Guest guest Posted January 16, 2007 Report Share Posted January 16, 2007 Respected members, With so much negativity prevailing in the world, how can an ordinary mortal stand up and believe in God? He does not get justice in this world for his righteous deeds, then how can he believe in the loving God? Kindly clarify Sundeep GOD STOPS GOOD PEOPLE FROM DOING WRONG BUT NOT THE RUTHLESS, THE POWER HUNGRY AND SELFISH PEOPLE. THEY REMAIN ENGAGED IN LUST FOR POWER AND MONEY AND LACK HUMANITY. THE HELPLESS LEAVE EVERYTHING TO GOD, BUT AT TIMES IT APPEARS AS IF GOD FAILS THEM. WHERE IS RIGHTEOUSNESS AND JUSTICE? N. PANDA - FROM MODERATOR Ram Ram, The following are the guidelines for Gita-Talk discussions. 1. Wherever possible, please quote Gita or other scriptures to substantiate the response 2. Kindly make your responses concise and to the point. (Up to twenty line maximum, if possible). 3. Please limit discussions to subject at hand. 4. Please do not include links to other sites or other organizations Ram Ram Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2007 Report Share Posted January 16, 2007 This is what I read somewhere for the similar kind of questions you mentioned below. It was a dark night and rainy and stormy weather. I was walking in my neighbourhood and saw a little girl shivering in the cold. I asked God with my full heart as to what is God doing..where is God..how can he make a samll little girl suffer like this? I was surprised to hear some voice..it was God..He said: "I understand your feeling..that is why I made you " What I feel is ..this is my opinion: Yes, there is corruption, problems, ruthlessness etc etc.. but again, at the same time, there is also kindness, generosity, love, affection, care ,concern etc etc. Do not worry if there is corruption or whatever....do whatever you can to the less fortunate compared to you and that is what matters. I feel this Bhagavadgita is meant to understand the higher Self by which we understand these scenarios step by step. Regards. . Regards.sundeepgupta1 <sundeepgupta1 wrote: Respected members,With so much negativity prevailing in the world, how can an ordinary mortal stand up and believe in God? He does not get justice in this world for his righteous deeds, then how can he believe in the loving God?Kindly clarifySundeep-------------------------GOD STOPS GOOD PEOPLE FROM DOING WRONG BUT NOT THE RUTHLESS, THE POWER HUNGRY AND SELFISH PEOPLE. THEY REMAIN ENGAGED IN LUST FOR POWER AND MONEY AND LACK HUMANITY. THE HELPLESS LEAVE EVERYTHING TO GOD, BUT AT TIMES IT APPEARS AS IF GOD FAILS THEM. WHERE IS RIGHTEOUSNESS AND JUSTICE? N. PANDA-------------------------FROM MODERATORRam Ram,The following are the guidelines for Gita-Talk discussions. 1. Wherever possible, please quote Gita or other scriptures tosubstantiate the response2. Kindly make your responses concise and to the point. (Up totwenty line maximum, if possible).3. Please limit discussions to subject at hand. 4. Please do not include links to other sites or other organizationsRam Ram Don't pick lemons. See all the new 2007 cars at Autos. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2007 Report Share Posted January 16, 2007 Dear Ones, namaste! By thinking "so much negativity prevailing in this world" we are adding to the negativity by such thoughts, isn't it? How can we stop such negative thoughts is the real first issue. Secondly isn't it a problematic to think oneself as ordinary mortal man who is at the mercy of world for his believing in God? Saints and Sages took upon themselves to know God inspite of injustices done to them. If one understands very very deeply what God or he, or this world is, and how they are related, one would surely find answers to such questions as some seemingly ordinary people all over the world in all times have found! This would suggest that the question could be rephrased as how can one live in this world that is so unjust? That is the core issue because that puts responsibility where it belongs and not on God as someone sitting somewhere separately from his creation and supposed to do justice for various people whose interest are in conflict with one another. Our problems are due to our taking ourselves as separate individuals, resulting into conflicts with each other. So those of us who are interested in Moksha, can discover that we are not individuals, limited, mortal beings but rather Signicant, always Purna in Ourselves without lacking anything world has to offer, always free, and thus live happily and cross the ocean of bhav-sagar-suffering! God has never failed those that knew Him/Her as very Core of their being! , "sundeepgupta1" <sundeepgupta1 wrote:>> Respected members,> > With so much negativity prevailing in the world, how can an ordinary> mortal stand up and believe in God? He does not get justice in this> world for his righteous deeds, then how can he believe in the loving> God?