Guest guest Posted November 8, 2004 Report Share Posted November 8, 2004 Dear All, For your attention and review a comparison of different software results are given as follows: Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- 10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software 1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs 2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire 3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli 4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst 5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura 6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One 7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL 8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish Basic Data Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA 1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* 5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* * Lahiri Ayanamsa Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, 5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s Explanations: 1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. 2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 3. KP & Vedic, 4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa 5. KP & Vedic, 6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH 7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) 8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) ATTENTION: 1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & SL) 2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. 3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. 1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software 1. 336-20-09 Raichurs 2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire 3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli 4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst 5 336-20-12 Astraura 6 336-21-20 Old One 7 336-20-14 JHL 8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or less the same) Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software 1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur 2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank 3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst 4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura 5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One 6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL 7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire will be very useful. Basic Data SN Software Sid Time KPA 1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* 3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 * Lahiri Ayanamsa Good Luck! tw , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> wrote: > Dear Members, > I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > Software,but after I bought and began using the > Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > levels),I have found it most useful and > simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > K.P., developed so far... > I therefore would strongly recommend > Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > With best wishes,I am, > Yours sincerely, > lyrastro1 > GOOD LUCK ! > > > Vaidun ji, > > Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile > Kundli for > PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are > designed KP > astrologers in mind. The details are available at > http://www.astrocamp.com. > > Regards, > > Punit Pandey > > > > On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > <vvidya@o...> wrote: > > Dear List Members, > > > > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > in 1988 when I was > > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > astrology was with KP. I had > > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > was very impressed with > > his astrological skills. There are few who can > match the phenomenal > > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > MANUALLY cast each chart, > > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > the ephemeris. It used > > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > finally arrive at the > > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > same job can be done in > > seconds. Amazing. > > > > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > in it but maybe not > > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > astrology program which > > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > request members to kindly > > advise me as to which would be the best program for > this. I will be much > > obliged. > > > > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > unable to find a > > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > now. I hope to be able > > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > > > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > > > > Vaidun Vidyadhar > > 1 / 94 Marius Street > > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > > Australia > > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > > Email: vvidya@o... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2004 Report Share Posted November 8, 2004 Dear tw853, With K.P. NEW ayanamsa the ascendant sub-sub is VENUS...while with all others the asc sub-sub is Kethu... Does that make any significant difference or not...should be examined to decide upon the correctness of the ayanamsa...? I generally follow New K.P. ayanamsa,frankly,blindly,simply because,not only am I convinced,but, I have implicit faith in both, M.G.G.Nair,and Professor Balachandran,who has explained briefly,but convincingly how he has derived these new Ayanamsa values,in K.P. & Astrology,Magazine,2003,Annual,pp. 66-93,and reproduced in these columns by Shri Kanak Bosmiaji... Yours sincerely, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear All,For your attention and review a comparison of different software results are given as follows:Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E101(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m-10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior JyotishBasic DataSr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-102.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-483.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-444.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-317.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.298.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* * Lahiri AyanamsaDifferences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, 5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s Explanations:1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 14203. KP & Vedic, 4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa 5. KP & Vedic, 6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only)ATTENTION:1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & SL)2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere.1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software1. 336-20-09 Raichurs2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst5 336-20-12 Astraura6 336-21-20 Old One7 336-20-14 JHL8 336-19-50 Junior JyotishNot much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or less the same)Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 KhaldeaATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire will be very useful.Basic DataSN Software Sid Time KPA 1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* 3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 * Lahiri AyanamsaGood Luck!tw , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> wrote:> Dear Members,> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.> Software,but after I bought and began using the> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub> levels),I have found it most useful and> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for> K.P., developed so far...> I therefore would strongly recommend> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...> With best wishes,I am,> Yours sincerely,> lyrastro1> GOOD LUCK !> > > Vaidun ji,> > Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile> Kundli for> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are> designed KP> astrologers in mind. The details are available at> http://www.astrocamp.com.> > Regards,> > Punit Pandey> > > > On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar> <vvidya@o...> wrote:> > Dear List Members,> > > > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP> in 1988 when I was> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic> astrology was with KP. I had> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and> was very impressed with> > his astrological skills. There are few who can> match the phenomenal> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to> MANUALLY cast each chart,> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and> the ephemeris. It used> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to> finally arrive at the> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the> same job can be done in> > seconds. Amazing. > > > > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP> in it but maybe not> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other> astrology program which> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I> request members to kindly> > advise me as to which would be the best program for> this. I will be much> > obliged.> > > > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was> unable to find a> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until> now. I hope to be able> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > > > Thanks for your time. With best regards.> > > > Vaidun Vidyadhar> > 1 / 94 Marius Street> > Tamworth, NSW 2340> > Australia> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)> > Mobile: 0414 870 083> > Email: vvidya@o...> > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2004 Report Share Posted November 8, 2004 tw ji, Thanks for taking the pain for the comparison. It is a welcome efforts and hope we will see more such efforts in future. I would like to add Varahamihira and publish it on my blog at http://www.astrocamp.com/Vedic Astrology/ Regards, Punit Pandey On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 05:48:10 -0000, tw853 <tw853 wrote: > > Dear All, > > For your attention and review a comparison of different software > results are given as follows: > > > Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, > Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > > 1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- > 10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > > SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software > 1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs > 2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire > 3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli > 4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst > 5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura > 6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One > 7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL > 8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > > Basic Data > > Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA > 1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 > 2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 > 3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 > 4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* > 5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 > 6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 > 7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 > 8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > > * Lahiri Ayanamsa > > Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, > 5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > > Explanations: > 1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due > to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. > 2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara > Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 > 3. KP & Vedic, > 4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa > 5. KP & Vedic, > 6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH > 7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) > 8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > > > ATTENTION: > > 1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star > Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & > SL) > > 2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except > around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > > 3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same > whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. > > > 1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 > > Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software > 1. 336-20-09 Raichurs > 2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire > 3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli > 4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst > 5 336-20-12 Astraura > 6 336-21-20 Old One > 7 336-20-14 JHL > 8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > > Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or > less the same) > > Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, > Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > > For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > > SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software > 1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur > 2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank > 3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst > 4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura > 5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One > 6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL > 7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > > ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire > will be very useful. > > Basic Data > > SN Software Sid Time KPA > 1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 > 2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* > 3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 > 4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 > 5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > > * Lahiri Ayanamsa > > Good Luck! > > tw > > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> > wrote: > > Dear Members, > > I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > > Software,but after I bought and began using the > > Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > > levels),I have found it most useful and > > simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > > specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > > principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > > in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > > K.P., developed so far... > > I therefore would strongly recommend > > Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > > e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > > With best wishes,I am, > > Yours sincerely, > > lyrastro1 > > GOOD LUCK ! > > > > > > Vaidun ji, > > > > Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile > > Kundli for > > PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are > > designed KP > > astrologers in mind. The details are available at > > http://www.astrocamp.com. > > > > Regards, > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > > > > > On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > > <vvidya@o...> wrote: > > > Dear List Members, > > > > > > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > > in 1988 when I was > > > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > > astrology was with KP. I had > > > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > > was very impressed with > > > his astrological skills. There are few who can > > match the phenomenal > > > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > > MANUALLY cast each chart, > > > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > > the ephemeris. It used > > > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > > finally arrive at the > > > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > > same job can be done in > > > seconds. Amazing. > > > > > > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > > in it but maybe not > > > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > > astrology program which > > > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > > request members to kindly > > > advise me as to which would be the best program for > > this. I will be much > > > obliged. > > > > > > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > > unable to find a > > > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > > now. I hope to be able > > > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > > > > > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > > > > > > Vaidun Vidyadhar > > > 1 / 94 Marius Street > > > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > > > Australia > > > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > > > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > > > Email: vvidya@o... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2004 Report Share Posted November 8, 2004 Dear tw, i have calculate value by manualy. givan bellow: TOB: 11.48.00 00.04.40 Time cerrection ----------------------------- 11.52.40 Local time 1.58 correction ______________- 11.54.38 02.44.32 S.T.(acording to THE AMERICAN EPHEMERIS FOR THE 20TH CENTURY BY: NEIL F.MICHELSEN A.C.S PUBLICATION U.S.A.) _________________ 14.39.10 TCV and this value match with only Raichur's software. check this and rerply regards kanak bosmia >"tw853" <tw853 > > > Re: Which is the best software program for KP - KPBC1 & A TEST- >Mon, 08 Nov 2004 05:48:10 -0000 > > >Dear All, > >For your attention and review a comparison of different software >results are given as follows: > > >Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > >1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- >10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > >SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software >1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs >2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire >3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli >4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst >5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura >6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One >7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL >8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > >Basic Data > >Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA >1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 >2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 >3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 >4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* >5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 >7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 >8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > >* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > >Explanations: >1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. >2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 >3. KP & Vedic, >4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >5. KP & Vedic, >6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH >7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) >8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > > >ATTENTION: > >1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >SL) > >2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > >3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. > > >1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 > >Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software >1. 336-20-09 Raichurs >2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire >3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli >4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst >5 336-20-12 Astraura >6 336-21-20 Old One >7 336-20-14 JHL >8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > >Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >less the same) > >Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > >For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > >SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software >1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur >2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank >3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst >4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura >5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One >6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL >7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > >ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >will be very useful. > >Basic Data > >SN Software Sid Time KPA >1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > >* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >Good Luck! > >tw > > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> >wrote: > > Dear Members, > > I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > > Software,but after I bought and began using the > > Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > > levels),I have found it most useful and > > simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > > specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > > principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > > in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > > K.P., developed so far... > > I therefore would strongly recommend > > Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > > e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > > With best wishes,I am, > > Yours sincerely, > > lyrastro1 > > GOOD LUCK ! > > > > > > Vaidun ji, > > > > Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile > > Kundli for > > PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are > > designed KP > > astrologers in mind. The details are available at > > http://www.astrocamp.com. > > > > Regards, > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > > > > > On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > > <vvidya@o...> wrote: > > > Dear List Members, > > > > > > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > > in 1988 when I was > > > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > > astrology was with KP. I had > > > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > > was very impressed with > > > his astrological skills. There are few who can > > match the phenomenal > > > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > > MANUALLY cast each chart, > > > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > > the ephemeris. It used > > > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > > finally arrive at the > > > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > > same job can be done in > > > seconds. Amazing. > > > > > > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > > in it but maybe not > > > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > > astrology program which > > > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > > request members to kindly > > > advise me as to which would be the best program for > > this. I will be much > > > obliged. > > > > > > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > > unable to find a > > > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > > now. I hope to be able > > > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > > > > > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > > > > > > Vaidun Vidyadhar > > > 1 / 94 Marius Street > > > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > > > Australia > > > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > > > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > > > Email: vvidya@o... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2004 Report Share Posted November 8, 2004 difference in ASC. There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same.. Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel I am open to correction, If my method is not correct good luck Try it then Judge.tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear All,For your attention and review a comparison of different software results are given as follows:Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E101(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m-10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior JyotishBasic DataSr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-102.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-483.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-444.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-317.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.298.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* * Lahiri AyanamsaDifferences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, 5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s Explanations:1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 14203. KP & Vedic, 4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa 5. KP & Vedic, 6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only)ATTENTION:1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & SL)2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere.1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software1. 336-20-09 Raichurs2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst5 336-20-12 Astraura6 336-21-20 Old One7 336-20-14 JHL8 336-19-50 Junior JyotishNot much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or less the same)Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 KhaldeaATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire will be very useful.Basic DataSN Software Sid Time KPA 1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* 3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 * Lahiri AyanamsaGood Luck!tw , Yogesh Rao Lajmi wrote:> Dear Members,> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.> Software,but after I bought and began using the> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub> levels),I have found it most useful and> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for> K.P., developed so far...> I therefore would strongly recommend> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...> With best wishes,I am,> Yours sincerely,> lyrastro1> GOOD LUCK !> > > Vaidun ji,> > Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile> Kundli for> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are> designed KP> astrologers in mind. The details are available at> http://www.astrocamp.com.> > Regards,> > Punit Pandey> > > > On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar> wrote:> > Dear List Members,> > > > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP> in 1988 when I was> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic> astrology was with KP. I had> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and> was very impressed with> > his astrological skills. There are few who can> match the phenomenal> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to> MANUALLY cast each chart,> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and> the ephemeris. It used> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to> finally arrive at the> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the> same job can be done in> > seconds. Amazing. > > > > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP> in it but maybe not> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other> astrology program which> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I> request members to kindly> > advise me as to which would be the best program for> this. I will be much> > obliged.> > > > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was> unable to find a> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until> now. I hope to be able> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > > > Thanks for your time. With best regards.> > > > Vaidun Vidyadhar> > 1 / 94 Marius Street> > Tamworth, NSW 2340> > Australia> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)> > Mobile: 0414 870 083> > Email: vvidya@o...> > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2004 Report Share Posted November 8, 2004 tw & members, Mr Raichur has kindly given me his ayanamsa for 1st January 1900 which works out at 22:22:15. I have programmed this into Solar Fire, Parashara Light and Goravani Jyotish and give the appropriate figures for the following example. Please see comments below ** ............... ** Ron Gaunt On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 05:48:10 +0000, you wrote: > > >Dear All, > >For your attention and review a comparison of different software >results are given as follows: > > >Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > >1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- >10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > >SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software >1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs >2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire ** 253-09-09 (note: SF shows 22-32-00 not 22-32-10 as shown above - so there is an immediate discrepancy of 10 " )** >3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli >4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst >5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura >6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One >7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL >8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish ** 9 253-07-56 Parashara Light (note PL shows 22-31-43 - a discrepancy of 17') 10 253-09-00 Goravani Jyotish (please note: I think the above should read Ju-Ke-Me Not Ju-Ke-Ke) ** > >Basic Data > >Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA >1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 >2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 ** " " 14-39-09 253-09 -09 22-32-00** >3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 >4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* >5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 >7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 >8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* ** 9 Parashara L. 253-07-56 22-31-43 10 Goravani Jyotish 253-09-00 22-32-10 > >* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > >Explanations: >1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. >2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 >3. KP & Vedic, >4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >5. KP & Vedic, >6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH >7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) >8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > > >ATTENTION: > >1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >SL) ** I think this should read 17 min not degrees ** >2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > >3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. ** Agreed. This is the same problem I saw when going through the books. The major difference is the angles in Mr Raichur's program and the other quality programs.** > >1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 > >Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software >1. 336-20-09 Raichurs >2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire ** 336-20-22 " " ** >3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli >4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst >5 336-20-12 Astraura >6 336-21-20 Old One >7 336-20-14 JHL >8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish ** 9 336-20-39 Parashara Light ** **10 336-20-14 Goravani Jyotish ** > >Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >less the same) ** 8 is calculated with Lahiri ayanamsa ** > >Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > >For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > >SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software >1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur >2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank >3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst >4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura >5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One >6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL >7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > >ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >will be very useful. ** 8 237-38-43 078-03-34 Solar Fire 9 236-17-10 077-57-55 Parashara Light > >Basic Data > >SN Software Sid Time KPA >1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >4. Old One 2-27-04 16-09-00 >5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 ** 6 Solar Fire 16-07-56 7 Parash. Light 16-07-15** ** PS I feel very confident about the planets accuracy in Solar Fire. I have checked out against historical sightings and they appear to be very accurate. ie. Babylonian clay tablet for 4th April 0263BC where Sun and Moon were exactly as observed ** > >* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >Good Luck! > >tw > > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> >wrote: >> Dear Members, >> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. >> Software,but after I bought and began using the >> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub >> levels),I have found it most useful and >> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a >> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams >> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which >> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for >> K.P., developed so far... >> I therefore would strongly recommend >> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his >> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... >> With best wishes,I am, >> Yours sincerely, >> lyrastro1 >> GOOD LUCK ! >> >> >> Vaidun ji, >> >> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile >> Kundli for >> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are >> designed KP >> astrologers in mind. The details are available at >> http://www.astrocamp.com. >> >> Regards, >> >> Punit Pandey >> >> >> >> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar >> <vvidya@o...> wrote: >> > Dear List Members, >> > >> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP >> in 1988 when I was >> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic >> astrology was with KP. I had >> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and >> was very impressed with >> > his astrological skills. There are few who can >> match the phenomenal >> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to >> MANUALLY cast each chart, >> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and >> the ephemeris. It used >> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to >> finally arrive at the >> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the >> same job can be done in >> > seconds. Amazing. >> > >> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP >> in it but maybe not >> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other >> astrology program which >> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I >> request members to kindly >> > advise me as to which would be the best program for >> this. I will be much >> > obliged. >> > >> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was >> unable to find a >> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until >> now. I hope to be able >> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >> > >> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. >> > >> > Vaidun Vidyadhar >> > 1 / 94 Marius Street >> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 >> > Australia >> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) >> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 >> > Email: vvidya@o... >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2004 Report Share Posted November 8, 2004 Anant, I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the Asc position. Ron Gaunt On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: >difference in ASC. > >There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. > >Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same.. > >Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. > >For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. > >For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp > >I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel > >I am open to correction, If my method is not correct > >good luck > >Try it then Judge. > >tw853 <tw853 wrote: > > >Dear All, > >For your attention and review a comparison of different software >results are given as follows: > > >Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > >1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- >10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > >SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software >1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs >2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire >3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli >4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst >5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura >6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One >7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL >8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > >Basic Data > >Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA >1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 >2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 >3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 >4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* >5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 >7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 >8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > >* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > >Explanations: >1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. >2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 >3. KP & Vedic, >4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >5. KP & Vedic, >6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH >7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) >8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > > >ATTENTION: > >1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >SL) > >2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > >3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. > > >1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 > >Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software >1. 336-20-09 Raichurs >2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire >3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli >4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst >5 336-20-12 Astraura >6 336-21-20 Old One >7 336-20-14 JHL >8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > >Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >less the same) > >Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > >For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > >SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software >1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur >2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank >3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst >4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura >5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One >6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL >7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > >ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >will be very useful. > >Basic Data > >SN Software Sid Time KPA >1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > >* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >Good Luck! > >tw > > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >wrote: >> Dear Members, >> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. >> Software,but after I bought and began using the >> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub >> levels),I have found it most useful and >> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a >> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams >> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which >> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for >> K.P., developed so far... >> I therefore would strongly recommend >> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his >> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... >> With best wishes,I am, >> Yours sincerely, >> lyrastro1 >> GOOD LUCK ! >> >> >> Vaidun ji, >> >> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile >> Kundli for >> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are >> designed KP >> astrologers in mind. The details are available at >> http://www.astrocamp.com. >> >> Regards, >> >> Punit Pandey >> >> >> >> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar >> wrote: >> > Dear List Members, >> > >> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP >> in 1988 when I was >> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic >> astrology was with KP. I had >> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and >> was very impressed with >> > his astrological skills. There are few who can >> match the phenomenal >> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to >> MANUALLY cast each chart, >> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and >> the ephemeris. It used >> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to >> finally arrive at the >> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the >> same job can be done in >> > seconds. Amazing. >> > >> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP >> in it but maybe not >> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other >> astrology program which >> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I >> request members to kindly >> > advise me as to which would be the best program for >> this. I will be much >> > obliged. >> > >> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was >> unable to find a >> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until >> now. I hope to be able >> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >> > >> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. >> > >> > Vaidun Vidyadhar >> > 1 / 94 Marius Street >> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 >> > Australia >> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) >> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 >> > Email: vvidya@o... >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 Yogesh, When you state " reproduced in these columns by Shri Kanak Bosmiaji " , I am not certain whether you infer that the document is reproduced in the magazine or this List. If it is this List do you have the date of the posting? Thanks Ron Gaunt On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 06:28:39 +0000, you wrote: >Dear tw853, > With K.P. NEW ayanamsa the ascendant sub-sub is VENUS...while with all others the asc sub-sub is Kethu... > Does that make any significant difference or not...should be examined to decide upon the correctness of the ayanamsa...? > I generally follow New K.P. ayanamsa,frankly,blindly,simply because,not only am I convinced,but, I have implicit faith in both, M.G.G.Nair,and Professor Balachandran,who has explained briefly,but convincingly how he has derived these new Ayanamsa values,in K.P. & Astrology,Magazine,2003,Annual,pp. 66-93,and reproduced in these columns by Shri Kanak Bosmiaji... > Yours sincerely, > lyrastro1 > GOOD LUCK ! > >tw853 <tw853 wrote: > >Dear All, > >For your attention and review a comparison of different software >results are given as follows: > > >Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > >1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- >10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > >SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software >1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs >2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire >3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli >4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst >5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura >6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One >7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL >8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > >Basic Data > >Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA >1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 >2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 >3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 >4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* >5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 >7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 >8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > >* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > >Explanations: >1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. >2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 >3. KP & Vedic, >4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >5. KP & Vedic, >6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH >7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) >8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > > >ATTENTION: > >1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >SL) > >2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > >3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. > > >1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 > >Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software >1. 336-20-09 Raichurs >2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire >3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli >4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst >5 336-20-12 Astraura >6 336-21-20 Old One >7 336-20-14 JHL >8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > >Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >less the same) > >Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > >For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > >SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software >1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur >2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank >3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst >4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura >5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One >6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL >7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > >ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >will be very useful. > >Basic Data > >SN Software Sid Time KPA >1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > >* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >Good Luck! > >tw > > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> >wrote: >> Dear Members, >> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. >> Software,but after I bought and began using the >> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub >> levels),I have found it most useful and >> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a >> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams >> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which >> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for >> K.P., developed so far... >> I therefore would strongly recommend >> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his >> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... >> With best wishes,I am, >> Yours sincerely, >> lyrastro1 >> GOOD LUCK ! >> >> >> Vaidun ji, >> >> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile >> Kundli for >> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are >> designed KP >> astrologers in mind. The details are available at >> http://www.astrocamp.com. >> >> Regards, >> >> Punit Pandey >> >> >> >> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar >> <vvidya@o...> wrote: >> > Dear List Members, >> > >> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP >> in 1988 when I was >> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic >> astrology was with KP. I had >> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and >> was very impressed with >> > his astrological skills. There are few who can >> match the phenomenal >> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to >> MANUALLY cast each chart, >> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and >> the ephemeris. It used >> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to >> finally arrive at the >> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the >> same job can be done in >> > seconds. Amazing. >> > >> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP >> in it but maybe not >> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other >> astrology program which >> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I >> request members to kindly >> > advise me as to which would be the best program for >> this. I will be much >> > obliged. >> > >> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was >> unable to find a >> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until >> now. I hope to be able >> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >> > >> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. >> > >> > Vaidun Vidyadhar >> > 1 / 94 Marius Street >> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 >> > Australia >> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) >> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 >> > Email: vvidya@o... >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 Dear All, Thank you very much for your comments. 1. Pl note that the aynamsa factor has been neutralized by using only so-called " New KPA " 22d-32m-10s given by Raichur's software in the both tables 1 (a) & 1 (b) of the example 1 (KPBC1) comparing Asc and Moon positions. That is why it is not necessary to examine to decide the correctness of the ayanamsa. To make it clearer, Asc 153-09-21 by Solar Fire is deducted by 22sec (New KPA 22-32-10 minus KPA 22-31-48 used by Ron Gaunt) to get a comparable Asc position with the same New KPA. Asc 253-09-26.04 by JHL is deducted by 50.71sec (New KPA 22-32-10 minus KPA 22-31-19.29 used by JHL) to get a comparable Asc position with the same New KPA. In JHL it can be calculated directly with New KPA by entering the " Custom (user defied) " ayanamsa. In the table of example 2, the KPA 16-07-14.65 of JHL (which is still in line) is used for all softwares. 31sec (difference between Raichur New KPA and JHL KPA) can be deducted to get Asc and Moon position with NEW KPA. 2. Difference between New KPA and old KPA is 30-50sec only. The difference in Asc of KPBC1 is around 17deg (equivalent to 1h8m differnce in BOT) giving different SL, SL & SSL. Does that make any significant difference or not is the will of the person (in examining longevity, health, prarabdha mentioned in Msg #890, etc - - -). 3. New KPA can be acceptable since there is not much difference. It also may not be a big deal for Guruji KSK who said that " the difference between what I follow, what Lahiri (6m difference) and Rajan follow is negligible " . 4. Of course, the difference of 1sec in Sid. Time is due to the Ephemeris used. Astrodienst and Astro-Kundle use Swiss Ephemeris. Their results are more or less the same but sometimes there are differences. But it's just a check point in the process of calculation. Acceptable is Kanak Bosmia's manual calculation, saying 14-39-10 matches with only Raichur's software. But how about 17 deg difference in Asc of KPBC1 and going out of line in the case of Leonardo da Vinci? It will be very interseting if manual calculations can be done. In fact, this is the only best simple way to check the results in stead of Sun calculation etc. I tried, but I couldn't because pages for ENG are not included in my photo copy of UTOH. Not much difference with positions of planets. It is understanable how equations in the software are delicate to adjust in making a balance over short and long term. 5. Anyway it's good since my purpose is not to judge which software is correct, but just to let our Group members know about the software results in the short term and in the long term like the chart of Leonardo da Vinci. Only one thing can be mentioned that Solar Fire is the one mentioned by late Lois Rodden of AsroDatabak. 6. If useful, some issues on New KPA may be discussed later just for academic purpose only even though it is said that the KP ayanamsa has been modified in 2003 and all old figures in the Books do not hold good. 7. As expected less difference for youger native, for John Edawrd,10 June 1953, We, 7-02 AM, UT-5h, Seneca, Sc, 34N41, 82W57 New KPA 23d-7m-0s as per Raichur for all softwares by adjustment Software Asc D-M-S Mo D-M-S Su D-M-S Raichur 78-49-10 42-02-15 56-10-58 AsroDatabank 78-55-00 42-03-00 56-11-00 Astrodienst 78-55-29 42-02-22 56-10-31 Astraura 78-55-41 42-02-36 56-10-45 Old One 78-54-43 42-04-16 56-10-49 JHl 78-55-43 42-02-38 56-11-05 Sid. Time 23-44-22 in Raichur, ST 22-44-23 Astrodienst, ST 23-44-23 Astraura, ST 23-44-22 Old One, ST 23-44-23 JHL; New KPA 23-7-0 in Raichur, KPA 23-6-38 Astraura, KPA 23-6 Old One, KPA 23-06-33 JHL, Lahiri 23-12-24 Astrdienst. Only around 6d difference in Asc, Monn & Sun mor or less consistent. Will be worst for forty-years-older (than Vinci) Joan of Arc, 15 Jan 1413 NS, 5 PM LMT , UT-0:23, Domremy La Pucelle, France, 48N27, 05E41; Astraura & mine Old One run on only dot matrix printer gone out of line; if interested, Raichur can be run and compared.(Sorry for not being able to clude those results due to some difficulties in running the program.) KPA 15-34-20 (JHL) for all softwares by adjustment Software Asc D-M-S Mo D-M-S AstroDatabank 105-53-40 334-36-40 Astrodienst 105-53-57 334-34-46 Astraura 105-50-31 91-46-22 Old One 113-02-40 103-45-05 JHL 105-51-12 334-35-23 Sid. Time 0-38-31 in Astrodienst, ST 0-38-11 Astraura, ST 23-44-22 Old One, ST 0-38-15 JHL; KPA 15-34-26 in Astraura, KPA 23-6 Old One, KPA 15-34-20 JHL, Lahiri 15-40-07 in Astrodienst. Best regards, tw P.S. Same request like Ron Gaunt for information on posting by Kanak Bosmiaji. , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> wrote: > Dear tw853, > With K.P. NEW ayanamsa the ascendant sub-sub is VENUS...while with all others the asc sub-sub is Kethu... > Does that make any significant difference or not...should be examined to decide upon the correctness of the ayanamsa...? > I generally follow New K.P. ayanamsa,frankly,blindly,simply because,not only am I convinced,but, I have implicit faith in both, M.G.G.Nair,and Professor Balachandran,who has explained briefly,but convincingly how he has derived these new Ayanamsa values,in K.P. & Astrology,Magazine,2003,Annual,pp. 66-93,and reproduced in these columns by Shri Kanak Bosmiaji... > Yours sincerely, > lyrastro1 > GOOD LUCK ! > > tw853 <tw853> wrote: > > Dear All, > > For your attention and review a comparison of different software > results are given as follows: > > > Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, > Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > > 1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- > 10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > > SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software > 1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs > 2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire > 3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli > 4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst > 5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura > 6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One > 7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL > 8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > > Basic Data > > Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA > 1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 > 2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 > 3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 > 4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* > 5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 > 6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 > 7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 > 8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > > * Lahiri Ayanamsa > > Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, > 5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > > Explanations: > 1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due > to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. > 2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara > Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 > 3. KP & Vedic, > 4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa > 5. KP & Vedic, > 6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH > 7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) > 8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > > > ATTENTION: > > 1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star > Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & > SL) > > 2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except > around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > > 3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same > whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. > > > 1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32- 10 > > Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software > 1. 336-20-09 Raichurs > 2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire > 3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli > 4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst > 5 336-20-12 Astraura > 6 336-21-20 Old One > 7 336-20-14 JHL > 8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > > Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or > less the same) > > Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, > Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > > For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > > SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software > 1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur > 2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank > 3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst > 4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura > 5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One > 6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL > 7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > > ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire > will be very useful. > > Basic Data > > SN Software Sid Time KPA > 1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 > 2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* > 3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 > 4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 > 5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > > * Lahiri Ayanamsa > > Good Luck! > > tw > > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> > wrote: > > Dear Members, > > I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > > Software,but after I bought and began using the > > Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > > levels),I have found it most useful and > > simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > > specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > > principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > > in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > > K.P., developed so far... > > I therefore would strongly recommend > > Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > > e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > > With best wishes,I am, > > Yours sincerely, > > lyrastro1 > > GOOD LUCK ! > > > > > > Vaidun ji, > > > > Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile > > Kundli for > > PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are > > designed KP > > astrologers in mind. The details are available at > > http://www.astrocamp.com. > > > > Regards, > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > > > > > On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > > <vvidya@o...