knowing what another isn't going through (((On K never ending co

[Guest guest]

Nisargadatta , " dennis_travis33 "

<dennis_travis33 wrote:

>

> Nisargadatta , " Werner Woehr " <wwoehr@>

> wrote:

> >

> > Marc,

> >

> > Is there a see-er, a hear-er, a listen-er, a feel-er, a smell-er,

a

> > thinker ?

> >

> > Or is there just seeing, hearing, listening, feeling, smelling,

> > thinking etc ?

> >

> > The idea of a witness is to install a separate entity doing all

> this.

> >

> > Werner

> >

> >

> Werner,

>

> that's what is your personal view about it....

>

> without Self....there could be neither " see-er " ....nor seeing

> and because of Self....it's possible to step out of " see-er "

> and " seeing "

>

> did you ever tried to live without breathing?....

>

> is " Werner " ,only, responsible for his breathe?

>

> please remember that a dead person can't breathe

>

> Marc

>

 

better: a dead body does not breath. it is a simple medical

observation

so what?