Guest guest Posted April 5, 2007 Report Share Posted April 5, 2007 Dear Surinder ji, I am personally against charging any money for the Lal Kitab upaya. Yes, I know that Pandit ji never charged any money from any one, rich or poor. Through my group Lalkitab_remedies I have been serving people for years and have never charged a single paisa. But things are different in my case. By the grace of God I am already very well off and I do not need any more money. But we must also not forget that for most of the people you have mentioned astrology could be a means of livelihood; unless they charge how would they feed their families. Therefore charging a token amount so that the astrologer and his family survives is justifiable. Agar vidwan nahi bachega to gyaan kaise bachega ? In order that the knowledge survives, the learned scholars have to be helped to survive. Unlike good old days when the society contributed for their survival, these days they have to fend for themselves. Therefore charging a reasonable amount can be justified. I agree that there are a lot of unscrupulous individuals who take advantage of their clients and fleece them thoroughly, I consider that unethical and deplore such people. God bless you, Bhooshan Priya , " s3_sood " <s3_sood wrote: > > Respactable scholars > > I am a novice as far as the Lal Kitab jyotish is concerned, I am a > bhagat of this astrology > > stream. I would like to raise one important question and wish that > every scholar give his > > opinion on this. I am aware that some of the members may find it > huting but believe me this > > will create a clear view for students like me. > > My question for the topic is KYA LAL KITAB WALON KO JATAK SE PAISE > LENE CHAHIYE YA NAHI? > > respected members I heard that Shri Roop Chand Joshi ji never took a > single paisa from > > anyone for readinding kundli and telling upaye. My in-laws family > use to go to Pundit ji for > > kundli and varshphal upaye and never paid him anything. I was > inspired by my in-laws family > > to show my chart to Pundit jis son Pt. Som nath ji when I visited > canada in 2003. But I was > > surprised to know that he charged every one a big amount. I too paid > him the fee alongwith > > some others people. But even after doing all the upayas I did not get > any benefit. > > I know many other astrologers who never accepted any fees. But most > of the known names of Lal Kitab are professionals. Pundit jis son Mr. > Som dutt his grandson Mr. Iqbal, Mr. Lal kitabi, Mr. Prabhakar, Mr. > Sekhri,Mr. Umesh sharma, Mr. Kulbeer, Mr. Goswami are either full > time or part time professionals. > > My point is whether it is right to do Lal Kitab astrology > professionally? I heard that 10-20 years ago no Lal kitab astrologer > was accepting a single paisa or a favour from the people. > > My view or opening statement in this matter is that all those who are > earning money through lal kitab are hurting the soul of Shri Pundit > Roop chand ji. This astrology is for LOK KALYAN not for earning > money. Plese guide me in this matter. > > Please forgive if someone is hurt > > Surinder Sood > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2007 Report Share Posted April 5, 2007 Respected Sir, since the word professonalism is written on the topic title. professionalism means something in which u r an prefectionist. if a person gains Rs. 10,00000 by ur upaya there is no harm in accepting Rs 10,000/ but if u are a novice and u experiment on people like guinnea pigs for free and ur experiments harm them. what is better of the two. accepting fees brings accountability and pushes the astrologer for perfection. of course there should be an undertaking that if the upaye fails, the astrologer will have to pay the penalty. kulbir bains - -- In , " " < wrote: > > Dear Surinder ji, > > I am personally against charging any money for the Lal Kitab upaya. > Yes, I know that Pandit ji never charged any money from any one, > rich or poor. > > Through my group Lalkitab_remedies I have been serving people for > years and have never charged a single paisa. But things are > different in my case. By the grace of God I am already very well off > and I do not need any more money. > > But we must also not forget that for most of the people you have > mentioned astrology could be a means of livelihood; unless they > charge how would they feed their families. Therefore charging a > token amount so that the astrologer and his family survives is > justifiable. > > Agar vidwan nahi bachega to gyaan kaise bachega ? > > In order that the knowledge survives, the learned scholars have to > be helped to survive. Unlike good old days when the society > contributed for their survival, these days they