Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Big Doubt ???

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Dear Sirs,

 

I am a school going kid as compared to spiritual scholars like u..

and I take the liberty of a kid to ask questions.. and in school

kids asking questions are considered to be studious..

 

I wanted to know... when we say a enlightened being or say siddha or

say one who has realised the ultimate truth... does the world

appears different to that person...

 

I am confused because I have often come across things which proclaim

that a realised being loves everyone and the whole world is like his

own extension for him etc etc...

 

so I was wondering if i actually know what are the final results.. I

will more enthusiastic to run instead of walking on the spiritual

path to know the ultimate truth...

 

love all,

 

sai.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

advaitin , " sai9701 " <sai9701 wrote:

> I am a school going kid as compared to spiritual scholars like u..

> and I take the liberty of a kid to ask questions.. and in school

> kids asking questions are considered to be studious..

 

Namaste

I am writing only because no one else did. Also, we all are

Lord's kids only!

 

> I wanted to know... when we say a enlightened being or say siddha

> or say one who has realised the ultimate truth... does the world

> appears different to that person...

 

I don't know about enlightened being, but don't we all see the world

differently? Actually, even the same world seems to appear

differently to ourselves, depending upon our own moods and

thoughts.

 

When happy, a showering rain seems joyful and poetic with music

and dance by the falling drops. And when unhappy, same rain

seems like falling tears from dark, dreadful sky! May be this is

exaggeration, but the point is I " see " same thing differently

based on what is goes on inside, rather outside.

 

We have little control of outside. But, what would happen

if inside is always balanced, peaceful and serene ? That has been a

gripping wonder for me so far.

 

We know all great sages have an unbroken peace, undiminished

serenity and unperturbed balance within themselves, all the time.

 

Sri Ramana had only compassion, and no complaint even when operated

without anesthesia or attacked by petty thieves. Ramakrishna

Paramahamsa was enraptured by mere listening to songs on Mother

Kali, unconcerned of throat cancer afflicting him. Christ pleaded

only for forgiveness for even those who crucified him, not

withstanding the inhumane treatment meted out.

 

A great Telugu poet Pothana, beautifully says in a verse spoken by

Prahlada, that wherever I look, Lord, I find only Thee. In a

parable I heard, the atheistic father had a huge writing displayed

in his hall that read " GOD IS NO WHERE " . And then, he asked his

devout son to read it. To the astonishment of the father and others,

the son reads the same writing as " GOD IS NOW HERE " ! Just a little

different way of looking!

 

Hari OM!

-Srinivas

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Namaste Sri Sai:

 

Sri Srinivas has already provided good insights to reconcile your

doubts. I really liked the last paragraph which has profound meaning:

 

advaitin , " Srinivas Nagulapalli "

<srini_nagul wrote:

 

> In a

> parable I heard, the atheistic father had a huge writing displayed

> in his hall that read " GOD IS NO WHERE " . And then, he asked his

> devout son to read it. To the astonishment of the father and

> others, the son reads the same writing as " GOD IS NOW HERE " !

> Just a little different way of looking!

 

============================================

 

Now let me get back to your question. Just for your information, the

question that you have asked was also asked by Arjuna (the hero of

Mahabhrat) to Lord Krishna. The entire dialog between Arjuna and Lord

Krishna are explained in Chapter 2 of Mahabharat, verses 55 to 72.

Please note that Arjuna is not a Kid and he had thee same doubt like

you - this means that you are a scholl going seeker with full eager

(thrust for knowledge) to get the wisdom.

 

You can go to the following link to get the complete answer to your

big doubt: http://www.advaitin.net/Sthita%20Prajna.htm

Also you can read the following linke which provides the essence of

Bhagavad Gita: http://www.advaitin.net/GitaEssence.htm

 

As Sri Srinivas correctly points out, that how we look at the world

depends on our 'attitude.' Persons with postive mental attitude looks

at the world very optimistic and considers it as heaven. Those who

are pessimistic look at the same world and believe that it is a Hell.

The world is the same, and it never likely change and only we have to

change, rather we have to change our attitude!. If we include others

in the world as part of us. For example, we consider members of our

own family as one and consequetnly, we are able to forgive and forget

their errors. If we can treat the entire world as one-family,

probably, our attitude will become more congenial and we will become

more compassionate and kind to others. This is basically the essence

of Vedanta - include everyone as you so that - the me in you see the

you in me.

 

With my warmest regards,

 

Ram Chandran

 

 

 

 

 

 

advaitin , " sai9701 " <sai9701 wrote:

>

> Dear Sirs,

>

> I am a school going kid as compared to spiritual scholars like u..

> and I take the liberty of a kid to ask questions.. and in school

> kids asking questions are considered to be studious..

>

> I wanted to know... when we say a enlightened being or say siddha

or

> say one who has realised the ultimate truth... does the world

> appears different to that person...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Dear Sai,

I do not know how old you are. I thought the following few words may be

helpful:

You said:

>>I wanted to know... when we say a enlightened being or say siddha or say one

who has realised the ultimate truth... does the world appears different to that

person...<<<

The world does not “appear” in any way different to an enlightened being or

sidha. However, he is enlightened with the Truth pervading the world, his own

self, others and Eswara itself. What is the use of knowing that Truth? Knowing

that makes a very big difference.

