Guest guest Posted July 4, 2004 Report Share Posted July 4, 2004 I would like the lerned members to post info on lalkitab books. And which books should be read and are not poullted by the writers opinions. Thanks Siddharth lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " <jyotish_mail> wrote: > Dear Learned Guruhan & members, > > Finally which book would you suggest for lalkitab learning which are > true copy of Pandit Roop Chand Joshi's Lalkitab. > > Thanks a Lot > Siddharth Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 4, 2004 Report Share Posted July 4, 2004 Siddharth ji, You have raised the good old question once again. I am sure you will find answer of this question in this groups archive. IMO if you like reading Hindi, you should go for Arun Samhita. And if you like reading English you can check Lal Kitab translation by Goswami and Vashishta. Photocopy of urdu book is also available in market. Regards, Punit Pandey lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " <jyotish_mail> wrote: > I would like the lerned members to post info on lalkitab books. > > And which books should be read and are not poullted by the writers > opinions. > > Thanks > Siddharth > > > > > lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " <jyotish_mail> > wrote: > > Dear Learned Guruhan & members, > > > > Finally which book would you suggest for lalkitab learning which > are > > true copy of Pandit Roop Chand Joshi's Lalkitab. > > > > Thanks a Lot > > Siddharth Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 6, 2004 Report Share Posted July 6, 2004 Hello All , Can u please tell me where i can get the Photocopies of the urdu book (is it the 1952 one or all 5 books ?) Also if the Urdu books are out of print i would be glad to scan all the pages and put it up on the internet(if i am not stepping on anyones toes by doing that). This seems like an excellent group. Tnx to all the people here for all the excellent posts. rajesh rn lalkitab , " Punit Pandey " <punitp@g...> wrote: > Siddharth ji, > > You have raised the good old question once again. I am sure you will > find answer of this question in this groups archive. > > IMO if you like reading Hindi, you should go for Arun Samhita. And if > you like reading English you can check Lal Kitab translation by > Goswami and Vashishta. Photocopy of urdu book is also available in > market. > > Regards, > > Punit Pandey > > lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " <jyotish_mail> > wrote: > > I would like the lerned members to post info on lalkitab books. > > > > And which books should be read and are not poullted by the writers > > opinions. > > > > Thanks > > Siddharth > > > > > > > > > > lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " <jyotish_mail> > > wrote: > > > Dear Learned Guruhan & members, > > > > > > Finally which book would you suggest for lalkitab learning which > > are > > > true copy of Pandit Roop Chand Joshi's Lalkitab. > > > > > > Thanks a Lot > > > Siddharth Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 6, 2004 Report Share Posted July 6, 2004 Hi Rajesh The scanning and public distribution of Pt Jee's(Late pt Roop Chand jee) books involves two issues i.e. [1] Legal, and [2] Ethical lets look at the legal issue [a] Pt Jee copyrighted his books. You cant play around with his rights and those of his assigns and successors. Pt Jee did not copyright his work. There are no legal constraints. Now the ethical issues All his life Pt Jee did not charge a paisa for all the help he gave to people. These books are the inheritance of the Joshi family from Pt Jee. Is it fair that we play around with their inheritance? I hope Pt. Som Dutt Jee will soon decide whether he wants to try and copyright his late father's works. If he does, we must then respect the commercial claims of the Joshi family on these books. If he does not wish to do so and specifically allows gratis distribution of the books written by his father only then should we think in terms putting these books up for public distribution. Regards R S lalkitab , " stock_surgeon2003 " <stock_surgeon2003> wrote: > Hello All , > Can u please tell me where i can get the Photocopies of the > urdu book (is it the 1952 one or all 5 books ?) Also if the Urdu > books are out of print i would be glad to scan all the pages and put > it up on the internet(if i am not stepping on anyones toes by doing > that). This seems like an excellent group. > Tnx to all the people here for all the excellent posts. > > rajesh rn > > lalkitab , " Punit Pandey " <punitp@g...