Conflicting analysis of horoscopes - your respected opinions requested

[Guest guest]

Hello respected Jyotishas, Jyotishas in Learning, and those interested in

astrology.

 

I am new to this group. Indeed, I sought it out because I am seeking additional

opinions for the horoscope matching of my niece. I am the grandson of a famous

jyotish, and while these topics interest me, I went into business and away from

astrology. This is the first time we've had cause to consult with a Jyotish.

 

My niece (her name is Love) is born and raised in the US. She is 26. She has

been dating a boy (Matthew) for a few months whom her parents like very much.

She came to her parents to ask if they would match the horoscopes, and they

asked me to help. We are Sindhi Indians; Matthew is Caucasian.

 

Friends, I have asked two different Jyotishas who are highly regarded and whom I

trust very much in their education and experience. I am feeling very conflicted

in what advice I should give to Love's parents.

 

I hope that you all will be willing to help me out.

 

The Guna (Ashtkoot) is coming to 33.5 (out of 36). That is excellent, I know!

The points that are not 100% are: Vashya (1 of 2) and Tara/Dina (1.5 of 3). The

rest are 100%.

 

The boy's nakshatra is Revati; Love's is Bharani.

 

The issue is that Matthew has Rahu in his 5th house and Ketu in his 11th house

in his Lagna chart. In his Navamsa chart, he has Ravi and Ketu in his 8th house.

He also has Sukra and Moon in his 12th house. He has nothing in his 7th house.

 

Love has Rahu in her 3rd house and Ketu in her 9th house. In her 7th house, she

has Pluto and Sani. Sukra is in her 2nd house.

 

I am happy to provide anymore details, including full planets in all houses.

They are looking for advice on whether to get engaged or not.

 

One Jyotish has said that the pair is FANTASTIC and that we should not let this

kind of pairing slip from our hands; that he will provide extremely good

partner, and be loyal and faithful companion. The other Jyotish has said the boy

will cheat on her and the relationship will end in about 10 years in a divorce;

that her life will be all broken promises as a result of his Ketu/Rahu; that he

will be suspicious of her always and cheating. He says that Love should run as

fast as she can because there is no indication of a divorce in her own

horoscope. He says there is every indication she should have a wonderful

marriage in her horoscope and to mix with this one would make problems. Again,

the other Jyotish tells us that it's the opposite; this would make her life

happy and complete.

 

There is no mangal in either horoscope.

 

If anyone can help shed some light; please do...We would be truly grateful.

 

Sincerely

 

Dhiraj Sharma Relwani

 

 

Here are the planets:

Matthew:

Lagna Chart:

5: Mang, Guru, Rahu

6: Pluto, Sani

8: Neptune, Uranus

11: Budh, Ravi, Ketu

12: Sukra, Moon

 

A Jyotish tells me it is significant to mention that his Navamsa Chart shows

Ravi and Ketu in 8th house.

 

Love:

Lagna Chart:

1: Ravi, Mang, Budh, Moon

2: Sukra

3: Rahu

7: Sani, Pluto

8: Guru, Uranus

9: Neptune, Ketu

[Guest guest]

Pl post birth details where r they now, what r they doing professionally for a

living some info on their parents can also help

 

more info the better esp withdates jobs in out dates etc

 

 

this is a v wide subject and ppl have diffeent approaches, patience and ur

destiny can lead u to the right answers

 

prashant

 

 

 

 

 

________________________________

dsharmarelwanijyotisha <dsharmarelwanijyotisha

 

Tuesday, September 8, 2009 6:57:03 AM

Conflicting analysis of horoscopes - your respected opinions

requested

 

 

Hello respected Jyotishas, Jyotishas in Learning, and those interested in

astrology.

 

I am new to this group. Indeed, I sought it out because I am seeking additional

opinions for the horoscope matching of my niece. I am the grandson of a famous

jyotish, and while these topics interest me, I went into business and away from

astrology. This is the first time we've had cause to consult with a Jyotish.

 

My niece (her name is Love) is born and raised in the US. She is 26. She has

been dating a boy (Matthew) for a few months whom her parents like very much.

She came to her parents to ask if they would match the horoscopes, and they

asked me to help. We are Sindhi Indians; Matthew is Caucasian.

 

Friends, I have asked two different Jyotishas who are highly regarded and whom I

trust very much in their education and experience. I am feeling very conflicted

in what advice I should give to Love's parents.

 

I hope that you all will be willing to help me out.

 

The Guna (Ashtkoot) is coming to 33.5 (out of 36). That is excellent, I know!

The points that are not 100% are: Vashya (1 of 2) and Tara/Dina (1.5 of 3). The

rest are 100%.

 

The boy's nakshatra is Revati; Love's is Bharani.

