Test of tropical versus sidereal zodiac-chart posted by renuji

[Guest guest]

Dear renu ji and grp Now every body got proof of sayana Zodiac givs better results .I find when evr a new Theory is coined they gets maximum mileage ,it did happend to all imported Neo predictiv methods too when Tarrot was fashion u can find ppl r running after tarrot readers even they were mocking the old traditional astrologers same thing happened when fengshui got introduced ,all where asking do u know fengshui then we can come over to u ,now wat happened ,it has gone with the wind I find every one writes Gigabytes of mails supporting reserch and it is as if the need of time .sure who is holding them frm doing reserch but what is the credential they can say for going for it ,did they prooved any way old system is wrong or not giving results ,did they ever try to understand where they might hav gone wrong ?? Did they try to see how old astrologers still living in villages how they r predicting without all this gimmicks with max accuracy ??( Now can come with an excuse that they never find such persons ,sure they r not sitting in net 24x7 only to proov u they r correct ) So where lies the fault ?? it is in our understanding and lack our hard work ,every one since the advent of net astrology these phenomenon is on the rise ,we can see more disagreemnt than any body commonly working for a cause .when there is hue and cry such ppl gets max attention now let us get back to the core of this mail dear grp can we take up this chart ??i invite every one to commnt on it ,all r free to use any system /zodiac or methods Let us see how the results r coming out rgrds sunil nair , "renunw" <renunw wrote:>> Dear Boaz ji,> > If I may intervene...a late comer to this discussion, I find this quite> interesting. Hence let me submit birth data, for which I invite you or> anyone else to analyze using Sayana/Nirayana chart.> > Natal Chart> > September 17, 1864> Time: 6:52:00> Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT)> Place: 79 E 50' 00", 6 N 55' 00"> Colombo, Sri Lanka> > > By the way,> > //The fact that majority of Indian people are practicing the> sidereal zodiac does not validate it//......and neither does it> invalidate it ...right?> > Anyone can treat this as a blind chart and analyze as per their> preferences in ayanamsa calculations.> > blessings,> > Renu> > > > > > , "zaobnali" zaob16@> wrote:> >> > Dear Sunil,> >> > Ernst's work makes sense to me. It is my understanding that the> ancient> > texts have not been preserved without corruption and people like Ernst> > are trying to carry tests in order to validate one interpretation or> > another. The fact that majority of Indian people are practicing the> > sidereal zodiac does not validate it. Similarly mid age most Europeans> > believed the world is flat following Church tradition and dogma. I> don't> > know enough about the origin of Yamakoti. Please ask Ernst for his> > opinion. Thanks.> >> > Best,> > Boaz> >> >

[Guest guest]

Dear Sunil ji,

 

Thanks for reminding the group regarding the chart. I think this would be an

interesting exercise and a good learning process, for anyone who is willing to

give a try.

 

blessings,

 

Renu

 

 

 

, " sunil nair "

<astro_tellerkerala wrote:

>

>

> Dear renu ji and grp

>

> Now every body got proof of sayana Zodiac givs better results .

>

> I find when evr a new Theory is coined they gets maximum mileage ,it did

> happend to all imported Neo predictiv methods too

>

> when Tarrot was fashion u can find ppl r running after tarrot readers

> even they were mocking the old traditional astrologers

> same thing happened when fengshui got introduced ,all where asking do u

> know fengshui then we can come over to u ,now wat happened ,it has gone

> with the wind

>

> I find every one writes Gigabytes of mails supporting reserch and it is

> as if the need of time .sure who is holding them frm doing reserch but

> what is the credential they can say for going for it ,did they prooved

> any way old system is wrong or not giving results ,did they ever try to

> understand where they might hav gone wrong ?? Did they try to see how

> old astrologers still living in villages how they r predicting without

> all this gimmicks with max accuracy ??( Now can come with an excuse that

> they never find such persons ,sure they r not sitting in net 24x7 only

> to proov u they r correct ) So where lies the fault ?? it is in our

> understanding and lack our hard work ,every one since the advent of net

> astrology these phenomenon is on the rise ,we can see more disagreemnt

> than any body commonly working for a cause .

>

> when there is hue and cry such ppl gets max attention

>

> now let us get back to the core of this mail

>

> dear grp can we take up this chart ??

>

> i invite every one to commnt on it ,all r free to use any system /zodiac

> or methods

>

> Let us see how the results r coming out

>

> rgrds sunil nair

>

>

>

>

> , " renunw " <renunw@>

> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Boaz ji,

> >

> > If I may intervene...a late comer to this discussion, I find this

> quite

> > interesting. Hence let me submit birth data, for which I invite you or

> > anyone else to analyze using Sayana/Nirayana chart.

> >

> > Natal Chart

> >

> > September 17, 1864

> > Time: 6:52:00

> > Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT)

> > Place: 79 E 50' 00 " , 6 N 55' 00 "

> > Colombo, Sri Lanka

> >

> >

> > By the way,

> >

> > //The fact that majority of Indian people are practicing the

> > sidereal zodiac does not validate it//......and neither does it

> > invalidate it ...right?

> >

> > Anyone can treat this as a blind chart and analyze as per their

> > preferences in ayanamsa calculations.

> >

> > blessings,

> >

> > Renu

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > , " zaobnali " zaob16@

> > wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear Sunil,

> > >

> > > Ernst's work makes sense to me. It is my understanding that the

> > ancient

> > > texts have not been preserved without corruption and people like

> Ernst

> > > are trying to carry tests in order to validate one interpretation or

> > > another. The fact that majority of Indian people are practicing the

> > > sidereal zodiac does not validate it. Similarly mid age most

> Europeans

> > > believed the world is flat following Church tradition and dogma. I

> > don't

> > > know enough about the origin of Yamakoti. Please ask Ernst for his

> > > opinion. Thanks.

> > >

> > > Best,

> > > Boaz

> > >

> > >

>