Guest guest Posted January 17, 2009 Report Share Posted January 17, 2009 Dear Sadhakas, Namaste! As pointed out by Moderatorji in the " Transition from Read-Learned Knowledge to Experiential Knowledge-Realization " , Karmas can be taken as separate topic by itself, so I would share my understanding to start with and invite comments. As Bhagwan says in Gita, Gahana karmanau gatih!(Pardon my sanskrit). Intricate are the ways of Karmas. Gita also teaches that " I " am not body-mind based limited individual I think, believe and act (as if I am body-mind). I am without any limitations is the main theme of Gita. (Swamiji says Paramatman is already attained/realized). In I am, " am " is sat, and " I " is Chit- knowingness! This body identification is clearly ignorance, and thus my being individual is also ignorance. An individual also thinks he/she is the doer of all karmas performed, and therefore he/she becomes bhokta (enjoyer) of fruits of actions leading him/her to swing between pairs of opposites such as pains and pleasures throughout the life. Actions originate from conditioning/sanskaras which he inherited from the environment around him/her while growing up. Because actions are done through the body-mind that he considers his (ignorance), these actions become his, not otherwise in themselves, actions are impersonal, and choice is dictated by conditioning (likes/dislikes). Mind is conditioned and doesn't even know it is! The environment is mass karmas or impressions on human consciousness from the beginning of the creation. These impressions are like a pool or stream of karmas, good and bad sanskaras due to thoughts and deeds of people like Gandhi, Hitler, mother Teresa, leaders of our times, wars, and so on. Actually these karmas/conditioning manifesting through individuals in different times, and places. It is as if these karmas are recycled/reincarnated through different bodies, and minds until some minds realize their essential nature is Atman, Pure Existence- Consciousness, Impersonal, Divine. Karmas cannot touch such Atman, as It is experiential realization. It is said that Karmas,as though, get burnt upon realization, as they were all committed in ignorance of SELF. Memory returns to such a one that one is ever Atman-self. Gita Ch 18: Nashto moha, smritirlabhthwa.... So in an impersonal way the reincarnation of conditioning/karmas/mind/soul continues across all generations and in all places, via the births and deaths of bodies made up of integration of five great elements, carrying causal bodies of such ignorance! Thus it is seen that individual is illusion and as such individual doer and hence karmas are also equally illusion in the wake of Self- knowledge! In shankara's Aparokshanubhuti, verses 90 onward emphasize this point negating even the prarabdha karmas for an individual which happen to bodies and not to Realized One. So it is more important to be free of such ignorance living in us as individual Karta-doer and karmas will lose their credence. Then Everything unfolds as it should by God, for God, to God! Namaskar................Pratap Bhatt ---------------------------- SUMMARY OF SADHAK POSTINGS - Intricate are the ways of Karmas - Individual due to body-mind association, thinks he is doer and enjoyer, purely out of ignorance - Karmas cannot touch such Atman - Actions are impersonal - On knowledge of true nature (Self, Atma) memory returns, all attachments vanish. (Nashtomoha smrittirlabdhvaa) - Let us be free from ignorance for it is by God, for God, to God. ------------------------------ GITA TALK GROUP GUIDELINES: PLEASE - 1. Only responses that further clarify Gita message will be posted. 2. Quote Gitaji/scriptures wherever possible.. 3. Limit personal feelings, opinions, beliefs etc. to the extent that they further help in understanding the Gita shlokas 4. Be as concise, to the point, respecting sadhaka's time. 5. Focus on subject at hand only. 6. Do not include links to the other sites. 7. Do not include your personal information (Ph #, address etc). 8. Do not personalize message 9. All responses may not be posted. 10. Moderator at his discretion, may modify the posting. 11. Take into consideration the novices, youth, westerners, non- sectarian audience. i.e. limit the use to Sanskrit words only. Provide English word bracketed. MODERATOR Ram Ram ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- Post message: Subscribe: - Un: - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 19, 2009 Report Share Posted January 19, 2009 Dear Sadhakas, Namaste! As pointed out by Moderatorji in the " Transition from Read-Learned Knowledge to Experiential Knowledge-Realization " , Karmas can be taken as separate topic by itself, so I would share my understanding to start with and invite comments. As Bhagwan says in Gita, Gahana karmanau gatih!