 

The issue is that Matthew has Rahu in his 5th house and Ketu in his 11th house

in his Lagna chart. In his Navamsa chart, he has Ravi and Ketu in his 8th house.

He also has Sukra and Moon in his 12th house. He has nothing in his 7th house.

 

Love has Rahu in her 3rd house and Ketu in her 9th house. In her 7th house, she

has Pluto and Sani. Sukra is in her 2nd house.

 

I am happy to provide anymore details, including full planets in all houses.

They are looking for advice on whether to get engaged or not.

 

One Jyotish has said that the pair is FANTASTIC and that we should not let this

kind of pairing slip from our hands; that he will provide extremely good

partner, and be loyal and faithful companion. The other Jyotish has said the boy

will cheat on her and the relationship will end in about 10 years in a divorce;

that her life will be all broken promises as a result of his Ketu/Rahu; that he

will be suspicious of her always and cheating. He says that Love should run as

fast as she can because there is no indication of a divorce in her own

horoscope. He says there is every indication she should have a wonderful

marriage in her horoscope and to mix with this one would make problems. Again,

the other Jyotish tells us that it's the opposite; this would make her life

happy and complete.

 

There is no mangal in either horoscope.

 

If anyone can help shed some light; please do...We would be truly grateful.

 

Sincerely

 

Dhiraj Sharma Relwani

 

Here are the planets:

Matthew:

Lagna Chart:

5: Mang, Guru, Rahu

6: Pluto, Sani

8: Neptune, Uranus

11: Budh, Ravi, Ketu

12: Sukra, Moon

 

A Jyotish tells me it is significant to mention that his Navamsa Chart shows

Ravi and Ketu in 8th house.

 

Love:

Lagna Chart:

1: Ravi, Mang, Budh, Moon

2: Sukra

3: Rahu

7: Sani, Pluto

8: Guru, Uranus

9: Neptune, Ketu

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Guest guest]

Thank you Prashant and my apologies for not including this information.

 

Both of them are living in New Jersey USA. The girl is sindhi, her parents have

their own importing business, have been happily married (no major problems) for

40 years. Girl is managing about 4 people at a online software company, she

herself is doing the global product management. She has been doing 2 years in

this same job. She has no plans to change jobs and expects a promotion within a

year. Her father had Kaal Sarp Yog, but a pooja was done to help when he was

young. No Mangal is either of her parents horoscopes. Their gunas match 24

points.

 

Boy is caucasian, parents are divorced very badly. Father cheated on the mother

consistently throughout life and remarried around 45. Boy says that he will

never cheat because he is close to his mom and has much more respect and better

relationship with her. He has made a very good impression on the families, even

I admit to liking him very much before I heard these conflicts about his

horoscope. He is working as a Finance Analyst for a telephone company for three

years. Before this, he did Social Work with the mentally handicapped for three

years. He is making less money than my niece by almost half. But, some things

are promising; he does seem to have ambition.

 

birth details are girl: 10 22 PM ridgewood nj 14th april 1983

birth details are boy: 2 44 AM new brunswick nj 19th february 1980

 

Thank you again.

 

, Prashant Kumar G B <gbp_kumar

wrote:

>

> Pl post birth details where r they now, what r they doing professionally for a

living some info on their parents can also help

>

> more info the better esp withdates jobs in out dates etc

>

>

> this is a v wide subject and ppl have diffeent approaches, patience and ur

destiny can lead u to the right answers

>

> prashant

>

>

>

>

>

> ________________________________

> dsharmarelwanijyotisha <dsharmarelwanijyotisha

>

> Tuesday, September 8, 2009 6:57:03 AM

> Conflicting analysis of horoscopes - your respected opinions

requested

>

>

> Hello respected Jyotishas, Jyotishas in Learning, and those interested in

astrology.

>

> I am new to this group. Indeed, I sought it out because I am seeking

additional opinions for the horoscope matching of my niece. I am the grandson of

a famous jyotish, and while these topics interest me, I went into business and

away from astrology. This is the first time we've had cause to consult with a

Jyotish.

>

> My niece (her name is Love) is born and raised in the US. She is 26. She has

been dating a boy (Matthew) for a few months whom her parents like very much.

She came to her parents to ask if they would match the horoscopes, and they

asked me to help. We are Sindhi Indians; Matthew is Caucasian.

>

> Friends, I have asked two different Jyotishas who are highly regarded and whom

I trust very much in their education and experience. I am feeling very

conflicted in what advice I should give to Love's parents.

>

> I hope that you all will be willing to help me out.

>

> The Guna (Ashtkoot) is coming to 33.5 (out of 36). That is excellent, I know!

The points that are not 100% are: Vashya (1 of 2) and Tara/Dina (1.5 of 3). The

rest are 100%.

>

> The boy's nakshatra is Revati; Love's is Bharani.