have to fend for > themselves. Therefore charging a reasonable amount can be justified. > > I agree that there are a lot of unscrupulous individuals who take > advantage of their clients and fleece them thoroughly, I consider > that unethical and deplore such people. > > God bless you, > > Bhooshan Priya > > > , " s3_sood " <s3_sood@> > wrote: > > > > Respactable scholars > > > > I am a novice as far as the Lal Kitab jyotish is concerned, I am > a > > bhagat of this astrology > > > > stream. I would like to raise one important question and wish > that > > every scholar give his > > > > opinion on this. I am aware that some of the members may find it > > huting but believe me this > > > > will create a clear view for students like me. > > > > My question for the topic is KYA LAL KITAB WALON KO JATAK SE PAISE > > LENE CHAHIYE YA NAHI? > > > > respected members I heard that Shri Roop Chand Joshi ji never took > a > > single paisa from > > > > anyone for readinding kundli and telling upaye. My in-laws family > > use to go to Pundit ji for > > > > kundli and varshphal upaye and never paid him anything. I was > > inspired by my in-laws family > > > > to show my chart to Pundit jis son Pt. Som nath ji when I visited > > canada in 2003. But I was > > > > surprised to know that he charged every one a big amount. I too > paid > > him the fee alongwith > > > > some others people. But even after doing all the upayas I did not > get > > any benefit. > > > > I know many other astrologers who never accepted any fees. But > most > > of the known names of Lal Kitab are professionals. Pundit jis son > Mr. > > Som dutt his grandson Mr. Iqbal, Mr. Lal kitabi, Mr. Prabhakar, > Mr. > > Sekhri,Mr. Umesh sharma, Mr. Kulbeer, Mr. Goswami are either full > > time or part time professionals. > > > > My point is whether it is right to do Lal Kitab astrology > > professionally? I heard that 10-20 years ago no Lal kitab > astrologer > > was accepting a single paisa or a favour from the people. > > > > My view or opening statement in this matter is that all those who > are > > earning money through lal kitab are hurting the soul of Shri > Pundit > > Roop chand ji. This astrology is for LOK KALYAN not for earning > > money. Plese guide me in this matter. > > > > Please forgive if someone is hurt > > > > Surinder Sood > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2007 Report Share Posted April 5, 2007 Dear Surinder ji, I am personally against charging any money for the Lal Kitab upaya. Yes, I know that Pandit ji never charged any money from any one, rich or poor. Through my group Lalkitab_remedies I have been serving people for years and have never charged a single paisa. But things are different in my case. By the grace of God I am already very well off and I do not need any more money. But we must also not forget that for most of the people you have mentioned astrology could be a means of livelihood; unless they charge how would they feed their families. Therefore charging a token amount so that the astrologer and his family survives is justifiable. Agar vidwan nahi bachega to gyaan kaise bachega ? In order that the knowledge survives, the learned scholars have to be helped to survive. Unlike good old days when the society contributed for their survival, these days they have to fend for themselves. Therefore charging a reasonable amount can be justified. I agree that there are a lot of unscrupulous individuals who take advantage of their clients and fleece them thoroughly, I consider that unethical and deplore such people. God bless you, Bhooshan Priya , " s3_sood " <s3_sood wrote: > > Respactable scholars > > I am a novice as far as the Lal Kitab jyotish is concerned, I am a > bhagat of this astrology > > stream. I would like to raise one important question and wish that > every scholar give his > > opinion on this. I am aware that some of the members may find it > huting but believe me this > > will create a clear view for students like me. > > My question for the topic is KYA LAL KITAB WALON KO JATAK SE PAISE > LENE CHAHIYE YA NAHI? > > respected members I heard that Shri Roop Chand Joshi ji never took a > single paisa from > > anyone for readinding kundli and telling upaye. My in-laws family > use to go to Pundit ji for > > kundli and varshphal upaye and never paid him anything. I was > inspired by my in-laws family > > to show my chart to Pundit jis son Pt. Som nath ji when I visited > canada in 2003. But I was > > surprised to know that he charged every one a big amount. I too paid > him the fee alongwith > > some others people. But even after doing all the upayas I did not get > any benefit. > > I know many other astrologers who never accepted any fees. But most > of the known names of Lal Kitab are professionals. Pundit jis son Mr. > Som dutt his grandson Mr. Iqbal, Mr. Lal kitabi, Mr. Prabhakar, Mr. > Sekhri,Mr. Umesh sharma, Mr. Kulbeer, Mr. Goswami are either full > time or part time professionals. > > My point is whether it is right to do Lal Kitab astrology > professionally? I heard that 10-20 years ago no Lal kitab astrologer > was accepting a single paisa or a favour from the people. > > My view or opening statement in this matter is that all those who are > earning money through lal kitab are hurting the soul of Shri Pundit > Roop chand ji. This astrology is for LOK KALYAN not for earning > money. Plese guide me in this matter. > > Please forgive if someone is hurt > > Surinder Sood > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2007 Report Share Posted April 5, 2007 Respected Sir, since the word professonalism is written on the topic title. professionalism means something in which u r an prefectionist. if a person gains Rs. 10,00000 by ur upaya there is no harm in accepting Rs 10,000/ but if u are a novice and u experiment on people like guinnea pigs for free and ur experiments harm them. what is better of the two. accepting fees brings accountability and pushes the astrologer for perfection. of course there should be an undertaking that if the upaye fails, the astrologer will have to pay the penalty. kulbir bains - -- In , " " < wrote: > > Dear Surinder ji, > > I am personally against charging any money for the Lal Kitab upaya. > Yes, I know that Pandit ji never charged any money from any one, > rich or poor. > > Through my group Lalkitab_remedies I have been serving people for > years and have never charged a single paisa. But things are > different in my case. By the grace of God I am already very well off > and I do not need any more money. > > But we must also not forget that for most of the people you have > mentioned astrology could be a means of livelihood; unless they > charge how would they feed their families. Therefore charging a > token amount so that the astrologer and his family survives is > justifiable. > > Agar vidwan nahi bachega to gyaan kaise bachega ? > > In order that the knowledge survives, the learned scholars have to > be helped to survive. Unlike good old days when the society > contributed for their survival, these days they have to fend for > themselves. Therefore charging a reasonable amount can be justified. > > I agree that there are a lot of unscrupulous individuals who take > advantage of their clients and fleece them thoroughly, I consider > that unethical and deplore such people. > > God bless you, > > Bhooshan Priya > > > , " s3_sood " <s3_sood@> > wrote: > > > > Respactable scholars > > > > I am a novice as far as the Lal Kitab jyotish is concerned, I am > a > > bhagat of this astrology > > > > stream. I would like to raise one important question and wish > that > > every scholar give his > > > > opinion on this. I am aware that some of the members may find it > > huting but believe me this > > > > will create a clear view for students like me. > > > > My question for the topic is KYA LAL KITAB WALON KO JATAK SE PAISE > > LENE CHAHIYE YA NAHI? > > > > respected members I heard that Shri Roop Chand Joshi ji never took > a > > single paisa from > > > > anyone for readinding kundli and telling upaye. My in-laws family > > use to go to Pundit ji for > > > > kundli and varshphal upaye and never paid him anything. I was > > inspired by my in-laws family > > > > to show my chart to Pundit jis son Pt. Som nath ji when I visited > > canada in 2003. But I was > > > > surprised to know that he charged every one a big amount. I too > paid > > him the fee alongwith > > > > some others people. But even after doing all the upayas I did not > get > > any benefit. > > > > I know many other astrologers who never accepted any fees. But > most > > of the known names of Lal Kitab are professionals. Pundit jis son > Mr. > > Som dutt his grandson Mr. Iqbal, Mr. Lal kitabi, Mr. Prabhakar, > Mr. > > Sekhri,Mr. Umesh sharma, Mr. Kulbeer, Mr. Goswami are either full > > time or part time professionals. > > > > My point is whether it is right to do Lal Kitab astrology > > professionally? I heard that 10-20 years ago no Lal kitab > astrologer > > was accepting a single paisa or a favour from the people. > > > > My view or opening statement in this matter is that all those who > are > > earning money through lal kitab are hurting the soul of Shri > Pundit > > Roop chand ji. This astrology is for LOK KALYAN not for earning > > money. Plese guide me in this matter. > > > > Please forgive if someone is hurt > > > > Surinder Sood > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.