Mistake in Faisala Kundali

July 27, 2009

Res Mr. Jain Im also aware about that tables at Page no. 72 & 73 of 1942 edition under headings DHOKEY KA 12 SAALAA CHAKKAR & AAM UMRA MAIN DHOKEY KA 12 SAALAA CHAKKAR.But I collected whole information from five editions & as result found the dhokey ka grah shud be Mars in that AKHIRI KUNDALI. Some of so called experts are sticky about "DHOKEY KA GRAH" & saying - "A perfectionist like Pundit ji cannot commit such mistake."For those people Im revealing another mistake in same AKHIRI KUNDALI of Original Book. According to the rules of making AKHIRI KUNDALI at page no 384 of 1942 edition,the SUN & MERCURY aren't placed in khana No. 7. As per rule both planets shud have been there.Bcoz there has been written a rule in 1942 -EDITION AT PAGE NO. 384- PEHLEY GHARON MAIN VARSHFAL KE GRAH AUR BAAD KE GHARON MAIN JANAM KUNDALI KE GRAH AUR US KUNDALI KE NO.10 MAIN DHOKEY KA GRAH LIKHENGEY.If we follow this rule there is a crystal-clear mistake in original lalkitab about KHANA NO. 7 also. Now what will be the opinion of them who declare that "A perfectionist like Pundit ji cannot commit such mistake. U also can imagine their devotion for research in this subject. Main bhi sweekar kartaa hun ki Pandit ji aisi galati kabhi nahi kar saktey, lekin jabki mujhe yah maloom hai ki is kitaab ka kaam QATIB kar rahey they ,to galati honey ki gunjayish bhi ho jaati hai. " Bus yahi baat samajhne ka fark hai. Agar fir bhi koyee aalim AKHIRI KUNDALI main khaali khana - 7 ko theek mantaa hai to bara-e-meharaani ise kisi tarikey se theek saabit to karo.Agar main galat saabit hotaa hun to publically maafi maangne main mujhe koyee aitraaj nahi hogaa.Varnaa is galati ki hee tarah Dhokey ka grah bhi to misprint ka natijaa ho saktaa hai. Otherwise not accepting mistake is a solo soliloquy as - OX GIVES MILK. With regardsPt.LalkitabeeV.ShuklaMb.- 9812020001 , "mpj571" <mpj571 wrote:>> Dear Vipin Shukla ji,> > You had pointed out that the dhoke ka grah in faisala kundali has been written wrong. Some readers in another group do not find your statement as correct. They claim that a meticulous person like Pandit ji could not have made any mistake. Therefore the dhoke ka grah venus has been written correctly. I think you should set this controversy right for all time to come so that we know finally which is the dhoke ka grah in the faisala kundali for the 44th year. Thanking you in advance,> > MP Jain>

July 28, 2009

Dear Vipin Shukla ji,

You have silenced your critics in just one stroke. Not incorporating the sun and

mercury in the 7th house of the faisala kundali is a blatant mistake which can

not be justified.

Sir, you must be a busy man, therefore I hesitate asking you but if you could

give the logical explanation as to how you arrived at Mars as the dhoke ka grah

in the faisala kundali. You can respond to this request at your convenience.

Respectfully,

MP Jain

, " lalkitabee " <lalkitabee wrote:

>

> Res Mr. Jain Im also aware about that tables at Page no. 72 & 73 of

> 1942 edition under headings DHOKEY KA 12 SAALAA CHAKKAR & AAM UMRA MAIN

> DHOKEY KA 12 SAALAA CHAKKAR.But I collected whole information from five

> editions & as result found the dhokey ka grah shud be Mars in that

> AKHIRI KUNDALI. Some of so called experts are sticky about " DHOKEY KA

> GRAH " & saying - " A perfectionist like Pundit ji cannot commit such

> mistake. " For those people Im revealing another mistake in same AKHIRI

> KUNDALI of Original Book. According to the rules of making AKHIRI

> KUNDALI at page no 384 of 1942 edition,the SUN & MERCURY aren't

> placed in khana No. 7. As per rule both planets shud have been

> there.Bcoz there has been written a rule in 1942 -EDITION AT PAGE NO.