> wrote: > > > Dear List Members, > > > > > > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > > in 1988 when I was > > > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > > astrology was with KP. I had > > > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > > was very impressed with > > > his astrological skills. There are few who can > > match the phenomenal > > > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > > MANUALLY cast each chart, > > > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > > the ephemeris. It used > > > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > > finally arrive at the > > > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > > same job can be done in > > > seconds. Amazing. > > > > > > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > > in it but maybe not > > > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > > astrology program which > > > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > > request members to kindly > > > advise me as to which would be the best program for > > this. I will be much > > > obliged. > > > > > > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > > unable to find a > > > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > > now. I hope to be able > > > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > > > > > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > > > > > > Vaidun Vidyadhar > > > 1 / 94 Marius Street > > > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > > > Australia > > > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > > > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > > > Email: vvidya@o... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 Dear Rongaunt The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is to verify wether the calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which determines the ASC. I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC. I am happy you are making a deep study of this. One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps Good Luck rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: Anant,I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etcpositions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as theSun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of ourBlind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa,and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Ascor Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably -whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc thedifferential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'.I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of theAsc position.Ron GauntOn Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote:>difference in ASC.> >There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon.> >Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same..> >Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. > >For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp.> >For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp> >I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel> >I am open to correction, If my method is not correct> >good luck> >Try it then Judge.>>tw853 wrote:>>>Dear All,>>For your attention and review a comparison of different software >results are given as follows:>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m->10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish>>Basic Data>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >>Explanations:>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420>3. KP & Vedic, >4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >5. KP & Vedic, >6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only)>>>ATTENTION:>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >SL)>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere.>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst>5 336-20-12 Astraura>6 336-21-20 Old One>7 336-20-14 JHL>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >less the same)>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >will be very useful.>>Basic Data>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>Good Luck!>>tw>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >wrote:>> Dear Members,>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.>> Software,but after I bought and began using the>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub>> levels),I have found it most useful and>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for>> K.P., developed so far...>> I therefore would strongly recommend>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...>> With best wishes,I am,>> Yours sincerely,>> lyrastro1>> GOOD LUCK !>> >> >> Vaidun ji,>> >> Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile>> Kundli for>> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are>> designed KP>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at>> http://www.astrocamp.com.>> >> Regards,>> >> Punit Pandey>> >> >> >> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar>> wrote:>> > Dear List Members,>> > >> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP>> in 1988 when I was>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic>> astrology was with KP. I had>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and>> was very impressed with>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can>> match the phenomenal>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to>> MANUALLY cast each chart,>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and>> the ephemeris. It used>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to>> finally arrive at the>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the>> same job can be done in>> > seconds. Amazing. >> > >> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP>> in it but maybe not>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other>> astrology program which>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I>> request members to kindly>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for>> this. I will be much>> > obliged.>> > >> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was>> unable to find a>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until>> now. I hope to be able>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >> > >> > Thanks for your time. With best regards.>> > >> > Vaidun Vidyadhar>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340>> > Australia>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083>> > Email: vvidya@o...>> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 THERE SEEMS TO BE A MIS UNDERSTANDING. THE DIFF IN ASC POINTED OUT IS 17 minutes NOT NOT Degrees. tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear All,Thank you very much for your comments.1. Pl note that the aynamsa factor has been neutralized by using only so-called "New KPA" 22d-32m-10s given by Raichur's software in the both tables 1 (a) & 1 (b) of the example 1 (KPBC1) comparing Asc and Moon positions. That is why it is not necessary to examine to decide the correctness of the ayanamsa. To make it clearer, Asc 153-09-21 by Solar Fire is deducted by 22sec (New KPA 22-32-10 minus KPA 22-31-48 used by Ron Gaunt) to get a comparable Asc position with the same New KPA. Asc 253-09-26.04 by JHL is deducted by 50.71sec (New KPA 22-32-10 minus KPA 22-31-19.29 used by JHL) to get a comparable Asc position with the same New KPA. In JHL it can be calculated directly with New KPA by entering the "Custom (user defied)" ayanamsa. In the table of example 2, the KPA 16-07-14.65 of JHL (which is still in line) is used for all softwares. 31sec (difference between Raichur New KPA and JHL KPA) can be deducted to get Asc and Moon position with NEW KPA.2. Difference between New KPA and old KPA is 30-50sec only. The difference in Asc of KPBC1 is around 17deg (equivalent to 1h8m differnce in BOT) giving different SL, SL & SSL. Does that make any significant difference or not is the will of the person (in examining longevity, health, prarabdha mentioned in Msg #890, etc - --).3. New KPA can be acceptable since there is not much difference. It also may not be a big deal for Guruji KSK who said that "the difference between what I follow, what Lahiri (6m difference) and Rajan follow is negligible".4. Of course, the difference of 1sec in Sid. Time is due to the Ephemeris used. Astrodienst and Astro-Kundle use Swiss Ephemeris. Their results are more or less the same but sometimes there are differences. But it's just a check point in the process of calculation. Acceptable is Kanak Bosmia's manual calculation, saying 14-39-10 matches with only Raichur's software. But how about 17 deg difference in Asc of KPBC1 and going out of line in the case of Leonardo da Vinci? It will be very interseting if manual calculations can be done. In fact, this is the only best simple way to check the results in stead of Sun calculation etc. I tried, but I couldn't because pages for ENG are not included in my photo copy of UTOH. Not much difference with positions of planets. It is understanable how equations in the software are delicate to adjust in making a balance over short and long term.5. Anyway it's good since my purpose is not to judge which software is correct, but just to let our Group members know about the software results in the short term and in the long term like the chart of Leonardo da Vinci. Only one thing can be mentioned that Solar Fire is the one mentioned by late Lois Rodden of AsroDatabak.6. If useful, some issues on New KPA may be discussed later just for academic purpose only even though it is said that the KP ayanamsa has been modified in 2003 and all old figures in the Books do not hold good. 7. As expected less difference for youger native, for John Edawrd,10 June 1953, We, 7-02 AM, UT-5h, Seneca, Sc, 34N41, 82W57New KPA 23d-7m-0s as per Raichur for all softwares by adjustmentSoftware Asc D-M-S Mo D-M-S Su D-M-SRaichur 78-49-10 42-02-15 56-10-58AsroDatabank 78-55-00 42-03-00 56-11-00Astrodienst 78-55-29 42-02-22 56-10-31Astraura 78-55-41 42-02-36 56-10-45Old One 78-54-43 42-04-16 56-10-49JHl 78-55-43 42-02-38 56-11-05Sid. Time 23-44-22 in Raichur, ST 22-44-23 Astrodienst, ST 23-44-23 Astraura, ST 23-44-22 Old One, ST 23-44-23 JHL; New KPA 23-7-0 in Raichur, KPA 23-6-38 Astraura, KPA 23-6 Old One, KPA 23-06-33 JHL, Lahiri 23-12-24 Astrdienst.Only around 6d difference in Asc, Monn & Sun mor or less consistent.Will be worst for forty-years-older (than Vinci) Joan of Arc, 15 Jan 1413 NS, 5 PM LMT , UT-0:23, Domremy La Pucelle, France, 48N27, 05E41; Astraura & mine Old One run on only dot matrix printer gone out of line; if interested, Raichur can be run and compared.(Sorry for not being able to clude those results due to some difficulties in running the program.)KPA 15-34-20 (JHL) for all softwares by adjustmentSoftware Asc D-M-S Mo D-M-SAstroDatabank 105-53-40 334-36-40Astrodienst 105-53-57 334-34-46Astraura 105-50-31 91-46-22Old One 113-02-40 103-45-05JHL 105-51-12 334-35-23Sid. Time 0-38-31 in Astrodienst, ST 0-38-11 Astraura, ST 23-44-22 Old One, ST 0-38-15 JHL; KPA 15-34-26 in Astraura, KPA 23-6 Old One, KPA 15-34-20 JHL, Lahiri 15-40-07 in Astrodienst.Best regards,twP.S. Same request like Ron Gaunt for information on posting by Kanak Bosmiaji. , Yogesh Rao Lajmi wrote:> Dear tw853,> With K.P. NEW ayanamsa the ascendant sub-sub is VENUS...while with all others the asc sub-sub is Kethu...> Does that make any significant difference or not...should be examined to decide upon the correctness of the ayanamsa...?> I generally follow New K.P. ayanamsa,frankly,blindly,simply because,not only am I convinced,but, I have implicit faith in both, M.G.G.Nair,and Professor Balachandran,who has explained briefly,but convincingly how he has derived these new Ayanamsa values,in K.P. & Astrology,Magazine,2003,Annual,pp. 66-93,and reproduced in these columns by Shri Kanak Bosmiaji...> Yours sincerely,> lyrastro1> GOOD LUCK !> > tw853 wrote:> > Dear All,> > For your attention and review a comparison of different software > results are given as follows:> > > Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, > Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10> > 1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m-> 10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.> > SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software> 1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs> 2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire> 3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli> 4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst> 5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura> 6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One> 7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL> 8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish> > Basic Data> > Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA> 1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10> 2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48> 3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44> 4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*> 5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 > 6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31> 7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29> 8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > > * Lahiri Ayanamsa> > Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, > 5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > > Explanations:> 1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due > to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.> 2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara > Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420> 3. KP & Vedic, > 4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa > 5. KP & Vedic, > 6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH> 7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)> 8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only)> > > ATTENTION:> > 1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star > Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & > SL)> > 2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except > around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.> > 3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same > whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere.> > > 1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10> > Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software> 1. 336-20-09 Raichurs> 2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire> 3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli> 4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst> 5 336-20-12 Astraura> 6 336-21-20 Old One> 7 336-20-14 JHL> 8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish> > Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or > less the same)> > Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, > Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55> > For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.> > SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software> 1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur> 2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank> 3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst> 4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura> 5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One> 6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL> 7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea> > ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire > will be very useful.> > Basic Data> > SN Software Sid Time KPA > 1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 > 2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* > 3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 > 4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 > 5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > > * Lahiri Ayanamsa> > Good Luck!> > tw> > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi > wrote:> > Dear Members,> > I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.> > Software,but after I bought and began using the> > Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub> > levels),I have found it most useful and> > simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a> > specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams> > principles,a software for horoscope matching...which> > in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for> > K.P., developed so far...> > I therefore would strongly recommend> > Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his> > e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...> > With best wishes,I am,> > Yours sincerely,> > lyrastro1> > GOOD LUCK !> > > > > > Vaidun ji,> > > > Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile> > Kundli for> > PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are> > designed KP> > astrologers in mind. The details are available at> > http://www.astrocamp.com.> > > > Regards,> > > > Punit Pandey> > > > > > > > On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar> > wrote:> > > Dear List Members,> > > > > > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP> > in 1988 when I was> > > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic> > astrology was with KP. I had> > > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and> > was very impressed with> > > his astrological skills. There are few who can> > match the phenomenal> > > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to> > MANUALLY cast each chart,> > > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and> > the ephemeris. It used> > > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to> > finally arrive at the> > > table of significators. Now, with computers, the> > same job can be done in> > > seconds. Amazing. > > > > > > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP> > in it but maybe not> > > enough. I am thinking of buying some other> > astrology program which> > > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I> > request members to kindly> > > advise me as to which would be the best program for> > this. I will be much> > > obliged.> > > > > > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was> > unable to find a> > > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until> > now. I hope to be able> > > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > > > > > Thanks for your time. With best regards.> > > > > > Vaidun Vidyadhar> > > 1 / 94 Marius Street> > > Tamworth, NSW 2340> > > Australia> > > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)> > > Mobile: 0414 870 083> > > Email: vvidya@o...> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 Dear Ron, The entire list of the new Ayanamsas,have been reproduced by Shri Bosmia in k_p_...some only a few days ago...However the list is available in the 2003 Annual of K.P. & Astrology,pp 92-93. If I can retrieve the list I shall mail it to you... With best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK ! rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: Yogesh,When you state " reproduced in these columns by Shri KanakBosmiaji", I am not certain whether you infer that the documentis reproduced in the magazine or this List. If it is this Listdo you have the date of the posting? ThanksRon GauntOn Mon, 08 Nov 2004 06:28:39 +0000, you wrote:>Dear tw853,> With K.P. NEW ayanamsa the ascendant sub-sub is VENUS...while with all others the asc sub-sub is Kethu...> Does that make any significant difference or not...should be examined to decide upon the correctness of the ayanamsa...?> I generally follow New K.P. ayanamsa,frankly,blindly,simply because,not only am I convinced,but, I have implicit faith in both, M.G.G.Nair,and Professor Balachandran,who has explained briefly,but convincingly how he has derived these new Ayanamsa values,in K.P. & Astrology,Magazine,2003,Annual,pp. 66-93,and reproduced in these columns by Shri Kanak Bosmiaji...> Yours sincerely,> lyrastro1> GOOD LUCK !>>tw853 <tw853 wrote:>>Dear All,>>For your attention and review a comparison of different software >results are given as follows:>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m->10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish>>Basic Data>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >>Explanations:>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420>3. KP & Vedic, >4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >5. KP & Vedic, >6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only)>>>ATTENTION:>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >SL)>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere.>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst>5 336-20-12 Astraura>6 336-21-20 Old One>7 336-20-14 JHL>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >less the same)>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >will be very useful.>>Basic Data>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>Good Luck!>>tw>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> >wrote:>> Dear Members,>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.>> Software,but after I bought and began using the>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub>> levels),I have found it most useful and>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for>> K.P., developed so far...>> I therefore would strongly recommend>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...>> With best wishes,I am,>> Yours sincerely,>> lyrastro1>> GOOD LUCK !>> >> >> Vaidun ji,>> >> Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile>> Kundli for>> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are>> designed KP>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at>> http://www.astrocamp.com.>> >> Regards,>> >> Punit Pandey>> >> >> >> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar>> <vvidya@o...> wrote:>> > Dear List Members,>> > >> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP>> in 1988 when I was>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic>> astrology was with KP. I had>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and>> was very impressed with>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can>> match the phenomenal>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to>> MANUALLY cast each chart,>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and>> the ephemeris. It used>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to>> finally arrive at the>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the>> same job can be done in>> > seconds. Amazing. >> > >> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP>> in it but maybe not>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other>> astrology program which>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I>> request members to kindly>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for>> this. I will be much>> > obliged.>> > >> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was>> unable to find a>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until>> now. I hope to be able>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >> > >> > Thanks for your time. With best regards.>> > >> > Vaidun Vidyadhar>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340>> > Australia>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083>> > Email: vvidya@o...>> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 Dear friends, Good wishes to all group members on the occassion of happy and very very luminous DEEPAWALI. Friends, may I know the exact address of bookstalls in Delhi,India,where K P Annuals and magazines are available.Hope you will respond me soon.Thanks. With regards, Ramesh MishraYogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Ron, The entire list of the new Ayanamsas,have been reproduced by Shri Bosmia in k_p_...some only a few days ago...However the list is available in the 2003 Annual of K.P. & Astrology,pp 92-93. If I can retrieve the list I shall mail it to you... With best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK ! rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: Yogesh,When you state " reproduced in these columns by Shri KanakBosmiaji", I am not certain whether you infer that the documentis reproduced in the magazine or this List. If it is this Listdo you have the date of the posting? ThanksRon GauntOn Mon, 08 Nov 2004 06:28:39 +0000, you wrote:>Dear tw853,> With K.P. NEW ayanamsa the ascendant sub-sub is VENUS...while with all others the asc sub-sub is Kethu...> Does that make any significant difference or not...should be examined to decide upon the correctness of the ayanamsa...?> I generally follow New K.P. ayanamsa,frankly,blindly,simply because,not only am I convinced,but, I have implicit faith in both, M.G.G.Nair,and Professor Balachandran,who has explained briefly,but convincingly how he has derived these new Ayanamsa values,in K.P. & Astrology,Magazine,2003,Annual,pp. 66-93,and reproduced in these columns by Shri Kanak Bosmiaji...> Yours sincerely,> lyrastro1> GOOD LUCK !>>tw853 <tw853 wrote:>>Dear All,>>For your attention and review a comparison of different software >results are given as follows:>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m->10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish>>Basic Data>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >>Explanations:>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420>3. KP & Vedic, >4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >5. KP & Vedic, >6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only)>>>ATTENTION:>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >SL)>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere.>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst>5 336-20-12 Astraura>6 336-21-20 Old One>7 336-20-14 JHL>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >less the same)>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >will be very useful.>>Basic Data>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>Good Luck!>>tw>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> >wrote:>> Dear Members,>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.>> Software,but after I bought and began using the>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub>> levels),I have found it most useful and>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for>> K.P., developed so far...>> I therefore would strongly recommend>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...>> With best wishes,I am,>> Yours sincerely,>> lyrastro1>> GOOD LUCK !>> >> >> Vaidun ji,>> >> Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile>> Kundli for>> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are>> designed KP>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at>> http://www.astrocamp.com.>> >> Regards,>> >> Punit Pandey>> >> >> >> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar>> <vvidya@o...> wrote:>> > Dear List Members,>> > >> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP>> in 1988 when I was>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic>> astrology was with KP. I had>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and>> was very impressed with>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can>> match the phenomenal>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to>> MANUALLY cast each chart,>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and>> the ephemeris. It used>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to>> finally arrive at the>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the>> same job can be done in>> > seconds. Amazing. >> > >> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP>> in it but maybe not>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other>> astrology program which>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I>> request members to kindly>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for>> this. I will be much>> > obliged.>> > >> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was>> unable to find a>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until>> now. I hope to be able>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >> > >> > Thanks for your time. With best regards.>> > >> > Vaidun Vidyadhar>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340>> > Australia>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083>> > Email: vvidya@o...>> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 Anant, Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the accuracy shown in the example. But there is still a difference between the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used geocentric in my example. Ron Gaunt On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote: >Dear Rongaunt > >The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is to verify wether the >calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. > >Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. > >The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which determines the ASC. > >I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC. > >I am happy you are making a deep study of this. > >One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps >Good Luck > > >rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: > > >Anant, > >I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc >positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the >Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our >Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, >and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc >or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - >whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the >differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. >I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the >Asc position. > > >Ron Gaunt > > > >On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: > >>difference in ASC. >> >>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. >> >>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same.. >> >>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. >> >>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. >> >>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp >> >>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel >> >>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct >> >>good luck >> >>Try it then Judge. >> >>tw853 wrote: >> >> >>Dear All, >> >>For your attention and review a comparison of different software >>results are given as follows: >> >> >>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 >> >>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- >>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. >> >>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software >>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs >>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire >>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli >>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst >>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura >>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One >>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL >>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish >> >>Basic Data >> >>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA >>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 >>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 >>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 >>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* >>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 >>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 >>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >> >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa >> >>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >> >>Explanations: >>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. >>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 >>3. KP & Vedic, >>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >>5. KP & Vedic, >>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH >>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) >>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) >> >> >>ATTENTION: >> >>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >>SL) >> >>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. >> >>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. >> >> >>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 >> >>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software >>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs >>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire >>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli >>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst >>5 336-20-12 Astraura >>6 336-21-20 Old One >>7 336-20-14 JHL >>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish >> >>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >>less the same) >> >>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 >> >>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. >> >>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software >>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur >>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank >>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst >>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura >>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One >>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL >>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea >> >>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >>will be very useful. >> >>Basic Data >> >>SN Software Sid Time KPA >>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >> >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa >> >>Good Luck! >> >>tw >> >> >> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >>wrote: >>> Dear Members, >>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. >>> Software,but after I bought and began using the >>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub >>> levels),I have found it most useful and >>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a >>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams >>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which >>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for >>> K.P., developed so far... >>> I therefore would strongly recommend >>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his >>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... >>> With best wishes,I am, >>> Yours sincerely, >>> lyrastro1 >>> GOOD LUCK ! >>> >>> >>> Vaidun ji, >>> >>> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile >>> Kundli for >>> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are >>> designed KP >>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at >>> http://www.astrocamp.com. >>> >>> Regards, >>> >>> Punit Pandey >>> >>> >>> >>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar >>> wrote: >>> > Dear List Members, >>> > >>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP >>> in 1988 when I was >>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic >>> astrology was with KP. I had >>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and >>> was very impressed with >>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can >>> match the phenomenal >>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to >>> MANUALLY cast each chart, >>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and >>> the ephemeris. It used >>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to >>> finally arrive at the >>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the >>> same job can be done in >>> > seconds. Amazing. >>> > >>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP >>> in it but maybe not >>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other >>> astrology program which >>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I >>> request members to kindly >>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for >>> this. I will be much >>> > obliged. >>> > >>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was >>> unable to find a >>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until >>> now. I hope to be able >>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >>> > >>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. >>> > >>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar >>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street >>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 >>> > Australia >>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) >>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 >>> > Email: vvidya@o... >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 Dear Ron, difference between the two calculated ascendant is due to difference between siderial time.1.Raichur 14-39-10 2.Solar Fire 14-34-29 defference between both siderial time is 00-04-41. Calculation of asc depend on siderial time. so it is clear that both siderial time are deffer so asc. also deffer. but if you calculet by manualy siderial time in rauchir's software is very correct.(see my old mail for calculation) regards kanak bosmia >rongaunt <rongaunt > > >Re: Re: Which is the best software program for KP - KPBC1 & A TEST- >Tue, 09 Nov 2004 17:01:15 +1000 > > >Anant, > >Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method >of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation >by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the accuracy >shown in the example. But there is still a difference between >the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way >Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used >geocentric in my example. > >Ron Gaunt > > >On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote: > > >Dear Rongaunt > > > >The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is to verify wether the > >calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. > > > >Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. > > > >The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which determines the ASC. > > > >I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC. > > > >I am happy you are making a deep study of this. > > > >One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps > >Good Luck > > > > > >rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: > > > > > >Anant, > > > >I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc > >positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the > >Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our > >Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, > >and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc > >or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - > >whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the > >differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. > >I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the > >Asc position. > > > > > >Ron Gaunt > > > > > > > >On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: > > > >>difference in ASC. > >> > >>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. > >> > >>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same.. > >> > >>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. > >> > >>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. > >> > >>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp > >> > >>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel > >> > >>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct > >> > >>good luck > >> > >>Try it then Judge. > >> > >>tw853 wrote: > >> > >> > >>Dear All, > >> > >>For your attention and review a comparison of different software > >>results are given as follows: > >> > >> > >>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, > >>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > >> > >>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- > >>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > >> > >>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software > >>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs > >>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire > >>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli > >>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst > >>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura > >>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One > >>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL > >>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > >> > >>Basic Data > >> > >>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA > >>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 > >>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 > >>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 > >>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* > >>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 > >>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 > >>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 > >>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > >> > >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >> > >>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, > >>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > >> > >>Explanations: > >>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due > >>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. > >>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara > >>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 > >>3. KP & Vedic, > >>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa > >>5. KP & Vedic, > >>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH > >>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) > >>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > >> > >> > >>ATTENTION: > >> > >>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star > >>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & > >>SL) > >> > >>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except > >>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > >> > >>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same > >>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. > >> > >> > >>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 > >> > >>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software > >>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs > >>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire > >>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli > >>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst > >>5 336-20-12 Astraura > >>6 336-21-20 Old One > >>7 336-20-14 JHL > >>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > >> > >>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or > >>less the same) > >> > >>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, > >>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > >> > >>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > >> > >>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software > >>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur > >>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank > >>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst > >>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura > >>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One > >>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL > >>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > >> > >>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire > >>will be very useful. > >> > >>Basic Data > >> > >>SN Software Sid Time KPA > >>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 > >>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* > >>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 > >>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 > >>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > >> > >>* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >> > >>Good Luck! > >> > >>tw > >> > >> > >> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi > >>wrote: > >>> Dear Members, > >>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > >>> Software,but after I bought and began using the > >>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > >>> levels),I have found it most useful and > >>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > >>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > >>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > >>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > >>> K.P., developed so far... > >>> I therefore would strongly recommend > >>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > >>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > >>> With best wishes,I am, > >>> Yours sincerely, > >>> lyrastro1 > >>> GOOD LUCK ! > >>> > >>> > >>> Vaidun ji, > >>> > >>> Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile > >>> Kundli for > >>> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are > >>> designed KP > >>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at > >>> http://www.astrocamp.com. > >>> > >>> Regards, > >>> > >>> Punit Pandey > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > >>> wrote: > >>> > Dear List Members, > >>> > > >>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > >>> in 1988 when I was > >>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > >>> astrology was with KP. I had > >>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > >>> was very impressed with > >>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can > >>> match the phenomenal > >>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > >>> MANUALLY cast each chart, > >>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > >>> the ephemeris. It used > >>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > >>> finally arrive at the > >>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > >>> same job can be done in > >>> > seconds. Amazing. > >>> > > >>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > >>> in it but maybe not > >>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > >>> astrology program which > >>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > >>> request members to kindly > >>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for > >>> this. I will be much > >>> > obliged. > >>> > > >>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > >>> unable to find a > >>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > >>> now. I hope to be able > >>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > >>> > > >>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > >>> > > >>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar > >>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street > >>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > >>> > Australia > >>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > >>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > >>> > Email: vvidya@o... > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2004 Report Share Posted November 9, 2004 Dear Anant Raichur, Thanks. Very sorry for my misreading. Let me correct my mistake, ie. 17min difference in Asc (equavalent to difference of 1m8s only in BOT.) Best regards, tw , anant raichur <anant_1608> wrote: > THERE SEEMS TO BE A MIS UNDERSTANDING. THE DIFF IN ASC POINTED OUT IS 17 minutes NOT NOT Degrees. > > > > tw853 <tw853> wrote: > > > > Dear All, > > Thank you very much for your comments. > > 1. Pl note that the aynamsa factor has been neutralized by using > only so-called " New KPA " 22d-32m-10s given by Raichur's software in > the both tables 1 (a) & 1 (b) of the example 1 (KPBC1) comparing > Asc and Moon positions. That is why it is not necessary to examine > to decide the correctness of the ayanamsa. To make it clearer, Asc > 153-09-21 by Solar Fire is deducted by 22sec (New KPA 22-32-10 minus > KPA 22-31-48 used by Ron Gaunt) to get a comparable Asc position with > the same New KPA. Asc 253-09-26.04 by JHL is deducted by 50.71sec > (New KPA 22-32-10 minus KPA 22-31-19.29 used by JHL) to get a > comparable Asc position with the same New KPA. In JHL it can be > calculated directly with New KPA by entering the " Custom (user > defied) " ayanamsa. In the table of example 2, the KPA 16-07-14.65 of > JHL (which is still in line) is used for all softwares. 31sec > (difference between Raichur New KPA and JHL KPA) can be deducted to > get Asc and Moon position with NEW KPA. > > 2. Difference between New KPA and old KPA is 30-50sec only. The > difference in Asc of KPBC1 is around 17deg (equivalent to 1h8m > differnce in BOT) giving different SL, SL & SSL. Does that make any > significant difference or not is the will of the person (in > examining longevity, health, prarabdha mentioned in Msg #890, etc - - > -). > > > 3. New KPA can be acceptable since there is not much > difference. It also may not be a big deal for Guruji KSK who said > that " the difference between what I follow, what Lahiri (6m > difference) and Rajan follow is negligible " . > > 4. Of course, the difference of 1sec in Sid. Time is due to the > Ephemeris used. Astrodienst and Astro-Kundle use Swiss Ephemeris. > Their results are more or less the same but sometimes there are > differences. But it's just a check point in the process of > calculation. Acceptable is Kanak Bosmia's manual calculation, > saying 14-39-10 matches with only Raichur's software. But how about > 17 deg difference in Asc of KPBC1 and going out of line in the case > of Leonardo da Vinci? It will be very interseting if manual > calculations can be done. In fact, this is the only best simple way > to check the results in stead of Sun calculation etc. I tried, but I > couldn't because pages for ENG are not included in my photo copy of > UTOH. Not much difference with positions of planets. It is > understanable how equations in the software are delicate to adjust in > making a balance over short and long term. > > > 5. Anyway it's good since my purpose is not to judge which > software is correct, but just to let our Group members know about the > software results in the short term and in the long term like the > chart of Leonardo da Vinci. Only one thing can be mentioned that > Solar Fire is the one mentioned by late Lois Rodden of AsroDatabak. > > 6. If useful, some issues on New KPA may be discussed later > just for academic purpose only even though it is said that the KP > ayanamsa has been modified in 2003 and all old figures in the Books > do not hold good. > > > 7. As expected less difference for youger native, for John > Edawrd,10 June 1953, We, 7-02 AM, UT-5h, Seneca, Sc, 34N41, 82W57 > > New KPA 23d-7m-0s as per Raichur for all softwares by adjustment > > Software Asc D-M-S Mo D-M-S Su D-M-S > Raichur 78-49-10 42-02-15 56-10-58 > AsroDatabank 78-55-00 42-03-00 56-11-00 > Astrodienst 78-55-29 42-02-22 56-10-31 > Astraura 78-55-41 42-02-36 56-10-45 > Old One 78-54-43 42-04-16 56-10-49 > JHl 78-55-43 42-02-38 56-11-05 > > Sid. Time 23-44-22 in Raichur, ST 22-44-23 Astrodienst, ST 23-44-23 > Astraura, ST 23-44-22 Old One, ST 23-44-23 JHL; New KPA 23-7-0 in > Raichur, KPA 23-6-38 Astraura, KPA 23-6 Old One, KPA 23-06-33 JHL, > Lahiri 23-12-24 Astrdienst. > > Only around 6d difference in Asc, Monn & Sun mor or less consistent. > > Will be worst for forty-years-older (than Vinci) Joan of Arc, 15 Jan > 1413 NS, 5 PM LMT , UT-0:23, Domremy La Pucelle, France, 48N27, > 05E41; Astraura & mine Old One run on only dot matrix printer gone > out of line; if interested, Raichur can be run and compared.(Sorry > for not being able to clude those results due to some difficulties in > running the program.) > > KPA 15-34-20 (JHL) for all softwares by adjustment > > Software Asc D-M-S Mo D-M-S > AstroDatabank 105-53-40 334-36-40 > Astrodienst 105-53-57 334-34-46 > Astraura 105-50-31 91-46-22 > Old One 113-02-40 103-45-05 > JHL 105-51-12 334-35-23 > > Sid. Time 0-38-31 in Astrodienst, ST 0-38-11 Astraura, ST 23-44-22 > Old One, ST 0-38-15 JHL; KPA 15-34-26 in Astraura, KPA 23-6 Old One, > KPA 15-34-20 JHL, Lahiri 15-40-07 in Astrodienst. > > Best regards, > > tw > > P.S. Same request like Ron Gaunt for information on posting by Kanak > Bosmiaji. > > > > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi > wrote: > > Dear tw853, > > With K.P. NEW ayanamsa the ascendant sub-sub is > VENUS...while with all others the asc sub-sub is Kethu... > > Does that make any significant difference or > not...should be examined to decide upon the correctness of the > ayanamsa...? > > I generally follow New K.P. > ayanamsa,frankly,blindly,simply because,not only am I convinced,but, > I have implicit faith in both, M.G.G.Nair,and Professor > Balachandran,who has explained briefly,but convincingly how he has > derived these new Ayanamsa values,in K.P. & > Astrology,Magazine,2003,Annual,pp. 66-93,and reproduced in these > columns by Shri Kanak Bosmiaji... > > Yours sincerely, > > lyrastro1 > > GOOD LUCK ! > > > > tw853 wrote: > > > > Dear All, > > > > For your attention and review a comparison of different software > > results are given as follows: > > > > > > Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, > > Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > > > > 1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D- 32m- > > 10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > > > > SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software > > 1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs > > 2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire > > 3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli > > 4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst > > 5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura > > 6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One > > 7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL > > 8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > > > > Basic Data > > > > Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA > > 1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 > > 2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 > > 3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 > > 4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* > > 5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 > > 6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 > > 7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 > > 8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > > > > * Lahiri Ayanamsa > > > > Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) > +5m.22s, > > 5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > > > > Explanations: > > 1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 > due > > to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. > > 2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara > > Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 > > 3. KP & Vedic, > > 4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa > > 5. KP & Vedic, > > 6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH > > 7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) > > 8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > > > > > > ATTENTION: > > > > 1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different > Star > > Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL > & > > SL) > > > > 2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, > except > > around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > > > > 3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same > > whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong > somewhere. > > > > > > 1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22- 32- > 10 > > > > Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software > > 1. 336-20-09 Raichurs > > 2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire > > 3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli > > 4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst > > 5 336-20-12 Astraura > > 6 336-21-20 Old One > > 7 336-20-14 JHL > > 8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > > > > Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or > > less the same) > > > > Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT- 0.44, > > Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > > > > For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > > > > SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software > > 1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur > > 2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank > > 3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst > > 4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura > > 5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One > > 6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL > > 7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > > > > ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire > > will be very useful. > > > > Basic Data > > > > SN Software Sid Time KPA > > 1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 > > 2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* > > 3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 > > 4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 > > 5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > > > > * Lahiri Ayanamsa > > > > Good Luck! > > > > tw > > > > > > , Yogesh Rao Lajmi > > > wrote: > > > Dear Members, > > > I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > > > Software,but after I bought and began using the > > > Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > > > levels),I have found it most useful and > > > simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > > > specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > > > principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > > > in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > > > K.P., developed so far... > > > I therefore would strongly recommend > > > Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > > > e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > > > With best wishes,I am, > > > Yours sincerely, > > > lyrastro1 > > > GOOD LUCK ! > > > > > > > > > Vaidun ji, > > > > > > Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile > > > Kundli for > > > PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are > > > designed KP > > > astrologers in mind. The details are available at > > > http://www.astrocamp.com. > > > > > > Regards, > > > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > > > > > > > > > On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > > > wrote: > > > > Dear List Members, > > > > > > > > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > > > in 1988 when I was > > > > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > > > astrology was with KP. I had > > > > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > > > was very impressed with > > > > his astrological skills. There are few who can > > > match the phenomenal > > > > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > > > MANUALLY cast each chart, > > > > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > > > the ephemeris. It used > > > > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > > > finally arrive at the > > > > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > > > same job can be done in > > > > seconds. Amazing. > > > > > > > > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > > > in it but maybe not > > > > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > > > astrology program which > > > > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > > > request members to kindly > > > > advise me as to which would be the best program for > > > this. I will be much > > > > obliged. > > > > > > > > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > > > unable to find a > > > > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > > > now. I hope to be able > > > > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > > > > > > > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > > > > > > > > Vaidun Vidyadhar > > > > 1 / 94 Marius Street > > > > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > > > > Australia > > > > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > > > > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > > > > Email: vvidya@o... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 10, 2004 Report Share Posted November 10, 2004 Dear Rongaunt What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter Geoceentric Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering the same value and then this will be clear. I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I change this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations. Good Luck] rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: Anant,Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your methodof calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculationby Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the accuracyshown in the example. But there is still a difference betweenthe two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the waySolar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I usedgeocentric in my example.Ron GauntOn Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote:>Dear Rongaunt> >The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is to verify wether the >calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them.> >Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC.> >The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which determines the ASC.> >I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC.> >I am happy you are making a deep study of this. > >One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps>Good Luck> >>rongaunt wrote:>>>Anant,>>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa,>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably ->whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'.>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the>Asc position.>>>Ron Gaunt>>>>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote:>>>difference in ASC.>> >>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon.>> >>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same..>> >>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. >> >>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp.>> >>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp>> >>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel>> >>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct>> >>good luck>> >>Try it then Judge.>>>>tw853 wrote:>>>>>>Dear All,>>>>For your attention and review a comparison of different software >>results are given as follows:>>>>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10>>>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m->>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.>>>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish>>>>Basic Data>>>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >>>>Explanations:>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420>>3. KP & Vedic, >>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >>5. KP & Vedic, >>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only)>>>>>>ATTENTION:>>>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >>SL)>>>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.>>>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere.>>>>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10>>>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst>>5 336-20-12 Astraura>>6 336-21-20 Old One>>7 336-20-14 JHL>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish>>>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >>less the same)>>>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55>>>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.>>>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea>>>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >>will be very useful.>>>>Basic Data>>>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>>>Good Luck!>>>>tw>>>>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >>wrote:>>> Dear Members,>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub>>> levels),I have found it most useful and>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for>>> K.P., developed so far...>>> I therefore would strongly recommend>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...>>> With best wishes,I am,>>> Yours sincerely,>>> lyrastro1>>> GOOD LUCK !>>> >>> >>> Vaidun ji,>>> >>> Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile>>> Kundli for>>> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are>>> designed KP>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at>>> http://www.astrocamp.com.>>> >>> Regards,>>> >>> Punit Pandey>>> >>> >>> >>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar>>> wrote:>>> > Dear List Members,>>> > >>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP>>> in 1988 when I was>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic>>> astrology was with KP. I had>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and>>> was very impressed with>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can>>> match the phenomenal>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to>>> MANUALLY cast each chart,>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and>>> the ephemeris. It used>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to>>> finally arrive at the>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the>>> same job can be done in>>> > seconds. Amazing. >>> > >>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP>>> in it but maybe not>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other>>> astrology program which>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I>>> request members to kindly>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for>>> this. I will be much>>> > obliged.>>> > >>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was>>> unable to find a>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until>>> now. I hope to be able>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >>> > >>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards.>>> > >>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340>>> > Australia>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083>>> > Email: vvidya@o...>>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 10, 2004 Report Share Posted November 10, 2004 Anant, Sorry, I possibly got a bit mixed up here. What Solar Fire has is a function to calculate Parallax Moon (which is Geographic ie relative to the position on the surface of the earth) as well as the Geocentric position for the Moon. It doesn't actually change the angles of the chart. As far as I am aware Solar Fire and all other programs show Geocentric positions for the planets. This is why there is a different calculation for parallax Moon. Ron Gaunt On Tue, 09 Nov 2004 22:49:44 -0800, you wrote: >Dear Rongaunt > >What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter Geoceentric >Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering the same value and then this will be clear. > >I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I change this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations. > >Good Luck] > > >rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: > > >Anant, > >Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method >of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation >by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the accuracy >shown in the example. But there is still a difference between >the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way >Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used >geocentric in my example. > >Ron Gaunt > > >On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote: > >>Dear Rongaunt >> >>The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is to verify wether the >>calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. >> >>Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. >> >>The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which determines the ASC. >> >>I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC. >> >>I am happy you are making a deep study of this. >> >>One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps >>Good Luck >> >> >>rongaunt wrote: >> >> >>Anant, >> >>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc >>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the >>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our >>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, >>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc >>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - >>whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the >>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. >>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the >>Asc position. >> >> >>Ron Gaunt >> >> >> >>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: >> >>>difference in ASC. >>> >>>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. >>> >>>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same.. >>> >>>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. >>> >>>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. >>> >>>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp >>> >>>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel >>> >>>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct >>> >>>good luck >>> >>>Try it then Judge. >>> >>>tw853 wrote: >>> >>> >>>Dear All, >>> >>>For your attention and review a comparison of different software >>>results are given as follows: >>> >>> >>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >>>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 >>> >>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- >>>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. >>> >>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software >>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs >>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire >>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli >>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst >>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura >>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One >>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL >>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish >>> >>>Basic Data >>> >>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA >>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 >>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 >>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 >>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* >>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >>>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 >>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 >>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >>> >>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa >>> >>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >>>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >>> >>>Explanations: >>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >>>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. >>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >>>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 >>>3. KP & Vedic, >>>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >>>5. KP & Vedic, >>>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH >>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) >>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) >>> >>> >>>ATTENTION: >>> >>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >>>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >>>SL) >>> >>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >>>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. >>> >>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >>>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. >>> >>> >>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 >>> >>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software >>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs >>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire >>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli >>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst >>>5 336-20-12 Astraura >>>6 336-21-20 Old One >>>7 336-20-14 JHL >>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish >>> >>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >>>less the same) >>> >>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >>>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 >>> >>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. >>> >>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software >>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur >>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank >>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst >>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura >>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One >>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL >>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea >>> >>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >>>will be very useful. >>> >>>Basic Data >>> >>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >>>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >>>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >>>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >>>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >>>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >>> >>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa >>> >>>Good Luck! >>> >>>tw >>> >>> >>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >>>wrote: >>>> Dear Members, >>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. >>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the >>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub >>>> levels),I have found it most useful and >>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a >>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams >>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which >>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for >>>> K.P., developed so far... >>>> I therefore would strongly recommend >>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his >>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... >>>> With best wishes,I am, >>>> Yours sincerely, >>>> lyrastro1 >>>> GOOD LUCK ! >>>> >>>> >>>> Vaidun ji, >>>> >>>> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile >>>> Kundli for >>>> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are >>>> designed KP >>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at >>>> http://www.astrocamp.com. >>>> >>>> Regards, >>>> >>>> Punit Pandey >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar >>>> wrote: >>>> > Dear List Members, >>>> > >>>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP >>>> in 1988 when I was >>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic >>>> astrology was with KP. I had >>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and >>>> was very impressed with >>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can >>>> match the phenomenal >>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to >>>> MANUALLY cast each chart, >>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and >>>> the ephemeris. It used >>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to >>>> finally arrive at the >>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the >>>> same job can be done in >>>> > seconds. Amazing. >>>> > >>>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP >>>> in it but maybe not >>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other >>>> astrology program which >>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I >>>> request members to kindly >>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for >>>> this. I will be much >>>> > obliged. >>>> > >>>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was >>>> unable to find a >>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until >>>> now. I hope to be able >>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >>>> > >>>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. >>>> > >>>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar >>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street >>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 >>>> > Australia >>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) >>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 >>>> > Email: vvidya@o... >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2004 Report Share Posted November 11, 2004 Anant, I decided to do a bit of further investigation, and have found that Solar Fire does in fact have an option for Geocentric calculation. I was of the opinion that the program did this automatically. But obviously I had it set up for geographic, and had never queried it, as nearly all other programs come up with the same or nearly the same Ascendant. Are you suggesting that the correct way is to always calculate angles using Geocentric? If so has any studies been done on this? One thing that has always been at the back of my mind is that as we live on the surface of the earth this should be the datum point. Garth Allen an excellent astrologer of the Western Sidereal system did a lot of work on the parallax Moon and showed it to be more important in casting Lunar Returns. Likewise my main method of prognostication for some years has been the Solar Eclipse, and I have found parallax Moon angles to be extremely accurate compared to geocentric. Another point is that I have frequently seen transit Ascendant exact aspect to a critical planet at the time of an accident - using the geographic calculation. However, I would need to do some micro checking to see how geocentric compares. By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. How does your program compare? Ron Gaunt On Wed, 10 Nov 2004 17:49:53 +1000, I wrote: > > >Anant, > >Sorry, I possibly got a bit mixed up here. What Solar Fire has >is a function to calculate Parallax Moon (which is Geographic ie >relative to the position on the surface of the earth) as well as >the Geocentric position for the Moon. It doesn't actually >change the angles of the chart. As far as I am aware Solar >Fire and all other programs show Geocentric positions for the >planets. This is why there is a different calculation for >parallax Moon. > >Ron Gaunt > > >On Tue, 09 Nov 2004 22:49:44 -0800, you wrote: > >>Dear Rongaunt >> >>What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter Geoceentric >>Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering the same value and then this will be clear. >> >>I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I change this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations. >> >>Good Luck] >> >> >>rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: >> >> >>Anant, >> >>Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method >>of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation >>by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the accuracy >>shown in the example. But there is still a difference between >>the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way >>Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used >>geocentric in my example. >> >>Ron Gaunt >> >> >>On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote: >> >>>Dear Rongaunt >>> >>>The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is to verify wether the >>>calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. >>> >>>Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. >>> >>>The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which determines the ASC. >>> >>>I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC. >>> >>>I am happy you are making a deep study of this. >>> >>>One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps >>>Good Luck >>> >>> >>>rongaunt wrote: >>> >>> >>>Anant, >>> >>>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc >>>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the >>>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our >>>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, >>>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc >>>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - >>>whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the >>>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. >>>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the >>>Asc position. >>> >>> >>>Ron Gaunt >>> >>> >>> >>>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: >>> >>>>difference in ASC. >>>> >>>>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. >>>> >>>>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same.. >>>> >>>>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. >>>> >>>>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. >>>> >>>>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp >>>> >>>>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel >>>> >>>>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct >>>> >>>>good luck >>>> >>>>Try it then Judge. >>>> >>>>tw853 wrote: >>>> >>>> >>>>Dear All, >>>> >>>>For your attention and review a comparison of different software >>>>results are given as follows: >>>> >>>> >>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >>>>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 >>>> >>>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m- >>>>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. >>>> >>>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software >>>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs >>>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire >>>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli >>>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst >>>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura >>>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One >>>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL >>>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish >>>> >>>>Basic Data >>>> >>>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA >>>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 >>>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 >>>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 >>>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* >>>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >>>>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 >>>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 >>>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >>>> >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa >>>> >>>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >>>>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >>>> >>>>Explanations: >>>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >>>>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. >>>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >>>>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 >>>>3. KP & Vedic, >>>>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >>>>5. KP & Vedic, >>>>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH >>>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) >>>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) >>>> >>>> >>>>ATTENTION: >>>> >>>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >>>>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >>>>SL) >>>> >>>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >>>>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. >>>> >>>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >>>>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. >>>> >>>> >>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10 >>>> >>>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software >>>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs >>>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire >>>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli >>>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst >>>>5 336-20-12 Astraura >>>>6 336-21-20 Old One >>>>7 336-20-14 JHL >>>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish >>>> >>>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >>>>less the same) >>>> >>>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >>>>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 >>>> >>>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. >>>> >>>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software >>>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur >>>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank >>>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst >>>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura >>>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One >>>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL >>>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea >>>> >>>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >>>>will be very useful. >>>> >>>>Basic Data >>>> >>>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >>>>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >>>>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >>>>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >>>>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >>>>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >>>> >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa >>>> >>>>Good Luck! >>>> >>>>tw >>>> >>>> >>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >>>>wrote: >>>>> Dear Members, >>>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. >>>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the >>>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub >>>>> levels),I have found it most useful and >>>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a >>>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams >>>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which >>>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for >>>>> K.P., developed so far... >>>>> I therefore would strongly recommend >>>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his >>>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... >>>>> With best wishes,I am, >>>>> Yours sincerely, >>>>> lyrastro1 >>>>> GOOD LUCK ! >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Vaidun ji, >>>>> >>>>> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile >>>>> Kundli for >>>>> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are >>>>> designed KP >>>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at >>>>> http://www.astrocamp.com. >>>>> >>>>> Regards, >>>>> >>>>> Punit Pandey >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar >>>>> wrote: >>>>> > Dear List Members, >>>>> > >>>>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP >>>>> in 1988 when I was >>>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic >>>>> astrology was with KP. I had >>>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and >>>>> was very impressed with >>>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can >>>>> match the phenomenal >>>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to >>>>> MANUALLY cast each chart, >>>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and >>>>> the ephemeris. It used >>>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to >>>>> finally arrive at the >>>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the >>>>> same job can be done in >>>>> > seconds. Amazing. >>>>> > >>>>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP >>>>> in it but maybe not >>>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other >>>>> astrology program which >>>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I >>>>> request members to kindly >>>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for >>>>> this. I