> > Kindly clarify> > Sundeep> > GOD STOPS GOOD PEOPLE FROM DOING WRONG BUT NOT THE RUTHLESS, THE POWER HUNGRY AND SELFISH PEOPLE. THEY REMAIN ENGAGED IN LUST FOR POWER AND MONEY AND LACK HUMANITY. THE HELPLESS LEAVE EVERYTHING TO GOD, BUT AT TIMES IT APPEARS AS IF GOD FAILS THEM. WHERE IS RIGHTEOUSNESS AND JUSTICE?> > N. PANDA> -> > FROM MODERATOR> Ram Ram,> > The following are the guidelines for Gita-Talk discussions.> > 1. Wherever possible, please quote Gita or other scriptures to> substantiate the response> > 2. Kindly make your responses concise and to the point. (Up to> twenty line maximum, if possible).> > 3. Please limit discussions to subject at hand.> > 4. Please do not include links to other sites or other organizations> > Ram Ram> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 17, 2007 Report Share Posted January 17, 2007 Wonderful. Well said. It is we who have to bell the cat. See only the positiveness in everything and just ignore the negative. It does tremendous good for our own spiritual progress. Love and Love alone.... P. Gopi Krishna ------ Kashmira Grewal Your query about how an ordinary mortal being is supposed to stand up and believe in God with so much negativity prevailing in the world, does merit reflection. But first you need to know of and believe one truth about the numerous cycles of life that we go thru. It is called 'The Game of Life'. In each cycle that we are born in, we work out our Karmas that we created in the previous lives and depending on the good or the bad of it, we fashion our lives accordingly. For the often heard wails of people around us, that those who indulge in every thing that is immoral and wrong seem to have everything and live wonderful lives, and those of us who are God fearing and do everything right are the ones to suffer - the reason is this.... When we have lead a good life, braving all odds, and having taken upon us all the agonies and the harshness of the material world, but not surrendered to evil, we are given an opportunity so full of abundance in our future lives that it would seem we have the world at our feet. Power is one aspect of this. Now what we do with this chance that we have been blessed with, will determine the kind of life we will lead in our next cycle. So, though it may sound unfair or even preposterous to the uninitiated mind, the right thing for each and everyone of us to do would be to concentrate on our Selves, keep our house clean, meaning our Inner Self, try and spread the good word around, and do not worry about who listens and doesn't. Help those who call out for it, do not consciously give in to temptations, however innocent it may seem to you. In short, we reap the harvest of what we have sown now in the next cycle. God is Supreme, and the Creator, but what most of us forget is that he has given us a free choice, a free will, and it is WE who are responsible for the heaven or the hell that we create for ourselves. And because He has created us, there can't be any doubt about the fact that He loves us too - like I said before, this is His Game, and we are but Characters who play out the roles. We are given a format, and then we are also given the ability to decipher this format. Depending on our integrity and our understanding of Him, we create the picture and the sound effects. There is NO Heaven or Hell, as commonly perceived by us - both are in effect our own Conscience. If you create a good record for yourself, you are living 'in Heaven', and if it is the other then you are living in a hell of your own making. So, coming back to your query, you shouldn't concern yourself with the 'negativity' prevailing around you - that is someone else's consequences being made public. Concentrate on YOUR OWN creations. Learn and practice to be in touch with your Inner Self. Learn to listen to your conscience - you can only do this if you shut out the unnecessary noise which are your thoughts. Do not allow distractions to misguide you or worse still, don't use this as an excuse for not doing what you know deep down to be the right thing for you. I hope that you have, for the moment been satisfied by this very sketchy explanation. I hope that this will prompt you to look for answers on a greater level, and I pray that may He guide you to the right place to look for them. It