refused to teach the would be student. So, by taking the student's right thumb as payment, the young student could no longer function as an archer. It was because Drona did'nt want to teach him, but the boy created a murthi, and worshipped Drona anyway, and therefore he got the Darshan of the Guru, even when the Guru had forbidden it. In this wasy, he became a great archer. It's an interesting story. Just taking a guess at the meaning - Darshan of the Guru is possible even from a great distance, because of devotion. But, there is a warning here to be sure one has the permission of the Guru. Lucky for us, Maa and Swami are'nt as rutheless as Guru Drona was. (Drona was a Guru for warriors). Also, Maa and Swami want us to learn from them and develop pure love and devotion. Jai Maa, Jai Swamiji Shankari Kali <shankari_kali > wrote: Dear Henny: There is a story in the Mahabharata. It goes like this. There was a young man who wanted to learn archery from the great master, but he was too far away, and too poor to receive training. He wanted to study from the great master who was teaching Arjuna, but he could not. He created an image. It was the image of the master, and everyday he practiced. He became very adept, and finally one day the master did discover him, because he was far more skilled than even Arjuna. Of course the last part of the story is not so inspiring at least for me. The guru decided that for payment he would take this young man's right hand. Weird story, but anyway, the moral here is, take the guru's teaching to heart. Distance would then not be an issue. Peace, Shankari Kali Mahadevan venkitaraman , "henny_v_i" <henny_v_i wrote: > > Namaste Vish, > > I hope you can clear up some confusion that has arisen in my mind. As > I live at the other side of the planet from the Devi Mandir, visiting > for me is quite an undertaking, not to mention the careful > introduction and preparation process needed in the family circle. I am > working on it, but need to plan and save and tread carefully. > So I have been happy to plod along quietly, strengthened by the idea > that physical distance does not matter and that Maa and Swamiji are in > my heart, and so are all pilgrimage places. But now I hear that > meditation cannot be taught by post or book, and I am wondering what I > have been doing all this time. I understand that those who live in > close proximity to the Guru receive many blessings, and although I > realize there are special blessings assocciated with being actually > physically near the Guru, I have always derived comfort from the > thought that there are many ways of being 'near' the Guru. Have I > misunderstood the importance of physical presence? > > with love, > Henny > Now that's room service! Choose from over 150,000 hotels in 45,000 destinations on Travel to find your fit. The fish are biting. Get more visitors on your site using Search Marketing. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 4, 2007 Report Share Posted February 4, 2007 Om Namah Shivaya! The story has more meanings. Guru Drona taught about using high level weapons. And so he is not a Sadguru. He had his own protocol which says the weapons could be taught only to Princes. So he refused to teach Ekalavya who was a hunter boy. Ekalavya was determined to study weapon using and so he was able to do that. It shows a Guru is mandatory for spiritual progress and not for getting Worldly knowledge. If every Tom, Dick and Harry is having weapons with high destructive capability, who is to check them? Do they know where to use them? And if they use them aginst the King? If Drona is committed to the King, isn't he supposed to do something to check Ekalavya? Also can't Ekalavya use his intelligence to study things other than to be an expert in using destructive arms? Cheers, Mahadevan venkitaraman , Nirmalananda Saraswati <nirmalananda1008 wrote: > > Guru Drohna took the thumb of the right hand of the student, as payment because the student was originally rejected by Drona. Drona had said that Arjuna would be the best in the world, so he refused to teach the would be student. So, by taking the student's right thumb as payment, the young student could no longer function as an archer. It was because Drona did'nt want to teach him, but the boy created a murthi, and worshipped Drona anyway, and therefore he got the Darshan of the Guru, even when the Guru had forbidden it. In this wasy, he became a great archer. > > It's an interesting story. Just taking a guess at the meaning - Darshan of the Guru is possible even from a great distance, because of devotion. But, there is a warning here to be sure one has the permission of the Guru. Lucky for us, Maa and Swami are'nt as rutheless as Guru Drona was. (Drona was a Guru for warriors). Also, Maa and Swami want us to learn from them and develop pure love and devotion. > Jai Maa, Jai Swamiji > > Shankari Kali <shankari_kali wrote: Dear Henny: > > There is a story in the Mahabharata. It goes like this. There was a young man who wanted to learn archery from the great master, but he was too far away, and too poor to receive training. He wanted to study from the great master who was teaching Arjuna, but he could not. > > He created an image. It was the image of the master, and everyday he practiced. He became very adept, and finally one day the master did discover him, because he was far more skilled than even Arjuna. > > Of course the last part of the story is not so inspiring at least for me. The guru decided that for payment he would take this young man's right hand. Weird story, but anyway, the moral here is, take the guru's teaching to heart. Distance would then not be an issue. > > Peace, > Shankari Kali > > Mahadevan venkitaraman > , "henny_v_i" <henny_v_i@> wrote: > > > > Namaste Vish, > > > > I hope you can clear up some confusion that has arisen in my mind. > As > > I live at the other side of the planet from the Devi Mandir, > visiting > > for me is quite an undertaking, not to mention the careful > > introduction and preparation process needed in the family