Guest guest Posted March 14, 2010 Report Share Posted March 14, 2010 Dear Freinds i m very new to this group, read various article by various professional , i just want to put some light on thumb rule of astrology , according to me idont think there is anythumb rule of astrolgy ,, i have seen various horoscope in which the planet are in exalted state in kendra,,, than also they dont give the appropiate result and many thing like all " Panch Maha Pursha Yoga " give the individual with all sort of blessing in form of health wealth , good surrounding happy family ,etc.,, but what i mean to say that any body having exalted jupter exalted in kendra have " hans Yoga " accoring to differnt shsastra we learn , it mean that having all sort of benefits in life ,,if that is true for everyone, than person born when jupiter incancer rashi have all the benefit ,, but there we need to see that the following issue what i think is appropiate before making any prediction 1) dont u consider the nakshatra in which tha planet is situated,, 2) dont u consider the degree in which the planet situated, 3) is the planet are in retrogade postion or not. 4) dont you consider the dasha previaling also , may be the debilated planet dasha prevail ,, than the result wuil be highly efected 5) if the same jupter having the aspect of the cruel or malefic planet dont u think the result will be affected,, so its not simply by seeing the lagna chart ,, WHAT I THINK ,, we should not predict, we want to go for the accurate prediction maximum time ,, i had read various article saying that if 2nd lord in 11th , and 11th lord in 2nd , one will be getting abundence of wealth ,, its not the thumb rule ,, but it only become powerful according to dasha ,, degree of planet and variuos other factor what i think had wrote earlier to be consider ,, and this is to consider with every yoga , if that is not true ,, every one will find some 4-5 dhan yoga in his or her horoscope ,, because there are so many ,, rgds Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2010 Report Share Posted March 14, 2010 Sir, In addition to your list; Individuals conduct also matters; It has also to be seen whether the native has maintained the exaltation, decreased the impact of debilitation / malefic tendencies of planets or vice-versa. If somebody's Jupiter is Raddi (showing no promise), does it mean that the native will go indulging in such acts that further harm it. In that case no beneficence of Jupiter will remain and how would next birth be possible. Astrology is tool to guide the individual to mold his tendencies for his advantage. No 2 finger prints are same, even 2 leaves on a tree are not exactly same, even 2 stones are not exactly matching. Then how could the promise shown by planetary positions in 2 / same / similar horoscope fructify in an exactly same way. Regards Kulbir Bains. On Sun, Mar 14, 2010 at 5:57 PM, astrovejai <astrovejai wrote: > > > Dear Freinds > > i m very new to this group, read various article by various professional , > i just want to put some light on thumb rule of astrology , according to me > idont think there is anythumb rule of astrolgy ,, i have seen various > horoscope in which the planet are in exalted state in kendra,,, than also > they dont give the appropiate result and many thing like all " Panch Maha > Pursha Yoga " give the individual with all sort of blessing in form of > health wealth , good surrounding happy family ,etc.,, > but what i mean to say that any body having exalted jupter exalted in > kendra have " hans Yoga " accoring to differnt shsastra we learn , it mean > that having all sort of benefits in life ,,if that is true for everyone, > than person born when jupiter incancer rashi have all the benefit ,, but > there we need to see that the following issue what i think is appropiate > before making any prediction > > 1) dont u consider the nakshatra in which tha planet is situated,, > 2) dont u consider the degree in which the planet situated, > 3) is the planet are in retrogade postion or not. > 4) dont you consider the dasha previaling also , may be the debilated > planet dasha prevail ,, than the result wuil be highly efected > 5) if the same jupter having the aspect of the cruel or malefic planet dont > u think the result will be affected,, > > so its not simply by seeing the lagna chart ,, WHAT I THINK ,, we should > not predict, we want to go for the accurate prediction maximum time ,, > > i had read various article saying that if 2nd lord in 11th , and 11th lord > in 2nd , one will be getting abundence of wealth ,, its not the thumb rule > ,, but it only become powerful according to dasha ,, degree of planet and > variuos other factor what i think had wrote earlier to be consider ,, and > this is to consider with every yoga , > if that is not true ,, every one will find some 4-5 dhan yoga in his or her > horoscope ,, because there are so many ,, > > rgds > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2010 Report Share Posted March 14, 2010 Vejal, there is a THUMB rule that there can't be thumb rules in Jyotishya. as this is not a demonstrable science on a assembly line, it can predict perfectly in most cases with good birth data, well qualified, good matured astrologers and a sincere querist/seeker in proportion to his/her karma at the given moment or at a time when karma allows them to use it either as a cushion or a pathfinder, or come out of a dark tunel with good hope, courage all along with tangible result in the long run but it is not always the cases as said for above reasons no rule can say this will be there due to this combination, transit, placement, yoga, balas etc it is a combination of all plus the karmic balance sheet / influences already said best wishes .