Guest guest Posted August 21, 2004 Report Share Posted August 21, 2004 Sardarji Sat Sri Akal, Theek thaak? Partner your idea is great. Let me add to what you have said( and establish my nuisance value atleast, if I havent achieved that already ). Kulbir the more I read the more I feel this is an ocean, figuratively speaking that is. By and by I am coming to the realisation the reading has to be supplemented by a certain mind set. Intuitively one should be able to refer to memory and ascertain which is the significator of what , go back to the book and then proceed with making a determination of benefic/malefic and then validate the determination with the subject's present circumstances. The tenets/principles can be taught ofcourse, but their effective application, that is going to come from the school of hard knocks - make a determination and have it trashed, go back to the books and start all over again and again. So whether such a course of study will help depends on the perspective of the person. I can read a book and learn, some people need a class room ambience. Different strokes for different folks as they say. Regards R S Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 21, 2004 Report Share Posted August 21, 2004 Respected Kulbir jee, The most important need of the day is that some one decodes the Lal Kitab. As aadarniya Lal Kitabee jee has said on many occasions that each couplet of the book is an axiom , a sutra . Like sutra in `laghu siddhant kaumudi' they need expansion and explanations. Therefore , I suggest that the two experts , and others if they can find , could come together and bring out a comprehensive edition of the original Lal Kitab . It will be authentic and explanatory ; unlike these days when we keep drawing from bazaar versions of the book. A book of that kind would be immortal and the experts will be remembered for all time to come , where as teaching lessons would be temporary and serving just a handful of people in this group. This book might be a profitable financial venture also. I too have the book by Samata Prasad jee , but again , it is not explanatory. For most part , it just lists the planets in the houses and their upaya. We all know that upaya can not be or should not be suggested like that . Yes for beginners it might be useful. With regards and naman to all gurujan, bhuwan lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal " <rakeshsahgal> wrote: > Sardarji Sat Sri Akal, > > Theek thaak? > > Partner your idea is great. > > Let me add to what you have said( and establish my nuisance value > atleast, if I havent achieved that already ). Kulbir the more I read > the more I feel this is an ocean, figuratively speaking that is. By > and by I am coming to the realisation the reading has to be > supplemented by a certain mind set. Intuitively one should be able to > refer to memory and ascertain which is the significator of what , go > back to the book and then proceed with making a determination of > benefic/malefic and then validate the determination with the subject's > present circumstances. > > The tenets/principles can be taught ofcourse, but their effective > application, that is going to come from the school of hard knocks - > make a determination and have it trashed, go back to the books and > start all over again and again. > > So whether such a course of study will help depends on the perspective > of the person. I can read a book and learn, some people need a class > room ambience. Different strokes for different folks as they say. > > Regards > > > R S Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 21, 2004 Report Share Posted August 21, 2004 bhuwan ji we were just thinking on the same lines we were just going to formally invite u and rakesh sahgal. lalkitabee is an expert in grammer, umesh ji is an expert of checking the kundali with accurate daiganoses, u have an innovative and brilliant, mind who has laboured hard on ina and outs of lalkitab, rakesh has gift of the gab as afr as english language is concerned, we have rajinder bhatia and prabhakar to guide us with their experience and comand over urdu language, not to forget thind sahib; then what the hell are we waiting for kulbir --- bhuwanvashishtha <bhuwanvashishtha wrote: > Respected Kulbir jee, > > The most important need of the day is that some one > decodes the Lal > Kitab. As aadarniya Lal Kitabee jee has said on many > occasions that > each couplet of the book is an axiom , a sutra . > Like sutra in `laghu > siddhant kaumudi' they need expansion and > explanations. > > Therefore , I suggest that the two experts , and > others if they can > find , could come together and bring out a > comprehensive edition of > the original Lal Kitab . It will be authentic and > explanatory ; > unlike these days when we keep drawing from bazaar > versions of the > book. A book of that kind would be immortal and the > experts will be > remembered for all time to come , where as teaching > lessons would be > temporary and serving just a handful of people in > this group. This > book might be a profitable financial venture also. > > I too have the book by Samata Prasad jee , but again > , it is not > explanatory. For most part , it just lists the > planets in the houses > and their upaya. We all know that upaya can not be > or should not be > suggested like that . Yes for beginners it might be > useful. > > With regards and naman to all gurujan, > > bhuwan lalkitab , " rakeshsahgal " > <rakeshsahgal> > wrote: > > Sardarji Sat Sri Akal, > > > > Theek thaak? > > > > Partner your idea is great. > > > > Let me add to what you have said( and establish my > nuisance value > > atleast, if I havent achieved that already ). > Kulbir the more I read > > the more I feel this is an ocean, figuratively > speaking that is. By > > and by I am coming to the realisation the reading > has to be > > supplemented by a certain mind set. Intuitively > one should be able > to > > refer to memory and ascertain which is the > significator of what , go > > back to the book and then proceed with making a > determination of > > benefic/malefic and then validate the > determination with the > subject's > > present circumstances. > > > > The tenets/principles can be taught ofcourse, but > their effective > > application, that is going to come from the school > of hard knocks - > > make a determination and have it trashed, go back > to the books and > > start all over again and again. > > > > So whether such a course of study will help > depends on the > perspective > > of the person. I can read a book and learn, some > people need a class > > room ambience. Different strokes for different > folks as they say. > > > > Regards > > > > > > R S > > New and Improved Mail - Send 10MB messages! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.