circle. I > am > > working on it, but need to plan and save and tread carefully. > > So I have been happy to plod along quietly, strengthened by the > idea > > that physical distance does not matter and that Maa and Swamiji are > in > > my heart, and so are all pilgrimage places. But now I hear that > > meditation cannot be taught by post or book, and I am wondering > what I > > have been doing all this time. I understand that those who live in > > close proximity to the Guru receive many blessings, and although I > > realize there are special blessings assocciated with being actually > > physically near the Guru, I have always derived comfort from the > > thought that there are many ways of being 'near' the Guru. Have I > > misunderstood the importance of physical presence? > > > > with love, > > Henny > > > > > > > > > > > > > Now that's room service! Choose from over 150,000 hotels > in 45,000 destinations on Travel to find your fit. > > > > > > The fish are biting. > Get more visitors on your site using Search Marketing. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 5, 2007 Report Share Posted February 5, 2007 Ahh , this is GREAT ! Thank you for posting this. I have learned more about the story from your post! These stories are so full of meaning and inspiration. Another interesting twist to the story: Drona told Arjuna that he would be the best in the world, but made him promise that, if they ever had to face each other in battle, that Arjuna would fight, and fight to kill. At the begining of the battle,when Arjuna temporarily lost his will to fight, one reason was that he saw his old master, Drona, in the ranks of the opposing army. Drona was sworn by duty to serve Duryondana, and had to fullfill his dharma, thus Arjuna and his master Drona wound up on opposing sides. Hari Krishna ! mahadevanv <mahadevanv > wrote: Om Namah Shivaya! The story has more meanings. Guru Drona taught about using high level weapons. And so he is not a Sadguru. He had his own protocol which says the weapons could be taught only to Princes. So he refused to teach Ekalavya who was a hunter boy. Ekalavya was determined to study weapon using and so he was able to do that. It shows a Guru is mandatory for spiritual progress and not for getting Worldly knowledge. If every Tom, Dick and Harry is having weapons with high destructive capability, who is to check them? Do they know where to use them? And if they use them aginst the King? If Drona is committed to the King, isn't he supposed to do something to check Ekalavya? Also can't Ekalavya use his intelligence to study things other than to be an expert in using destructive arms? Cheers, Mahadevan venkitaraman , Nirmalananda Saraswati <nirmalananda1008 wrote: > > Guru Drohna took the thumb of the right hand of the student, as payment because the student was originally rejected by Drona. Drona had said that Arjuna would be the best in the world, so he refused to teach the would be student. So, by taking the student's right thumb as payment, the young student could no longer function as an archer. It was because Drona did'nt want to teach him, but the boy created a murthi, and worshipped Drona anyway, and therefore he got the Darshan of the Guru, even when the Guru had forbidden it. In this wasy, he became a great archer. > > It's an interesting story. Just taking a guess at the meaning - Darshan of the Guru is possible even from a great distance, because of devotion. But, there is a warning here to be sure one has the permission of the Guru. Lucky for us, Maa and Swami are'nt as rutheless as Guru Drona was. (Drona was a Guru for warriors). Also, Maa and Swami want us to learn from them and develop pure love and devotion. > Jai Maa, Jai Swamiji > > Shankari Kali <shankari_kali wrote: Dear Henny: > > There is a story in the Mahabharata. It goes like this. There was a young man who wanted to learn archery from the great master, but he was too far away, and too poor to receive training. He wanted to study from the great master who was teaching Arjuna, but he could not. > > He created an image. It was the image of the master, and everyday he practiced. He became very adept, and finally one day the master did discover him, because he was far more skilled than even Arjuna. > > Of course the last part of the story is not so inspiring at least for me. The guru decided that for payment he would take this young man's right hand. Weird story, but anyway, the moral here is, take the guru's teaching to heart. Distance would then not be an issue. > > Peace, > Shankari Kali > > Mahadevan venkitaraman > , "henny_v_i" <henny_v_i@> wrote: > > > > Namaste Vish, > > > > I hope you can clear up some confusion that has arisen in my mind. > As > > I live at the other side of the planet from the Devi Mandir, > visiting > > for me is quite an undertaking, not to mention the careful > > introduction and preparation process needed in the family circle. I > am > > working on it, but need to plan and save and tread carefully. > > So I have been happy to plod along quietly, strengthened by the > idea > > that physical distance does not matter and that Maa and Swamiji are > in > > my heart, and so are all pilgrimage places. But now I hear that > > meditation cannot be taught by post or book, and I am wondering > what I > > have been doing all this time. I understand that those who live in > > close proximity to the Guru receive many blessings, and although I > > realize there are special blessings assocciated with being actually > > physically near the Guru, I have always derived comfort from the > > thought that there are many ways of being 'near' the Guru. Have I > > misunderstood the importance of physical presence? > > > > with love, > > Henny > > > > > > > > > > > > > Now that's room service! Choose from over 150,000 hotels > in 45,000 destinations on Travel to find your fit. > > > > > > The fish are biting. > Get more visitors on your site using Search Marketing. > Any questions? Get answers on any topic at Answers. Try it now. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.