- G B Prashant Kumar Life Member ICAS. /database?method=reportRows & tbl=6 ________________________________ astrovejai <astrovejai Sun, March 14, 2010 5:57:04 PM there is no thumb rule in astrology Dear Freinds i m very new to this group, read various article by various professional , i just want to put some light on thumb rule of astrology , according to me idont think there is anythumb rule of astrolgy ,, i have seen various horoscope in which the planet are in exalted state in kendra,,, than also they dont give the appropiate result and many thing like all " Panch Maha Pursha Yoga " give the individual with all sort of blessing in form of health wealth , good surrounding happy family ,etc.,, but what i mean to say that any body having exalted jupter exalted in kendra have " hans Yoga " accoring to differnt shsastra we learn , it mean that having all sort of benefits in life ,,if that is true for everyone, than person born when jupiter incancer rashi have all the benefit ,, but there we need to see that the following issue what i think is appropiate before making any prediction 1) dont u consider the nakshatra in which tha planet is situated,, 2) dont u consider the degree in which the planet situated, 3) is the planet are in retrogade postion or not. 4) dont you consider the dasha previaling also , may be the debilated planet dasha prevail ,, than the result wuil be highly efected 5) if the same jupter having the aspect of the cruel or malefic planet dont u think the result will be affected,, so its not simply by seeing the lagna chart ,, WHAT I THINK ,, we should not predict, we want to go for the accurate prediction maximum time ,, i had read various article saying that if 2nd lord in 11th , and 11th lord in 2nd , one will be getting abundence of wealth ,, its not the thumb rule ,, but it only become powerful according to dasha ,, degree of planet and variuos other factor what i think had wrote earlier to be consider ,, and this is to consider with every yoga , if that is not true ,, every one will find some 4-5 dhan yoga in his or her horoscope ,, because there are so many ,, rgds Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2010 Report Share Posted March 14, 2010 Astrovejaiji, //1) don't u consider the nakshatra in which the planet is situated,,// Dear Sri Prashant ji is very correct here to quote that there is a THUMB RULE that there can't be thumb rules in Astrology. For your first suggestion: //1) don't u consider the nakshatra in which the planet is situated,,// Example-If a Planet is in its own star and sub then sub sub will become sub lord of the planet and it will yield result for that planet more effectively.But it is also not thumb rule.It will depend upon many factors. Consider Sat is in Saturn Star , Sat Sub and Jupiter sub sub, then we consider that Saturn is in Saturn Star Jupiter Sub.In this case Jupiter  will yield result for that planet more effectively.But it is also not thumb rule.It will depend upon many other factors applicable in a particular chart. with thanks & regards, Dhirendra Nath Misra  ________________________________ Prashant Kumar G B <gbp_kumar Sun, March 14, 2010 10:16:51 PM Re: there is no thumb rule in astrology  Vejal, there is a THUMB rule that there can't be thumb rules in Jyotishya. as this is not a demonstrable science on a assembly line, it can predict perfectly in most cases with good birth data, well qualified, good matured astrologers and a sincere querist/seeker in proportion to his/her karma at the given moment or at a time when karma allows them to use it either as a cushion or a pathfinder, or come out of a dark tunel with good hope, courage all along with tangible result in the long run but it is not always the cases as said for above reasons no rule can say this will be there due to this combination, transit, placement, yoga, balas etc it is a combination of all plus the karmic balance sheet / influences already said best wishes ..- G B Prashant Kumar Life Member ICAS. http://groups. / group/Jyotish_ Remedies/ database? method=reportRow s & tbl=6 ____________ _________ _________ __ astrovejai <astrovejai > Sun, March 14, 2010 5:57:04 PM there is no thumb rule in astrology Dear Freinds i m very new to this group, read various article by various professional , i just want to put some light on thumb rule of astrology , according to me idont think there is anythumb rule of astrolgy ,, i have seen various horoscope in which the planet are in exalted state in kendra,,, than also they dont give the appropiate result and many thing like all " Panch Maha Pursha Yoga " give the individual with all sort of blessing in form of health wealth , good surrounding happy family ,etc.,, but what i mean to say that any body having exalted jupter exalted in kendra have " hans Yoga " accoring to differnt shsastra we learn , it mean that having all sort of benefits in life ,,if that is true for everyone, than person born when jupiter incancer rashi have all the benefit ,, but there we need to see that the following issue what i think is appropiate before making any prediction 1) dont u consider the nakshatra in which tha planet is situated,, 2) dont u consider the degree in which the planet situated, 3) is the planet are in retrogade postion or not. 4) dont you consider the dasha previaling also , may be the debilated planet dasha prevail ,, than the result wuil be highly efected 5) if the same jupter having the aspect of the cruel or malefic planet dont u think the result will be affected,, so its not simply by seeing the lagna chart ,, WHAT I THINK ,, we should not predict, we want to go for the accurate prediction maximum time ,, i had read various article saying that