will be much >>>>> > obliged. >>>>> > >>>>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was >>>>> unable to find a >>>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until >>>>> now. I hope to be able >>>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >>>>> > >>>>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. >>>>> > >>>>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar >>>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street >>>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 >>>>> > Australia >>>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) >>>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 >>>>> > Email: vvidya@o... >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2004 Report Share Posted November 11, 2004 Dear Ron Gaunt, Asc for KPBC1 253-08-44, New KPA 22-32-10 @ DOB is Geocentric. It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. >By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. Best regards, tw , rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: > > Anant, > > I decided to do a bit of further investigation, and have found > that Solar Fire does in fact have an option for Geocentric > calculation. I was of the opinion that the program did this > automatically. But obviously I had it set up for geographic, > and had never queried it, as nearly all other programs come up > with the same or nearly the same Ascendant. > > Are you suggesting that the correct way is to always calculate > angles using Geocentric? If so has any studies been done on > this? > > One thing that has always been at the back of my mind is that as > we live on the surface of the earth this should be the datum > point. Garth Allen an excellent astrologer of the Western > Sidereal system did a lot of work on the parallax Moon and showed > it to be more important in casting Lunar Returns. Likewise my > main method of prognostication for some years has been the Solar > Eclipse, and I have found parallax Moon angles to be extremely > accurate compared to geocentric. Another point is that I have > frequently seen transit Ascendant exact aspect to a critical > planet at the time of an accident - using the geographic > calculation. However, I would need to do some micro checking > to see how geocentric compares. > > By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. How > does your program compare? > > > Ron Gaunt > > > > On Wed, 10 Nov 2004 17:49:53 +1000, I wrote: > > > > > > >Anant, > > > >Sorry, I possibly got a bit mixed up here. What Solar Fire has > >is a function to calculate Parallax Moon (which is Geographic ie > >relative to the position on the surface of the earth) as well as > >the Geocentric position for the Moon. It doesn't actually > >change the angles of the chart. As far as I am aware Solar > >Fire and all other programs show Geocentric positions for the > >planets. This is why there is a different calculation for > >parallax Moon. > > > >Ron Gaunt > > > > > >On Tue, 09 Nov 2004 22:49:44 -0800, you wrote: > > > >>Dear Rongaunt > >> > >>What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter Geoceentric > >>Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering the same value and then this will be clear. > >> > >>I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I change this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations. > >> > >>Good Luck] > >> > >> > >>rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: > >> > >> > >>Anant, > >> > >>Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method > >>of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation > >>by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the accuracy > >>shown in the example. But there is still a difference between > >>the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way > >>Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used > >>geocentric in my example. > >> > >>Ron Gaunt > >> > >> > >>On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote: > >> > >>>Dear Rongaunt > >>> > >>>The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is to verify wether the > >>>calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. > >>> > >>>Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. > >>> > >>>The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which determines the ASC. > >>> > >>>I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC. > >>> > >>>I am happy you are making a deep study of this. > >>> > >>>One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps > >>>Good Luck > >>> > >>> > >>>rongaunt wrote: > >>> > >>> > >>>Anant, > >>> > >>>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc > >>>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the > >>>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our > >>>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, > >>>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc > >>>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - > >>>whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the > >>>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. > >>>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the > >>>Asc position. > >>> > >>> > >>>Ron Gaunt > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: > >>> > >>>>difference in ASC. > >>>> > >>>>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. > >>>> > >>>>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same.. > >>>> > >>>>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. > >>>> > >>>>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. > >>>> > >>>>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp > >>>> > >>>>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel > >>>> > >>>>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct > >>>> > >>>>good luck > >>>> > >>>>Try it then Judge. > >>>> > >>>>tw853 wrote: > >>>> > >>>> > >>>>Dear All, > >>>> > >>>>For your attention and review a comparison of different software > >>>>results are given as follows: > >>>> > >>>> > >>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, > >>>>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > >>>> > >>>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D- 32m- > >>>>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > >>>> > >>>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software > >>>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs > >>>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire > >>>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli > >>>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst > >>>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura > >>>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One > >>>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL > >>>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > >>>> > >>>>Basic Data > >>>> > >>>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA > >>>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 > >>>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 > >>>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 > >>>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* > >>>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 > >>>>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 > >>>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 > >>>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > >>>> > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >>>> > >>>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, > >>>>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > >>>> > >>>>Explanations: > >>>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due > >>>>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. > >>>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara > >>>>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 > >>>>3. KP & Vedic, > >>>>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa > >>>>5. KP & Vedic, > >>>>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH > >>>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) > >>>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only) > >>>> > >>>> > >>>>ATTENTION: > >>>> > >>>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star > >>>>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & > >>>>SL) > >>>> > >>>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except > >>>>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > >>>> > >>>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same > >>>>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere. > >>>> > >>>> > >>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22- 32-10 > >>>> > >>>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software > >>>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs > >>>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire > >>>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli > >>>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst > >>>>5 336-20-12 Astraura > >>>>6 336-21-20 Old One > >>>>7 336-20-14 JHL > >>>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > >>>> > >>>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or > >>>>less the same) > >>>> > >>>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT- 0.44, > >>>>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > >>>> > >>>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > >>>> > >>>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software > >>>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur > >>>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank > >>>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst > >>>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura > >>>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One > >>>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL > >>>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > >>>> > >>>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire > >>>>will be very useful. > >>>> > >>>>Basic Data > >>>> > >>>>SN Software Sid Time KPA > >>>>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 > >>>>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* > >>>>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 > >>>>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 > >>>>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > >>>> > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >>>> > >>>>Good Luck! > >>>> > >>>>tw > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi > >>>>wrote: > >>>>> Dear Members, > >>>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > >>>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the > >>>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > >>>>> levels),I have found it most useful and > >>>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > >>>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > >>>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > >>>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > >>>>> K.P., developed so far... > >>>>> I therefore would strongly recommend > >>>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > >>>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > >>>>> With best wishes,I am, > >>>>> Yours sincerely, > >>>>> lyrastro1 > >>>>> GOOD LUCK ! > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> Vaidun ji, > >>>>> > >>>>> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile > >>>>> Kundli for > >>>>> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are > >>>>> designed KP > >>>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at > >>>>> http://www.astrocamp.com. > >>>>> > >>>>> Regards, > >>>>> > >>>>> Punit Pandey > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > >>>>> wrote: > >>>>> > Dear List Members, > >>>>> > > >>>>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > >>>>> in 1988 when I was > >>>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > >>>>> astrology was with KP. I had > >>>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > >>>>> was very impressed with > >>>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can > >>>>> match the phenomenal > >>>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > >>>>> MANUALLY cast each chart, > >>>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > >>>>> the ephemeris. It used > >>>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > >>>>> finally arrive at the > >>>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > >>>>> same job can be done in > >>>>> > seconds. Amazing. > >>>>> > > >>>>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > >>>>> in it but maybe not > >>>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > >>>>> astrology program which > >>>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > >>>>> request members to kindly > >>>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for > >>>>> this. I will be much > >>>>> > obliged. > >>>>> > > >>>>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > >>>>> unable to find a > >>>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > >>>>> now. I hope to be able > >>>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > >>>>> > > >>>>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > >>>>> > > >>>>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar > >>>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street > >>>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > >>>>> > Australia > >>>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > >>>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > >>>>> > Email: vvidya@o... > >>>>> > > >>>>> > > >>>>> > > >>>>> > > >>>>> > > >>>>> > > >>>>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2004 Report Share Posted November 11, 2004 Dear Ron Gaunt, Could you check Sid Time 14:34:29 in relation to Asc 13Sag09:21. Asc 13Sag09:21 Moon 6Pis20:34 ST 0* 14:34:29 Ayanamsa at date of birth 7Pi28:12 ie 22:31:48 Typing error in reverse? in Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric Thanks and best regards, tw , " tw853 " <tw853> wrote: > > Dear Ron Gaunt, > > Asc for KPBC1 253-08-44, New KPA 22-32-10 @ DOB is Geocentric. > > It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. > > > >By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows > > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. > > It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. > > Best regards, > > tw > > > , rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: > > > > Anant, > > > > I decided to do a bit of further investigation, and have found > > that Solar Fire does in fact have an option for Geocentric > > calculation. I was of the opinion that the program did this > > automatically. But obviously I had it set up for geographic, > > and had never queried it, as nearly all other programs come up > > with the same or nearly the same Ascendant. > > > > Are you suggesting that the correct way is to always calculate > > angles using Geocentric? If so has any studies been done on > > this? > > > > One thing that has always been at the back of my mind is that as > > we live on the surface of the earth this should be the datum > > point. Garth Allen an excellent astrologer of the Western > > Sidereal system did a lot of work on the parallax Moon and showed > > it to be more important in casting Lunar Returns. Likewise my > > main method of prognostication for some years has been the Solar > > Eclipse, and I have found parallax Moon angles to be extremely > > accurate compared to geocentric. Another point is that I have > > frequently seen transit Ascendant exact aspect to a critical > > planet at the time of an accident - using the geographic > > calculation. However, I would need to do some micro checking > > to see how geocentric compares. > > > > By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows > > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. How > > does your program compare? > > > > > > Ron Gaunt > > > > > > > > On Wed, 10 Nov 2004 17:49:53 +1000, I wrote: > > > > > > > > > > >Anant, > > > > > >Sorry, I possibly got a bit mixed up here. What Solar Fire has > > >is a function to calculate Parallax Moon (which is Geographic ie > > >relative to the position on the surface of the earth) as well as > > >the Geocentric position for the Moon. It doesn't actually > > >change the angles of the chart. As far as I am aware Solar > > >Fire and all other programs show Geocentric positions for the > > >planets. This is why there is a different calculation for > > >parallax Moon. > > > > > >Ron Gaunt > > > > > > > > >On Tue, 09 Nov 2004 22:49:44 -0800, you wrote: > > > > > >>Dear Rongaunt > > >> > > >>What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter > Geoceentric > > >>Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering the > same value and then this will be clear. > > >> > > >>I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but > only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I change > this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations. > > >> > > >>Good Luck] > > >> > > >> > > >>rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: > > >> > > >> > > >>Anant, > > >> > > >>Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method > > >>of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation > > >>by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the accuracy > > >>shown in the example. But there is still a difference between > > >>the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way > > >>Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used > > >>geocentric in my example. > > >> > > >>Ron Gaunt > > >> > > >> > > >>On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote: > > >> > > >>>Dear Rongaunt > > >>> > > >>>The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is > to verify wether the > > >>>calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has > part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position > of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan > Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. > > >>> > > >>>Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc > at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the > calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes > for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to > center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X > 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. > > >>> > > >>>The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which > determines the ASC. > > >>> > > >>>I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC. > > >>> > > >>>I am happy you are making a deep study of this. > > >>> > > >>>One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC > Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat > to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps > > >>>Good Luck > > >>> > > >>> > > >>>rongaunt wrote: > > >>> > > >>> > > >>>Anant, > > >>> > > >>>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc > > >>>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the > > >>>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our > > >>>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, > > >>>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc > > >>>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - > > >>>whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the > > >>>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. > > >>>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the > > >>>Asc position. > > >>> > > >>> > > >>>Ron Gaunt > > >>> > > >>> > > >>> > > >>>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: > > >>> > > >>>>difference in ASC. > > >>>> > > >>>>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise > at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the > Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when > Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. > > >>>> > > >>>>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and > ASC should be very nearly the same.. > > >>>> > > >>>>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. > > >>>> > > >>>>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. > > >>>> > > >>>>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun > should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp > > >>>> > > >>>>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel > > >>>> > > >>>>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct > > >>>> > > >>>>good luck > > >>>> > > >>>>Try it then Judge. > > >>>> > > >>>>tw853 wrote: > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>>Dear All, > > >>>> > > >>>>For your attention and review a comparison of different > software > > >>>>results are given as follows: > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + > 00.00, > > >>>>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > > >>>> > > >>>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D- > 32m- > > >>>>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > > >>>> > > >>>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software > > >>>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs > > >>>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire > > >>>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli > > >>>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst > > >>>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura > > >>>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One > > >>>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL > > >>>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > > >>>> > > >>>>Basic Data > > >>>> > > >>>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA > > >>>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 > > >>>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 > > >>>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 > > >>>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* > > >>>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 > > >>>>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 > > >>>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 > > >>>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > > >>>> > > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa > > >>>> > > >>>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) > +5m.22s, > > >>>>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > > >>>> > > >>>>Explanations: > > >>>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # > 1410 due > > >>>>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. > > >>>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara > > >>>>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 > > >>>>3. KP & Vedic, > > >>>>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri > Ayanamsa > > >>>>5. KP & Vedic, > > >>>>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH > > >>>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) > > >>>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 > only) > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>>ATTENTION: > > >>>> > > >>>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different > Star > > >>>>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie > same SL & > > >>>>SL) > > >>>> > > >>>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except > > >>>>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > > >>>> > > >>>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same > > >>>>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong > somewhere. > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22- > 32-10 > > >>>> > > >>>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software > > >>>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs > > >>>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire > > >>>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli > > >>>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst > > >>>>5 336-20-12 Astraura > > >>>>6 336-21-20 Old One > > >>>>7 336-20-14 JHL > > >>>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > > >>>> > > >>>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more > or > > >>>>less the same) > > >>>> > > >>>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT- > 0.44, > > >>>>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > > >>>> > > >>>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > > >>>> > > >>>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software > > >>>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur > > >>>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank > > >>>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst > > >>>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura > > >>>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One > > >>>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL > > >>>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > > >>>> > > >>>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar > Fire > > >>>>will be very useful. > > >>>> > > >>>>Basic Data > > >>>> > > >>>>SN Software Sid Time KPA > > >>>>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 > > >>>>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* > > >>>>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 > > >>>>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 > > >>>>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > > >>>> > > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa > > >>>> > > >>>>Good Luck! > > >>>> > > >>>>tw > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi > > >>>>wrote: > > >>>>> Dear Members, > > >>>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > > >>>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the > > >>>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > > >>>>> levels),I have found it most useful and > > >>>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > > >>>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > > >>>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > > >>>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > > >>>>> K.P., developed so far... > > >>>>> I therefore would strongly recommend > > >>>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > > >>>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > > >>>>> With best wishes,I am, > > >>>>> Yours sincerely, > > >>>>> lyrastro1 > > >>>>> GOOD LUCK ! > > >>>>> > > >>>>> > > >>>>> Vaidun ji, > > >>>>> > > >>>>> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile > > >>>>> Kundli for > > >>>>> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are > > >>>>> designed KP > > >>>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at > > >>>>> http://www.astrocamp.com. > > >>>>> > > >>>>> Regards, > > >>>>> > > >>>>> Punit Pandey > > >>>>> > > >>>>> > > >>>>> > > >>>>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > > >>>>> wrote: > > >>>>> > Dear List Members, > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > > >>>>> in 1988 when I was > > >>>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > > >>>>> astrology was with KP. I had > > >>>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > > >>>>> was very impressed with > > >>>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can > > >>>>> match the phenomenal > > >>>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > > >>>>> MANUALLY cast each chart, > > >>>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > > >>>>> the ephemeris. It used > > >>>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > > >>>>> finally arrive at the > > >>>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > > >>>>> same job can be done in > > >>>>> > seconds. Amazing. > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > > >>>>> in it but maybe not > > >>>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > > >>>>> astrology program which > > >>>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > > >>>>> request members to kindly > > >>>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for > > >>>>> this. I will be much > > >>>>> > obliged. > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > > >>>>> unable to find a > > >>>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > > >>>>> now. I hope to be able > > >>>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar > > >>>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street > > >>>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > > >>>>> > Australia > > >>>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > > >>>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > > >>>>> > Email: vvidya@o... > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > > > >>>>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2004 Report Share Posted November 11, 2004 On Thu, 11 Nov 2004 04:13:23 +0000, you wrote: tw, Please see ** ............. ** Ron Gaunt > > >Dear Ron Gaunt, > >Could you check Sid Time 14:34:29 in relation to Asc 13Sag09:21. > >Asc 13Sag09:21 >Moon 6Pis20:34 >ST 0* 14:34:29 ** ST at 0*= 14:34:29 = LST 14:39:09 ** > >Ayanamsa at date of birth 7Pi28:12 ie 22:31:48 > >Typing error in reverse? in Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and >13Sag24:01 for geocentric ** No typing error. What is a little confusing is that the " co-ordinate system " is shown as " geocentric " even when one applies the option for " geocentric latitude " . What appears to happen in most programs is that it is taken as given that the angles are " geographic " whilst the planetary data is " geocentric " . (I have assumed this as most other programs seem not to give an option, but obviously display geographic angles with geocentric planetary positions.) > >Thanks and best regards, > >tw > > > , " tw853 " <tw853> wrote: >> >> Dear Ron Gaunt, >> >> Asc for KPBC1 253-08-44, New KPA 22-32-10 @ DOB is