(Pardon my sanskrit). Intricate are the ways of Karmas. Gita also teaches that " I " am not body-mind based limited individual I think, believe and act (as if I am body-mind). I am without any limitations is the main theme of Gita. (Swamiji says Paramatman is already attained/realized). In I am, " am " is sat, and " I " is Chit-knowingness! This body identification is clearly ignorance, and thus my being individual is also ignorance. An individual also thinks he/she is the doer of all karmas performed, and therefore he/she becomes bhokta (enjoyer) of fruits of actions leading him/her to swing between pairs of opposites such as pains and pleasures throughout the life. Actions originate from conditioning/sanskaras which he inherited from the environment around him/her while growing up. Because actions are done through the body-mind that he considers his (ignorance), these actions become his, not otherwise in themselves, actions are impersonal, and choice is dictated by conditioning (likes/dislikes). Mind is conditioned and doesn't even know it is! The environment is mass karmas or impressions on human consciousness from the beginning of the creation. These impressions are like a pool or stream of karmas, good and bad sanskaras due to thoughts and deeds of people like Gandhi, Hitler, mother Teresa, leaders of our times, wars, and so on. Actually these karmas/conditioning manifesting through individuals in different times, and places. It is as if these karmas are recycled/reincarnated through different bodies, and minds until some minds realize their essential nature is Atman, Pure Existence- Consciousness, Impersonal, Divine. Karmas cannot touch such Atman, as It is experiential realization. It is said that Karmas,as though, get burnt upon realization, as they were all committed in ignorance of SELF. Memory returns to such a one that one is ever Atman-self. Gita Ch 18: Nashto moha, smritirlabhthwa.... So in an impersonal way the reincarnation of conditioning/karmas/mind/soul continues across all generations and in all places, via the births and deaths of bodies made up of integration of five great elements, carrying causal bodies of such ignorance! Thus it is seen that individual is illusion and as such individual doer and hence karmas are also equally illusion in the wake of Self- knowledge! In shankara's Aparokshanubhuti, verses 90 onward emphasize this point negating even the prarabdha karmas for an individual which happen to bodies and not to Realized One. So it is more important to be free of such ignorance living in us as individual Karta-doer and karmas will lose their credence. Then Everything unfolds as it should by God, for God, to God! Namaskar................Pratap Bhatt ---------------------------- NEW POSTING Hari Om. The purpose of Gita is to free us from life cycle and bondage of birth cycle. ITs v.v.easy to understand with a small example. A thief is brought before the magistrate to analyze if he is an accused. The magistrate asks the thief 'Did you do this crime?' The thief says,'Yes sir!' He is given a punishment for his action! He goes to jail to undergo his punishment. The same way whatever we do are recorded by our sense organs and is stored in 'Chith'. Whatever we do good or bad, we get reward or punishment for the same. This is known as Karma bondage. But whatever we do if we attach everything to the Lotus feet of Krushna, He becomes the advocate for us and he takes care of us. Now the whole karma bondage path changes. We dont attach ourselves to the result of any action we do. We say that everything is left to Krushna. So there is no impressions of the actions done by us in our Chith. This is the first step to free us from this life and death cycle. Hari OM. With regards, Ushasridhar. Namasthe (leaving the good or bad of this karma to Krushna) ----------------------- Dear sadak, Ref: Sri Pratap writing ---Becoming Free from Karma Bondage - Actions, Impressions, Doer ship, Enjoyability. When attachment towards world, family, friends, taste, touch, Etc are there, what Sri Pratab said exits. When detachments obtained, What Sri Pratab said automatically dispels. From the actions of Karma with attachment-- " I " , " ME " -- " MINE " comes bondage, doer ship etc. Ex: When Sant Samartha Ramadoss child died falling in big vessel of water, He said, " Bagavan probably gave this child only short life span in which it said Ram Ram during Bajan and gone to Sri Ram " . When Sant Tukaram was offered Pushpaka Viman (flying chariot) to Vaikunt, he simply sat and went unmindfull to even bid bye to his children and wife. Sant Purander Doss was very rich man. On seeing Bagavan in his diamond ring just abandonded crores of property, went to Panderpur. When people asked how he is going to live? He said, " when Bagavan is taking care of whole Visvam, HE will also take care of me " . Sant Kulasekar Alwar was in direct contact with Sri Ranganather (Sri Vishnu). His son until age of 32 could not be married. His wife pleaded him to ask with God. Kulasekar was singing in praise of- Bagavan in temple Sri Rangam. As he was about to come out, he remembered his wife` s plea. Went in and started