is said, that when we finally awaken, and honestly look for help He gives it to us - we don't need to wander, looking for it, because when we encounter it, we WILL recongnise it for what it is!. I am sure that you have finally reached the point of retribution, because if you hadn't you would be here asking questions. God Bless Regards, Kashmira Grewal ----------- From Avadhoot Maharaj Dear Souls; This is the age of Kali, the age of quarrel and dissension. As predicted in the Bhagavat Purana or Srimad Bhagavatam this age will progressively get worse until at the end there are no devotees of the Lord left on the planet. At that time the Lord incarnates in His form as Kalki to annihilate all the demons and reestablish 'dharma'. So, if things appear to be getting worse all the time it is the sign of the times. Eventually, due to sinful activities there will be no more rain, no more vegetation. Man will be forced to eat man. Still, there is one good thing about this dreadful age and that is this. According to the Vedic shastra man can very easily achieve liberation in this age simply by 'Kalau tad hari kirtanat' or glorifying the Supreme Lord Hari or Krishna. If we use our valuable time in speaking Hari Katha or talks about the Supreme Lord we shall not be affected by all the terrible things of this world and in the end go back Home, back to Godhead. Hare Krishna, avadhoot -- Bharathi <bh_4321 wrote: This is what I read somewhere for the similar kind of questions you mentioned below. It was a dark night and rainy and stormy weather. I was walking in my neighbourhood and saw a little girl shivering in the cold. I asked God with my full heart as to what is God doing..where is God..how can he make a samll little girl suffer like this? I was surprised to hear some voice..it was God..He said: "I understand your feeling..that is why I made you " What I feel is ..this is my opinion: Yes, there is corruption, problems, ruthlessness etc etc.. but again, at the same time, there is also kindness, generosity, love, affection, care ,concern etc etc. Do not worry if there is corruption or whatever....do whatever you can to the less fortunate compared to you and that is what matters. I feel this Bhagavadgita is meant to understand the higher Self by which we understand these scenarios step by step. Regards. . Regards.sundeepgupta1 <sundeepgupta1 > wrote: Respected members,With so much negativity prevailing in the world, how can an ordinary mortal stand up and believe in God? He does not get justice in this world for his righteous deeds, then how can he believe in the loving God?Kindly clarifySundeep-------------------------GOD STOPS GOOD PEOPLE FROM DOING WRONG BUT NOT THE RUTHLESS, THE POWER HUNGRY AND SELFISH PEOPLE. THEY REMAIN ENGAGED IN LUST FOR POWER AND MONEY AND LACK HUMANITY. THE HELPLESS LEAVE EVERYTHING TO GOD, BUT AT TIMES IT APPEARS AS IF GOD FAILS THEM. WHERE IS RIGHTEOUSNESS AND JUSTICE? N. PANDA-------------------------FROM MODERATORRam Ram,The following are the guidelines for Gita-Talk discussions. 1. Wherever possible, please quote Gita or other scriptures tosubstantiate the response2. Kindly make your responses concise and to the point. (Up totwenty line maximum, if possible).3. Please limit discussions to subject at hand. 4. Please do not include links to other sites or other organizationsRam Ram Don't pick lemons.See all the new 2007 cars at Autos. P. Gopi Krishna Here’s a new way to find what you're looking for - Answers Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 19, 2007 Report Share Posted January 19, 2007 Respected members, ram ram The question here is how an ordinary mortal believe in God even if he is getting injustice in world. I shall understand it in that way : As mentioned in GITA, self is non-doer means three modes of material nature are only working. Again it is mentioned, that work which is done with expectation of fruit binds the soul to its fruit which can be good, bad or mixed. In case of ordinary mortal like us actions are performed with attachment and liable to get results. It is law of karma which operates and gives us good and bad results. The good person gets injustice, it is the reaction of its previous karma which he is receiving. We should remember that we receive the fruits of our actions which we might have done in previous births. There is a huge accumulation of our actions of previous births. At right time and place, we receive reaction to our action we did in past. The nature of a person never remains same, depending on what modes of nature one has acquired, one acts accordingly. The ordinary mortal