Fwd: Fw: Jaimini and parasara

[Guest guest]

sohamsa , " Shanmukha " <teli_sha2002 wrote:

 

Om Namah Sivaya

 

Namaste Sri Tripathy,

 

I dont know whether I am misunderstood or I am not able to communicate

correctly. The point is I never said fresh thinking / research is unnecessary. I

welcomed it manytimes in this list itself, for example Chara Karaka, Drigdasa

articles by Narasimha. The point I differ is to state / doubt the caliber and

efficacy of other commentators of Jaimin, when you never read them. If a person

like Sri Narasimha writes that way many students here will definitely be

influenced and the necessary research into Jaimini will be lost. People will

always read the all-in-one books, forgetting the references, which will be

detrimental in the long run. This is been done for centuries and at least shall

we try to bring out those works to light.

 

Sri Narasimha based his paper only on BPHS, not all the available resources.

 

By the way, I admitted on AIA list, that there are contradicting points in 3rd

and 4th chapter only, which somehow surfaced this century by the efforts of

gaints like Sri S.K.Kar, Sri Ghosh etc.

 

Hope I am understood.

 

Warm Regards,

Shanmukha

 

sohamsa , " Mrutyunjay Tripathy " <astrologer_mrutyunjay@

wrote:

 

Dear friend,

 

 

Shree Shanmukha Jee.

 

When you have already admitted in other jyotish(AIA) groups that

 

you have the same four chapters of Jaimin Upadesha Sutra (predictive part)

available with you...and suggest the need for research...

 

 

So at the end you came to the same point ...

 

the need for fresh thinking and research...on

 

the basis of available resources...

 

the points origianlly echoed in the Sthira Dasa paper by PVR.

 

Hope you will come up with some contributions on Jaimini Upadesa Sutra.

 

Regards,

 

Mrutyunjay Tripathy

 

 

Jaimini Sutras.sohamsa , teli Shanmukha <teli_sha2002@

wrote:

 

 

 

--- On Wed, 5/8/09, As Th wrote:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hi shanmukh

 

 

I am trying to post this message to you in sohmasa for last 3 days.My post is

not published by sohmasa group

 

 

The stand of SJC is very clear in the books they write

 

 

1.Crux of vedic astrology

2.Vedic Astrology-Integrated approach

 

 

Both books area vailable as free download in scribd.com

 

 

They both have ample references by the author stating that Jaimini and

parashara system are same with only minor differences as it is possible among

different authors

 

 

The details are given in the first few pages of both books

 

 

The statements made by Sarbani ratha and other members of SJC are really

stupid

 

 

regardss

 

 

vishnu

 

 

 

recommends that you upgrade to the new and safer Internet

Explorer 8. http://downloads./in/internetexplorer/

 

 

 

--- End forwarded message ---