Guest guest Posted January 20, 2008 Report Share Posted January 20, 2008 Dear Name_Is_Ego ji, We all appreciate, irrespective of the statement being ascribed to a famous or a traditional pandit. It belies conventional logics and also the contrary to what our scriptures have said. Even should we keep them aside, it should be able to applied on individual horoscopes with certain satisfaction. So far to my own knowledge, this newly formulated principle has not met with any success in any group i.e. people dis-agreed on its relevance for their own individual experience .....most of them who replied were all practising astrologers of certain stature of their own..... So long a principle is NOT tested....like what Ms Mridula Trivedi did for Jupiter in Scorpio or Jupiter aspecting Mars with respect to 7H relation. One agrees or not, she presented it for every one to see...with her own logics....for a moment it did take attention of Late Sri P.S. Sastri. But in this case, the principle seems to fail in all the seven cases, that I posted in the group....can post more...but it may sound it to be more of opposition.....for I am still open to the idea.....so long some body can prove it .....with the submitted charts If there are some conditions, then kindly state the conditions for the same, so that we can look into and provide more birth data qualifying the criteria...... Nameisego saab, to raise the broadest statement, that there exceptions to all rules is ok, but kindly share what those exceptions are....else, it would be statement in wilderness. With regards, Sreeram_Srinivas , " nameisego " <nameisego wrote: Dear Krishna, Show me one rule of astrology which has no exception. I am not the person who has coined this dictum. It is from astrologer par excellence who was world famous, used to say this and he had heard it from his Guru. Tatavam-Asi , Krishnamurthy > Seetharama krishna_1998@ wrote: > > > > Dear Sreeram ji, > > > > For a similar challenge earlier on a different topic, the > response I got from him is simply > > > > " As I said, we need to look at other planetary positions also. > > Generalisations should always be taken with a pinch of salt. " > > > > With such response, one can not challenge any dictum per say. > And, people can go on giving dictums after dictums! > > > > Regards, > > Krishna > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.