Guest guest Posted September 12, 2008 Report Share Posted September 12, 2008 ADIYEN,MY THAGAPANAAR ATTAINED SRI VAIKUNTAM ON 16TH FEB'2006.I HAVE ONE ELDER BROTHER. HE HAS JOINED A RAJA YOG MEDITATION GRP 'ISRC'OF SRI RAMCHANDRAJI MAHARAJ OF SHAHJAHANPUR.ACCORDING TO THEIR GROUP 'AMAVASYA TARAPANAM' IS NOT REQUIRED AS THEY SAY BY DOING SO YOU ARE CALLING YOUR THAGAPANAAR WHO WOULD BE OTHERWISE GOING TOWARDS SRI VAIKUNTAM!!!! ALSO IN THEIR MEDITATION FURTHER PROGRESS IS HINDERED BY DOING THESE TARAPANAM'S!!!!SO NOW HE HAS STOPPED DOING THE SAME.HE STAY'S IN SANFRANCISCO/CALIFORNIA/USA.MY MOTHER & MYSELF WANT HIM TO DO IT, AS OUR SAMPRADAYA SAYS WE MUST DO OUR PITHRU KARAYANGAL REGULARLY.HOW SHOULD WE COUNTER THEIR ARGUMENT? & WHAT IS THE ACTUAL REASON ACCORDING TO OUR SHASTRA FOR DOING AMAVASYA TARAPANAM?WHAT PARIHARAM CAN WE DO IN CASE HE DOESN'T DO IT?PLEASE BE KIND ENOUGH & ENLIGHTEN US.DASANU DASAN Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2008 Report Share Posted September 15, 2008 Srimathe Ramanujaya Namaha Dear Sri.Rajesh Swami As far as my little knowledge goes,once a soul reaches SriVaikuntam it never returns as it is solely engaged in doing Kainkaryam To Sriman Narayanan and Thayar. The tharpanams we do is to proptiate the Pithru Devathais who in turn sends our oblations to our forefathers' soul in Sri Vaikuntam. Hence the interpretation that we are calling back our forefathers is not apt. However since your elder brother has accepted the principles of Sahajamarg of Sri Ramachandra Mission of Saharanpur and follows the rituals of the mission, I feel that nothing can be done to make him, accept our sampradayams. WE can only pray to Sriman Narayanan and Thayar to shower Their Choicest blessings to him, and make him ponder over our great traditions and do corrective actions to get back your departed father's blessings. Srimath Andavan Thiruvadipodi Dasan Srinivasan. andavan , " N.S.Rajesh " <rajesh_narasima wrote: > > ADIYEN, > > MY THAGAPANAAR ATTAINED SRI VAIKUNTAM ON 16TH FEB'2006. > > I HAVE ONE ELDER BROTHER. HE HAS JOINED A RAJA YOG MEDITATION GRP 'ISRC' > OF SRI RAMCHANDRAJI MAHARAJ OF SHAHJAHANPUR. > ACCORDING TO THEIR GROUP 'AMAVASYA TARAPANAM' IS NOT REQUIRED AS THEY SAY BY DOING SO YOU ARE CALLING YOUR THAGAPANAAR WHO WOULD BE OTHERWISE GOING TOWARDS SRI VAIKUNTAM!!!! ALSO IN THEIR MEDITATION FURTHER PROGRESS IS HINDERED BY DOING THESE TARAPANAM'S!!!! > SO NOW HE HAS STOPPED DOING THE SAME. > HE STAY'S IN SANFRANCISCO/CALIFORNIA/USA. > MY MOTHER & MYSELF WANT HIM TO DO IT, AS OUR SAMPRADAYA SAYS WE MUST DO OUR PITHRU KARAYANGAL REGULARLY. > > HOW SHOULD WE COUNTER THEIR ARGUMENT? & WHAT IS THE ACTUAL REASON ACCORDING TO OUR SHASTRA FOR DOING AMAVASYA TARAPANAM? > WHAT PARIHARAM CAN WE DO IN CASE HE DOESN'T DO IT? > > > PLEASE BE KIND ENOUGH & ENLIGHTEN US. > > DASANU > DASAN > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2008 Report Share Posted September 18, 2008 Dear Sir, A few questions on this topic have been bothering me for quite some time. I would humbly request to be enlightened on the following: It is said that when a person breathes his last, his "jeevaatma" exits the body from a particular outlet and also continues to hover round the place for 10-12 days. Is this true? Does the "jeevaatma" have to wait for generations before attaining Sri Vaikuntam? Where does it stay till then? How does this relate to "punarjanma"? Is "punarjanma" inevitable? Do "Bharanyasam" and "Samaashrayanam" make a difference? Is there a difference between "jeevaatma" and "atma"? I seek the pardon of all Bhaagavathars if my questions are offensive and controversial. Regards Srikanth S vasan1937 wrote: Srimathe Ramanujaya Namaha Dear Sri.Rajesh Swami As far as my little knowledge goes,once a soul reaches SriVaikuntam it never returns as it is solely engaged in doing Kainkaryam To Sriman Narayanan and Thayar. The tharpanams we do is to proptiate the Pithru Devathais who in turn sends our oblations to our forefathers' soul in Sri Vaikuntam. Hence the interpretation that we are calling back our forefathers is not apt. However since your elder brother has accepted the principles of Sahajamarg of Sri Ramachandra Mission of Saharanpur and follows the rituals of the mission, I feel that nothing can be done to make him, accept our sampradayams. WE can only pray to Sriman Narayanan and Thayar to shower Their Choicest blessings to him, and make him ponder over our great traditions and do corrective actions to get back your departed father's blessings. Srimath Andavan Thiruvadipodi Dasan Srinivasan. andavan , "N.S.Rajesh" <rajesh_narasima wrote: > > ADIYEN, > > MY THAGAPANAAR ATTAINED SRI VAIKUNTAM ON 16TH FEB'2006. > > I HAVE ONE ELDER BROTHER. HE HAS JOINED A RAJA YOG MEDITATION GRP 'ISRC' > OF SRI RAMCHANDRAJI MAHARAJ OF SHAHJAHANPUR. > ACCORDING TO THEIR GROUP 'AMAVASYA TARAPANAM' IS NOT REQUIRED AS THEY SAY BY DOING SO YOU ARE CALLING YOUR THAGAPANAAR WHO WOULD BE OTHERWISE GOING TOWARDS SRI VAIKUNTAM!!!! ALSO IN THEIR MEDITATION FURTHER PROGRESS IS HINDERED BY DOING THESE TARAPANAM'S!!!! > SO NOW HE HAS STOPPED DOING THE SAME. > HE STAY'S IN SANFRANCISCO/CALIFORNIA/USA. > MY MOTHER & MYSELF WANT HIM TO DO IT, AS OUR SAMPRADAYA SAYS WE MUST DO OUR PITHRU KARAYANGAL REGULARLY. > > HOW SHOULD WE COUNTER THEIR ARGUMENT? & WHAT IS THE ACTUAL REASON ACCORDING TO OUR SHASTRA FOR DOING AMAVASYA TARAPANAM? > WHAT PARIHARAM CAN WE DO IN CASE HE DOESN'T DO IT? > > > PLEASE BE KIND ENOUGH & ENLIGHTEN US. > > DASANU > DASAN > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.