Blasphemy - No more discussions on this and related topic

[Guest guest]

Namaste Sri Tony:

 

With all respects, we want to request you to stop making your own

interpretations that are contrary to statements made by sages and

saints. The only reference that you have provided so far is your

published unpublished BOOK (unknown to everyone other than you)

 

Refer your post # 35669

" I don't think Sankara talked much about saguna, nirguna. Ramana says

that sat-cit-ananda are qualities of the Self, that is attributes in

my book. Nir Guna by definition has no nature. Everyone is talking

about Saguna for there is nothing to say about Nir Guna.........Tony. "

 

Probably all your statements come from your " BOOK " and please note

that your BOOK is not an authority for " Sankara's Advaita

Philosophy. " Given this fact, please stop quoting from your own BOOK

and state from valid and reliable sources for your words.

 

Scholarly members including Anandaji, Rishiji, Peterji, Sadanandaji

and others have alreay explained to you in very clear terms why your

observations do not fall in line with Sankara's thoughts and

writings.

 

Please note that a number of novice members expect the list to

provide them with the correct understanding of Sankara's advaita

philosophy. Please do not contradict statements taken from Sankara's

works and statements of the sages of the Upanishads.

 

There is nothing wrong in each of us having our own frame-work for

our understanding. But we do not have any right to force our thoughts

on others and expect everyone to accept what we say. One of the

primary reason that we all participate in the list discussions is to

correct and enhance our understanding. But if we fail to recognize

our shortcomings, we can't call ourselves as advaitins.

 

We request the members not to continue this and related subject

thread and let us move on to topics that are directly relevant to

Sankara's advaita philophy.

 

regards,

 

Advaitin List Moderator

 

 

 

 

advaitin , " Tony OClery " <aoclery wrote:

>

> >

> Namaste,Dhyana,

>

> In illusion and delusion we are all devatma swarupas, we are all

> avatars. I have my feeling that I am a advaitin, and it is nice of

you

> to pray and do mouna for me but an exercise in futility really.

> However if it makes you feel good then by all means do

it.......Tony.

>

[Guest guest]

Dear Moderators,

 

Please accept my apologies, I have just now sent a post on this topic. Your

mail below and mine crossed each other while doing a send and receive. I

should learn to receive before I send!

 

with best wishes,

 

Peter

 

________________________________

 

advaitin [advaitin ] On Behalf

Of advaitins

21 April 2007 14:38

advaitin

Re: Blasphemy - No more discussions on this and related

topic

 

 

 

Namaste Sri Tony:

 

With all respects, we want to request you to stop making your own

interpretations that are contrary to statements made by sages and

saints. The only reference that you have provided so far is your

published unpublished BOOK (unknown to everyone other than you)

<snip>

 

We request the members not to continue this and related subject

thread and let us move on to topics that are directly relevant to

Sankara's advaita philophy.

 

regards,

 

Advaitin List Moderator