Guest guest Posted October 4, 2009 Report Share Posted October 4, 2009 omkaradatta , " Tim G. " <fewtch wrote: On the Guru/Disciple, Student/Teacher relationship, and Advaita in general ***************** Omkaradatta: The 'goal' is to go beyond the help of all outside agency altogether. One is totally on one's own. As far as I know (and fwiw), Jed Mckenna is very emphatic about this point. " Outward? " Inward. As long as " I need you " for something (emotional needs in particular), I am there. My need, desire, hope, fear... is my existence, as a being separate from you. I'm not saying there's anything wrong with the teacher/student thing -- only, it's limited. A teacher can suggest, hint, guide, instruct, etc. Unfortunately, " advaita " isn't a math class, it's about the end of the self/other separation, and teacher/student is a (supposed :-p) self/other relationship. So, see the limitations, that's all. > How can one be on one's own when the unifying > experience is the whole of life itself? Because *you are* the whole of life itself, and (in theory at least) not aware of it. If you encounter things/beings that seem to be other than you, and also encounter yourself (which requires an encounterer and encounteree), the split is there. > The limitation is only perceived by an individual imposing > those limits on such a relationship. Relationship within " Oneness " isn't possible. It's an illusion. Relationship requires two or more. Not that human beings can't interact, but there is no relationship involved. Unbeknownst to us, we are actually " in relationship " with two aspects of ourselves. > So the boundary between teacher (that IS the truth) and student > begin to dissolve as the unity gets closer between that truth, and > the duality just isn't seen anymore. Sure, that can happen (at least in theory) although lovers get very close over many years, all the time, and don't 'wake up' from it'. Good luck finding an actually-awake teacher to get close enough to for that to happen (I mean the well wishes sincerely). Life is, perhaps, the only teacher. And who ever said disillusionment can't be a good teacher? It's just not a pleasant one :-p. > Its good to see you move for a change, getting a bit > worried, a bit pissed off. I was getting worried you > weren't human there. Remember, we aren't actually in relationship ;-). I am what you take me to be, and vice-versa, eh? > The rest is just support for me and a lot of > goofing around, which I see you like too ;D > *sighs* I see you as you are, but it gets confusing... > it really does lol People see others as *they* are, not as the other actually is. I can only testify to it, can't prove it or anything. But I can say that all one has of the other are the words, interpreted and " translated " by one's own psyche. Anyhoo... I'm off to bed, nice chatting with ya :-). --- End forwarded message --- Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.