when proceeds the spiritual path, slowly slowly reduce the power of karma. He knows that he should bear pleasure and pain with equanimity, as no further action should be issued out beacause of good or bad reaction he received from nature. In conclusion, we should see an immortal self in ordinary mortal who has lived countless births and did all kinds of karmas. When he receives injustice, he should feel that he is blessed as his bad karma is burning out. But, nature is very strong till one achieves jnana or realisation, this reaction to life is very difficult. We should struggle hard and surrender all injustice or justice to Lord's lotus feet. Lord is loving but he does not interfere in nature's work till one is exclusiely devoted to him. Hari om Vipin Gupta -- dear gita members,let us understand that "what ever happens, happens for good" and let us provide warmth, love and affection to sufferers and let us provide if we can, food , jobs, shelter to such souls,gita - ism seshadri Seshadri Srinivasan Namaste, A related question, Can good be defined in the absence of bad ? A good person or action exists only because we perceive a bad person or action to exist. In my view, one cannot exist in the absence of another. If there are some examples to the contrary, I would love to hear them Hari Om Suhas -------- Bharathi <bh_4321 wrote: This is what I read somewhere for the similar kind of questions you mentioned below. It was a dark night and rainy and stormy weather. I was walking in my neighbourhood and saw a little girl shivering in the cold. I asked God with my full heart as to what is God doing..where is God..how can he make a samll little girl suffer like this? I was surprised to hear some voice..it was God..He said: "I understand your feeling..that is why I made you " What I feel is ..this is my opinion: Yes, there is corruption, problems, ruthlessness etc etc.. but again, at the same time, there is also kindness, generosity, love, affection, care ,concern etc etc. Do not worry if there is corruption or whatever....do whatever you can to the less fortunate compared to you and that is what matters. I feel this Bhagavadgita is meant to understand the higher Self by which we understand these scenarios step by step. Regards. . Regards.sundeepgupta1 <sundeepgupta1 > wrote: Respected members,With so much negativity prevailing in the world, how can an ordinary mortal stand up and believe in God? He does not get justice in this world for his righteous deeds, then how can he believe in the loving God?Kindly clarifySundeep-------------------------GOD STOPS GOOD PEOPLE FROM DOING WRONG BUT NOT THE RUTHLESS, THE POWER HUNGRY AND SELFISH PEOPLE. THEY REMAIN ENGAGED IN LUST FOR POWER AND MONEY AND LACK HUMANITY. THE HELPLESS LEAVE EVERYTHING TO GOD, BUT AT TIMES IT APPEARS AS IF GOD FAILS THEM. WHERE IS RIGHTEOUSNESS AND JUSTICE? N. PANDA-------------------------FROM MODERATORRam Ram,The following are the guidelines for Gita-Talk discussions. 1. Wherever possible, please quote Gita or other scriptures tosubstantiate the response2. Kindly make your responses concise and to the point. (Up totwenty line maximum, if possible).3. Please limit discussions to subject at hand. 4. Please do not include links to other sites or other organizationsRam Ram Don't pick lemons. See all the new 2007 cars at Autos. Here’s a new way to find what you're looking for - Answers Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 20, 2007 Report Share Posted January 20, 2007 Respected members, ram ram The question here is how an ordinary mortal believe in God even if he is getting injustice in world. I shall understand it in that way : As mentioned in GITA, self is non-doer means three modes of material nature are only working. Again it is mentioned, that work which is done with doership and expectation of fruit, binds the soul to its fruit which can be good, bad or mixed. When actions are performed with attachment the law of karma operates giving good and bad results. A good person receiving injustice is the reaction of his previous karmas even from past births, which he is receiving. At right time and place, we receive reaction to our action we did in the past. When one takes up the spiritual path, bearing pleasure and pain with equanimity, losing a sense of doership, this limits the good or bad reactions. In conclusion, when injustice is received one should feel that he is blessed as his bad karma is burning away. But, nature is very strong till one achieves jnana or realisation. Attaining this state is difficult, however it is easily attainable, when we surrender everything to