> 384- PEHLEY GHARON MAIN VARSHFAL KE GRAH AUR BAAD KE GHARON MAIN JANAM

> KUNDALI KE GRAH AUR US KUNDALI KE NO.10 MAIN DHOKEY KA GRAH LIKHENGEY.If

> we follow this rule there is a crystal-clear mistake in original

> lalkitab about KHANA NO. 7 also. Now what will be the opinion of them

> who declare that " A perfectionist like Pundit ji cannot commit such

> mistake. U also can imagine their devotion for research in this

> subject. Main bhi sweekar kartaa hun ki Pandit ji aisi galati kabhi nahi

> kar saktey, lekin jabki mujhe yah maloom hai ki is kitaab ka kaam QATIB

> kar rahey they ,to galati honey ki gunjayish bhi ho jaati hai. " Bus

> yahi baat samajhne ka fark hai. Agar fir bhi koyee aalim AKHIRI

> KUNDALI main khaali khana - 7 ko theek mantaa hai to bara-e-meharaani

> ise kisi tarikey se theek saabit to karo.Agar main galat saabit hotaa

> hun to publically maafi maangne main mujhe koyee aitraaj nahi

> hogaa.Varnaa is galati ki hee tarah Dhokey ka grah bhi to misprint ka

> natijaa ho saktaa hai. Otherwise not accepting mistake is a solo

> soliloquy as - OX GIVES MILK. With regardsPt.LalkitabeeV.ShuklaMb.-

> 9812020001 , " mpj571 "

> <mpj571@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Vipin Shukla ji,

> >

> > You had pointed out that the dhoke ka grah in faisala kundali has been

> written wrong. Some readers in another group do not find your statement

> as correct. They claim that a meticulous person like Pandit ji could not

> have made any mistake. Therefore the dhoke ka grah venus has been

> written correctly. I think you should set this controversy right for all

> time to come so that we know finally which is the dhoke ka grah in the

> faisala kundali for the 44th year. Thanking you in advance,

> >

> > MP Jain

> >

>

July 28, 2009

Respected Lalkitabi ji,

Here i give your statement which are you write in another group where i explain

my views about Aakhiri faisla Kundlee, here you have objection to on the table

and method, which I used.

Now i am confused read your message on this matter becaz you also use these

table and method.

I am highly obliged if you clarify that which method or table we use to find out

the " Dhokey Ka Grah "

Thanks & Regard

Umesh Sharma

Respected Umesh JI

I was seeing horoscope charts provided by you in foto section & reading your

views at the topic which was raised by Kulbir Ji as-- " PEHLE GHARON MEIN

VARSHPHAL KE GRAH LIKHE JAYENGE AUR BAAD KE GHARON

MEIN JANAM KUNDALI KE GRAH LIKHE JAYENGE AUR IS KE 10 MEIN DOKHE KE

GRAH LIKHE JAYENGE. NATIJE PAR FAISLA HOGA. JO GRAH IS KUNDALI MEIN

DO DAFA AA JAYE WAH APNA FAISLA IS NAYI KUNDALI KE MUTABIK ACHA YA

BURA KISMAT KA FAISLA DENGE. IS TARKIB SE NA AVEN WAH VARSHPHAL KE

MUTABIK FAISLA DENGE..

But umesh ji the technique used by u to find out the Planet OF DHOKA, that

implies only the horoscope which is provided by you.Why u forgot to use the

kundali which has been used at last of 1942 edition ? iN that edition the

technique used by you to search Dhokhe ka planet,absolutely fails ,The planet of

cheating is VENUS in that horoscope (Yograj ji & Nirmal ji please correct me

with the help of 1942 book).If we use only verdicts of u then what will be

planet of DHOKHA . I think u used SOORAJ NUMBER 11 or 12 INDEXES to find out

the planet of DHOKHA.If so then i want to say that serial (TARTEEB) of the

planets deffers in both indexes, due to this ,using ur technique there will be

confusion to find out " DHOKE KA PLANET " in 48 th & 52 nd year of varshfal So

what u say about that with ur deep insight.In fact as per using of Varshfal &

janm kundali for faisle ki kundali, that is so simple as u explained & it is

much obvious by that example of the book 1942 at page no. 384.

With regards

Lalkitabee