Guest guest Posted March 29, 2005 Report Share Posted March 29, 2005 Dear Inder You might be correct. In the example given by me (KP no. 149), the 11th sub-lord (Venus) is the star of Retro. Planet (Jup.) & Jup. is Retro. in the Natal chart of querriest too. All members, Pls. give your opinion on what Inder is Saying. Inder wrote: Dear friends, The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative. Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer may come as positive. I am bit confused here. Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule. Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp posion as per kp rules. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 30, 2005 Report Share Posted March 30, 2005 Dear friends, The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative. Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer may come as positive. I am bit confused here. Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule. Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp posion as per kp rules. Pl comment. Inder Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 30, 2005 Report Share Posted March 30, 2005 Dear Inder, 1. In my personal opinion, there may three options. a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering " NO " to Dear Abhay, " Retrograde-Horary chart " , KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146- 147; b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable; c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the querist. 2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB 2005, p 52. 3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87. 4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, " It is important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result " . According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number. Best regards, tw , " Inder " <indervohra2001> wrote: > > Dear friends, > The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative. > > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer > may come as positive. > > I am bit confused here. > > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule. > Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > posion as per kp rules. > > Pl comment. > > Inder Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 31, 2005 Report Share Posted March 31, 2005 Dear Inder,tw853 et al, Fortunately for us,Guruji KSK has provided us all,with the most unique method of Ruling Planets...we can always take recourse to them,whenever in doubt...! ? Best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Inder,1. In my personal opinion, there may three options.a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering "NO" to Dear Abhay, "Retrograde-Horary chart", KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146-147;b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable;c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the querist.2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB 2005, p 52.3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87.4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, "It is important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result". According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number.Best regards,tw , "Inder" <indervohra2001> wrote:> > Dear friends,> The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative.> > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer > may come as positive.> > I am bit confused here.> > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule.> Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > posion as per kp rules.> > Pl comment.> > Inder India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 31, 2005 Report Share Posted March 31, 2005 NoBody Knows the Answer to the following query...?? ---------------- Dear Inder You might be correct. In the example given by me (KP no. 149), the 11th sub-lord (Venus) is the star of Retro. Planet (Jup.) & Jup. is Retro. in the Natal chart of querriest too. All members, Pls. give your opinion on what Inder is Saying. Inder wrote: Dear friends, The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative. Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer may come as positive. I am bit confused here. Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule. Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp posion as per kp rules. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 31, 2005 Report Share Posted March 31, 2005 Dear Rao, In the RPs also we have to discard retro planets or planets in retro star or sub lord. Dear Tw853, You have qouted some books etc. It is difficult to get hold of these. Can you very briefly say what these authors have said in case of 11th sub lord being retro or in star of retro planet. Inder , Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> wrote: > Dear Inder,tw853 et al, > Fortunately for us,Guruji KSK has provided us all,with the most unique method of Ruling Planets...we can always take recourse to them,whenever in doubt...! ? > Best wishes, > lyrastro1 > GOOD LUCK ! > > tw853 <tw853> wrote: > > Dear Inder, > > 1. In my personal opinion, there may three options. > > a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering " NO " to Dear > Abhay, " Retrograde-Horary chart " , KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146- > 147; > > b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable; > > c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the > querist. > > 2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP > Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 > & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB > 2005, p 52. > > 3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by > Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87. > > 4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, " It is > important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary > figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious > concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other > wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result " . > According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the > time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number. > > Best regards, > > > tw > > > > , " Inder " <indervohra2001> > wrote: > > > > Dear friends, > > The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in > the > > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative. > > > > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if > that > > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, > answer > > may come as positive. > > > > I am bit confused here. > > > > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule. > > Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > > posion as per kp rules. > > > > Pl comment. > > > > Inder > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 31, 2005 Report Share Posted March 31, 2005 Dear Mr.inderji, How can we take in to consideration that 11th CSL in the planet of retrogression as simply negative and predict if the matter is well going to happen shortly.Just like a person well qualified and well skilled,if he asks a question on job...if 11th CSL SAT IN STAR OF JUPITER RETRO DENOTES he will not at all get a job in future or for 2 years.How can it be correct?. Ofcourse,tough time can be understood but we cannot nullify the happening of getting a job in a near future.Say two weeks or maximum one month may be he can try....why not he will get a job soon if he tries hard??. Kindly reply to this learned members. Thanks Balaji Gopalakrishnan Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Inder,tw853 et al, Fortunately for us,Guruji KSK has provided us all,with the most unique method of Ruling Planets...we can always take recourse to them,whenever in doubt...! ? Best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Inder,1. In my personal opinion, there may three options.a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering "NO" to Dear Abhay, "Retrograde-Horary chart", KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146-147;b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable;c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the querist.2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB 2005, p 52.3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87.4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, "It is important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result". According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number.Best regards,tw , "Inder" <indervohra2001> wrote:> > Dear friends,> The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative.> > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer > may come as positive.> > I am bit confused here.> > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule.> Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > posion as per kp rules.> > Pl comment.> > Inder India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 31, 2005 Report Share Posted March 31, 2005 Dear Balaji, I recommend you try arriving at the significators,using the now-famous sub-sub theory...made very practicable by the late Pt.K.R.Kar,and Prof.Balachandran... Last years annual alone contains an excellent article by Prof.Balachandran...it may help you a lot... With best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !"Balaji G.krishnan" <balaji_g_krishnan wrote: Dear Mr.inderji, How can we take in to consideration that 11th CSL in the planet of retrogression as simply negative and predict if the matter is well going to happen shortly.Just like a person well qualified and well skilled,if he asks a question on job...if 11th CSL SAT IN STAR OF JUPITER RETRO DENOTES he will not at all get a job in future or for 2 years.How can it be correct?. Ofcourse,tough time can be understood but we cannot nullify the happening of getting a job in a near future.Say two weeks or maximum one month may be he can try....why not he will get a job soon if he tries hard??. Kindly reply to this learned members. Thanks Balaji Gopalakrishnan Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Inder,tw853 et al, Fortunately for us,Guruji KSK has provided us all,with the most unique method of Ruling Planets...we can always take recourse to them,whenever in doubt...! ? Best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Inder,1. In my personal opinion, there may three options.a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering "NO" to Dear Abhay, "Retrograde-Horary chart", KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146-147;b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable;c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the querist.2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB 2005, p 52.3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87.4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, "It is important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result". According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number.Best regards,tw , "Inder" <indervohra2001> wrote:> > Dear friends,> The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative.> > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer > may come as positive.> > I am bit confused here.> > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule.> Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > posion as per kp rules.> > Pl comment.> > Inder India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 31, 2005 Report Share Posted March 31, 2005 Dear Lajimiji Thank you so much for your sincere and kind response to my query. Even though,I have heard and read some articles on Sub-sub theory,but I was hesitating to touch on that for two reasons. 1.Accuracy of the chart...ofcourse,if its with Raichurji's software I hope will be correct. 