Guest guest Posted November 28, 2006 Report Share Posted November 28, 2006 Arjuna exhausted himself and seemed to be at crossroads and said " I am utterly confused please tell me what is good for me. " He uses the word shreyas. So long he had been talking about what was preyas to him, what he wanted to do. .Now he was asking what he should do. Then and then only the Lord started talking .In our life too we go on telling the lord what to do and never ask Him what we should do. When we do ask He starts telling us what to do .Similarly when Arjuna said sishyastheham shaadhimaam thwaam prapannam, I am your desciple I surrender to you, only then Krishna starts giving him the advice because advice given unasked will not be taken well! Arjuna's arguments were blown into shreds by Krishna who says kuthasthwaam kashmalamidham vishame samupasthitham 'wherefrom did you get this nonsensical ideas at the most inopportune moment?' Krishna dismisses all the seemingly lofty arguments of Arjuna as being unaryajushtam ignoble, aswargyam that which shuts the gates of heaven for you , akeerthikaram disgraceful for a hero like you He calls it klaibyam unmanliness. Then comes the real reason for Arjuna's mental conflict. He says " How can I fight Bhishma and Drona on the battle field as they are worthy of my reverence? Finally he surrenders to the Lord by saying sishyastheham. Now starts the real discourse of Bhagavatgita. Krishna says asochyaananvasochasthwam prajnaavadhaamschabhashase`You are grieving over those who need not be grieved about.' What Krishna means here is that Bhishma and Drona had no compunction to fight against their own grandson and pupil respectively, not because they were heartless but because they had no confusion about their duty, svadharma like Arjuna. Further Krishna says that Arjuna had tried to conceal his confusion under his arguments as though they were words of wisdom prajnaavadhaamscha bhaashase. The arguments of Arjuna are ridiculed by Krishna because if he were really wise panditha he would not have worried over life and death. .Then Krishna starts giving Arjuna the divine wisdom. Nathwevaamham jathunaasam nathvam neme naradhipaah states Krishna, ' there was never a time when you, I, and all these men in front ceased to be nor will there be a time when we all will cease to be. This is the answer to the question who am I. You are not what you think you are , says the Lord .The anxiety about living and dying comes only through identifying yourself with the body. Death is not the end of you but it is only a change of circumstance. You are not overly worried about changing from boyhood to youth or to old age which you consider a natural occurrence. So too death is only natural change about which you need not worry. Then Krishna goes on to talk about what is real and what is transient Naasatho vidhyathe bhaavo naa bhaavo vidhyathe sathah, says Krishna. What exists can never cease to exist and what does not exist can never come into existence. This sounds like high philosophy but this can be applied to our everyday life. Most of our problems arise because we imagine something to be real when it is not. We identify ourselves with our body ,mind ,and intellect while the real `I' is different from all these. This can be verified through a simple exercise by trying to answer the question Who am I ? The obvious answer would be ` I .am so and so.' But that is only your name. You may say that I am father of so and so or husband of so and so. But it is only your relationship. Even when you say I am a professor or I am an intellectual, it only denotes your professional and intellectual status. So, who are you in reality ? We commonly speak about our body as when we say " My body aches all over. " This proves that you are not your body. Similarly when we use expressions like " My mind is upset " or " My intellect has failed to grasp this " it is obvious that we are separate from our mind and intellect. That the real self must be something different from our body, mind, and intellect we are able to perceive with no difficulty at all .But there is another `I' which we have to reckon with , and that is our ego, which is the consciousness that I am. Even this is absent when we are in deep sleep because we are not aware of ourselves then. But there is some entity who is aware of our existence even at that stage which makes us say that we had a sound sleep. This is the real `I' which is even different from our ego .This is what Krishna calls avinaasi or sariri. Except that , everything else can be termed as transitory or antavantah. All our experiences, joy and sorrow, heat and cold etc are also transitory ,which have to be endured. There is no stoicism involved in this as we cannot fail to see that all our problems or difficulties pass after some time whether we face them boldly or cringe away in fear. That is what Krishna means when He says that all experiences are due to the contact of the senses with the sense objects and they are fleeting and transitory aagamapayino anityaah and advises Arjuna to bear with them patiently .They have nothing to do with the real ' I 'which is the pure self, different from body mind and intellect. The real self is thus shown to be different from body, mind and intellect. Krishna tells Arjuna that it is impossible for him to kill anyone. Bhishma and Drona have existence beyond their bodies which are only outer covering and when one dies he only sheds off this body to acquire another as we discard our old clothes to put on new ones. This sounds alright if death occurs at old age when the body has become jeerna or old. But how can this analogy of discarding old clothes and putting on new ones be applied when death occurs at young age or childhood when the body cannot be termed as old? Jeerna here means that it had served its purpose. A body is acquired for the purpose of exhausting a particular karma and when the result of that karma has been experienced, that body has served its purpose and becomes jeerna. The residue of karma cannot be exhausted in that body and hence it is shed to acquire a different one suited for the purpose. So death is not something to be feared or grieved about at any age Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.