Guest guest Posted August 24, 2001 Report Share Posted August 24, 2001 Namaskara, Yesterday I posted a question regarding the significance of 21 mOdakas offered to Sri Ganesha in one of the dvaita lists. I thank all those who replied. Although your replies broadened my understanding, some questions still remained. Incidentally, I found all the answers in Sri Bannanje govindacharya's lecture on Sri Ganesha sent to us by Sri Mukund. The lecture addresses the following questions: 1. What is the significance of the number 21? 2. What do we mean when we say that Ganapati was born from the dust of parvati's body? 3. Who are parvati and shiva? 4. Why did shiva cut the head of his son? 5. Why did shiva choose elephant's head? 6. Why did shiva cut the head of an elephant sleeping in North-south direction(ie.,head positioned in north)? 7. Why does Shiva and Ganapati wear snake around their neck and belly? 8. why does Ganapati have an elephant face? Here are the answers (translated of course from whatever I understood from the cassette) : 1) Prapancha (world) has a numeral significance (Starting from inside): A. Pancha vidha antaHkaraNas(namely, manassu,buddhi, chinte(thought), chetana, ahamkaara). These are 5 in number. B. pancha jnyanEndriyas(five sense organs) C. panchakarmEndriyas (five again) D. pancha tanmaatra(namely, sparsha, shabdha,rasa, ruupa, gandha)(five in number) (A+B+C+D=20) e. pancha bhuuta(namely, akaasha(space)(#21), wind(#22), water(#23), fire(#24), earth(#25) since, the akaasha devata is Ganapati. 21 is his number. Hence all the significance in offering 21 mOdakas, flowers etc signifying and respecting his position in the tatvas. Answer to question2. Sri Parvati controls speech in the subtle form. The sound(shabdha) comes from naabhi(navel). It travels through hrudaya(heart), kuttige(throat) and comes out through our mouth which is then called as " Vaikhari " . shabdha is very pure in naabhi. That is the devara bhashe. As it travels through, it looses its purity and comes out as mala(vaikhari). The suukhsma vaakku is parvati. The mala that comes out of speech and reaches our ear is Ganapati. Here mala means sthoola roopa (gross sound as opposed to the subtle sound with which the speech starts in the navel). If there is no aakasha we will not hear anything. Helping the sound travel is vaayu the wind. Wind will blow the shabdha to our ear. So, the birth of Ganesha signifies the relationship of sound/space and how we hear the sound thru the space. Answer for question3. Parvati is vaakkdevata. Shiva is manassu devata. They are mana-maatu dampatigaLu. Whatever mind suggests, it comes out as talk. Answer for question4. The mind can think properly if there is a control in our speech(which comes out from mouth). If we keep on talking some rubbish without thinking then manassu devata(shiva) gets angry. Shiva likes to do more thinking and less talking. He is a abhimaani of mouna. If the head has a big mouth, then that is not good. Hence, shiva cuts the head that has a big mouth. Answer to question5. Head has 4 sensory organs viz.,eyes, ears, nose, mouth. Shiva was in a search of a head which has a small mouth which does not talk much, but with big ears and big nose. (Here, eyes does not matter.) So, he found an elephant with big ears to listen to everything and big nose to have praana shakti. Answer to question6. It seems there are two kinds of energy flowing, one in north-east and the other in south-west. The n-e energy is good for our spiritual growth as the energy flows in upward in direction. Whereas, the s-w energy flows in circular fashion(no matter where you start you will end up back where you started). [this is the other reason why we do pradakshiNas in clockwise direction] So, when you sleep in the northerly direction, you will face south when you get up. This is not good. So dakshiNa means no spiritual growth. Hence, Shiva cut the head of an elephant which was