2.Previous experience of many astrologers still not known. If you have tested and accepted that as good by experience,definitely I will follow that. Best regards Balaji GopalakrishnanYogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Balaji, I recommend you try arriving at the significators,using the now-famous sub-sub theory...made very practicable by the late Pt.K.R.Kar,and Prof.Balachandran... Last years annual alone contains an excellent article by Prof.Balachandran...it may help you a lot... With best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !"Balaji G.krishnan" <balaji_g_krishnan wrote: Dear Mr.inderji, How can we take in to consideration that 11th CSL in the planet of retrogression as simply negative and predict if the matter is well going to happen shortly.Just like a person well qualified and well skilled,if he asks a question on job...if 11th CSL SAT IN STAR OF JUPITER RETRO DENOTES he will not at all get a job in future or for 2 years.How can it be correct?. Ofcourse,tough time can be understood but we cannot nullify the happening of getting a job in a near future.Say two weeks or maximum one month may be he can try....why not he will get a job soon if he tries hard??. Kindly reply to this learned members. Thanks Balaji Gopalakrishnan Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Inder,tw853 et al, Fortunately for us,Guruji KSK has provided us all,with the most unique method of Ruling Planets...we can always take recourse to them,whenever in doubt...! ? Best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Inder,1. In my personal opinion, there may three options.a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering "NO" to Dear Abhay, "Retrograde-Horary chart", KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146-147;b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable;c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the querist.2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB 2005, p 52.3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87.4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, "It is important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result". According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number.Best regards,tw , "Inder" <indervohra2001> wrote:> > Dear friends,> The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative.> > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer > may come as positive.> > I am bit confused here.> > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule.> Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > posion as per kp rules.> > Pl comment.> > Inder India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 31, 2005 Report Share Posted March 31, 2005 Dear Balaji, I have not "mastered" the sub-sub theory yet... but I am experimenting with it since the past year or so,and cross-checking wherever and whenever possible/feasible,with the usual K.P. method,with Mr.Raichur's software,as it is accurate upto the sub-sub level. Yours sincerely, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !"Balaji G.krishnan" <balaji_g_krishnan wrote: Dear Lajimiji Thank you so much for your sincere and kind response to my query. Even though,I have heard and read some articles on Sub-sub theory,but I was hesitating to touch on that for two reasons. 1.Accuracy of the chart...ofcourse,if its with Raichurji's software I hope will be correct. 2.Previous experience of many astrologers still not known. If you have tested and accepted that as good by experience,definitely I will follow that. Best regards Balaji GopalakrishnanYogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Balaji, I recommend you try arriving at the significators,using the now-famous sub-sub theory...made very practicable by the late Pt.K.R.Kar,and Prof.Balachandran... Last years annual alone contains an excellent article by Prof.Balachandran...it may help you a lot... With best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !"Balaji G.krishnan" <balaji_g_krishnan wrote: Dear Mr.inderji, How can we take in to consideration that 11th CSL in the planet of retrogression as simply negative and predict if the matter is well going to happen shortly.Just like a person well qualified and well skilled,if he asks a question on job...if 11th CSL SAT IN STAR OF JUPITER RETRO DENOTES he will not at all get a job in future or for 2 years.How can it be correct?. Ofcourse,tough time can be understood but we cannot nullify the happening of getting a job in a near future.Say two weeks or maximum one month may be he can try....why not he will get a job soon if he tries hard??. Kindly reply to this learned members. Thanks Balaji Gopalakrishnan Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Inder,tw853 et al, Fortunately for us,Guruji KSK has provided us all,with the most unique method of Ruling Planets...we can always take recourse to them,whenever in doubt...! ? Best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Inder,1. In my personal opinion, there may three options.a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering "NO" to Dear Abhay, "Retrograde-Horary chart", KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146-147;b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable;c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the querist.2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB 2005, p 52.3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87.4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, "It is important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result". According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number.Best regards,tw , "Inder" <indervohra2001> wrote:> > Dear friends,> The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative.> > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer > may come as positive.> > I am bit confused here.> > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule.> Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > posion as per kp rules.> > Pl comment.> > Inder India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 31, 2005 Report Share Posted March 31, 2005 Dear lajimiji Thank u so much.Let me try that whenever possible. bye Balaji GYogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Balaji, I have not "mastered" the sub-sub theory yet... but I am experimenting with it since the past year or so,and cross-checking wherever and whenever possible/feasible,with the usual K.P. method,with Mr.Raichur's software,as it is accurate upto the sub-sub level. Yours sincerely, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !"Balaji G.krishnan" <balaji_g_krishnan wrote: Dear Lajimiji Thank you so much for your sincere and kind response to my query. Even though,I have heard and read some articles on Sub-sub theory,but I was hesitating to touch on that for two reasons. 1.Accuracy of the chart...ofcourse,if its with Raichurji's software I hope will be correct. 