>

> The issue is that Matthew has Rahu in his 5th house and Ketu in his 11th house

in his Lagna chart. In his Navamsa chart, he has Ravi and Ketu in his 8th house.

He also has Sukra and Moon in his 12th house. He has nothing in his 7th house.

>

> Love has Rahu in her 3rd house and Ketu in her 9th house. In her 7th house,

she has Pluto and Sani. Sukra is in her 2nd house.

>

> I am happy to provide anymore details, including full planets in all houses.

They are looking for advice on whether to get engaged or not.

>

> One Jyotish has said that the pair is FANTASTIC and that we should not let

this kind of pairing slip from our hands; that he will provide extremely good

partner, and be loyal and faithful companion. The other Jyotish has said the boy

will cheat on her and the relationship will end in about 10 years in a divorce;

that her life will be all broken promises as a result of his Ketu/Rahu; that he

will be suspicious of her always and cheating. He says that Love should run as

fast as she can because there is no indication of a divorce in her own

horoscope. He says there is every indication she should have a wonderful

marriage in her horoscope and to mix with this one would make problems. Again,

the other Jyotish tells us that it's the opposite; this would make her life

happy and complete.

>

> There is no mangal in either horoscope.

>

> If anyone can help shed some light; please do...We would be truly grateful.

>

> Sincerely

>

> Dhiraj Sharma Relwani

>

> Here are the planets:

> Matthew:

> Lagna Chart:

> 5: Mang, Guru, Rahu

> 6: Pluto, Sani

> 8: Neptune, Uranus

> 11: Budh, Ravi, Ketu

> 12: Sukra, Moon

>

> A Jyotish tells me it is significant to mention that his Navamsa Chart shows

Ravi and Ketu in 8th house.

>

> Love:

> Lagna Chart:

> 1: Ravi, Mang, Budh, Moon

> 2: Sukra

> 3: Rahu

> 7: Sani, Pluto

> 8: Guru, Uranus

> 9: Neptune, Ketu

>

 

[Guest guest]

Dear friend,

 

 

I am presenting the analysis of the girl's chart only without

 

going into the details of the marriage match making process.

 

In the girl's chart...

 

7th lord of rasi and navams chart Venus suffers from papa kartari yoga.

 

9th lord of dharma is moon

 

badly placed in the 6th house

 

because house lord mars is strongly

 

afflicted by 6th cusp.

 

Please note here that lagna and 6th lord

 

getting strongly afflicted by 6th cusp

 

mars will act as 6th lord to major extent

 

and as lagna lord to minor extent.

 

Mars with Chandra lagna ( navamsa debilited moon)

 

and 12th to marriage karaka venus

 

increases the Mars blemish.

 

The exception of own sign placement not applicable here.

 

In the Rasi Chart Upapada Lagna with ketu is good.

 

But stability to be seen from 2nd and 8th from UL

 

2nd lord Saturn in house of isolation -12th.

 

8th lord from UL is moon placed in 6th - house 12th to

house of marriage.

 

In the navamsa chart bastard planet Mercury exalted in second house to Upapada

Lagna.

 

Navamsa Lagna has Rahu plus moon.

 

Both Rahu and moon get debilited in sign scorpio.

 

Rahu-Moon period commences from November 2015 onwards.

 

Humbly speaking rahu-moon combination is held

 

as combination for separation/divorce/cheating/ widowhood/ marriage with a widow

or widower in all

 

classics of astrology.

 

Sticking to moral austerity/

learning and doing meditational exercises

 

to have control over passion and impules/

 

worship of Goddes Durga /Gouri.

 

reading of Mangal Chandi Stotra and

 

Maha Mrityunjay Mantra may be helpful

 

in avoiding mishaps in relationships.

 

Severe weakness of Darakaraka Sun is additional factor to the problem in

relationship besides

 

the weakness of venus in rasi and navamsa chart.

 

Exaltation of venus and mercury in navamsa has no value

 

as they suffer serious weakness (papa kartari yoga) and

 

affliction by 6th house and

 

weakness of rasi dispositor mars in the Rasi Chart.

 

 

Regards,

 

Mrutyunjay Tripathy

 

Body Longitude Nakshatra Pada Rasi Navamsa

 

Lagna 16 Sc 34' 53.32 " Anu 4 Sc Sc

Sun - DK 0 Ar 59' 56.76 " Aswi 1 Ar Ar

Moon - AmK 23 Ar 21' 21.51 " Bhar 4 Ar Sc

Mars - PiK 13 Ar 28' 11.04 " Bhar 1 Ar Le

Mercury - BK 19 Ar 18' 37.32 " Bhar 2 Ar Vi

Jupiter ® - MK 16 Sc 47' 30.90 " Jye 1 Sc Sg

Venus - PK 8 Ta 23' 44.03 " Krit 4 Ta Pi

Saturn ® - GK 8 Li 00' 04.24 " Swat 1 Li Sg

Rahu - AK 4 Ge 44' 11.77 " Mrig 4 Ge Sc

Ketu 4 Sg 44' 11.77 " Mool 2 Sg Ta

Maandi 9 Cp 42' 22.99 " USha 4 Cp Pi

Gulika 27 Sg 35' 46.16 " USha 1 Sg Sg

> Thank you Prashant and my apologies for not including this information.