Geocentric. >> >> It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for >geocentric. >> >> >> >By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows >> > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. >> >> It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for >geocentric. >> >> Best regards, >> >> tw >> >> >> , rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: >> > >> > Anant, >> > >> > I decided to do a bit of further investigation, and have found >> > that Solar Fire does in fact have an option for Geocentric >> > calculation. I was of the opinion that the program did this >> > automatically. But obviously I had it set up for geographic, >> > and had never queried it, as nearly all other programs come up >> > with the same or nearly the same Ascendant. >> > >> > Are you suggesting that the correct way is to always calculate >> > angles using Geocentric? If so has any studies been done on >> > this? >> > >> > One thing that has always been at the back of my mind is that as >> > we live on the surface of the earth this should be the datum >> > point. Garth Allen an excellent astrologer of the Western >> > Sidereal system did a lot of work on the parallax Moon and showed >> > it to be more important in casting Lunar Returns. Likewise my >> > main method of prognostication for some years has been the Solar >> > Eclipse, and I have found parallax Moon angles to be extremely >> > accurate compared to geocentric. Another point is that I have >> > frequently seen transit Ascendant exact aspect to a critical >> > planet at the time of an accident - using the geographic >> > calculation. However, I would need to do some micro checking >> > to see how geocentric compares. >> > >> > By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows >> > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. How >> > does your program compare? >> > >> > >> > Ron Gaunt >> > >> > >> > >> > On Wed, 10 Nov 2004 17:49:53 +1000, I wrote: >> > >> > > >> > > >> > >Anant, >> > > >> > >Sorry, I possibly got a bit mixed up here. What Solar Fire has >> > >is a function to calculate Parallax Moon (which is Geographic ie >> > >relative to the position on the surface of the earth) as well as >> > >the Geocentric position for the Moon. It doesn't actually >> > >change the angles of the chart. As far as I am aware Solar >> > >Fire and all other programs show Geocentric positions for the >> > >planets. This is why there is a different calculation for >> > >parallax Moon. >> > > >> > >Ron Gaunt >> > > >> > > >> > >On Tue, 09 Nov 2004 22:49:44 -0800, you wrote: >> > > >> > >>Dear Rongaunt >> > >> >> > >>What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter >> Geoceentric >> > >>Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering >the >> same value and then this will be clear. >> > >> >> > >>I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but >> only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I >change >> this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations. >> > >> >> > >>Good Luck] >> > >> >> > >> >> > >>rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: >> > >> >> > >> >> > >>Anant, >> > >> >> > >>Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method >> > >>of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation >> > >>by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the >accuracy >> > >>shown in the example. But there is still a difference between >> > >>the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way >> > >>Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used >> > >>geocentric in my example. >> > >> >> > >>Ron Gaunt >> > >> >> > >> >> > >>On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote: >> > >> >> > >>>Dear Rongaunt >> > >>> >> > >>>The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is >> to verify wether the >> > >>>calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has >> part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position >> of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan >> Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. >> > >>> >> > >>>Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the >Asc >> at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the >> calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 >minutes >> for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to >> center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 >X >> 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. >> > >>> >> > >>>The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which >> determines the ASC. >> > >>> >> > >>>I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in >ASC. >> > >>> >> > >>>I am happy you are making a deep study of this. >> > >>> >> > >>>One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC >> Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic >Lat >> to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps >> > >>>Good Luck >> > >>> >> > >>> >> > >>>rongaunt wrote: >> > >>> >> > >>> >> > >>>Anant, >> > >>> >> > >>>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc >> > >>>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the >> > >>>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our >> > >>>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, >> > >>>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either >Asc >> > >>>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - >> > >>>whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc >the >> > >>>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. >> > >>>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the >> > >>>Asc position. >> > >>> >> > >>> >> > >>>Ron Gaunt >> > >>> >> > >>> >> > >>> >> > >>>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: >> > >>> >> > >>>>difference in ASC. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise >> at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the >> Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when >> Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and >> ASC should be very nearly the same.. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun >> should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp >> > >>>> >> > >>>>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel >> > >>>> >> > >>>>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct >> > >>>> >> > >>>>good luck >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Try it then Judge. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>tw853 wrote: >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Dear All, >> > >>>> >> > >>>>For your attention and review a comparison of different >> software >> > >>>>results are given as follows: >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + >> 00.00, >> > >>>>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 >> > >>>> >> > >>>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA >22D- >> 32m- >> > >>>>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software >> > >>>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs >> > >>>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire >> > >>>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli >> > >>>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst >> > >>>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura >> > >>>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One >> > >>>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL >> > >>>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Basic Data >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA >> > >>>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 >> > >>>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 >> > >>>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 >> > >>>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* >> > >>>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >> > >>>>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 >> > >>>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 >> > >>>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >> > >>>> >> > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) >> +5m.22s, >> > >>>>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Explanations: >> > >>>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # >> 1410 due >> > >>>>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. >> > >>>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & >Parashara >> > >>>>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 >> > >>>>3. KP & Vedic, >> > >>>>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri >> Ayanamsa >> > >>>>5. KP & Vedic, >> > >>>>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH >> > >>>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) >> > >>>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 >> only) >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>>ATTENTION: >> > >>>> >> > >>>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different >> Star >> > >>>>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie >> same SL & >> > >>>>SL) >> > >>>> >> > >>>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, >except >> > >>>>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >> > >>>>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong >> somewhere. >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA >22- >> 32-10 >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software >> > >>>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs >> > >>>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire >> > >>>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli >> > >>>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst >> > >>>>5 336-20-12 Astraura >> > >>>>6 336-21-20 Old One >> > >>>>7 336-20-14 JHL >> > >>>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets >more >> or >> > >>>>less the same) >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT- >> 0.44, >> > >>>>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 >> > >>>> >> > >>>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software >> > >>>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur >> > >>>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank >> > >>>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst >> > >>>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura >> > >>>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One >> > >>>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL >> > >>>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea >> > >>>> >> > >>>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar >> Fire >> > >>>>will be very useful. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Basic Data >> > >>>> >> > >>>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >> > >>>>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >> > >>>>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >> > >>>>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >> > >>>>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >> > >>>>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >> > >>>> >> > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa >> > >>>> >> > >>>>Good Luck! >> > >>>> >> > >>>>tw >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >> > >>>>wrote: >> > >>>>> Dear Members, >> > >>>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. >> > >>>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the >> > >>>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub >> > >>>>> levels),I have found it most useful and >> > >>>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a >> > >>>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams >> > >>>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which >> > >>>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for >> > >>>>> K.P., developed so far... >> > >>>>> I therefore would strongly recommend >> > >>>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his >> > >>>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... >> > >>>>> With best wishes,I am, >> > >>>>> Yours sincerely, >> > >>>>> lyrastro1 >> > >>>>> GOOD LUCK ! >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> Vaidun ji, >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile >> > >>>>> Kundli for >> > >>>>> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are >> > >>>>> designed KP >> > >>>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at >> > >>>>> http://www.astrocamp.com. >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> Regards, >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> Punit Pandey >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar >> > >>>>> wrote: >> > >>>>> > Dear List Members, >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP >> > >>>>> in 1988 when I was >> > >>>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic >> > >>>>> astrology was with KP. I had >> > >>>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and >> > >>>>> was very impressed with >> > >>>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can >> > >>>>> match the phenomenal >> > >>>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to >> > >>>>> MANUALLY cast each chart, >> > >>>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and >> > >>>>> the ephemeris. It used >> > >>>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to >> > >>>>> finally arrive at the >> > >>>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the >> > >>>>> same job can be done in >> > >>>>> > seconds. Amazing. >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP >> > >>>>> in it but maybe not >> > >>>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other >> > >>>>> astrology program which >> > >>>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I >> > >>>>> request members to kindly >> > >>>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for >> > >>>>> this. I will be much >> > >>>>> > obliged. >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was >> > >>>>> unable to find a >> > >>>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until >> > >>>>> now. I hope to be able >> > >>>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar >> > >>>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street >> > >>>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 >> > >>>>> > Australia >> > >>>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) >> > >>>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 >> > >>>>> > Email: vvidya@o... >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2004 Report Share Posted November 11, 2004 Dear Ron You are correct. All software show the GEOCENTRIC longitudes of the Planets. (The other sytem is the HELIO CENTRIC). There is no difference of opinion on that. The difference is in respect of the ASCENDENT and other Cusps. Here two factors are important. The SIDEIAL TIME. and Latitude of the Place. This Latitude is generally the Geograpgic Lat. THIS HAS TO BE CONVERTED into GEOCENTRIC Latitude. To test You try getting the ASC by various SW for a Place on or ver near the equator. You should get results with very negligible variation. As you travel away from the equator, the diff in GEOGRaphic and Geo centric Latitudes increases. IN THE UNIVERSAL TABLE OF HOUSES co-authored by self, the correction to be made to the Geographical Latitude, to get correct figures from the TOH has been indicated. Happy Divali good luckrongaunt <rongaunt wrote: Anant,Sorry, I possibly got a bit mixed up here. What Solar Fire hasis a function to calculate Parallax Moon (which is Geographic ierelative to the position on the surface of the earth) as well asthe Geocentric position for the Moon. It doesn't actuallychange the angles of the chart. As far as I am aware SolarFire and all other programs show Geocentric positions for theplanets. This is why there is a different calculation forparallax Moon.Ron GauntOn Tue, 09 Nov 2004 22:49:44 -0800, you wrote:>Dear Rongaunt> >What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter Geoceentric>Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering the same value and then this will be clear.> >I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I change this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations.> >Good Luck]>>>rongaunt wrote:>>>Anant,>>Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method>of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation>by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the accuracy>shown in the example. But there is still a difference between>the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way>Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used>geocentric in my example.>>Ron Gaunt>>>On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote:>>>Dear Rongaunt>> >>The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is to verify wether the >>calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them.>> >>Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the Asc at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 minutes for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 X 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC.>> >>The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which determines the ASC.>> >>I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in ASC.>> >>I am happy you are making a deep study of this. >> >>One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic Lat to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps>>Good Luck>> >>>>rongaunt wrote:>>>>>>Anant,>>>>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc>>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the>>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our>>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa,>>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either Asc>>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably ->>whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc the>>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'.>>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the>>Asc position.>>>>>>Ron Gaunt>>>>>>>>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote:>>>>>difference in ASC.>>> >>>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when Sun's Centre is on the Horizon.>>> >>>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and ASC should be very nearly the same..>>> >>>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. >>> >>>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp.>>> >>>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp>>> >>>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel>>> >>>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct>>> >>>good luck>>> >>>Try it then Judge.>>>>>>tw853 wrote:>>>>>>>>>Dear All,>>>>>>For your attention and review a comparison of different software >>>results are given as follows:>>>>>>>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + 00.00, >>>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10>>>>>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA 22D-32m->>>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.>>>>>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software>>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs>>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire>>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli>>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst>>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura>>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One>>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL>>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish>>>>>>Basic Data>>>>>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA>>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10>>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48>>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44>>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*>>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >>>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31>>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29>>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >>>>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>>>>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) +5m.22s, >>>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >>>>>>Explanations:>>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # 1410 due >>>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.>>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & Parashara >>>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420>>>3. KP & Vedic, >>>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri Ayanamsa >>>5. KP & Vedic, >>>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH>>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)>>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 only)>>>>>>>>>ATTENTION:>>>>>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different Star >>>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie same SL & >>>SL)>>>>>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, except >>>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.>>>>>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >>>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong somewhere.>>>>>>>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA 22-32-10>>>>>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software>>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs>>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire>>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli>>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst>>>5 336-20-12 Astraura>>>6 336-21-20 Old One>>>7 336-20-14 JHL>>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish>>>>>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets more or >>>less the same)>>>>>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT-0.44, >>>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55>>>>>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.>>>>>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software>>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur>>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank>>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst>>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura>>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One>>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL>>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea>>>>>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar Fire >>>will be very useful.>>>>>>Basic Data>>>>>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >>>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >>>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >>>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >>>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >>>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >>>>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>>>>>>Good Luck!>>>>>>tw>>>>>>>>>--- In , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >>>wrote:>>>> Dear Members,>>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.>>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the>>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub>>>> levels),I have found it most useful and>>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a>>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams>>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which>>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for>>>> K.P., developed so far...>>>> I therefore would strongly recommend>>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his>>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...>>>> With best wishes,I am,>>>> Yours sincerely,>>>> lyrastro1>>>> GOOD LUCK !>>>> >>>> >>>> Vaidun ji,>>>> >>>> Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile>>>> Kundli for>>>> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are>>>> designed KP>>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at>>>> http://www.astrocamp.com.>>>> >>>> Regards,>>>> >>>> Punit Pandey>>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar>>>> wrote:>>>> > Dear List Members,>>>> > >>>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP>>>> in 1988 when I was>>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic>>>> astrology was with KP. I had>>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and>>>> was very impressed with>>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can>>>> match the phenomenal>>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to>>>> MANUALLY cast each chart,>>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and>>>> the ephemeris. It used>>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to>>>> finally arrive at the>>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the>>>> same job can be done in>>>> > seconds. Amazing. >>>> > >>>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP>>>> in it but maybe not>>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other>>>> astrology program which>>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I>>>> request members to kindly>>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for>>>> this. I will be much>>>> > obliged.>>>> > >>>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was>>>> unable to find a>>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until>>>> now. I hope to be able>>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >>>> > >>>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards.>>>> > >>>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar>>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street>>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340>>>> > Australia>>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)>>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083>>>> > Email: vvidya@o...