facing south. Answer to question7. Snake signifies kunDalini the driving force for spirituality. The snake's hood faces downward (dakshina) when this power is in the sleep state. Ganapati controls the uplifting of kunDalini thru the bottom 3 chakras (mooladhara, swadhisthana, maNipura - gonad etc glands up to the navel portion). Hence the snake with the hood up, around Ganapati's navel. Similar explanation applies to Shiva wearing snake around his neck. Also, Ganapati is described as clad with red clothes that signifies rajas or creation. The 3 chakras mentioned above help rajas or creative activity. Answer to question8. Ganapati wakes us up, as his antaryami is Vishwambhara ruupa who controls the wake state. In upanishads, that ruupa has 7 anga(limbs viz., 2legs, 4 hands and 1 long trunk). This is gaja mukha. Ganapati is upaasaka of vishwambhara who in turn has a gaja mukha. Hence, Ganapati got that face. I am thankful to Sri BG for these wonderful explanations. Hope you all like it. Any errors in this write-up are mine. Let me know if you find any mistakes. ||Srii krishnaarpaNamastu|| Thanks, Anita Durg Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Messenger http://phonecard./ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 24, 2001 Report Share Posted August 24, 2001 Thanks for this posting. Has Shri Bannanje provided any Pramana's in the casette for this explanation. Is there a reason why Panchabhuta's have to be noted in the order you have mentioned below. What happens if the order changes ? Rgds Naveen --- > Yesterday I posted a question regarding the > significance of 21 mOdakas > offered to Sri Ganesha in one of the dvaita lists. > Here are the answers (translated of course from > whatever I understood > from > the cassette) : > 1) Prapancha (world) has a numeral significance > (Starting from inside): > A. Pancha vidha antaHkaraNas(namely, manassu,buddhi, > chinte(thought), > chetana, ahamkaara). These are 5 in number. > B. pancha jnyanEndriyas(five sense organs) > C. panchakarmEndriyas (five again) > D. pancha tanmaatra(namely, sparsha, shabdha,rasa, > ruupa, gandha)(five > in > number) > (A+B+C+D=20) > e. pancha bhuuta(namely, akaasha(space)(#21), > wind(#22), water(#23), > fire(#24), earth(#25) > > since, the akaasha devata is Ganapati. 21 is his > number. Hence all the > significance in offering 21 mOdakas, flowers etc > signifying and > respecting > his position in the tatvas. Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Messenger http://phonecard./ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 24, 2001 Report Share Posted August 24, 2001 Thanks for this posting. Has Shri Bannanje provided any Pramana's in the casette for this explanation. Is there a reason why Panchabhuta's have to be noted in the order you have mentioned below. If there isn't then the number 21 still loses its significane. Rgds Naveen --- > Yesterday I posted a question regarding the > significance of 21 mOdakas > offered to Sri Ganesha in one of the dvaita lists. > Here are the answers (translated of course from > whatever I understood > from > the cassette) : > 1) Prapancha (world) has a numeral significance > (Starting from inside): > A. Pancha vidha antaHkaraNas(namely, manassu,buddhi, > chinte(thought), > chetana, ahamkaara). These are 5 in number. > B. pancha jnyanEndriyas(five sense organs) > C. panchakarmEndriyas (five again) > D. pancha tanmaatra(namely, sparsha, shabdha,rasa, > ruupa, gandha)(five > in > number) > (A+B+C+D=20) > e. pancha bhuuta(namely, akaasha(space)(#21), > wind(#22), water(#23), > fire(#24), earth(#25) > > since, the akaasha devata is Ganapati. 21 is his > number. Hence all the > significance in offering 21 mOdakas, flowers etc > signifying and > respecting > his position in the tatvas. Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Messenger http://phonecard./ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 24, 2001 Report Share Posted August 24, 2001 || Shree gurubhyO namaha harihi OM || Hi Praveen, Taittareeya says, " tasmAdvA EtasmAt Atmana AkAshah sambhUtaha | AkAshaat vaayuhu | vAyO ragnihi | agNeraapaha | adbhyah prithivee | prithivyaam Oshadayahaha | OshadeebhyO annam | annaat purushaha | " which puts Akaasha, Vaayu, Agni, Apa, prithvee as the order among the five gross elements. Harihi OM tatsat, ------------------------------- Jay Nelamangala RJAY Consultants Inc., Tel: (703)904-0196 Fax: (703)904-8496 - " Naveen BR " <brnaveen Friday, August 24, 2001 9:53 AM Re: Significance of 21 mOdakas > Thanks for this posting. Has Shri Bannanje provided > any Pramana's in the casette for this explanation. Is > there a reason why Panchabhuta's have to be noted in > the order you have mentioned below. If there isn't > then the number 21 still loses its significane. > > Rgds > > Naveen > > > --- > Yesterday I posted a question regarding the > > significance of 21 mOdakas > > offered to Sri Ganesha in one of the dvaita lists. > > > Here are the answers (translated of course from > > whatever I understood > > from > > the cassette) : > > 1) Prapancha (world) has a numeral significance > > (Starting from inside): > > A. Pancha vidha antaHkaraNas(namely, manassu,buddhi, > > chinte(thought), > > chetana, ahamkaara). These are 5 in number. > > B. pancha jnyanEndriyas(five sense organs) > > C. panchakarmEndriyas (five again) > > D. pancha tanmaatra(namely, sparsha, shabdha,rasa, > > ruupa, gandha)(five > > in > > number) > > (A+B+C+D=20) > > e. pancha bhuuta(namely, akaasha(space)(#21), > > wind(#22), water(#23), > > fire(#24), earth(#25) > > > > since, the akaasha devata is Ganapati. 21 is his > > number. Hence all the > > significance in offering 21 mOdakas, flowers etc > > signifying and > > respecting > > his position in the tatvas. > > > > > Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Messenger > http://phonecard./ > > > nAham kartA hariH kartA tatpUjA karmachaakhilam.h| > taThaapi matkR^itaa pUja tatprasaadhEna naanyaThaa| > tadbhakti tadphalam.h mahyam.h tatprasaadaat.h punaH punaH | > karmanyaasO harAvevam.h vishNOsthR^iptikaraH sadhA || > > " I am not the doer, shri Hari is the doer, all the actions that I do are His worship. Even then, the worship I do is through His grace and not otherwise. That devotion and the fruits of the actions that come to me are due to His recurring grace " > If one always practices to do actions with a dedicated spirit to Hari, in this way, it pleases Vishnu. > --- Quoted by Sri madhvAchArya in GitA tAtparya > -- > To send an empty E-mail (without subject and body info.) to - > -- > Visit VMS at http://www.madhva.org > -- > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 24, 2001 Report Share Posted August 24, 2001 On Friday, August 24, 2001 Naveen Bannur wrote: > Thanks for this posting. Has Shri Bannanje provided > any Pramana's in the casette for this explanation. Is > there a reason why Panchabhuta's have to be noted in > the order you have mentioned below. What happens if > the order changes ? The commentary of Shankarshana Odeyaru for this HKS verse # 14 in the " Vighneswara stotra sandhi " is available at: http://www.dvaita.org/list/list_41/msg00045.html To access this info, you'll need: userid : dvaita password : dvaita Regards, Meera Tadipatri Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 24, 2001 Report Share Posted August 24, 2001 I suggest you to go through HArikathamRuthasara commentary by Sankarshana Odeyaru.and an article appeared in Taranaga(1999) by Sri Bannanje GovindhAcharya will clear all the doubts. Regards, Madhusudan Bheemasenarao >Naveen BR <brnaveen > >Re: Significance of 21 mOdakas >Fri, 24 Aug 2001 06:53:24 -0700 (PDT) > >Thanks for this posting. Has Shri Bannanje provided >any Pramana's in the casette for this explanation. Is >there a reason why Panchabhuta's have to be noted in >the order you have mentioned below. If