>

> Both of them are living in New Jersey USA. The girl is sindhi, her parents

have their own importing business, have been happily married (no major problems)

for 40 years. Girl is managing about 4 people at a online software company, she

herself is doing the global product management. She has been doing 2 years in

this same job. She has no plans to change jobs and expects a promotion within a

year. Her father had Kaal Sarp Yog, but a pooja was done to help when he was

young. No Mangal is either of her parents horoscopes. Their gunas match 24

points.

>

> Boy is caucasian, parents are divorced very badly. Father cheated on the

mother consistently throughout life and remarried around 45. Boy says that he

will never cheat because he is close to his mom and has much more respect and

better relationship with her. He has made a very good impression on the

families, even I admit to liking him very much before I heard these conflicts

about his horoscope. He is working as a Finance Analyst for a telephone company

for three years. Before this, he did Social Work with the mentally handicapped

for three years. He is making less money than my niece by almost half. But, some

things are promising; he does seem to have ambition.

>

> birth details are girl: 10 22 PM ridgewood nj 14th april 1983

> birth details are boy: 2 44 AM new brunswick nj 19th february 1980

>

> Thank you again.

>

> , Prashant Kumar G B <gbp_kumar@>

wrote:

> >

> > Pl post birth details where r they now, what r they doing professionally for

a living some info on their parents can also help

> >

> > more info the better esp withdates jobs in out dates etc

> >

> >

> > this is a v wide subject and ppl have diffeent approaches, patience and ur

destiny can lead u to the right answers

> >

> > prashant

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > ________________________________

> > dsharmarelwanijyotisha <dsharmarelwanijyotisha@>

> >

> > Tuesday, September 8, 2009 6:57:03 AM

> > Conflicting analysis of horoscopes - your respected opinions

requested

> >

> >

> > Hello respected Jyotishas, Jyotishas in Learning, and those interested in

astrology.

> >

> > I am new to this group. Indeed, I sought it out because I am seeking

additional opinions for the horoscope matching of my niece. I am the grandson of

a famous jyotish, and while these topics interest me, I went into business and

away from astrology. This is the first time we've had cause to consult with a

Jyotish.

> >

> > My niece (her name is Love) is born and raised in the US. She is 26. She has

been dating a boy (Matthew) for a few months whom her parents like very much.

She came to her parents to ask if they would match the horoscopes, and they

asked me to help. We are Sindhi Indians; Matthew is Caucasian.

> >

> > Friends, I have asked two different Jyotishas who are highly regarded and

whom I trust very much in their education and experience. I am feeling very

conflicted in what advice I should give to Love's parents.

> >

> > I hope that you all will be willing to help me out.

> >

> > The Guna (Ashtkoot) is coming to 33.5 (out of 36). That is excellent, I

know! The points that are not 100% are: Vashya (1 of 2) and Tara/Dina (1.5 of

3). The rest are 100%.

> >

> > The boy's nakshatra is Revati; Love's is Bharani.

> >

> > The issue is that Matthew has Rahu in his 5th house and Ketu in his 11th

house in his Lagna chart. In his Navamsa chart, he has Ravi and Ketu in his 8th

house. He also has Sukra and Moon in his 12th house. He has nothing in his 7th

house.

> >

> > Love has Rahu in her 3rd house and Ketu in her 9th house. In her 7th house,

she has Pluto and Sani. Sukra is in her 2nd house.

> >

> > I am happy to provide anymore details, including full planets in all houses.

They are looking for advice on whether to get engaged or not.

> >

> > One Jyotish has said that the pair is FANTASTIC and that we should not let

this kind of pairing slip from our hands; that he will provide extremely good

partner, and be loyal and faithful companion. The other Jyotish has said the boy

will cheat on her and the relationship will end in about 10 years in a divorce;

that her life will be all broken promises as a result of his Ketu/Rahu; that he

will be suspicious of her always and cheating. He says that Love should run as

fast as she can because there is no indication of a divorce in her own

horoscope. He says there is every indication she should have a wonderful

marriage in her horoscope and to mix with this one would make problems. Again,

the other Jyotish tells us that it's the opposite; this would make her life

happy and complete.

> >

> > There is no mangal in either horoscope.

> >

> > If anyone can help shed some light; please do...We would be truly grateful.

