Different TP Hora Lord using Vishun-nabi and Lahiri Ayanamsa

[Guest guest]

Hi PVR,

 

In JHora 7.1, I opened a few charts and made some comparisons of Moon's

longitude between using Lahiri and Vishnu-nabhi ayanamsa.

 

In some charts, the difference is very small. In some charts, the

difference seems larger. For example, in Roger Federer's chart, the

longitude differences of Moon is 3 minutes and 33.97 seconds.

 

Any comments on this varying longitude differences?

 

One of the main reason for your adoption and recommendation of

Vishnu-nabi ayanamsa is because of the superior results with annual

lunar return charts.

 

I understand that your TP book will be published when it is completed. I

assumed that your book will explain with a lot of example charts your

preference for this ayanamsa.

 

But from now until the publication of your book, I believe many of us

are still continuing to interpret upcoming TP charts for ourselves and

others. My gut feel is that many of us would like to have more faith in

using your recommendation, especially in cases of different Hora Lord.

 

Thus, may I suggest you kindly provide us a little sneak preview of your

best case study in your upcoming TP book so that we can do our own

independent research and conclude for ourselves if Vishnu-nabhi is

better. For example, provide us a birth data and a particular TP year

where the Hora Lord is different when using Vishnu-nabhi.

 

Or, if it is more time-saving to explain using Roger Federer's chart,

could you kindly comment on his 2005 TP year where Vishnu-nabhi gives

Saturn as Hora Lord and Lahiri gives Jupiter?

 

Roger Federer's Birth Data :

 

August 8, 1981

Time: 8:40:00

Time Zone: 2:00:00 (East of GMT)

Place: 7 E 35' 00 " , 47 N 33' 00 " Basel, Switzerland.

(source : http://www.rogerfederer.com/en/rogers/profile/index.cfm)

 

Thank you.

 

Best Wishes

Pushya

[Guest guest]

Namaste Pushya,

 

The difference between this mean plane Lahiri variation and regular Lahiri is not constant. It oscillates. It also changes from one planet to another. Moon is in a considerably different plane than all other planets. The current Sun-earth plane (used in regualr Lahiri) and mean Sun-earth plane (used in modified mean plane Lahiri) are at an angle. This angle can even be 5 degrees. When Moon, who is in a totally different plane is projected onto these two planes, obviously there is a difference in the longitude. Depending on the angle between these two planes, sometimes the difference in longitudes is small and sometimes big. Depending on how apart Moon's plane is from these planes, Moon's longitude may deviate more or less.

 

Best regards,NarasimhaDo Ganapathi Homam Yourself: http://www.VedicAstrologer.org/homamSpirituality: Free Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.netFree Jyotish software (Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.orgSri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website: http://www.SriJagannath.org

 

 

-

pushya

jhora

Friday, April 18, 2008 1:25 PM

Different TP Hora Lord using Vishun-nabi and Lahiri Ayanamsa

 

 

Hi PVR,In JHora 7.1, I opened a few charts and made some comparisons of Moon'slongitude between using Lahiri and Vishnu-nabhi ayanamsa.In some charts, the difference is very small. In some charts, thedifference seems larger. For example, in Roger Federer's chart, thelongitude differences of Moon is 3 minutes and 33.97 seconds.Any comments on this varying longitude differences?One of the main reason for your adoption and recommendation ofVishnu-nabi ayanamsa is because of the superior results with annuallunar return charts.I understand that your TP book will be published when it is completed. Iassumed that your book will explain with a lot of example charts yourpreference for this ayanamsa.But from now until the publication of your book, I believe many of usare still continuing to interpret upcoming TP charts for ourselves andothers. My gut feel is that many of us would like to have more faith inusing your recommendation, especially in cases of different Hora Lord.Thus, may I suggest you kindly provide us a little sneak preview of yourbest case study in your upcoming TP book so that we can do our ownindependent research and conclude for ourselves if Vishnu-nabhi isbetter. For example, provide us a birth data and a particular TP yearwhere the Hora Lord is different when using Vishnu-nabhi.Or, if it is more time-saving to explain using Roger Federer's chart,could you kindly comment on his 2005 TP year where Vishnu-nabhi givesSaturn as Hora Lord and Lahiri gives Jupiter?Roger Federer's Birth Data :August 8, 1981Time: 8:40:00Time Zone: 2:00:00 (East of GMT)Place: 7 E 35' 00", 47 N 33' 00" Basel, Switzerland.(source : http://www.rogerfederer.com/en/rogers/profile/index.cfm)Thank you.Best WishesPushya

 

 

Checked by AVG. Version: 7.5.524 / Virus Database: 269.23.2/1386 - Release 4/18/2008 5:24 PM