again singing about God. It happened 3 times. Out of temple 4th time, he thought what is this bondage my son and his wedding stupid. Then Paramathuma called him and said, " Hey Kulasekar Go your son will get married " . Jai Devar of poori jaganath determined to be bachelor life time. But when God Jaganath said in his dream, someone will approach him for giving a girl in wedding to him, Jaidev was calm. Next day a Batt came to Jai Dev and said that in his dream God asked to marry his daughter Padmavathi to Jai Dev who is in Ashram only by himself. But for wish of Jaganath he gladly got married. Padmavathi and Jai dev showed very great role about Bakthi not about any attachment. So Karma Bondage - Actions, Impressions, Doership, Enjoyership, all vanishes by itself when attachment goes. No need to try to release them, they get lost by themselves. It is like bad company goes away when one emerges into Sat Sangh. Bad company and Sat Sangh cannot be together. Partly this and partly that will only end up in more bondage, Karmas, Doer Ship. Jai Sri Krishna baiya sathyanarayan --------------------------- SUMMARY OF SADHAK POSTINGS - Intricate are the ways of Karmas - Individual due to body-mind association, thinks he is doer and enjoyer, body identification is purely out of ignorance - Karmas cannot touch such Atman - Actions are impersonal; choice is dictated by likes-dislikes (conditioning) - actions with attachment-- " I " , " ME " -- " MINE " leads to bondage, doer ship - when attachment goes, Actions, Impressions, Doership, Enjoyership, all vanishes by itself like bad company and satsang cannot coexist. - When one dedicates actions to the Lotus feet of Lord Krishna, there is no binding influence of karmas. - On knowledge of true nature (Self, Atma) memory returns, all attachments vanish. (Nashtomoha smrittirlabdhvaa) - Let us be free from ignorance for it is by God, for God, to God. ------------------------------ GITA TALK GROUP GUIDELINES: PLEASE - 1. Only responses that further clarify Gita message will be posted. 2. Quote Gitaji/scriptures wherever possible.. 3. Limit personal feelings, opinions, beliefs etc. to the extent that they further help in understanding the Gita shlokas 4. Be as concise, to the point, respecting sadhaka's time. 5. Focus on subject at hand only. 6. Do not include links to the other sites. 7. Do not include your personal information (Ph #, address etc). 8. Do not personalize message 9. All responses may not be posted. 10. Moderator at his discretion, may modify the posting. 11. Take into consideration the novices, youth, westerners, non- sectarian audience. i.e. limit the use to Sanskrit words only. Provide English word bracketed. MODERATOR Ram Ram ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- Post message: Subscribe: - Un: - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 5, 2009 Report Share Posted February 5, 2009 Dear Sadhakas, Namaste! As pointed out by Moderatorji in the " Transition from Read-Learned Knowledge to Experiential Knowledge-Realization " , Karmas can be taken as separate topic by itself, so I would share my understanding to start with and invite comments. As Bhagwan says in Gita, Gahana karmanau gatih!(Pardon my sanskrit). Intricate are the ways of Karmas. Gita also teaches that " I " am not body-mind based limited individual I think, believe and act (as if I am body-mind). I am without any limitations is the main theme of Gita. (Swamiji says Paramatman is already attained/realized). In I am, " am " is sat, and " I " is Chit- knowingness! This body identification is clearly ignorance, and thus my being individual is also ignorance. An individual also thinks he/she is the doer of all karmas performed, and therefore he/she becomes bhokta (enjoyer) of fruits of actions leading him/her to swing between pairs of opposites such as pains and pleasures throughout the life. Actions originate from conditioning/sanskaras which he inherited from the environment around him/her while growing up. Because actions are done through the body-mind that he considers his (ignorance), these actions become his, not otherwise in themselves, actions are impersonal, and choice is dictated by conditioning (likes/dislikes). Mind is conditioned and doesn't even know it is! The environment is mass karmas or impressions on human consciousness from the beginning of the creation. These impressions are like a pool or stream of karmas, good and bad sanskaras due to thoughts and deeds of people like Gandhi, Hitler, mother Teresa, leaders of our times, wars, and so on. Actually these karmas/conditioning manifesting through individuals in different times, and places. It is as if these karmas are recycled/reincarnated through different bodies, and minds until some minds realize their essential nature is Atman, Pure Existence- Consciousness, Impersonal, Divine. Karmas cannot touch such Atman, as It is experiential realization. It is said that Karmas,as though, get burnt upon realization, as they were all committed in ignorance of SELF. Memory returns to such a one that one is ever Atman-self. Gita Ch 18: Nashto moha, smritirlabhthwa.... So in an impersonal way the reincarnation of conditioning/karmas/mind/soul continues across all generations and in all places, via the births and deaths of bodies made up of integration of five great elements, carrying causal bodies of such ignorance! Thus it is seen that individual is illusion and as such individual doer and hence karmas are also equally illusion in the wake of Self- knowledge! In shankara's Aparokshanubhuti, verses 90 onward emphasize this point negating even the prarabdha karmas for an individual which happen to bodies and not to Realized One. So it is more important to be free of such ignorance living in us as individual Karta-doer and karmas will lose their credence. Then Everything unfolds as it should by God, for God, to God! Namaskar................Pratap Bhatt --------------------------- Dear Sadhak Regarding our actions very human being is judged by the law of Karma.If we surrender to Lord Krishna still however we have to get results as per of Karmas( actions ) Truly yours S S Bhatt ---------------------------- NEW POSTING Dear Sadhakas, Namaste! Based on Sathyanaranaji's comments, I would like to re-emphasize the point made here. On the path of inquiry/knowledge, one doesn't have to do anything, because if " doing " such as giving up attachment involves " a doer " then it is not going to give up attachment to " I " , " me " and " mine " . In fact one has to understand deeply that sense of " I " or " me " cannot free itself from attachment, because " attachment " is the nature of " I " . Why? because " I " is so inadequate, insufficient in itself due to perceived isolation from Totality, Godhood, so it will attract or repel to complete itself, unfortunately through objects. See the fact of our experience, when there is attachment for a " thing " or person is happening in the moments, there are only feelings-thoughts(of attachment) breeding in our consciousness (awareness), there is no " me " or I in our experience, but we take ourselves to be " I/me " as if it is permanently there. This creates duality of " me " and " expectations from " thing " or person in moments, all only in our mind(in consciousness, really). Both are in the same mind, artificially divided as two creating the trouble for us. Experientially There is ONLY " ONE CONSCIOUSNESS " appearing as two " me " , the body identified person, and attachment for " other " . Both are perceived objects of Consciousness we are! Can one just see this, just be there without doing anything, just witness as it unfolds? If one can, attachment withers away! " No such " I/me " exists in our experience, is crucial breakthrough and a giant leap toward giving up attachment and hosts of other problems that go with it, naturally. That which doesn't exist, how can one be attached to it, or get rid of? So no " I " or " me " , therefore " mine " goes out the door. Then, no " doer either " . Then only Karmas as needed/guided by this understanding, but no " my Karmas " or " my fruits " . All is God's prasadam. Then no bondage either. The root of all attachment is " me " so just tackle that with this inquiry/understanding! Lord Krishna says this in Gita but it may not be coming out that way until or unless one takes all chapters of Gita to bear upon our understanding. One cannot take one verse at a time in isolation and interpret it to derive any meaningful implementaion in our life. This is my respectful and humble seeing, dear Sadhakas! Namaskar......... Pratap Bhatt ---------------------------- SUMMARY OF SADHAK POSTINGS - Intricate are the ways of Karmas - Individual due to body-mind association, thinks he is doer and enjoyer, purely out of ignorance - Karmas cannot touch such Atman - Actions are impersonal - On knowledge of true nature (Self, Atma) memory returns, all attachments vanish. (Nashtomoha smrittirlabdhvaa) - Let us be free from ignorance for it is by God, for God, to God. ------------------------------ GITA TALK GROUP GUIDELINES: PLEASE - 1. Only responses that further clarify Gita message will be posted. 2. Quote Gitaji/scriptures wherever possible.. 3. Limit personal feelings, opinions, beliefs etc. to the extent that they further help in understanding the Gita shlokas 4. Be as concise, to the point, respecting sadhaka's time. 5. Focus on subject at hand only. 6. Do not include links to the other sites. 7. Do not include your personal information (Ph #, address etc). 8. Do not personalize message 9. All responses may not be posted. 10. Moderator at his discretion, may modify the posting. 11. Take into consideration the novices, youth, westerners, non- sectarian audience. i.e. limit the use to Sanskrit words only. Provide English word bracketed. MODERATOR Ram Ram ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- Post message: Subscribe: - Un: - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.