> >

> > Sincerely

> >

> > Dhiraj Sharma Relwani

> >

> > Here are the planets:

> > Matthew:

> > Lagna Chart:

> > 5: Mang, Guru, Rahu

> > 6: Pluto, Sani

> > 8: Neptune, Uranus

> > 11: Budh, Ravi, Ketu

> > 12: Sukra, Moon

> >

> > A Jyotish tells me it is significant to mention that his Navamsa Chart shows

Ravi and Ketu in 8th house.

> >

> > Love:

> > Lagna Chart:

> > 1: Ravi, Mang, Budh, Moon

> > 2: Sukra

> > 3: Rahu

> > 7: Sani, Pluto

> > 8: Guru, Uranus

> > 9: Neptune, Ketu

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

[Guest guest]

Dear Mrutyunjay Ji,

 

Thank you extremely for this information. This is so different from what our

Jyotishas have told us about my niece's chart! I understand people have

different interpretation, but perhaps people also feel uncomfortable telling

parents these things for the daughter.

 

I thank you for this....I will respond back more after I have digested the

information.

 

I thank you most sincerely.

 

, " astrologer_mrutyunjay "

<astrologer_mrutyunjay wrote:

>

> Dear friend,

>

>

> I am presenting the analysis of the girl's chart only without

>

> going into the details of the marriage match making process.

>

> In the girl's chart...

>

> 7th lord of rasi and navams chart Venus suffers from papa kartari yoga.

>

> 9th lord of dharma is moon

>

> badly placed in the 6th house

>

> because house lord mars is strongly

>

> afflicted by 6th cusp.

>

> Please note here that lagna and 6th lord

>

> getting strongly afflicted by 6th cusp

>

> mars will act as 6th lord to major extent

>

> and as lagna lord to minor extent.

>

> Mars with Chandra lagna ( navamsa debilited moon)

>

> and 12th to marriage karaka venus

>

> increases the Mars blemish.

>

> The exception of own sign placement not applicable here.

>

> In the Rasi Chart Upapada Lagna with ketu is good.

>

> But stability to be seen from 2nd and 8th from UL

>

> 2nd lord Saturn in house of isolation -12th.

>

> 8th lord from UL is moon placed in 6th - house 12th to

> house of marriage.

>

> In the navamsa chart bastard planet Mercury exalted in second house to Upapada

Lagna.

>

> Navamsa Lagna has Rahu plus moon.

>

> Both Rahu and moon get debilited in sign scorpio.

>

> Rahu-Moon period commences from November 2015 onwards.

>

> Humbly speaking rahu-moon combination is held

>

> as combination for separation/divorce/cheating/ widowhood/ marriage with a

widow or widower in all

>

> classics of astrology.

>

> Sticking to moral austerity/

> learning and doing meditational exercises

>

> to have control over passion and impules/

>

> worship of Goddes Durga /Gouri.

>

> reading of Mangal Chandi Stotra and

>

> Maha Mrityunjay Mantra may be helpful

>

> in avoiding mishaps in relationships.

>

> Severe weakness of Darakaraka Sun is additional factor to the problem in

relationship besides

>

> the weakness of venus in rasi and navamsa chart.

>

> Exaltation of venus and mercury in navamsa has no value

>

> as they suffer serious weakness (papa kartari yoga) and

>

> affliction by 6th house and

>

> weakness of rasi dispositor mars in the Rasi Chart.

>

>

> Regards,

>

> Mrutyunjay Tripathy

>

> Body Longitude Nakshatra Pada Rasi Navamsa

>

> Lagna 16 Sc 34' 53.32 " Anu 4 Sc Sc

> Sun - DK 0 Ar 59' 56.76 " Aswi 1 Ar Ar

> Moon - AmK 23 Ar 21' 21.51 " Bhar 4 Ar Sc

> Mars - PiK 13 Ar 28' 11.04 " Bhar 1 Ar Le

> Mercury - BK 19 Ar 18' 37.32 " Bhar 2 Ar Vi

> Jupiter ® - MK 16 Sc 47' 30.90 " Jye 1 Sc Sg

> Venus - PK 8 Ta 23' 44.03 " Krit 4 Ta Pi

> Saturn ® - GK 8 Li 00' 04.24 " Swat 1 Li Sg

> Rahu - AK 4 Ge 44' 11.77 " Mrig 4 Ge Sc

> Ketu 4 Sg 44' 11.77 " Mool 2 Sg Ta

> Maandi 9 Cp 42' 22.99 " USha 4 Cp Pi

> Gulika 27 Sg 35' 46.16 " USha 1 Sg Sg

> > Thank you Prashant and my apologies for not including this information.

