Guest guest Posted December 5, 2005 Report Share Posted December 5, 2005 Nisargadatta , " whitehorserides " <green1911@v...> wrote: > > Nisargadatta , " Robert " <porrboy> wrote: > > So where's robert and the answers, so far al, waaba, and marc are offering comments, opinoions to the questions. but why can't you , Robert, say what school of thought is this so called master, what's his credentials, what are the conditions. If i walked into a school classroom in France and listened to questions and answers about Franco prussian war or the history of britain, the master is the books that contain the history. However the history books, from France and the history books from Britain, can contain different information, different accounts of history, correct. Just like the American media, report the news to their american flag wavers different from the Arabs report the news, to the arabs. it's all news about the same event but one gets to hear one way, the other gets another slant, therefore two different understandingsof the same one evernt. _____________get it. .. Therefore when student asked 'master' Britain,the answer may be different than _____master France. Now you understand why i asked , " who is the master and of what is he master of, why is he master, what is the set up.? so, no need to make fun of my question, it is valid, and resonable Whitehorserides > > Hey, > > > > I have lurked about this group from time to time and found much of > > interest. But till now did not post. So please be gentle.... > > I have a question based on the following... > > > > Student: Master how is your world different than mine? > > > > My world is non-verbal, the unspoken has no place in your world. > > In my world words and their meanings have no being. My world is > real, > > yours is made of dreams. If you observe your world, not as you > imagine > > it to be, but as it is, you will find yourself in my world. Your > world > > is the abode of desire and fear. You cannot find peace in your > world. > > > > > > My question is, " What do you think is meant by the suggestion of a > > non-verbal world and what is being suggested by saying the unspoken > > has no place in our world? Whitehorserides questions > > good am, > > you have not addressed this ? to any one specific but first lets > estalish the premise first. > > who is the student addressing, who is this so called master/ > > Why is this master, master? > > What 's he a master of? > > Or claims to be. > > First off one must know who is speaking. > Though i can imagine, or think i know the answer he's given, to the > student, i'm just curious as to why the difference is going on. > or perceived differece. student asks _____in your world, master?????? > > give me more to chew on and i may have an answer. > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 5, 2005 Report Share Posted December 5, 2005 you are looking for something to start your usual " holy trial " . that's the validity of your question. Nisargadatta , " whitehorserides " <green1911@v...> wrote: > > Nisargadatta , " whitehorserides " > <green1911@v...> wrote: > > > > Nisargadatta , " Robert " <porrboy> wrote: > > > > > So where's robert and the answers, so far al, waaba, and marc are > offering comments, opinoions to the questions. > > but why can't you , Robert, say what school of thought is this so > called master, what's his credentials, what are the conditions. > > If i walked into a school classroom in France and listened to > questions and answers about Franco prussian war or the history of > britain, the master is the books that contain the history. > > However the history books, from France and the history books from > Britain, can contain different information, different accounts of > history, correct. > > Just like the American media, report the news to their american flag > wavers different from the Arabs report the news, to the arabs. > it's all news about the same event but one gets to hear one way, the > other gets another slant, therefore two different understandingsof > the same one evernt. _____________get it. > > . > > Therefore when student asked 'master' Britain,the answer may be > different than _____master France. > > Now you understand why i asked , " who is the master and of what is > he master of, why is he master, what is the set up.? > > so, no need to make fun of my question, it is valid, and resonable > > Whitehorserides > > > > > > Hey, > > > > > > I have lurked about this group from time to time and found much > of > > > interest. But till now did not post. So please be gentle.... > > > I have a question based on the following... > > > > > > Student: Master how is your world different than mine? > > > > > > My world is non-verbal, the unspoken has no place in your world. > > > In my world words and their meanings have no being. My world is > > real, > > > yours is made of dreams. If you observe your world, not as you > > imagine > > > it to be, but as it is, you will find yourself in my world. Your > > world > > > is the abode of desire and fear. You cannot find peace in your > > world. > > > > > > > > > My question is, " What do you think is meant by the suggestion of > a > > > non-verbal world and what is being suggested by saying the > unspoken > > > has no place in our world? > > > > > Whitehorserides questions > > > > good am, > > > > you have not addressed this ? to any one specific but first lets > > estalish the premise first. > > > > who is the student addressing, who is this so called master/ > > > > Why is this master, master? > > > > What 's he a master of? > > > > Or claims to be. > > > > First off one must know who is speaking. > > Though i can imagine, or think i know the answer he's given, to > the > > student, i'm just curious as to why the difference is going on. > > or perceived differece. student asks _____in your world, > master?????? > > > > give me more to chew on and i may have an answer. > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.