Guest guest Posted December 7, 2009 Report Share Posted December 7, 2009 Respected members; The hour kundali given on 1. page 363 of 1941 edition; 2. page 89 of 1942 edition; 3. page 221 of 1952 edition; the kundali for 25th minute does not matches the kundali printed for it; in fact the kundali for 25th minute comes to be same as the hour kundali. saturn in 5 moved 25 houses again reaches 5th house. so the minute for the printed kundali with Saturn in first house can only be erected for 9th minute; 21st minute; 33rd minute; 45th minute or 57th minute. Kindly confirm what should be printed in place of 25 because 25 is definitely wrong and a misprint. Regards Kulbir. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 7, 2009 Report Share Posted December 7, 2009 Res Kulbir Ji Yes U r absolutely right.I think the minute kundali was prepared for 45th minute & misprinted 25th minute. Kyonki urdu main 25 aur 45 likhtey huve 2 aur 4 ki banaavat ko dekhtey huve is misprint ki gunjayish ho sakti hai. Ek baat aur :- KYAA AAPKO NAHI LAGTAA KI PUJYA PANDIT JI NE SURAJ KO CHALAAYAIN YA SANICHCHAR KO CHALAAYAIN LIKHKAR VISHAY KA VISTAAR KAR DIYA HAI. JABKI AAP KISI BHI GRAH KO CHALAAYAIN GINTI KE HISAAB SE TO VAH THIK USI JAGAH PAHUNCH JAATAA HAI JAISA KI PUJYA PANDIT JI NE PAHUNCHAYA HAI.ISKE ALAAWAA JARAA VARSHFAL SE BANAAYEE GAYEE MAHINA KUNDALI PAR BHI GAUR KARO VAHAAN BHI SURAJ KO KUCHH AJEEB TARIKEY SE CHALAYAA GAYAA MALOOM HOTAA HAI. With regards pt.lalkitabee v.shukla , " kulbir " <kulbirbains wrote: > > Respected members; > The hour kundali given on > 1. page 363 of 1941 edition; > 2. page 89 of 1942 edition; > 3. page 221 of 1952 edition; > > the kundali for 25th minute does not matches the kundali printed for it; > in fact the kundali for 25th minute comes to be same as the hour kundali. saturn in 5 moved 25 houses again reaches 5th house. > > so the minute for the printed kundali with Saturn in first house can only be erected for 9th minute; 21st minute; 33rd minute; 45th minute or 57th minute. > > Kindly confirm what should be printed in place of 25 because 25 is definitely wrong and a misprint. > > Regards > Kulbir. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 7, 2009 Report Share Posted December 7, 2009 Dear Kulbir bhai, You are right. There is a misprint. I have crosschecked it should be 45 and not 25. Regards, Varun Trivedi , " kulbir " <kulbirbains wrote: > > Respected members; > The hour kundali given on > 1. page 363 of 1941 edition; > 2. page 89 of 1942 edition; > 3. page 221 of 1952 edition; > > the kundali for 25th minute does not matches the kundali printed for it; > in fact the kundali for 25th minute comes to be same as the hour kundali. saturn in 5 moved 25 houses again reaches 5th house. > > so the minute for the printed kundali with Saturn in first house can only be erected for 9th minute; 21st minute; 33rd minute; 45th minute or 57th minute. > > Kindly confirm what should be printed in place of 25 because 25 is definitely wrong and a misprint. > > Regards > Kulbir. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 7, 2009 Report Share Posted December 7, 2009 Respected lalkitabee ji, Using the word 'chalana' will not be appropriate in the context of Sun in the 'month' kundali. Here the sun is fixed and not moved [chalaya] according to the month. The Lal Kitab says " varsh phal ki kundali ke jis khane mein sooraj baitha hove, us khane ko umra ke mahine ka hindsa de kar tamam kundali muqammal kae len " [ page 88; 1942 ed] Where as in the subsequent kundalis of day, hour, minute etc the planets are moved [and not fixed