> >

> > Both of them are living in New Jersey USA. The girl is sindhi, her parents

have their own importing business, have been happily married (no major problems)

for 40 years. Girl is managing about 4 people at a online software company, she

herself is doing the global product management. She has been doing 2 years in

this same job. She has no plans to change jobs and expects a promotion within a

year. Her father had Kaal Sarp Yog, but a pooja was done to help when he was

young. No Mangal is either of her parents horoscopes. Their gunas match 24

points.

> >

> > Boy is caucasian, parents are divorced very badly. Father cheated on the

mother consistently throughout life and remarried around 45. Boy says that he

will never cheat because he is close to his mom and has much more respect and

better relationship with her. He has made a very good impression on the

families, even I admit to liking him very much before I heard these conflicts

about his horoscope. He is working as a Finance Analyst for a telephone company

for three years. Before this, he did Social Work with the mentally handicapped

for three years. He is making less money than my niece by almost half. But, some

things are promising; he does seem to have ambition.

> >

> > birth details are girl: 10 22 PM ridgewood nj 14th april 1983

> > birth details are boy: 2 44 AM new brunswick nj 19th february 1980

> >

> > Thank you again.

> >

> > , Prashant Kumar G B <gbp_kumar@>

wrote:

> > >

> > > Pl post birth details where r they now, what r they doing professionally

for a living some info on their parents can also help

> > >

> > > more info the better esp withdates jobs in out dates etc

> > >

> > >

> > > this is a v wide subject and ppl have diffeent approaches, patience and ur

destiny can lead u to the right answers

> > >

> > > prashant

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > > ________________________________

> > > dsharmarelwanijyotisha <dsharmarelwanijyotisha@>

> > >

> > > Tuesday, September 8, 2009 6:57:03 AM

> > > Conflicting analysis of horoscopes - your respected opinions

requested

> > >

> > >

> > > Hello respected Jyotishas, Jyotishas in Learning, and those interested in

astrology.

> > >

> > > I am new to this group. Indeed, I sought it out because I am seeking

additional opinions for the horoscope matching of my niece. I am the grandson of

a famous jyotish, and while these topics interest me, I went into business and

away from astrology. This is the first time we've had cause to consult with a

Jyotish.

> > >

> > > My niece (her name is Love) is born and raised in the US. She is 26. She

has been dating a boy (Matthew) for a few months whom her parents like very

much. She came to her parents to ask if they would match the horoscopes, and

they asked me to help. We are Sindhi Indians; Matthew is Caucasian.

> > >

> > > Friends, I have asked two different Jyotishas who are highly regarded and

whom I trust very much in their education and experience. I am feeling very

conflicted in what advice I should give to Love's parents.

> > >

> > > I hope that you all will be willing to help me out.

> > >

> > > The Guna (Ashtkoot) is coming to 33.5 (out of 36). That is excellent, I

know! The points that are not 100% are: Vashya (1 of 2) and Tara/Dina (1.5 of

3). The rest are 100%.

> > >

> > > The boy's nakshatra is Revati; Love's is Bharani.

> > >

> > > The issue is that Matthew has Rahu in his 5th house and Ketu in his 11th

house in his Lagna chart. In his Navamsa chart, he has Ravi and Ketu in his 8th

house. He also has Sukra and Moon in his 12th house. He has nothing in his 7th

house.

> > >

> > > Love has Rahu in her 3rd house and Ketu in her 9th house. In her 7th

house, she has Pluto and Sani. Sukra is in her 2nd house.

> > >

> > > I am happy to provide anymore details, including full planets in all

houses. They are looking for advice on whether to get engaged or not.

> > >

> > > One Jyotish has said that the pair is FANTASTIC and that we should not let

this kind of pairing slip from our hands; that he will provide extremely good

partner, and be loyal and faithful companion. The other Jyotish has said the boy

will cheat on her and the relationship will end in about 10 years in a divorce;

that her life will be all broken promises as a result of his Ketu/Rahu; that he

will be suspicious of her always and cheating. He says that Love should run as

fast as she can because there is no indication of a divorce in her own

horoscope. He says there is every indication she should have a wonderful

marriage in her horoscope and to mix with this one would make problems. Again,

the other Jyotish tells us that it's the opposite; this would make her life

happy and complete.

> > >

> > > There is no mangal in either horoscope.

> > >

> > > If anyone can help shed some light; please do...We would be truly

grateful.

> > >

> > > Sincerely

> > >

> > > Dhiraj Sharma Relwani

> > >

> > > Here are the planets:

> > > Matthew:

> > > Lagna Chart:

> > > 5: Mang, Guru, Rahu

> > > 6: Pluto, Sani

> > > 8: Neptune, Uranus

> > > 11: Budh, Ravi, Ketu

> > > 12: Sukra, Moon

> > >

> > > A Jyotish tells me it is significant to mention that his Navamsa Chart

shows Ravi and Ketu in 8th house.

