KP & Traditional Astrology

[Guest guest]

With Due respect to all members,

It pains me when brothers fight over petty matters.

A son cannot ever replace the Father unless the Father is no more. KP may be compared to the prodigal son of a great Father, a Father who can never die. Traditional astrology is the Father. It is the Milk, and KP is the cream from this same Milk.

KP is very good for matters when the Birth time is perfect. Traditional astrology encompasses many matters over and above a perfect Birth time. KP is also good for exact nature of events while Traditional astrology at times with the knowledge of our present day astrologers, is limited to generalisations. KP has come only from Traditional astrology which the master KrishnaMurthy ji has never denied. So why should we break or heads in this cheap bickerings.

Regards to Meena , it was not in his Kundli probably to attain much fame as per KrishnaMurthy. In any case Meena has given some sample illustrations which cannot replace the logical explanations which we find in KP. So we cannot compare them both or say that one is the Original and the other is not. It is live Thomas Elva Edison discovering the Bulb, but whenever we go out to buy any Lighting equipment for our houses, do we remember his name ? No. But we remember "Philips".

So lets get down to stopping such mundane matters and talk something constructive. N pointing fingers at any system, individual or approach or any comparisons. This will only lead to frictions, heat, misunderstandings and bad blood.

A polite request to you all.

best wishes,

Bhaskar.

[Guest guest]

Dear Bhaskarji,

That K.P. is derived from Traditional Astrology has been said and written by KSK,many times over...but he claims that thesub system,the Ruling Planets system,and the division of a star into subs and sub-subs in proportion to the Planets dasa in the Vimshottari Dasa,and that the cusp is the beginning of a House , etc., are his discoveries...this myth about Meena being the 'father' of stellar Astrology K.P. style has been exposed by KSK himself many years ago... but was actively promoted by some "more loyal than the king" followers of B.V.Raman long since KSK exposed this myth...and they are incorrogibly at it again,it seems... !

&nb[Moderator Note: Message edited by moderators] With kind regards,

Yogesh Lajmi

 

 

 

Bhaskar <bhaskar_jyotish Sent: Thursday, September 17, 2009 7:32:22 PM KP & Traditional Astrology

 

 

With Due respect to all members,

It pains me when brothers fight over petty matters.

A son cannot ever replace the Father unless the Father is no more. KP may be compared to the prodigal son of a great Father, a Father who can never die. Traditional astrology is the Father. It is the Milk, and KP is the cream from this same Milk.

KP is very good for matters when the Birth time is perfect. Traditional astrology encompasses many matters over and above a perfect Birth time. KP is also good for exact nature of events while Traditional astrology at times with the knowledge of our present day astrologers, is limited to generalisations. KP has come only from Traditional astrology which the master KrishnaMurthy ji has never denied. So why should we break or heads in this cheap bickerings.

Regards to Meena , it was not in his Kundli probably to attain much fame as per KrishnaMurthy. In any case Meena has given some sample illustrations which cannot replace the logical explanations which we find in KP. So we cannot compare them both or say that one is the Original and the other is not. It is live Thomas Elva Edison discovering the Bulb, but whenever we go out to buy any Lighting equipment for our houses, do we remember his name ? No. But we remember "Philips".

So lets get down to stopping such mundane matters and talk something constructive. N pointing fingers at any system, individual or approach or any comparisons. This will only lead to frictions, heat, misunderstandings and bad blood.

A polite request to you all.

best wishes,

Bhaskar.