like the sun in the month kundali] according to the astrological movement i.e. the house where the planet is placed is always counted as 1 and then the planet is moved to the desired number. Thanks for pointing out this difference. With respect, varun Trivedi , " Lalkitabee " <lalkitabee wrote: > > Res Kulbir Ji > Yes U r absolutely right.I think the minute kundali was prepared for 45th minute & misprinted 25th minute. Kyonki urdu main 25 aur 45 likhtey huve 2 aur 4 ki banaavat ko dekhtey huve is misprint ki gunjayish ho sakti hai. > Ek baat aur :- KYAA AAPKO NAHI LAGTAA KI PUJYA PANDIT JI NE SURAJ KO CHALAAYAIN YA SANICHCHAR KO CHALAAYAIN LIKHKAR VISHAY KA VISTAAR KAR DIYA HAI. JABKI AAP KISI BHI GRAH KO CHALAAYAIN GINTI KE HISAAB SE TO VAH THIK USI JAGAH PAHUNCH JAATAA HAI JAISA KI PUJYA PANDIT JI NE PAHUNCHAYA HAI.ISKE ALAAWAA JARAA VARSHFAL SE BANAAYEE GAYEE MAHINA KUNDALI PAR BHI GAUR KARO VAHAAN BHI SURAJ KO KUCHH AJEEB TARIKEY SE CHALAYAA GAYAA MALOOM HOTAA HAI. > With regards > pt.lalkitabee > v.shukla > , " kulbir " <kulbirbains@> wrote: > > > > Respected members; > > The hour kundali given on > > 1. page 363 of 1941 edition; > > 2. page 89 of 1942 edition; > > 3. page 221 of 1952 edition; > > > > the kundali for 25th minute does not matches the kundali printed for it; > > in fact the kundali for 25th minute comes to be same as the hour kundali. saturn in 5 moved 25 houses again reaches 5th house. > > > > so the minute for the printed kundali with Saturn in first house can only be erected for 9th minute; 21st minute; 33rd minute; 45th minute or 57th minute. > > > > Kindly confirm what should be printed in place of 25 because 25 is definitely wrong and a misprint. > > > > Regards > > Kulbir. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 7, 2009 Report Share Posted December 7, 2009 Gurudev, " 'Qot rami tot arbores' jitni shakhayen utne hi ped, har shakha utni hi shashakta jita ki ped swayam; each branch is a tree in itself. " yeh sab to aap gurujano ke aashirvaad, margdarshan aur sehyog se hi sambhav hoga. Respect and Regards Kulbir. , " Lalkitabee " <lalkitabee wrote: > > Res Kulbir Ji > Yes U r absolutely right.I think the minute kundali was prepared for 45th minute & misprinted 25th minute. Kyonki urdu main 25 aur 45 likhtey huve 2 aur 4 ki banaavat ko dekhtey huve is misprint ki gunjayish ho sakti hai. > Ek baat aur :- KYAA AAPKO NAHI LAGTAA KI PUJYA PANDIT JI NE SURAJ KO CHALAAYAIN YA SANICHCHAR KO CHALAAYAIN LIKHKAR VISHAY KA VISTAAR KAR DIYA HAI. JABKI AAP KISI BHI GRAH KO CHALAAYAIN GINTI KE HISAAB SE TO VAH THIK USI JAGAH PAHUNCH JAATAA HAI JAISA KI PUJYA PANDIT JI NE PAHUNCHAYA HAI.ISKE ALAAWAA JARAA VARSHFAL SE BANAAYEE GAYEE MAHINA KUNDALI PAR BHI GAUR KARO VAHAAN BHI SURAJ KO KUCHH AJEEB TARIKEY SE CHALAYAA GAYAA MALOOM HOTAA HAI. > With regards > pt.lalkitabee > v.shukla > , " kulbir " <kulbirbains@> wrote: > > > > Respected members; > > The hour kundali given on > > 1. page 363 of 1941 edition; > > 2. page 89 of 1942 edition; > > 3. page 221 of 1952 edition; > > > > the kundali for 25th minute does not matches the kundali printed for it; > > in fact the kundali for 25th minute comes to be same as the hour kundali. saturn in 5 moved 25 houses again reaches 5th house. > > > > so the minute for the printed kundali with Saturn in first house can only be erected for 9th minute; 21st minute; 33rd minute; 45th minute or 57th minute. > > > > Kindly confirm what should be printed in place of 25 because 25 is definitely wrong and a misprint. > > > > Regards > > Kulbir. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.