BSE Share Price Index Forecast for 20 Oct 2009

October 20, 2009

To All,

A File BSE_20Oct09.jpg has been uploaded in the files section of

this group, which contains graphical forecast of Bombay Stock Exchange

for today.

-Vinay Jha

October 20, 2009

Dear Vinay Jha,

I must congradulate and thank you for this bold attempt.

There are three parts in this story.

1) The general sentiment for the day (Though only given upto 13:56) is down and

has been proven correct.

2) I day trading each swing is important. The gross mistake in this regard is

the Upward trend given by you upto 11:56AM which never happened and it has all

the down with only minor swings. The danger is if I depend on this chart, I will

be expecting a rise in moring say at about 10:15AM and trade where are it never

came up.

3) The second part of the day is not provided which in reality could swing

either ways (though tody it did not happen).

This is only to point the problem and never to discourage you. pls take it in a

good sense. and to help you further in your search.

I am aware that it is very difficult and the attempt itself should be welcomed.

with warm regards

A.G.Suresh Babu Shenoy.

, " VJha " <vinayjhaa16 wrote:

>

> To All,

>

> A File BSE_20Oct09.jpg has been uploaded in the files section of

> this group, which contains graphical forecast of Bombay Stock Exchange

> for today.

>

> -Vinay Jha

>

October 20, 2009

Suresh Ji,

I needed more time to do the job, and in spite of all the hurry I could

prepare a graph only upto 13:54 PM only, because I had to post the

prediction by 10 am.

Due to this hurry, I comitted some errors in evaluating the kundalis,

because making and judging 21 kundalis within a short time and then

comparing them with each other to make a graph is a tremendous task. It

is really a bold attempt, for the first time in my life.

Yet, I am encouraged with the results, some of which are overlooked by

you because you do not possess the data I worked upon. It is not your

fault, but a result of near impossibility of posting a large file

containing so many kundalis in files section.

I am posting a post-event comparison of SENSEX and my projection in the

files section within half an hour. The comparison must be FAIR, which I

need to explain :

I made distinct kundalis programmatically whenever any planet changed a

house in horoscopes of Bombay. I neglected to make separate kundalis

when lordshiops and raashis of bhaavas changed, which explains the

differences in real graph with my projection. But if real graph is

smoothed so as to match with the timings of my projections (ie, timings

of planetary transitions), then a FAIR comparison can be made. Such a

comparison is being uploaded in the files section shortly.

At present, I am preparing a scale for determining the magnitude of

change in graph due to planetary influences, and as far as I know it is

one of the most difficult tasks in astrology. My past experience in rain

forecasting is helping me in quatification of planetary influences. My

aim is to help real Day Traders and if you read the post even comparison

soon to be posted by me, you will believe that I am moving in the right

direction, in spite of some errors due to hurry. The astrological data I

possess is tremendously powerful and accurate, the shortcoming is mine :

I am not able to process so much data within a day. I am improving my

software, and I hope to present better forecasts within a few days.

<<<The gross mistake in this regard is the Upward trend given by you

upto 11:56AM which never happened and it has all the down with only

minor swings. The danger is if I depend on this chart, I will be

expecting a rise in moring say at about 10:15AM and trade where are it

never came up.>>>

My graph really started from 10:03 AM (10:02:59), and the upward swing

you speak of lasted till 12:05:47 PM and not 11:56 AM (11:56 AM is due

to BSE's scaling but my timings are due to planetary transitions).

Between 10:03 AM and 12:06 PM, SENSEX moved from 17326 to ~17394 in

fact and ~17415 in my projection. Actual upswing was +68 while I

projected +89. You should not say the " upswing ... never happened " .

Secondly, one should not select ANY point of my projection for making

comparison with ANY other point. Points of planetary transitions should

be used for this purpose. I had given such timings in my earlier

forecasts of SENSEX (Oct 15 and 16), which in the 20 Oct graph such

cardinal points can be discerned from the curve itself. I must write an

explanatory note with every forecast to remove such confusions. I hope

your doubts will evaporate when you read the next file

(BSE_20Oct09_Analysis.doc).

Thanks for your interest.

-VJ

==================== =====

, " Suresh Babu "

<sureshbabuag wrote:

>

> Dear Vinay Jha,

>

> I must congradulate and thank you for this bold attempt.

>

> There are three parts in this story.

>

> 1) The general sentiment for the day (Though only given upto 13:56) is

down and has been proven correct.

> 2) I day trading each swing is important. The gross mistake in this

regard is the Upward trend given by you upto 11:56AM which never

happened and it has all the down with only minor swings. The danger is

if I depend on this chart, I will be expecting a rise in moring say at

about 10:15AM and trade where are it never came up.

> 3) The second part of the day is not provided which in reality could

swing either ways (though tody it did not happen).

>

> This is only to point the problem and never to discourage you. pls

take it in a good sense. and to help you further in your search.

>

> I am aware that it is very difficult and the attempt itself should be

welcomed.

>

> with warm regards

> A.G.Suresh Babu Shenoy.

>

> , " VJha " vinayjhaa16@ wrote:

> >

> > To All,

> >

> > A File BSE_20Oct09.jpg has been uploaded in the files

section of

> > this group, which contains graphical forecast of Bombay Stock

Exchange

> > for today.

> >

> > -Vinay Jha

> >

>

October 20, 2009

Dear Vinay jha,

What I wrote was meant to be discouragement or degradation of your efforts. Even

if you had made a mistake even after getting enough time, it won't matter much

as we know the work is tedious and it is human to commit mistakes.

That said, what I wrote on the swings is looking at the graphs of Bse & the one

posted by you.

I was actually happy to see the general trend to correct as posted by you,

irrespective of the inbetween swings. That itself is a good work considering the

odds.

So congrats and definetly I shall go through your article. My only complaint is

I am not getting enough time to work on this.

regards

A.G.Suresh Babu Shenoy

________________________________

VJha <vinayjhaa16

Tue, October 20, 2009 7:40:37 PM

Re: BSE Share Price Index Forecast for 20 Oct 2009