The sun appears to you moving from east to west everyday. What is the truth?

You know the truth and the apparent movement of the sun does not affect you in

any way.

So, when one knows the Truth of the world itself, and also about he himself

and Eswara, his total approach towards the world, Eswara and he himself changes.

With all good wishes

 

 

 

R. S. Mani

 

 

 

Ahhh...imagining that irresistible " new car " smell?

Check outnew cars at Autos.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Namaste all.

 

I might only be adding to the big doubt. However, can't resist

writing this.

 

I can't say how an enlightened one 'views' the world, for I am not

one. Yet, I think we can just begin with some examples.

 

When I am a pedestrian on the roads, my body-sense rules my

movements. When I am behind the wheel on the same roads, the sense

of the size of the vehicle I am driving governs my actions. So, when

I go universal, I should imagine I would 'behave' as the 'Whole'.

That is what is implied by Ananda of Sat-Chit-Ananda, where I don't

have to 'view' or 'behave' because both these verbs of action have

validity only with reference to the existence of something other than

me.

 

With my current limited knowledge, I can't of course visualize the

situation. Language might not be of any help for me to explain it

when I self-realize. Perhaps, I might then find it a misadventure to

attempt such futility. In terms of words, I can only dare say this

much: I would then be in love with everything which is my real

default nature. That is Unviersal Love, not in any way different

from Sat-Chit-Ananda, where lover, love and beloved are fused into

One. That is not a situation and we, self-proclaimed mortals,

accustomed to sitautions can't fully visualize it. Or, why should we

visualize it at all? The answer is in the Ramana smile. Just be.

You already are. The question at whom Bhagwan smiled is immaterial

to Him. For us, it is a big doubt.

 

PraNAms.

 

Madathil Nair

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Namaste All.

 

My previous post # 35784 refers.

 

How foolish I was to forget our jagadguru on the occasion of his

birthday and attempt on my egotistic own to visualize the behaviour of

an enlighted one! How an enlighted one 'acts' is well-described by our

Acharya in the gem called Kaupeena Panchakam. Let us all read it at

the link below translated by none other than our respected Shri

Ramachanderji:

 

http://www.celextel.org/adisankara/kaupeenapanchakam.html

 

Each word of the panchakam calls for years of reflection and meditation.

 

PraNAms.

 

Madathil Nair

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

sai9701 <sai9701 wrote: Dear Sirs,

 

I am a school going kid as compared to spiritual scholars like u..

and I take the liberty of a kid to ask questions.. and in school

kids asking questions are considered to be studious..

Dear friend,

I am sure that the realized person, having understood the

duality to be unreal, does not interfere with any goings- on of the world. That

the realized should act in a particular way is only the conceptualization of the

unrealized. J.Krishnamurti says that the scientific mind leaves a footprint in

the sands of time, being concerned with the the world of measurement; whereas

the religious mind, knowing the measurement to be unreal, does not leave any

footprints in the sands of time. Both have their relevance, except that the

world of time does not lead to the timeless, the timeless having no path, no

goal, nor a purpose, being unlimited. It is like the flight of the eagle.

Further, you can't give a distinguishing mark to the religious mind, that being

beyond the realm of conceptualization. Even Vasishta says that a realized man

cannot be identified by the outer signs, even though certain marks are mentioned

in the scriptures, which are only by way of

concession extended to the ignorant still believing in the reality of duality,

confounding even the truth to be something to be achieved, being yet another

self-perpetuating goal. I think the realized cannot behave in a way different

from the unrealized, behavior etc flowing only from the mind, which has left far

behind by the realized.

 

with regards

Sankarraman

 

with regards

Sankarraman

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ahhh...imagining that irresistible " new car " smell?

Check outnew cars at Autos.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Wow!Chinna Thambi Avargale : ( my own younger brother)

 

Good Thinking. Keep sharing your views.

 

May i share this with you ?

 

Shogen asked: `Why does the enlightened man not stand on his feet

and explain himself?' And he also said: `It is not necessary for

Speech to come from the tongue.'

 

Smile!

 

Here is a small anecdote from the Ramayana ! Read and enjoy!

 

Enlightened man will not hate wrong-doer

 

 

A man chased by a tiger climbed up a tree, but to his horror, found

a bear there. When the former asked the bear to push him down, as he

was their common enemy, the latter demurred saying that he had taken

shelter with it. When the bear fell asleep, the man, egged on by the

tiger, tried to push the bear down, though it woke up in time. Now

the tiger demanded the man as he had proved to be a traitor. ``He

had trusted me and if he had done a wrong, God will punish him,''

the bear said. This story, reminding us that none is free from

transgression, was cited by no less a person than the Divine Mother,

Sita, when Anjaneya suggested to Her, after She was free to act,

that the demoness- guards posted around Her by Ravana, while She was

kept in custody, be knocked down as they had tortured Her during the

dark days. The wonderful reply of Sita was that these women were

then in Ravana's service and they had only loyally carried out his

commands. Why should one show his rage against them because they

were not to be blamed? By nature the members of the demon race are

sadistic. ``It is up to us to excuse their aberration. Pious people

show utmost consideration and mercy to sinners.''

