Guest guest Posted June 2, 2008 Report Share Posted June 2, 2008 In AdvaitaToZen , Pesi <pedsie6 wrote: > P: But you like going to sleep every night, and > every night you cease to exist for a while. while > completely unconscious there is no time, a billion > years go by as fast as second. There can not be any > subjective difference between the non-conciousness > of deep sleep and that of death. So, its imagination > which kindles the fear of death. Thanx for pointing at this. Yes, it is imagination. But there is also the imagination in the evening that Stefan will wake up again the next morning... Greetings Stefan P: Very true! Every brain on surrendering to sleep expects or take for granted that its consciousness and memory will return in the morning. Every night, as you know, a number of people die in their sleep, and those never know they died. Let's fancifully suppose, tonight, a genii, just for a lark, switches our consciousness while we are sleep, and we wake up inside the other's body. Would we know? I doubt it. All memories of Pete were left behind in Pete's brain. So my consciousness on waking up, as it does every morning, will check for memories of an identity, and will find only Stefan's memories. It won't, even for a moment suspect the switch, because every detail of being you will be there, and none of being me. What is the point of this silly thought experiment? Well the point is even sillier, How do we know that this, in fact, doesn't happen every night? It could be that every night while memories sleep, our consciousness play musical chairs, and randomly switch bodies. So every morning, we are a different person, but we identify with whatever story-line we find in a brain. How would that change our view of death? Well, were that true, and I don't say it is, then, death exist, and doesn't. And all there is, is generic consciousness playing musical chairs with memories stored in an infinitude of brains. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.