Fwd: Sankara's advaita isn't A-Dvaita./stop again !

[Guest guest]

GuruRatings , " Tony OClery " <aoclery wrote:

 

GuruRatings , " Era Molnar " <mi_nok@> wrote:

>

> > Namaste,

> >

> > Unless he taught it in secret like Jesus to his apostles, then

> > Sankara's teachings are only to the level of Saguna or dualism not Nir

> > Guna or A-Dvaita..........I can't understand why the great minds on

> > advaitin sites don't pick up on this........Tony.

> >

>

>

> These statements are the reason, that all advaitin list owners banned

> you at one time, or an other, Tony. Harsha Ananda and all the learned

> members answered over and over to your " Nir Guna " obsession, but you

> keep on and on and on.. like a broken recording... As the moderator of

> the advaitin club said referring to this, that the reason your' banned

> is because you sound like a scholar to the beginners and confuse them

> with your miss informations.

>

> Don't make me cross post again please.

>

>

> Era

 

Namaste,

 

In the words of the prophet...'up yours'. If people cannot think for

themselves and can only quote scriptures written hundreds of years ago

, and edited, translated god knows how many times, it is their

problem. Some people pretend to be advaitins when in fact they are

guru worshipping dvaitins. My 'obsession' was explained logically by

me and even quoting the veda to keep people happy.

I have no problem with what people believe or don't believe but

logical conclusions shouldn't be banned. Otherwise you end up with

heretics like Jesus and Manour being martyred for much the same thing

as I said.........Tony.

 

--- End forwarded message ---

[Guest guest]

advaitajnana , " Tony OClery " <aoclery wrote:

>

> GuruRatings , " Tony OClery " <aoclery@> wrote:

>

> GuruRatings , " Era Molnar " <mi_nok@> wrote:

> >

> > > Namaste,

> > >

> > > Unless he taught it in secret like Jesus to his apostles, then

> > > Sankara's teachings are only to the level of Saguna or dualism

not Nir

> > > Guna or A-Dvaita..........I can't understand why the great minds on

> > > advaitin sites don't pick up on this........Tony.

> > >

> >

> >

> > These statements are the reason, that all advaitin list owners banned

> > you at one time, or an other, Tony. Harsha Ananda and all the learned

> > members answered over and over to your " Nir Guna " obsession, but you

> > keep on and on and on.. like a broken recording... As the moderator of

> > the advaitin club said referring to this, that the reason your' banned

> > is because you sound like a scholar to the beginners and confuse them

> > with your miss informations.

> >

> > Don't make me cross post again please.

> >

> >

> > Era

>

> Namaste,

>

> In the words of the prophet...'up yours'. If people cannot think for

> themselves and can only quote scriptures written hundreds of years ago

> , and edited, translated god knows how many times, it is their

> problem. Some people pretend to be advaitins when in fact they are

> guru worshipping dvaitins. My 'obsession' was explained logically by

> me and even quoting the veda to keep people happy.

> I have no problem with what people believe or don't believe but

> logical conclusions shouldn't be banned. Otherwise you end up with

> heretics like Jesus and Manour being martyred for much the same thing

> as I said.........Tony.

Namaste,

 

To add to the above: The real reason they didn't like what I said was

because they considered it 'nihilism'. The reason they did that was

because they couldn't imagine going beyond their own minds and

lifetimes of memorised philosophies.So they could only hold on to

their minds in the form of the Jiva and the total aggregate of the

Jivas..Ishvara/Saguna Brahman.

Imagining an attributeless qualityless Nir Guna was too frightening

for them to bear, for it cannot be imagined. It also led to the fact

that nothing ever happened....Fear or rather Fear of Extinction is why

they so roundly opposed what I was saying...Tony.