 

http://rwww.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/2000/04/08/stories/10080906.htm

 

So , to answer you question , Sai-ji , an enlightened person does

not keep scores . He/she is most forgiving. He /she is

compassionate. He/she does not fear anyone or anything - He /she is

secure . Above all , he he/she has no false ego. When you see or

hear one , you will know! SONEONE MENTIONED rAMANA BHAGWAN !HIS EYES

SAYS IT ALL - the power of Jnana Dristi!

 

Bhatrihari , the famous pholosopher- poet says in his Niti Shatakam

 

There are four kinds of people:] (1) " Good people " who help others

without caring for their own welfare, (2) " Common people " who help

others so long as it doesn't hurt their own self-interest,

(3) " Demonic people " who destroy others' welfare for their selfish

interest, and (4) those who destroy others' welfare for no reason

whatsoever—I don't know what name they should be given!

 

But wo says you are a kid and others are all great spiritual

scholars ! From the mouths of babes , great Truths come ! My one

month granddaughter teaches me the virtues of Tolerance and Patience

and unconditional love!

 

with love

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I think the main question was ' does the world

appears different to that person... '

 

How it appears to a realised person could not be answered by unrealised. It

could be only from the mind and what one read or heard.

 

From what one read it could be like this-

 

To the realised the world appear as it would to any unrealised. But the

realised is firmly established with the truth that what appears to Him as

different is nothing but Brahaman in different forms. But for the unrealised

it is only theory till realisation.

 

podury

 

 

On 4/26/07, sai9701 <sai9701 wrote:

>

> Dear Sirs,

>

> I am a school going kid as compared to spiritual scholars like u..

> and I take the liberty of a kid to ask questions.. and in school

> kids asking questions are considered to be studious..

>

> I wanted to know... when we say a enlightened being or say siddha or

> say one who has realised the ultimate truth... does the world

> appears different to that person...

>

> I am confused because I have often come across things which proclaim

> that a realised being loves everyone and the whole world is like his

> own extension for him etc etc...

>

> so I was wondering if i actually know what are the final results.. I

> will more enthusiastic to run instead of walking on the spiritual

> path to know the ultimate truth...

>

> love all,

>

> sai.

>

>

>

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Well, if you all are looking for a an enlightened response(big

smile) to this 'big doubt' raised by our beloved member Sa-ji ,

here are two verses from Forty Verses on Reality by none other than

our most beloved of all Saints Sri Sri Ramana Bhagwan ....

 

To those who have not realized the Self,

 

as well as to those who have,

 

the word 'I' refers to the body,

 

but with this difference,

 

that for those who have not realized,

 

the 'I' is confined to the body

 

whereas for those who have realized the Self

 

within the body the 'I' shines as the limitless Self. (verse 17)

 

And

 

To those who have not realized (the Self)

 

as well as to those who have the world is real.

 

But to those who have not realized,

 

Truth is adapted to the measure of the world,

 

whereas to those that have,

 

Truth shines as the Formless Perfection,

 

and as the Substratum of the world.

 

This is all the difference between them. ( verse 18)

 

This is serious stuff ! Hard to digest , is it not ? But we have

living proof of such self-realized souls who are still 'alive'

through their teachings ... Although Sri Ramana bhagwan is not

physically prsent among us , he Shines as the 'unmanisfested' Sat

in our hearts - Our Atma Guru!

 

Salutations to the lotus feet of one the greatest sages of our

times !

 

Sri Ramanarpanamastu!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Ram Chandran <ramvchandran wrote:

 

> In a

> parable I heard, the atheistic father had a huge writing displayed

> in his hall that read " GOD IS NOWHERE " . And then, he asked his

> devout son to read it. To the astonishment of the father and

> others, the son reads the same writing as " GOD IS NOW HERE " !

> Just a little different way of looking!

Dear Sir,

Even the idea that " GOD IS NOWHERE " . is hundred

percent correct, calling the bluff to the idea that It is a created phenomenal

object to be categorized, classified and pigeon-holed by the mind seeking some

curious shell. Let us not look askance at it, wanting to interpret it in terms

of personal predilections. The father is equally correct. It is a different

matter that both the father and son may not have clearly understood what they

are talking about, except that they are repeating what they have heard it and

repeating it second-hand. Pessimism , optimism, positive thinking, negations-all

these things are only mind-begotten, the one not being superior or inferior to

the other. Is it not that the Self is neither existence nor non-existence,

neither both, nor even the negation of both.

with respectful regards

Sankarraman=============

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ahhh...imagining that irresistible " new car " smell?

Check outnew cars at Autos.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...