there isn't >then the number 21 still loses its significane. > >Rgds > >Naveen > > >--- > Yesterday I posted a question regarding the > > significance of 21 mOdakas > > offered to Sri Ganesha in one of the dvaita lists. > > > Here are the answers (translated of course from > > whatever I understood > > from > > the cassette) : > > 1) Prapancha (world) has a numeral significance > > (Starting from inside): > > A. Pancha vidha antaHkaraNas(namely, manassu,buddhi, > > chinte(thought), > > chetana, ahamkaara). These are 5 in number. > > B. pancha jnyanEndriyas(five sense organs) > > C. panchakarmEndriyas (five again) > > D. pancha tanmaatra(namely, sparsha, shabdha,rasa, > > ruupa, gandha)(five > > in > > number) > > (A+B+C+D=20) > > e. pancha bhuuta(namely, akaasha(space)(#21), > > wind(#22), water(#23), > > fire(#24), earth(#25) > > > > since, the akaasha devata is Ganapati. 21 is his > > number. Hence all the > > significance in offering 21 mOdakas, flowers etc > > signifying and > > respecting > > his position in the tatvas. > > > > >Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Messenger >http://phonecard./ _______________ Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 25, 2001 Report Share Posted August 25, 2001 Thanks for this response. It was one of the questions. But what of having Panchabhutas itself changing in order with the rest. Also if we are dealing with the Tatwas( ref original mail which speaks of 21st position among Tatwas), then why do we have panch vidha Ahankaras. Aren't the chaturvimshati Tatwas inclusive of the Dashendriyas, Pancha Tanmatra, Pancha Butah, Manasu, Mahat tatwa, Avyakta Tatwa and Ahankara Tatwa. Rgds Naveen --- Jay /RCI <jay wrote: > || Shree gurubhyO namaha harihi OM || > > Hi Praveen, > > Taittareeya says, > > " tasmAdvA EtasmAt Atmana AkAshah sambhUtaha | > AkAshaat vaayuhu | vAyO > ragnihi | > agNeraapaha | adbhyah prithivee | prithivyaam > Oshadayahaha | OshadeebhyO > annam | > annaat purushaha | " > > which puts Akaasha, Vaayu, Agni, Apa, prithvee > as the order among > the five gross elements. > > > Here are the answers (translated of course from > > > whatever I understood > > > from > > > the cassette) : > > > 1) Prapancha (world) has a numeral significance > > > (Starting from inside): > > > A. Pancha vidha antaHkaraNas(namely, > manassu,buddhi, > > > chinte(thought), > > > chetana, ahamkaara). These are 5 in number. > > > B. pancha jnyanEndriyas(five sense organs) > > > C. panchakarmEndriyas (five again) > > > D. pancha tanmaatra(namely, sparsha, > shabdha,rasa, > > > ruupa, gandha)(five > > > in > > > number) > > > (A+B+C+D=20) > > > e. pancha bhuuta(namely, akaasha(space)(#21), > > > wind(#22), water(#23), > > > fire(#24), earth(#25) > > > > > > since, the akaasha devata is Ganapati. 21 is his > > > number. Hence all the > > > significance in offering 21 mOdakas, flowers etc > > > signifying and > > > respecting > > > his position in the tatvas. > > > > > > > > > > Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute > with Messenger > > http://phonecard./ > > > > > > nAham kartA hariH kartA tatpUjA karmachaakhilam.h| > > taThaapi matkR^itaa pUja tatprasaadhEna > naanyaThaa| > > tadbhakti tadphalam.h mahyam.h tatprasaadaat.h > punaH punaH | > > karmanyaasO harAvevam.h vishNOsthR^iptikaraH sadhA > || > > > > " I am not the doer, shri Hari is the doer, all the > actions that I do are > His worship. Even then, the worship I do is through > His grace and not > otherwise. That devotion and the fruits of the > actions that come to me are > due to His recurring grace " > > If one always practices to do actions with a > dedicated spirit to Hari, in > this way, it pleases Vishnu. > > --- Quoted by Sri madhvAchArya in > GitA tAtparya > > -- > > To send an empty E-mail (without > subject and body info.) to > - > > -- > > Visit VMS at http://www.madhva.org > > -- > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.