LK discussion group The Mukammal Kundali at Page No. 384 of 1942 edition

[Guest guest]

Jain sahib, the whole scenario is confusing. In 1952 edition it is

written that for dhoke ka grah 2nd exception sun of 7th house has to

be taken in no.5 of the sequence when house no 1 is vacant (as in this

kundali) and the formula is different from that given in 1942 book.

If we stick to 42 only then also as per the table we place sun in 7

and follow the sequence 44 comes under column of rahu. Can't

understand how you found moon. I also don't have the proper planatary

table sequence of 52 book. In this kundali one peculiar point about

venus is that it is the only planet that comes to natal position in

44th varshphal i.e. 8th house. It is requested that 1. Kindly give the

talika of 52. 2. Which method is to be adopted for dhoke ka grah. 3.

What is the difference in 42 and 52 method. Do they compliment each

other or are they different. Regards. Kulbir.

 

On 7/6/09, mpj571 <mpj571 wrote:

> Sirs,

>

> According to my calculation the dhoke ka grah for the 44th year should be

> the MOON.

>

> In the Janma Kundali the Sun is in the 7th house. It reaches the throne in

> the 7th year. Therefore if the sun is written on top of the 7th year and the

> sequence of dhoke ke grah completed then the MOON will emerge as the dhoke

> ka grah for the 44th year.Therefore it should be moon in place of venus as

> printed in the book.

>

> Others may also verify this.

>

> Respectfully,

>

> MP Jain

>

>

>

>

, " lalkitabee " <lalkitabee

> wrote:

>>

>> Res learned members

>>

>>

>> Before discussing the " Mukammal kundali " in detail as Kulbir Ji has

>> desired, I would like to point out what appears to be a printing mistake

>> in the original book. I have a doubt about MUKAMMAL KUNDALI,I think there

>> shud be a correction in original Lalkitab 1942 edition at page no.384.

>>

>> There Pujya Pandit Ji mentioned venus as " DHOKEY KA GRAH " in khana 10 of

>> MUKAMMAL KUNDALI.. But as per the system of " DHOKEY KA GRAH " ,I found that

>> it shud be Mars not Venus.

>>

>> Please share ur views about this.Specially I invite Mr.Varun Ji, Umesh

>> Ji,Bhatia ji ,Yograj Ji,Kondal Ji & Kulbir Ji & Mr. Wandahl.It is request

>> from me to spare some time from daily life of own of all of u.

>>

>> Once it is settled whether there is a mistake or not,then I can proceed

>> with the discussion.

>>

>> With Regards

>>

>> Pt.Lalkitabee

>>

>>

>> V.Shukla

>>

>

>

>

 

--

Sent from my mobile device