>>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2004 Report Share Posted November 11, 2004 Dear Ron Gaunt, There is a significant difference between around 13Sag08:44 by Astrodienst & other sofwares, and 13Sag24:01 by Solar Fire, ALL on SAME GEOCENTRIC basis(using more or less same New KPA.) It seems to imply that the following provided data are GEOGRAPHIC. >>> " Asc 13Sag09:21 > >Moon 6Pis20:34 > > > > ** ST at 0*= 14:34:29 = LST 14:39:09 ** > > > > >Ayanamsa at date of birth 7Pi28:12 ie 22:31:48 " If the above provided data are GEOCENTRIC sT 0* 14:34:29 can't be matched with Asc 13Sag09:21. Observations are based on only GEOCENTRIC commonly used in chart making softwares. tw > > , rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: > On Thu, 11 Nov 2004 04:13:23 +0000, you wrote: > > tw, > > Please see ** ............. ** > > Ron Gaunt > > > > > > > >Dear Ron Gaunt, > > > >Could you check Sid Time 14:34:29 in relation to Asc 13Sag09:21. > > > >Asc 13Sag09:21 > >Moon 6Pis20:34 > >ST 0* 14:34:29 > > ** ST at 0*= 14:34:29 = LST 14:39:09 ** > > > > >Ayanamsa at date of birth 7Pi28:12 ie 22:31:48 > > > >Typing error in reverse? in Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and > >13Sag24:01 for geocentric > > ** No typing error. What is a little confusing is that the > " co-ordinate system " is shown as " geocentric " even when one > applies the option for " geocentric latitude " . What appears > to happen in most programs is that it is taken as given that the > angles are " geographic " whilst the planetary data is > " geocentric " . (I have assumed this as most other programs > seem not to give an option, but obviously display geographic > angles with geocentric planetary positions.) > > > > > > >Thanks and best regards, > > > >tw > > > > > > , " tw853 " <tw853> wrote: > >> > >> Dear Ron Gaunt, > >> > >> Asc for KPBC1 253-08-44, New KPA 22-32-10 @ DOB is Geocentric. > >> > >> It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for > >geocentric. > >> > >> > >> >By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows > >> > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. > >> > >> It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for > >geocentric. > >> > >> Best regards, > >> > >> tw > >> > >> > >> , rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: > >> > > >> > Anant, > >> > > >> > I decided to do a bit of further investigation, and have found > >> > that Solar Fire does in fact have an option for Geocentric > >> > calculation. I was of the opinion that the program did this > >> > automatically. But obviously I had it set up for geographic, > >> > and had never queried it, as nearly all other programs come up > >> > with the same or nearly the same Ascendant. > >> > > >> > Are you suggesting that the correct way is to always calculate > >> > angles using Geocentric? If so has any studies been done on > >> > this? > >> > > >> > One thing that has always been at the back of my mind is that as > >> > we live on the surface of the earth this should be the datum > >> > point. Garth Allen an excellent astrologer of the Western > >> > Sidereal system did a lot of work on the parallax Moon and showed > >> > it to be more important in casting Lunar Returns. Likewise my > >> > main method of prognostication for some years has been the Solar > >> > Eclipse, and I have found parallax Moon angles to be extremely > >> > accurate compared to geocentric. Another point is that I have > >> > frequently seen transit Ascendant exact aspect to a critical > >> > planet at the time of an accident - using the geographic > >> > calculation. However, I would need to do some micro checking > >> > to see how geocentric compares. > >> > > >> > By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows > >> > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. How > >> > does your program compare? > >> > > >> > > >> > Ron Gaunt > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > On Wed, 10 Nov 2004 17:49:53 +1000, I wrote: > >> > > >> > > > >> > > > >> > >Anant, > >> > > > >> > >Sorry, I possibly got a bit mixed up here. What Solar Fire has > >> > >is a function to calculate Parallax Moon (which is Geographic ie > >> > >relative to the position on the surface of the earth) as well as > >> > >the Geocentric position for the Moon. It doesn't actually > >> > >change the angles of the chart. As far as I am aware Solar > >> > >Fire and all other programs show Geocentric positions for the > >> > >planets. This is why there is a different calculation for > >> > >parallax Moon. > >> > > > >> > >Ron Gaunt > >> > > > >> > > > >> > >On Tue, 09 Nov 2004 22:49:44 -0800, you wrote: > >> > > > >> > >>Dear Rongaunt > >> > >> > >> > >>What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter > >> Geoceentric > >> > >>Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering > >the > >> same value and then this will be clear. > >> > >> > >> > >>I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but > >> only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I > >change > >> this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations. > >> > >> > >> > >>Good Luck] > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >>rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote: > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >>Anant, > >> > >> > >> > >>Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method > >> > >>of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation > >> > >>by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the > >accuracy > >> > >>shown in the example. But there is still a difference between > >> > >>the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way > >> > >>Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used > >> > >>geocentric in my example. > >> > >> > >> > >>Ron Gaunt > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >>On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote: > >> > >> > >> > >>>Dear Rongaunt > >> > >>> > >> > >>>The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is > >> to verify wether the > >> > >>>calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has > >> part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position > >> of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan > >> Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them. > >> > >>> > >> > >>>Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the > >Asc > >> at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the > >> calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 > >minutes > >> for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to > >> center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 > >X > >> 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC. > >> > >>> > >> > >>>The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which > >> determines the ASC. > >> > >>> > >> > >>>I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in > >ASC. > >> > >>> > >> > >>>I am happy you are making a deep study of this. > >> > >>> > >> > >>>One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC > >> Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic > >Lat > >> to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps > >> > >>>Good Luck > >> > >>> > >> > >>> > >> > >>>rongaunt wrote: > >> > >>> > >> > >>> > >> > >>>Anant, > >> > >>> > >> > >>>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc > >> > >>>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the > >> > >>>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our > >> > >>>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa, > >> > >>>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either > >Asc > >> > >>>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably - > >> > >>>whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc > >the > >> > >>>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'. > >> > >>>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the > >> > >>>Asc position. > >> > >>> > >> > >>> > >> > >>>Ron Gaunt > >> > >>> > >> > >>> > >> > >>> > >> > >>>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote: > >> > >>> > >> > >>>>difference in ASC. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise > >> at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the > >> Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when > >> Sun's Centre is on the Horizon. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and > >> ASC should be very nearly the same.. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun > >> should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>good luck > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Try it then Judge. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>tw853 wrote: > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Dear All, > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>For your attention and review a comparison of different > >> software > >> > >>>>results are given as follows: > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + > >> 00.00, > >> > >>>>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10 > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA > >22D- > >> 32m- > >> > >>>>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software > >> > >>>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs > >> > >>>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire > >> > >>>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli > >> > >>>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst > >> > >>>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura > >> > >>>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One > >> > >>>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL > >> > >>>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Basic Data > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA > >> > >>>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10 > >> > >>>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48 > >> > >>>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44 > >> > >>>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32* > >> > >>>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 > >> > >>>>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31 > >> > >>>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29 > >> > >>>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) > >> +5m.22s, > >> > >>>>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Explanations: > >> > >>>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # > >> 1410 due > >> > >>>>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04. > >> > >>>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & > >Parashara > >> > >>>>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420 > >> > >>>>3. KP & Vedic, > >> > >>>>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri > >> Ayanamsa > >> > >>>>5. KP & Vedic, > >> > >>>>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH > >> > >>>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group) > >> > >>>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700- 2300 > >> only) > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>ATTENTION: > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different > >> Star > >> > >>>>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie > >> same SL & > >> > >>>>SL) > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, > >except > >> > >>>>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same > >> > >>>>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong > >> somewhere. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA > >22- > >> 32-10 > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software > >> > >>>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs > >> > >>>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire > >> > >>>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli > >> > >>>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst > >> > >>>>5 336-20-12 Astraura > >> > >>>>6 336-21-20 Old One > >> > >>>>7 336-20-14 JHL > >> > >>>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets > >more > >> or > >> > >>>>less the same) > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT- > >> 0.44, > >> > >>>>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55 > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software > >> > >>>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur > >> > >>>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank > >> > >>>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst > >> > >>>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura > >> > >>>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One > >> > >>>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL > >> > >>>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar > >> Fire > >> > >>>>will be very useful. > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Basic Data > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>SN Software Sid Time KPA > >> > >>>>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 > >> > >>>>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* > >> > >>>>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 > >> > >>>>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 > >> > >>>>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>Good Luck! > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>>tw > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>> > >> > >>>> , Yogesh Rao Lajmi > >> > >>>>wrote: > >> > >>>>> Dear Members, > >> > >>>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P. > >> > >>>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the > >> > >>>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub > >> > >>>>> levels),I have found it most useful and > >> > >>>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a > >> > >>>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams > >> > >>>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which > >> > >>>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for > >> > >>>>> K.P., developed so far... > >> > >>>>> I therefore would strongly recommend > >> > >>>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his > >> > >>>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already... > >> > >>>>> With best wishes,I am, > >> > >>>>> Yours sincerely, > >> > >>>>> lyrastro1 > >> > >>>>> GOOD LUCK ! > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> Vaidun ji, > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> Have a look at " Varahamihira for Windows " and " Mobile > >> > >>>>> Kundli for > >> > >>>>> PalmOS " by the company running this group. Both are > >> > >>>>> designed KP > >> > >>>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at > >> > >>>>> http://www.astrocamp.com. > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> Regards, > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> Punit Pandey > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar > >> > >>>>> wrote: > >> > >>>>> > Dear List Members, > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP > >> > >>>>> in 1988 when I was > >> > >>>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic > >> > >>>>> astrology was with KP. I had > >> > >>>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and > >> > >>>>> was very impressed with > >> > >>>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can > >> > >>>>> match the phenomenal > >> > >>>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to > >> > >>>>> MANUALLY cast each chart, > >> > >>>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and > >> > >>>>> the ephemeris. It used > >> > >>>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to > >> > >>>>> finally arrive at the > >> > >>>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the > >> > >>>>> same job can be done in > >> > >>>>> > seconds. Amazing. > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP > >> > >>>>> in it but maybe not > >> > >>>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other > >> > >>>>> astrology program which > >> > >>>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I > >> > >>>>> request members to kindly > >> > >>>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for > >> > >>>>> this. I will be much > >> > >>>>> > obliged. > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was > >> > >>>>> unable to find a > >> > >>>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until > >> > >>>>> now. I hope to be able > >> > >>>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards. > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar > >> > >>>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street > >> > >>>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340 > >> > >>>>> > Australia > >> > >>>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home) > >> > >>>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083 > >> > >>>>> > Email: vvidya@o... > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > > >> > >>>>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2004 Report Share Posted November 11, 2004 Dear Ron, I have been reading with interest the discussion on Ayanamsa...but I keep wondering why a simple method of verifying the Ayanamsa used is not experimented with by you Ron... Use RPs for timing events like "at what time,exactly, will expected friend arrive ?" etc....which I am sure will help you get the time to the nearest second and verify it by actual observation...! You could carry out such experiments many times,as you have your computer,and try out different ayanamsas...and compare the results...such experiments can be done with arrival of trains,planes,interstate busses etc... I am not a mathematical genius like uall,hence I am suggesting a simple calculation... With best wishes, Yours sincerely, L.Y.Rao. GOOD LUCK !rongaunt <rongaunt wrote: On Thu, 11 Nov 2004 04:13:23 +0000, you wrote:tw,Please see ** ............. **Ron Gaunt>>>Dear Ron Gaunt,>>Could you check Sid Time 14:34:29 in relation to Asc 13Sag09:21.>>Asc 13Sag09:21>Moon 6Pis20:34>ST 0* 14:34:29** ST at 0*= 14:34:29 = LST 14:39:09 **>>Ayanamsa at date of birth 7Pi28:12 ie 22:31:48>>Typing error in reverse? in Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and >13Sag24:01 for geocentric** No typing error. What is a little confusing is that the"co-ordinate system" is shown as "geocentric" even when oneapplies the option for "geocentric latitude". What appearsto happen in most programs is that it is taken as given that theangles are "geographic" whilst the planetary data is"geocentric". (I have assumed this as most other programsseem not to give an option, but obviously display geographicangles with geocentric planetary positions.) >>Thanks and best regards,>>tw >>> , "tw853" <tw853> wrote:>> >> Dear Ron Gaunt,>> >> Asc for KPBC1 253-08-44, New KPA 22-32-10 @ DOB is Geocentric.>> >> It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for >geocentric.>> >> >> >By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows>> > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. >> >> It's very strange that Solar Fire is giving 13Sag24:01 for >geocentric.>> >> Best regards,>> >> tw>> >> >> , rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote:>> > >> > Anant,>> > >> > I decided to do a bit of further investigation, and have found>> > that Solar Fire does in fact have an option for Geocentric>> > calculation. I was of the opinion that the program did this>> > automatically. But obviously I had it set up for geographic,>> > and had never queried it, as nearly all other programs come up>> > with the same or nearly the same Ascendant. >> > >> > Are you suggesting that the correct way is to always calculate>> > angles using Geocentric? If so has any studies been done on>> > this?>> > >> > One thing that has always been at the back of my mind is that as>> > we live on the surface of the earth this should be the datum>> > point. Garth Allen an excellent astrologer of the Western>> > Sidereal system did a lot of work on the parallax Moon and showed>> > it to be more important in casting Lunar Returns. Likewise my>> > main method of prognostication for some years has been the Solar>> > Eclipse, and I have found parallax Moon angles to be extremely>> > accurate compared to geocentric. Another point is that I have>> > frequently seen transit Ascendant exact aspect to a critical>> > planet at the time of an accident - using the geographic>> > calculation. However, I would need to do some micro checking>> > to see how geocentric compares.>> > >> > By the way using ayanamsa 22:22:30 circa 1900, Solar Fire shows>> > Asc 13Sag08:54 for geographic and 13Sag24:01 for geocentric. How>> > does your program compare?>> > >> > >> > Ron Gaunt>> > >> > >> > >> > On Wed, 10 Nov 2004 17:49:53 +1000, I wrote:>> > >> > >>> > >>> > >Anant,>> > >>> > >Sorry, I possibly got a bit mixed up here. What Solar Fire has>> > >is a function to calculate Parallax Moon (which is Geographic ie>> > >relative to the position on the surface of the earth) as well as>> > >the Geocentric position for the Moon. It doesn't actually>> > >change the angles of the chart. As far as I am aware Solar>> > >Fire and all other programs show Geocentric positions for the>> > >planets. This is why there is a different calculation for>> > >parallax Moon.>> > >>> > >Ron Gaunt>> > >>> > >>> > >On Tue, 09 Nov 2004 22:49:44 -0800, you wrote:>> > >>> > >>Dear Rongaunt>> > >> >> > >>What exactly does the option mean ? Does it allow you to enter >> Geoceentric>> > >>Lat. instead of Geographic. ? Try both alternatives entering >the >> same value and then this will be clear.>> > >> >> > >>I have presumed that users do not know the Geocentric Lat, but >> only the Geograpgic, and enter this figure. In the programme I >change >> this geographic Lat to Geocenrtc Lat for further calculations.>> > >> >> > >>Good Luck]>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>rongaunt <rongaunt@b...> wrote:>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>Anant,>> > >>>> > >>Thanks for the information. From this I gather that your method>> > >>of calculating the Asc position is correct. But, the calculation>> > >>by Solar Fire is obviously also correct - because of the >accuracy>> > >>shown in the example. But there is still a difference between>> > >>the two calculated ascendants. I wonder why? By the way>> > >>Solar Fire offers options of geographic and geocentric. I used>> > >>geocentric in my example.>> > >>>> > >>Ron Gaunt>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>On Mon, 08 Nov 2004 21:24:32 -0800, you wrote:>> > >>>> > >>>Dear Rongaunt>> > >>> >> > >>>The checking of the ASC with Sunrise, Center of Sun,s Disk, is >> to verify wether the >> > >>>calculations used for ASC are correct or not. The Ayanmsa has >> part in this comparison, as in any calculation, the SAYANA position >> of SUN, and The Sayana ASC are calculated, and then the Nirayan >> Positions are found by deducting the Ayanamsa from them.>> > >>> >> > >>>Your statement that the Sun's Longitude at Sunrise, and the >Asc >> at that time, do not differ by more than 2 min, means that the >> calculations of Asc are acceptable. The Asc moves roughly 15 >minutes >> for every minute of time. The Time of Sun Rise, from upper limb to >> center varies from 3 to 4 minutes. 30 seconds of diff will mean 30 >X >> 15 = 7.5 minutes in the ASC.>> > >>> >> > >>>The other equally sensitive point is the Siderial Time, which >> determines the ASC.>> > >>> >> > >>>I do not find any difference to give the 17 minutes diff in >ASC.>> > >>> >> > >>>I am happy you are making a deep study of this. >> > >>> >> > >>>One VERY IMPORTANT THING IS We have to use the GEO-CENTRIC >> Latitude, in our calculations. My prog. converts the Geograprphic >Lat >> to Geogentric, before getting the ASC and other House Cusps>> > >>>Good Luck>> > >>> >> > >>>>> > >>>rongaunt wrote:>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>Anant,>> > >>>>> > >>>I have experimented with Solar Fire which gives sunrise, etc>> > >>>positions. S.F. obviously shows the mid point of the Sun as the>> > >>>Sun is within 2' of the Ascendant at sunrise on the day of our>> > >>>Blind Chart example. However, calculating with your ayanamsa,>> > >>>and the one I was working with shows no difference in either >Asc>> > >>>or Sun positions. In fact changing the ayanamsa considerably ->> > >>>whilst it changes the degrees and minutes of the Sun and Asc >the>> > >>>differential between and Asc and Sun remains the same ie 2'.>> > >>>I cannot see how this can be used to prove the validity of the>> > >>>Asc position.>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>Ron Gaunt>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>On Sun, 07 Nov 2004 23:38:24 -0800, you wrote:>> > >>>>> > >>>>difference in ASC.>> > >>>> >> > >>>>There is a simple test. Find out the correct time of SUN Rise >> at a place. The usual Time is given for the Upper Limb to be at the >> Horizon. Add 3mt, 30 sec. to this time. This gives the Time when >> Sun's Centre is on the Horizon.>> > >>>> >> > >>>>Now cast the Horoscope for this time. The Sun's Longitude and >> ASC should be very nearly the same..>> > >>>> >> > >>>>Similar test for MID Day .Half the Sum of Sunrise+sunset. >> > >>>> >> > >>>>For this time, Suns, Long must be same as 10th cusp.>> > >>>> >> > >>>>For sunset : Deduct 3 m. 30 sec from stand sunset. The Sun >> should be almost exactly on the 7th Cusp>> > >>>> >> > >>>>I have based by prog on basis of Formuale given By Raphel>> > >>>> >> > >>>>I am open to correction, If my method is not correct>> > >>>> >> > >>>>good luck>> > >>>> >> > >>>>Try it then Judge.>> > >>>>>> > >>>>tw853 wrote:>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Dear All,>> > >>>>>> > >>>>For your attention and review a comparison of different >> software >> > >>>>results are given as follows:>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Example 1: KPBC1, Male, 3 November 1911, Fr, 11:48 AM UT + >> 00.00, >> > >>>>Ipswich, England, 52N04, 001E10>> > >>>>>> > >>>>1(a). Comparison of Asc position by using the same New KPA >22D->> 32m->> > >>>>10s as given by Raichur Software posted in KP Group.>> > >>>>>> > >>>>SN D-M-S RL-SL-S Software>> > >>>>1. 253-25-31 Ju-Ve-Ve Raichurs>> > >>>>2. 253-08-59 Ju-Ke-Ke Solar Fire>> > >>>>3. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astro-Kundli>> > >>>>4. 253-08-44 Ju-Ke-Ke Astrodienst>> > >>>>5. 253-08-48 Ju-Ke-Ke Astraura>> > >>>>6. 253-08-11 Ju-Ke-Ke Old One>> > >>>>7. 253-08-36 Ju-Ke-Ke JHL>> > >>>>8. 253-07-50 Ju-Ke-Ke Junior Jyotish>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Basic Data>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Sr Software Sid Time Asc D-M-S KPA>> > >>>>1.Raichur 14-39-10 253-25-31 22-32-10>> > >>>>2.Solar Fire 14-34-29? 153-09-21 22-31-48>> > >>>>3.Astro-Kundli 253-09-10 22-31-44>> > >>>>4.Astrodienst 14-39-09 275-40-45 22-37-32*>> > >>>>5.Astraura 14-39-09 253-09-35.48 22-31-23 >> > >>>>6.Old One 14-39-09 253-09-21 22-31>> > >>>>7.JHL 14-39-09 253-09-26.04 22-31-19.29>> > >>>>8.Jr Jyotish 253-03 22-37* >> > >>>>>> > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Differences from New KPA: 1) 0 (base), 2) –22s, 3) –26s, 4) >> +5m.22s, >> > >>>>5) –47s, 6) –1.10, 7) –50.31s, 8) +4m.50s >> > >>>>>> > >>>>Explanations:>> > >>>>1. Pl note 253-22-49 (Ju-Ve-Ve) in posting of KP Group Msg # >> 1410 due >> > >>>>to Lat 52N06 other than 52N04.>> > >>>>2. Western Tropical, very close to Goravani Jyotish & >Parashara >> > >>>>Light, as per kind favor of Ron Ganut in KP Group Msg # 1420>> > >>>>3. KP & Vedic, >> > >>>>4. Western tropical, also available sideral with Lahiri >> Ayanamsa >> > >>>>5. KP & Vedic, >> > >>>>6. based on KPA from KSK's tables & UTOH>> > >>>>7. Jagannatha Hora Lite (Pandit Sanjay Rath's Study Group)>> > >>>>8. Prof V. K. Choudhry'a SA Study Group (Vedic for 1700-2300 >> only)>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>ATTENTION:>> > >>>>>> > >>>>1. SN 1 Software gives around 17d higher Asc with different >> Star >> > >>>>Lord & Sub Lord. (For other cusps more or less the same, ie >> same SL & >> > >>>>SL)>> > >>>>>> > >>>>2. For other softwares no difference in deg-min, SL & S, >except >> > >>>>around 30sec lower in SN 6 Software.>> > >>>>>> > >>>>3. House system is not the problem, because Asc is the same >> > >>>>whether Placidus, Koch or Equal is used. Something is wrong >> somewhere.>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>1 (b). Comparison of Moon position by using the same New KPA >22->> 32-10>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Sr Deg-Min-Sec Software>> > >>>>1. 336-20-09 Raichurs>> > >>>>2. 336-20-34 Solar Fire>> > >>>>3. 336-20-21 Astro-Kundli>> > >>>>4. 336-20-12 Astrodienst>> > >>>>5 336-20-12 Astraura>> > >>>>6 336-21-20 Old One>> > >>>>7 336-20-14 JHL>> > >>>>8 336-19-50 Junior Jyotish>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Not much difference except in SN 6 & 8. (For other planets >more >> or >> > >>>>less the same)>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Example 2. Leonardo da Vinci, 23 April 1452, 9-40 PM LMT, UT->> 0.44, >> > >>>>Vinci, Italy, 43N47, 10E55>> > >>>>>> > >>>>For comparison the same KPA 16d-07m-15s is used.>> > >>>>>> > >>>>SN Asc D-M-S Moon D-M-S Software>> > >>>>1. 227-30-40 078-01-54 Raichur>> > >>>>2. 230-27-45 316-53-45 AstroDatabank>> > >>>>3. 230-31-23 316-53-51 Astrodienst>> > >>>>4. 230-30-53 078-04-18 Astraura>> > >>>>5. 238-26-01 092-20-55 Old One>> > >>>>6. 230-27-26 316-54-03 JHL>> > >>>>7. 230-32-27 316-54-10 Khaldea>> > >>>>>> > >>>>ATTENTION: SN 1, 4 & 5 sofware have gone out of line. Solar >> Fire >> > >>>>will be very useful.>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Basic Data>> > >>>>>> > >>>>SN Software Sid Time KPA >> > >>>>1. Raichur 11-31-41 16-07-46 >> > >>>>2. Astrodienst 11-47-47 16-12-57* >> > >>>>3. Astraura 11-47-44 16-07-19 >> > >>>>4. Old One 12-27-04 16-09-00 >> > >>>>5. JHL 11-47-27 16-07-14.65 >> > >>>>>> > >>>>* Lahiri Ayanamsa>> > >>>>>> > >>>>Good Luck!>> > >>>>>> > >>>>tw>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>--- In , Yogesh Rao Lajmi >> > >>>>wrote:>> > >>>>> Dear Members,>> > >>>>> I have with me Mr.K.Subramaniam's K.P.>> > >>>>> Software,but after I bought and began using the>> > >>>>> Software developed by Shri A.R.Raichur(upto subsub>> > >>>>> levels),I have found it most useful and>> > >>>>> simple-to-use,and Shri Raichur also provides a>> > >>>>> specially developed on K.P. Dasavidha Poruthams>> > >>>>> principles,a software for horoscope matching...which>> > >>>>> in my humble opinion is prhaps the best Software for>> > >>>>> K.P., developed so far...>> > >>>>> I therefore would strongly recommend>> > >>>>> Shri Raichur's Software...for K.P. followers...his>> > >>>>> e-mai ID has appeared in these columns already...>> > >>>>> With best wishes,I am,>> > >>>>> Yours sincerely,>> > >>>>> lyrastro1>> > >>>>> GOOD LUCK !>> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> Vaidun ji,>> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> Have a look at "Varahamihira for Windows" and "Mobile>> > >>>>> Kundli for>> > >>>>> PalmOS" by the company running this group. Both are>> > >>>>> designed KP>> > >>>>> astrologers in mind. The details are available at>> > >>>>> http://www.astrocamp.com.>> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> Regards,>> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> Punit Pandey>> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> >> > >>>>> On Thu, 28 Oct 2004 21:40:15 +1000, Vaidun Vidyadhar>> > >>>>> wrote:>> > >>>>> > Dear List Members,>> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > I am new to this list though I was introduced to KP>> > >>>>> in 1988 when I was>> > >>>>> > living in Madras. My introduction to vedic>> > >>>>> astrology was with KP. I had>> > >>>>> > bought all the books of Shri Krishnamurthi then and>> > >>>>> was very impressed with>> > >>>>> > his astrological skills. There are few who can>> > >>>>> match the phenomenal>> > >>>>> > accuracy of his predictions. Those days, I had to>> > >>>>> MANUALLY cast each chart,>> > >>>>> > be it natal or horary, with the help of tables and>> > >>>>> the ephemeris. It used>> > >>>>> > to take 2 hours of manual calculations to be able to>> > >>>>> finally arrive at the>> > >>>>> > table of significators. Now, with computers, the>> > >>>>> same job can be done in>> > >>>>> > seconds. Amazing. >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > I have Goravani Jyotish which has some element of KP>> > >>>>> in it but maybe not>> > >>>>> > enough. I am thinking of buying some other>> > >>>>> astrology program which>> > >>>>> > incorporates the elements of KP more fully. Can I>> > >>>>> request members to kindly>> > >>>>> > advise me as to which would be the best program for>> > >>>>> this. I will be much>> > >>>>> > obliged.>> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > I have always had an enduring interest in KP but was>> > >>>>> unable to find a>> > >>>>> > website or list which was fully devoted to KP, until>> > >>>>> now. I hope to be able>> > >>>>> > to learn a lot from you all and hone my KP skills. >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > Thanks for your time. With best regards.>> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > Vaidun Vidyadhar>> > >>>>> > 1 / 94 Marius Street>> > >>>>> > Tamworth, NSW 2340>> > >>>>> > Australia>> > >>>>> > Tel: 61-2-67 668428 (home)>> > >>>>> > Mobile: 0414 870 083>> > >>>>> > Email: vvidya@o...>> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > >> > >>>>> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.