2.Previous experience of many astrologers still not known. If you have tested and accepted that as good by experience,definitely I will follow that. Best regards Balaji GopalakrishnanYogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Balaji, I recommend you try arriving at the significators,using the now-famous sub-sub theory...made very practicable by the late Pt.K.R.Kar,and Prof.Balachandran... Last years annual alone contains an excellent article by Prof.Balachandran...it may help you a lot... With best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !"Balaji G.krishnan" <balaji_g_krishnan wrote: Dear Mr.inderji, How can we take in to consideration that 11th CSL in the planet of retrogression as simply negative and predict if the matter is well going to happen shortly.Just like a person well qualified and well skilled,if he asks a question on job...if 11th CSL SAT IN STAR OF JUPITER RETRO DENOTES he will not at all get a job in future or for 2 years.How can it be correct?. Ofcourse,tough time can be understood but we cannot nullify the happening of getting a job in a near future.Say two weeks or maximum one month may be he can try....why not he will get a job soon if he tries hard??. Kindly reply to this learned members. Thanks Balaji Gopalakrishnan Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1 wrote: Dear Inder,tw853 et al, Fortunately for us,Guruji KSK has provided us all,with the most unique method of Ruling Planets...we can always take recourse to them,whenever in doubt...! ? Best wishes, lyrastro1 GOOD LUCK !tw853 <tw853 wrote: Dear Inder,1. In my personal opinion, there may three options.a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering "NO" to Dear Abhay, "Retrograde-Horary chart", KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146-147;b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable;c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the querist.2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB 2005, p 52.3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87.4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, "It is important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result". According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number.Best regards,tw , "Inder" <indervohra2001> wrote:> > Dear friends,> The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in the > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative.> > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if that > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, answer > may come as positive.> > I am bit confused here.> > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule.> Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > posion as per kp rules.> > Pl comment.> > Inder India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 1, 2005 Report Share Posted April 1, 2005 Yes dear , this is the point I am trying to raise. My feeling is that Retro planets act in different or reverse way. Say Jupiter is to give promotion during the expansion of thr organisation where native is working. But Retro jupiter may give promotion to native during decline of organisation when many others left. If the native has Jup retro in his chart then in his horary chart also promotion will be indiacted by retro Jupiter. So retro does not mean denial always. One has to see what retro planet is signfying as per Kp rules. Inder , " Balaji G.krishnan " <balaji_g_krishnan> wrote: > Dear Mr.inderji, > > How can we take in to consideration that 11th CSL in the planet of retrogression as simply negative and predict if the matter is well going to happen shortly.Just like a person well qualified and well skilled,if he asks a question on job...if 11th CSL SAT IN STAR OF JUPITER RETRO DENOTES he will not at all get a job in future or for 2 years.How can it be correct?. > > Ofcourse,tough time can be understood but we cannot nullify the happening of getting a job in a near future.Say two weeks or maximum one month may be he can try....why not he will get a job soon if he tries hard??. > > Kindly reply to this learned members. > > Thanks > Balaji Gopalakrishnan > > > Yogesh Rao Lajmi <lyrastro1> wrote: > Dear Inder,tw853 et al, > Fortunately for us,Guruji KSK has provided us all,with the most unique method of Ruling Planets...we can always take recourse to them,whenever in doubt...! ? > Best wishes, > lyrastro1 > GOOD LUCK ! > > tw853 <tw853> wrote: > > Dear Inder, > > 1. In my personal opinion, there may three options. > > a/ Guruji KSK original as mentioned in answering " NO " to Dear > Abhay, " Retrograde-Horary chart " , KP Reader VI, Edition 1978, pp 146- > 147; > > b/ Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory may be applicable; > > c/ Sometimes it may be an exceptional case or unclear mind of the > querist. > > 2. KSK original has been appraised by Dr. Bal Krishna Singh in KP > Year Book (KPYB)2003, p 17, , in Prof. Vijay Kumar in KPYB 2003, p 52 > & 2004, p 25, R. Gopal in KPYB 2005, p 19, Rajendra Kumar in KPYB > 2005, p 52. > > 3. The application of Dr. Kar's Retrogression theory is expalined by > Prof. K. Balachandran in KPYB 2002, p 87. > > 4. There may be some exceptional cases . Alan Leo, " It is > important to remember that no question should be asked, nor Horary > figure cast, unless the mind is truly serious and quite anxious > concerning the matter upon which the information is sought. Other > wise, disappointment and erroneous judgement will certainly result " . > According to Bamadeva Mohanty mentions in KPYB 2002, p 49, at the > time of the query, the querist gets confused in giving a number. > > Best regards, > > > tw > > > > , " Inder " <indervohra2001> > wrote: > > > > Dear friends, > > The basic rule of KP horary is that if sublord of 11th cusp is in > the > > star of a retro planet, the answer of the querry is in negative. > > > > Sometimes I am finding this to be not correct. I also saw that if > that > > retro planet is also retro in the natal chart of the querriest, > answer > > may come as positive. > > > > I am bit confused here. > > > > Do other members have ever noticed falure of this basic rule. > > Sh Sahni of hans group also mentioned that instead of seeing > > retro or direct motion one sholud consider the placements and cusp > > posion as per kp rules. > > > > Pl comment. > > > > Inder > > > > > > India Matrimony: Find your life partner online. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 1, 2005 Report Share Posted April 1, 2005 Dear Abhay, 1. Pl refer as regards to KP Msg #3404 & KP Reader VI, p 145 (In a Natal chart, a planet in direct motion or retrograde-- no difference.) 2. No comment on any other rule or feeling without any support of sufficient samples of practical cases. Best regards, tw , Abhay Godse <abhaygodse@e...> wrote: > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.