if 2nd lord in 11th , and 11th lord in 2nd , one will be getting abundence of wealth ,, its not the thumb rule ,, but it only become powerful according to dasha ,, degree of planet and variuos other factor what i think had wrote earlier to be consider ,, and this is to consider with every yoga , if that is not true ,, every one will find some 4-5 dhan yoga in his or her horoscope ,, because there are so many ,, rgds Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2010 Report Share Posted March 14, 2010 Beautiful post, Prashant jee! Thank you very much. Rohiniranjan , Prashant Kumar G B <gbp_kumar wrote: > > Vejal, > > there is a THUMB rule that there can't be thumb rules in Jyotishya. > > as this is not a demonstrable science on a assembly line, it can predict perfectly in most cases with good birth data, well qualified, good matured astrologers and a sincere querist/seeker in proportion to his/her karma at the given moment or at a time when karma allows them to use it either as a cushion or a pathfinder, or come out of a dark tunel with good hope, courage all along with tangible result in the long run > > but it is not always the cases as said for above reasons > > no rule can say this will be there due to this combination, transit, placement, yoga, balas etc it is a combination of all plus the karmic balance sheet / influences already said > > best wishes > > > > > .- G B Prashant Kumar Life Member ICAS. > /database?method=reportRows & tbl=6 > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 15, 2010 Report Share Posted March 15, 2010 Dear Friends, Jupiter in exaltation theoritically gives yoga as per astrological guide lines,it is not necessary that he should be happy by all means. Shri Parashant Ji has put very cogently " a sincere querist/seeker in proportion to his/her karma at the given moment " Several impending issues in the chart need consideration to infer about life.when one lives in a society after janma,the factors for growth,development and for rewards and incentives many factors play important role. It is absolutely true to in fer//karma allows them to use it either as a cushion or a pathfinder, or come out of a dark tunel with good hope, courage all along with tangible result in the long run// From birth to death,there is thumb rule as a common factor of all human lives.Universalization of karmas and the results is not correct.As every birth is unique in it's own way. Vattem Krishnan Cyber Jyotish Services(For all counseling services)Dr.B.V.Raman " Fools Obey Planets While  Wisemen Can Control Them " Planets are neutral Controllers of Mans Karma --- On Sun, 3/14/10, Prashant Kumar G B <gbp_kumar wrote: Prashant Kumar G B <gbp_kumar Re: there is no thumb rule in astrology Sunday, March 14, 2010, 12:46 PM  Vejal, there is a THUMB rule that there can't be thumb rules in Jyotishya. as this is not a demonstrable science on a assembly line, it can predict perfectly in most cases with good birth data, well qualified, good matured astrologers and a sincere querist/seeker in proportion to his/her karma at the given moment or at a time when karma allows them to use it either as a cushion or a pathfinder, or come out of a dark tunel with good hope, courage all along with tangible result in the long run but it is not always the cases as said for above reasons no rule can say this will be there due to this combination, transit, placement, yoga, balas etc it is a combination of all plus the karmic balance sheet / influences already said best wishes ..- G B Prashant Kumar Life Member ICAS. http://groups. / group/Jyotish_ Remedies/ database? method=reportRow s & tbl=6 ____________ _________ _________ __ astrovejai <astrovejai > Sun, March 14, 2010 5:57:04 PM there is no thumb rule in astrology Dear Freinds i m very new to this group, read various article by various professional , i just want to put some light on thumb rule of astrology , according to me idont think there is anythumb rule of astrolgy ,, i have seen various horoscope in which the planet are in exalted state in kendra,,, than also they dont give the appropiate result and many thing like all " Panch Maha Pursha Yoga " give the individual with all sort of blessing in form of health wealth , good surrounding happy family ,etc.,, but what i mean to say that any body having exalted jupter exalted in kendra have " hans Yoga " accoring to differnt shsastra we learn , it mean that having all sort of benefits in life ,,if that is true for everyone, than person born when jupiter incancer rashi have all the benefit ,, but there we need to see that the following issue what i think is appropiate before making any prediction 1) dont u consider the nakshatra in which tha planet is situated,, 2) dont u consider the degree in which the planet situated, 3) is the planet are in retrogade postion or not. 4) dont you consider the dasha previaling also , may be the debilated planet dasha prevail ,, than the result wuil be highly efected 5) if the same jupter having the aspect of the cruel or malefic planet dont u think the result will be affected,, so its not simply by seeing the lagna chart ,, WHAT I THINK ,, we should not predict, we want to go for the accurate prediction maximum time ,, i had read various article saying that if 2nd lord in 11th , and 11th lord in 2nd , one will be getting abundence of wealth ,, its not the thumb rule ,, but it only become powerful according to dasha ,, degree of planet and variuos other factor what i think had wrote earlier to be consider ,, and this is to consider with every yoga , if that is not true ,, every one will find some 4-5 dhan yoga in his or her horoscope ,, because there are so many ,, rgds Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.