Lord's lotus feet. Lord is loving but He does not interfere in nature's work till one is exclusively devoted to Him. Hari om Vipin , " sundeepgupta1 " <sundeepgupta1 wrote: > > Respected members, > > With so much negativity prevailing in the world, how can an ordinary > mortal stand up and believe in God? He does not get justice in this > world for his righteous deeds, then how can he believe in the loving > God? > > Kindly clarify > > Sundeep > > GOD STOPS GOOD PEOPLE FROM DOING WRONG BUT NOT THE RUTHLESS, THE POWER HUNGRY AND SELFISH PEOPLE. THEY REMAIN ENGAGED IN LUST FOR POWER AND MONEY AND LACK HUMANITY. THE HELPLESS LEAVE EVERYTHING TO GOD, BUT AT TIMES IT APPEARS AS IF GOD FAILS THEM. WHERE IS RIGHTEOUSNESS AND JUSTICE? > > N. PANDA > - > > FROM MODERATOR > Ram Ram, > > The following are the guidelines for Gita-Talk discussions. > > 1. Wherever possible, please quote Gita or other scriptures to > substantiate the response > > 2. Kindly make your responses concise and to the point. (Up to > twenty line maximum, if possible). > > 3. Please limit discussions to subject at hand. > > 4. Please do not include links to other sites or other organizations > > Ram Ram > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2007 Report Share Posted January 23, 2007 Namaste, While I agree with the views below, from an intellectual stand point, o The world is apparently just and unjust. From any worldly perspective, it is not perfectly just or perfectly unjust. o The good and bad, or satwa, rajas and tamas are required for creation. Without an of these qualities, there cannot be creation. (Chp 14) o Without problems man will never excercise his intellect. And unless he faces serious problems, he never seriously thinks of the spiritual path. (7-16 onwards) A little bit of thought and one can see that a perfect world is actually unlivable. Bottomline is we should not worry about things we cannot change and concentrate on lifting ourselves. By lifting ourselves we lift the world around us as well Hari Om Suhas , " vipin2k0892002 " <vipin2k0892002 wrote: > > Respected members, > ram ram > > The question here is how an ordinary mortal believe in God even if he > is getting injustice in world. I shall understand it in that way : > As mentioned in GITA, self is non-doer means three modes of material > nature are only working. Again it is mentioned, that work which is done with doership and expectation of fruit, binds the soul to its fruit which can be good, bad or mixed. When actions are performed with attachment the law of karma operates giving good and bad results. A good person receiving injustice is the reaction of his previous karmas even from past births, which he is receiving. At right time and place, we receive reaction to our action we did in the past. > > When one takes up the spiritual path, bearing pleasure and > pain with equanimity, losing a sense of doership, this limits the good or bad reactions. > > In conclusion, when injustice is received one should feel that he is blessed as his bad karma is burning away. But, nature is very strong till one achieves jnana or realisation. Attaining this state is difficult, however it is easily attainable, when we surrender everything to Lord's lotus feet. Lord is loving but He does not interfere in nature's work till one is exclusively devoted to Him. > > Hari om > Vipin > > , " sundeepgupta1 " <sundeepgupta1@> > wrote: > > > > Respected members, > > > > With so much negativity prevailing in the world, how can an ordinary > > mortal stand up and believe in God? He does not get justice in this > > world for his righteous deeds, then how can he believe in the loving > > God? > > > > Kindly clarify > > > > Sundeep > > -------------------------------- - > > GOD STOPS GOOD PEOPLE FROM DOING WRONG BUT NOT THE RUTHLESS, THE > POWER HUNGRY AND SELFISH PEOPLE. THEY REMAIN ENGAGED IN LUST FOR POWER > AND MONEY AND LACK HUMANITY. THE HELPLESS LEAVE EVERYTHING TO GOD, BUT > AT TIMES IT APPEARS AS IF GOD FAILS THEM. WHERE IS RIGHTEOUSNESS AND > JUSTICE? > > > > N. PANDA > > -------------------------------- -- > > > > FROM MODERATOR > > Ram Ram, > > > > The following are the guidelines for Gita-Talk discussions. > > > > 1. Wherever possible, please quote Gita or other scriptures to > > substantiate the response > > > > 2. Kindly make your responses concise and to the point. (Up to > > twenty line maximum, if possible). > > > > 3. Please limit discussions to subject at hand. > > > > 4. Please do not include links to other sites or other organizations > > > > Ram Ram > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.