> wrote: > > Siddharth ji, > > > > You have raised the good old question once again. I am sure you > will > > find answer of this question in this groups archive. > > > > IMO if you like reading Hindi, you should go for Arun Samhita. And > if > > you like reading English you can check Lal Kitab translation by > > Goswami and Vashishta. Photocopy of urdu book is also available in > > market. > > > > Regards, > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " > <jyotish_mail> > > wrote: > > > I would like the lerned members to post info on lalkitab books. > > > > > > And which books should be read and are not poullted by the > writers > > > opinions. > > > > > > Thanks > > > Siddharth > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " > <jyotish_mail> > > > wrote: > > > > Dear Learned Guruhan & members, > > > > > > > > Finally which book would you suggest for lalkitab learning > which > > > are > > > > true copy of Pandit Roop Chand Joshi's Lalkitab. > > > > > > > > Thanks a Lot > > > > Siddharth Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 6, 2004 Report Share Posted July 6, 2004 hello rakesh Well i would glady go buy a reprint of the LalKitab but there are none forthcoming and a xerox copy is as bad as a scanned in version. 250 books published cant take care of all the people who want to have read those books unfortunately.... If its published again thats excellent .... If not i dont see the difference between photocopies sold in the book stalls and a ebook floating around ...(exept maybe for the " free " cost associated with the ebook and the money down an unscrupluous traders pockets with the photocopy's) Like i said in my post earlier i will scan it in if i am not stepping on anyones toes. Regards Rajesh lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal " <rakeshsahgal> wrote: > Hi Rajesh > > The scanning and public distribution of Pt Jee's(Late pt Roop Chand > jee) books involves two issues i.e. > > [1] Legal, and > [2] Ethical > > > lets look at the legal issue > > [a] Pt Jee copyrighted his books. You cant play around with his rights > and those of his assigns and successors. > > Pt Jee did not copyright his work. There are no legal > constraints. > > > Now the ethical issues > > All his life Pt Jee did not charge a paisa for all the help he gave to > people. > These books are the inheritance of the Joshi family from Pt Jee. Is it > fair that we play around with their inheritance? > I hope Pt. Som Dutt Jee will soon decide whether he wants to try and > copyright his late father's works. > If he does, we must then respect the commercial claims of the Joshi > family on these books. > If he does not wish to do so and specifically allows gratis > distribution of the books written by his father > only then should we think in terms putting these books up for public > distribution. > > > Regards > > > R S > > > > lalkitab , " stock_surgeon2003 " > <stock_surgeon2003> wrote: > > Hello All , > > Can u please tell me where i can get the Photocopies of the > > urdu book (is it the 1952 one or all 5 books ?) Also if the Urdu > > books are out of print i would be glad to scan all the pages and > put > > it up on the internet(if i am not stepping on anyones toes by doing > > that). This seems like an excellent group. > > Tnx to all the people here for all the excellent posts. > > > > rajesh rn > > > > lalkitab , " Punit Pandey " <punitp@g...> wrote: > > > Siddharth ji, > > > > > > You have raised the good old question once again. I am sure you > > will > > > find answer of this question in this groups archive. > > > > > > IMO if you like reading Hindi, you should go for Arun Samhita. > And > > if > > > you like reading English you can check Lal Kitab translation by > > > Goswami and Vashishta. Photocopy of urdu book is also available > in > > > market. > > > > > > Regards, > > > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > > > lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " > > <jyotish_mail> > > > wrote: > > > > I would like the lerned members to post info on lalkitab books. > > > > > > > > And which books should be read and are not poullted by the > > writers > > > > opinions. > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > Siddharth > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > lalkitab , " jyotish_mail " > > <jyotish_mail> > > > > wrote: > > > > > Dear Learned Guruhan & members, > > > > > > > > > > Finally which book would you suggest for lalkitab learning > > which > > > > are > > > > > true copy of Pandit Roop Chand Joshi's Lalkitab. > > > > > > > > > > Thanks a Lot > > > > > Siddharth Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.