> > >

> > > Love:

> > > Lagna Chart:

> > > 1: Ravi, Mang, Budh, Moon

> > > 2: Sukra

> > > 3: Rahu

> > > 7: Sani, Pluto

> > > 8: Guru, Uranus

> > > 9: Neptune, Ketu

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

[Guest guest]

Mrutyunjay Tripathy Ji,

 

I was wondering if it is not too much trouble (though I know it is already

asking a lot) if you might be able to do a similar brief analysis for the boy.

 

We had never heard anything like this about my niece and are now realizing, our

Jyotishas have personal interest since they know the families. Would be helpful

to know what your knowledge says of the boy's charts.

 

We appreciate this and are saying blessings onto your name.

 

Thank you.

 

 

, " astrologer_mrutyunjay "

<astrologer_mrutyunjay wrote:

>

> Dear friend,

>

>

> I am presenting the analysis of the girl's chart only without

>

> going into the details of the marriage match making process.

>

> In the girl's chart...

>

> 7th lord of rasi and navams chart Venus suffers from papa kartari yoga.

>

> 9th lord of dharma is moon

>

> badly placed in the 6th house

>

> because house lord mars is strongly

>

> afflicted by 6th cusp.

>

> Please note here that lagna and 6th lord

>

> getting strongly afflicted by 6th cusp

>

> mars will act as 6th lord to major extent

>

> and as lagna lord to minor extent.

>

> Mars with Chandra lagna ( navamsa debilited moon)

>

> and 12th to marriage karaka venus

>

> increases the Mars blemish.

>

> The exception of own sign placement not applicable here.

>

> In the Rasi Chart Upapada Lagna with ketu is good.

>

> But stability to be seen from 2nd and 8th from UL

>

> 2nd lord Saturn in house of isolation -12th.

>

> 8th lord from UL is moon placed in 6th - house 12th to

> house of marriage.

>

> In the navamsa chart bastard planet Mercury exalted in second house to Upapada

Lagna.

>

> Navamsa Lagna has Rahu plus moon.

>

> Both Rahu and moon get debilited in sign scorpio.

>

> Rahu-Moon period commences from November 2015 onwards.

>

> Humbly speaking rahu-moon combination is held

>

> as combination for separation/divorce/cheating/ widowhood/ marriage with a

widow or widower in all

>

> classics of astrology.

>

> Sticking to moral austerity/

> learning and doing meditational exercises

>

> to have control over passion and impules/

>

> worship of Goddes Durga /Gouri.

>

> reading of Mangal Chandi Stotra and

>

> Maha Mrityunjay Mantra may be helpful

>

> in avoiding mishaps in relationships.

>

> Severe weakness of Darakaraka Sun is additional factor to the problem in

relationship besides

>

> the weakness of venus in rasi and navamsa chart.

>

> Exaltation of venus and mercury in navamsa has no value

>

> as they suffer serious weakness (papa kartari yoga) and

>

> affliction by 6th house and

>

> weakness of rasi dispositor mars in the Rasi Chart.

>

>

> Regards,

>

> Mrutyunjay Tripathy

>

> Body Longitude Nakshatra Pada Rasi Navamsa

>

> Lagna 16 Sc 34' 53.32 " Anu 4 Sc Sc

> Sun - DK 0 Ar 59' 56.76 " Aswi 1 Ar Ar

> Moon - AmK 23 Ar 21' 21.51 " Bhar 4 Ar Sc

> Mars - PiK 13 Ar 28' 11.04 " Bhar 1 Ar Le

> Mercury - BK 19 Ar 18' 37.32 " Bhar 2 Ar Vi

> Jupiter ® - MK 16 Sc 47' 30.90 " Jye 1 Sc Sg

> Venus - PK 8 Ta 23' 44.03 " Krit 4 Ta Pi

> Saturn ® - GK 8 Li 00' 04.24 " Swat 1 Li Sg

> Rahu - AK 4 Ge 44' 11.77 " Mrig 4 Ge Sc

> Ketu 4 Sg 44' 11.77 " Mool 2 Sg Ta

> Maandi 9 Cp 42' 22.99 " USha 4 Cp Pi

> Gulika 27 Sg 35' 46.16 " USha 1 Sg Sg

> > Thank you Prashant and my apologies for not including this information.

> >

> > Both of them are living in New Jersey USA. The girl is sindhi, her parents

have their own importing business, have been happily married (no major problems)

for 40 years. Girl is managing about 4 people at a online software company, she

herself is doing the global product management. She has been doing 2 years in

this same job. She has no plans to change jobs and expects a promotion within a

year. Her father had Kaal Sarp Yog, but a pooja was done to help when he was

young. No Mangal is either of her parents horoscopes. Their gunas match 24

points.

> >

> > Boy is caucasian, parents are divorced very badly. Father cheated on the

mother consistently throughout life and remarried around 45. Boy says that he

will never cheat because he is close to his mom and has much more respect and

better relationship with her. He has made a very good impression on the

families, even I admit to liking him very much before I heard these conflicts

about his horoscope. He is working as a Finance Analyst for a telephone company

for three years. Before this, he did Social Work with the mentally handicapped

for three years. He is making less money than my niece by almost half. But, some

things are promising; he does seem to have ambition.

> >

> > birth details are girl: 10 22 PM ridgewood nj 14th april 1983

> > birth details are boy: 2 44 AM new brunswick nj 19th february 1980

> >

> > Thank you again.

> >

> > , Prashant Kumar G B <gbp_kumar@>

wrote:

> > >

> > > Pl post birth details where r they now, what r they doing professionally

for a living some info on their parents can also help

> > >

> > > more info the better esp withdates jobs in out dates etc

> > >

> > >

> > > this is a v wide subject and ppl have diffeent approaches, patience and ur

destiny can lead u to the right answers

> > >

> > > prashant

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > > ________________________________

> > > dsharmarelwanijyotisha <dsharmarelwanijyotisha@>

> > >

> > > Tuesday, September 8, 2009 6:57:03 AM

> > > Conflicting analysis of horoscopes - your respected opinions

requested

> > >

> > >

> > > Hello respected Jyotishas, Jyotishas in Learning, and those interested in

astrology.

> > >

> > > I am new to this group. Indeed, I sought it out because I am seeking

additional opinions for the horoscope matching of my niece. I am the grandson of

a famous jyotish, and while these topics interest me, I went into business and

away from astrology. This is the first time we've had cause to consult with a

Jyotish.

> > >

> > > My niece (her name is Love) is born and raised in the US. She is 26. She

has been dating a boy (Matthew) for a few months whom her parents like very

much. She came to her parents to ask if they would match the horoscopes, and

they asked me to help. We are Sindhi Indians; Matthew is Caucasian.

> > >

> > > Friends, I have asked two different Jyotishas who are highly regarded and

whom I trust very much in their education and experience. I am feeling very

conflicted in what advice I should give to Love's parents.

> > >

> > > I hope that you all will be willing to help me out.

> > >

> > > The Guna (Ashtkoot) is coming to 33.5 (out of 36). That is excellent, I

know! The points that are not 100% are: Vashya (1 of 2) and Tara/Dina (1.5 of

3). The rest are 100%.

> > >

> > > The boy's nakshatra is Revati; Love's is Bharani.

> > >

> > > The issue is that Matthew has Rahu in his 5th house and Ketu in his 11th

house in his Lagna chart. In his Navamsa chart, he has Ravi and Ketu in his 8th

house. He also has Sukra and Moon in his 12th house. He has nothing in his 7th

house.

> > >

> > > Love has Rahu in her 3rd house and Ketu in her 9th house. In her 7th

house, she has Pluto and Sani. Sukra is in her 2nd house.

> > >

> > > I am happy to provide anymore details, including full planets in all

houses. They are looking for advice on whether to get engaged or not.

> > >

> > > One Jyotish has said that the pair is FANTASTIC and that we should not let

this kind of pairing slip from our hands; that he will provide extremely good

partner, and be loyal and faithful companion. The other Jyotish has said the boy

will cheat on her and the relationship will end in about 10 years in a divorce;

that her life will be all broken promises as a result of his Ketu/Rahu; that he

will be suspicious of her always and cheating. He says that Love should run as

fast as she can because there is no indication of a divorce in her own

horoscope. He says there is every indication she should have a wonderful

marriage in her horoscope and to mix with this one would make problems. Again,

the other Jyotish tells us that it's the opposite; this would make her life

happy and complete.

> > >

> > > There is no mangal in either horoscope.

> > >

> > > If anyone can help shed some light; please do...We would be truly

grateful.

> > >

> > > Sincerely

> > >

> > > Dhiraj Sharma Relwani

> > >

> > > Here are the planets:

> > > Matthew:

> > > Lagna Chart:

> > > 5: Mang, Guru, Rahu

> > > 6: Pluto, Sani

> > > 8: Neptune, Uranus

> > > 11: Budh, Ravi, Ketu

> > > 12: Sukra, Moon

> > >

> > > A Jyotish tells me it is significant to mention that his Navamsa Chart

shows Ravi and Ketu in 8th house.

> > >

> > > Love:

> > > Lagna Chart:

> > > 1: Ravi, Mang, Budh, Moon

> > > 2: Sukra

> > > 3: Rahu

> > > 7: Sani, Pluto

> > > 8: Guru, Uranus

> > > 9: Neptune, Ketu

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > >