Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

[lalkitab] Lagna Sarini Further Task/miglani ji

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Miglani ji,

 

The lagn sarani debate has nearly covered all points.

our objective was to verify that can modern software calculations be

applied effectively to lalkitab analysis. that has been answered by

all the participating unanimously accepting that it is the correct

method and exclusive use of sarani is not important rather obsolete.

if desh,kaal,patar principle is applied to astrology it should also

be applied to the progress made in calculative part also.

anyway there are professinals who are assigned with the preparing

panchangs etc. it is a separate branch from predictive and remedial

astrology and these people also don't claim to be master of

predictive or remedial part.

here in this group what kalsi ji thinks is panda knowledge is what

matters most.

it is not wrong to assume that people using internet do have some

good software for calculative part. many are available for free on

various sites.

may i have the audacity to request you to concentrate on the so

called panda part. please give it a thought as to what is really

important.

 

 

kulbir

 

 

 

 

 

, " kpmiglani "

<kpmiglani wrote:

>

> Dear Kalsi ji,

>

> We are not interested in any more tricks. If you are willing to

have

> a fair, fearless and objective academic discussion to be carried

step

> by step I am prepared to take you on.

>

> Sincerely,

>

> KP Miglani

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

, " Shivdev Kalsi "

> <shivdev.kalsi@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Miglani Ji/Bhooshan Ji/Trivedi & Tyagi ji,

> > My replies to your suggestions are in capital letters. You can

see

> where the

> > whole fuss stands.

> > Dear Punit Ji, you are well aware of astronomy, please check up

the

> errors

> > because it is a lengthy reply may some errors remain

> > ============================================================

> > If I have understood you correctly you mean to say that :

> > We should look up for the Ascendant in the sarini for the same

time

> as given

> > irrespective of the place of birth.

> > YES YOU HAVE UNDERSTOOD CORRECTLY. YOU WILL KNOW THAT THERE WILL

> NEVER BE A

> > DIFFERENCE OF SIX SIGNS AS YOU GIVEN IN YOUR EARLIER

> CALCULATIONS.NO DOUBT

> > ONE HAS TO APPLY LATITUDINAL CORRECTIONS TO ASCENDENT WHICH

RANGES

> > FROM 0.5DEGREE TO

> > 1.00 PER DEGREE PER LATTITUDE. HIGHER IS THE LATTITUDE HIGHER

RATE

> OF

> > CORRECTION PER DEGREE LATTITUDE.

> > For example if some one is born at 7 am on January 13, 1972 in

> London, we

> > should look up the Sarini and say that his Lagna would be Makar

at

> one

> > degree [ 1Cp0]

> > Let us examine your contention through a few examples

> > Date of birth for all the places : January 13, 1972

> > Time of birth for all the places : 7 am [ no DST]

> > Lagna from the Sarini for all the places should be : Makar at 1

> degree [

> > ayanansha correction not done]

> > Now let us find out the Lagna through software and see how

correct

> the Lagna

> > from the Sarini is:

> > Lagna through the software

> > Madras : 3 Cp 51 [ Makar at 3d51]-SOFTWARE

> > 1 CP 0 -SARNI

> > I ADD SOME MORE CITIES OF INDIA

> > DELHI: 23°SAG 27

> > SHILLONG 10 CP 37

> > AMRITSAR : 19 SG 27

> > WHY THIS DIFFERENCE IS THERE IN THESE LAGANS AT THE SAME TIME

> BECAUSE THE

> > LOCAL MEAN TIME IS DIFFERENT AT THAT TIME FOR EACH PLACE. ONE

HAS

> TO SEE THE

> > SARNI AS PER LOCAL MEAN TIME (LMT) IF THE SARNI IS MADE ON A

PLACE

> NEAR TO

> > STANDARD TIME MERIDIAN. THIS SARNI IS BASED UPON MADRAS LMT WE

CAN

> USE IT

> > SAFELY RATHER THIS IS UNIVERSALLY APPLICABLE TO ALL LOCAL MEAN

> TIMES.

> >

> > Islamabad : 24 Sg 01 [ Dhanu 24d01 ]

> > LET US CHECK

> > IT IS 6.52.50 LMT THERE

> > AS WE ARE USING SARNI SIDE BY SIDE WE HAVE TO CALCULATE ASCENDENT

> > FOR 7.00 LMT YOU HAVE TO ADD 7 MINUTES TO STANDARD TIME &

> > 33-13= 20 DEGREE LAT. DIFFERNCE APPROXYMATELY 10 DEGREE TO BE

ADDED

> TO THE

> > RESULT OBTAINED BY SOFTWARE OR DEDUCTED FROM MADRAS ASC AT 7.07

PST

> > THE VALUE IS 25 SAG 53 AS PER SOFTWARE

> > VERIFICATION FROM MADRAS SARNI

> > DEDUCT 10 DEGREES FROM MADRAS RESULT 1 CP 0 = 23 SAG 51

> > NEAR TO CORRECT 25 SAG 53

> >

> > Moscow : 27 Sc 43 [ Brishchik 27d43 ]

> > LET US CHECK

> > IT IS 6..30.18 LMT THERE BUT WE NEED 7.00 LMT

> > AS WE ARE USING SARNI SIDE BY SIDE WE HAVE TO CALCULATE ASCENDENT

> > (I) FOR 7.00 LMT YOU HAVE TO ADD 29 MINUTES 44 sec &

> > (II) 55-13= 42 DEGREE SINCE MOSKOW IS AT HIGER LATTITUDE MORE

THAN

> 40 AS AN

> > AVERAGE WE WILL APPLY CORRECTION 42X0.7=29 DEGREES LAT. DIFFERNCE

> > APPROXYMATELY 29 DEGREE TO BE ADDED TO THE RESULT OBTAINED BY

> SOFTWARE OR

> > DEDUCTED FROM MADRAS ASC

> > (III) AT 7.29.44 RST

> > THE VALUE IS 4 SAG 02 -AS PER SOFTWARE

> > VERIFICATION FROM MADRAS SARNI

> > DEDUCT 29 DEGREES FROM MADRAS RESULT 1 CP 0 = 2 SAG 0

> > NEAR TO CORRECT 4 SAG 02

> >

> > New York : 22 Sg 22 [ Dhanu 22d22]

> > LET US CHECK

> > IT IS 7.04. LMT THERE BUT WE NEED 7.00 LMT

> > AS WE ARE USING SARNI SIDE BY SIDE WE HAVE TO CALCULATE ASCENDENT

> > (I) FOR 7.00 LMT YOU HAVE TO DEDUCT 4 MINUTES 0 sec &

> > (II) 40-13= 27 DEGREE SINCE NEWYORK IS AT HIGER LATTITUDE MORE

THAN

> 40 AS AN

> > AVERAGE WE WILL APPLY CORRECTION 28X0.6=19 DEGREES LAT. DIFFERNCE

> > APPROXYMATELY 19 DEGREE TO BE ADDED TO THE RESULT OBTAINED BY

> SOFTWARE OR

> > DEDUCTED FROM MADRAS ASC

> > (III) AT 6.56.00 AST

> > THE VALUE IS 21 SAG 19 -AS PER SOFTWARE

> > VERIFICATION FROM MADRAS SARNI

> > DEDUCT 20 DEGREES FROM MADRAS RESULT 1 CP 0 = 12 SAG 19

> > NEAR TO CORRECT 21 SAG 19

> >

> >

> > Helsinki : 22 Sc 37 [ Brishchik 22d37]

> > LET US CHECK TD -20.12

> > IT IS 6.39.48. LMT THERE BUT WE NEED 7.00 LMT

> > AS WE ARE USING SARNI SIDE BY SIDE WE HAVE TO CALCULATE ASCENDENT

> > (I) FOR 7.00 LMT YOU HAVE TO ADD 20.12 MINUTES &

> > (II) 60-13= 47 DEGREE SINCE HELSINKI IS AT HIGER LATTITUDE MORE

> THAN 40 AS

> > AN AVERAGE WE WILL APPLY CORRECTION 47X0.7=33 DEGREES LAT.

DIFFERNCE

> > APPROXYMATELY 33 DEGREE TO BE ADDED TO THE RESULT OBTAINED BY

> SOFTWARE OR

> > DEDUCTED FROM MADRAS ASC

> > (III) AT 7.20.12 FST

> > THE VALUE IS 28 SCO 18 -AS PER SOFTWARE

> > VERIFICATION FROM MADRAS SARNI

> > DEDUCT 33 DEGREES FROM MADRAS RESULT 1 CP 0 = 28 SCO 00

> > NEAR TO CORRECT 28 SCO 18

> >

> > Singapore : 24 Sg 52 [ Dhanu 24d52]

> > LET US CHECK TD -64.24

> > IT IS 5.55.36. LMT THERE BUT WE NEED 7.00 LMT

> > AS WE ARE USING SARNI SIDE BY SIDE WE HAVE TO CALCULATE ASCENDENT

> > (I) FOR 7.00 LMT YOU HAVE TO ADD 20.12 MINUTES &

> > (II) 13-1= 12 DEGREE SINCE SINGAPORE IS AT LATTITUDE LESS THAN

> MADRAS AS AN

> > AVERAGE WE WILL APPLY CORRECTION 12X0.5=6 DEGREES LAT. DIFFERNCE

> > APPROXYMATELY 6 DEGREE TO BE DEDUCTED TO THE RESULT OBTAINED BY

> SOFTWARE OR

> > ADDED FROM MADRAS ASC

> > (III) AT 8.04.24 SST

> > THE VALUE IS 10 CP 12 -AS PER SOFTWARE

> > VERIFICATION FROM MADRAS SARNI

> > ADD 6 DEGREES FROM MADRAS RESULT 1 CP 0 = 7 CP 00

> > NEAR TO CORRECT 10 CP 12

> >

> > London : 9 Sg 58 [ Dhanu at 9d58]

> > LET US CHECK TD -0.20

> > IT IS 6.59.40. LMT THERE BUT WE NEED 7.00 LMT

> > AS WE ARE USING SARNI SIDE BY SIDE WE HAVE TO CALCULATE ASCENDENT

> > (I) FOR 7.00 LMT YOU HAVE TO ADD 00.20 MINUTES &

> > (II) 51-13= 38 DEGREE SINCE LONDON IS AT LATTITUDE MORETHAN

MADRAS

> AS AN

> > AVERAGE WE WILL APPLY CORRECTION 38X0.7=27 DEGREES LAT. DIFFERNCE

> > APPROXYMATELY 27 DEGREE TO BE ADDED TO THE RESULT OBTAINED BY

> SOFTWARE OR

> > DEDUCTED FROM MADRAS ASC

> > (III) AT 6.59.40BST

> > THE VALUE IS 9 SG 53 -AS PER SOFTWARE

> > VERIFICATION FROM MADRAS SARNI

> > DEDUCT 27 DEGREES FROM MADRAS RESULT 1 CP 0 = 3 SG 00

> > NEAR TO CORRECT 9 SG 53

> >

> > Oslo : 23 Sc 40 [ Brishchik 23 d 40 ]

> > LET US CHECK TD -17.00

> > IT IS 6.43.00. LMT THERE BUT WE NEED 7.00 LMT

> > AS WE ARE USING SARNI SIDE BY SIDE WE HAVE TO CALCULATE ASCENDENT

> > (I) FOR 7.00 LMT YOU HAVE TO ADD 17.00 MINUTES &

> > (II) 60-13= 47 DEGREE SINCE LONDON IS AT LATTITUDE MORE THAN

MADRAS

> AS AN

> > AVERAGE WE WILL APPLY CORRECTION 47X0.7=33 DEGREES LAT. DIFFERNCE

> > APPROXYMATELY 33 DEGREE TO BE ADDED TO THE RESULT OBTAINED BY

> SOFTWARE OR

> > DEDUCTED FROM MADRAS ASC

> > (III) AT 7.17.00NST

> > THE VALUE IS 26 SCO 50 -AS PER SOFTWARE

> > VERIFICATION FROM MADRAS SARNI

> > DEDUCT 33 DEGREES FROM MADRAS RESULT 1 CP 0 = 28 SCO 00

> > NEAR TO CORRECT 26 SCO 50

> >

> > Now you see for yourself; forget about the degrees even the

Lagna

> changes

> > not by just one Rasi, it changes by two Rasi for a few places.

> > DEAR MIGLANI JI, SARNIS NEVER BE SO INACCURATE AS YOU SAID.

THERE

> MAY BE

> > MINOR ERRORS DUE TO MANUAL CALCULATIONS AND LATITUDINAL

CORRECTIONS.

> > BECAUSE, THE RATE OF CORRECTION CHANGES EVERY 10 DEGREE OF

> LATTITUDE.

> > EVEN FOR THE OPERATION OF THE SOFTWARE YOU NEED TO CHECK THE

> PERIMETERS, THE

> > SOFTWARE IS USING. FOR EXAMPLE MY SOFTWARE TAKES THE STANDARD

TIME

> > DIFFERENCE FOR SINGAPORE AS 7.30 HRS WHILE IT SHUOLD BE 8.00 HRS.

> > HERE 4G THEORY COMES(GIVE GOLD GET GOLD OR GIVE GARBAGE GET

> GARBAGE) IN USE

> > OF SARNI AS WELL AS SOFTWARE

> >

> > This is an answer to your trick.

> > SAMAJHANAY WAALEY SAMAJH GAYE JO NAA SAMJHEY….

> > AAP TO 6-6 SIGNS KAA DIFFERENCE DIKHA RAHAY THAY

> >

> > LET US USE YOUR GROUP's THEORY FOR CHECKING THE CORRECTNESS OF

> SOFTWARE

> > ITSELF

> >

> > YOU CALCULATED THE ASCENDENT FOR OSLO AS

> >

> > CASE I

> > Oslo : 23 Sc 40 [ Brishchik 23 d 40 ] AT 7.00 NST

> > TIME DIFFERENCE FROM INDIA IS 4.30 HRS

> > AS PER YOUR THEORY BRISHCHIK 23SC40 SHALL RISE IN INDIA AT

> > 7.00-4.30=2.30 AM

> > HERE IS THE ASCENDENT IN INDIA AT 2.30 AM ON 13.1.1972

> > TULA 23 DEGREE 9MIN DIFFERENCE OF FULL ONE SIGN

> > CASE 2

> > New York : 22 Sg 22 [ Dhanu 22d22]

> > TIME DIFFERENCE FROM INDIA IS 10.30 HRS

> > AS PER YOUR THEORY Dhanu 22d22 SHALL RISE IN INDIA AT

> > 7.00-10.30=6.30 PM

> > HERE IS THE ASCENDENT IN INDIA AT 2.30 AM ON 13.1.1972

> > KARKA 9 DEGREE 41MIN SOFTWARE GAVE ERROR BY 58 SIGNS

> > SO YOUR THEORY HAS PROVED THAT SOFTWARE IS WRONG & SARNI KA TO

KYA

> KEHNA

> >

> > Therefore we once again reiterate the stand taken by the Lal

Kitab

> > Discussion group that :

> > A Sarini should not be used for places either in India or abroad

> except for

> > the place it has been calculated for and the adjoining places in

> that

> > region.

> > YES YOUR REITRATION IS RIGHT FOR THOSE WHO DONOT KNOW THE BASICS

OF

> > ASTRONOMY & JUST WITH BASIC 'PANDA'KNOWLEDGE PUT FINGER ON THE

> CORRECT DATA

> > AND FORGET THAT THREE FINGERS ARE STILL POINTING TOWARDS THEM

> > Yours truly,

> > Shiv Dev Kalsi

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > On 11/11/07, Punit Pandey <punitp@> wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear Miglani ji,

> > >

> > > Just a small correction that this is NOT the stand taken by

this

> forum.

> > > Everybody is free to use whatever method s/he likes and finds

> working. I

> > > personally prefer to discuss analytical part rather than

> mathematical part

> > > to prove or disprove something. For example, we have

discussing

> it in the

> > > past that astronomically Rahu and Ketu can not be in the same

> house, but

> > > in

> > > Lal Kitab it is true. That doesn't prove Lal Kitab incorrect.

We

> need to

> > > analyse and discuss multipe foreign charts and check its

> applicablitiy.

> > > Based on that only we should conclude something.

> > >

> > > Thanks & Regards,

> > >

> > > Punit Pandey

> > >

> > > On 11/10/07, krishna pal miglani <kpmiglani@<kpmiglani%

> 40.co.in>>

> > > wrote:

> > > >

> > > > Dear Kalsi ji,

> > > >

> > > > If I have understood you correctly you mean to say that :

> > > >

> > > > We should look up for the Ascendant in the sarini for the

same

> time as

> > > > given irrespective of the place of birth.

> > > >

> > > > For example if some one is born at 7 am on January 13, 1972

in

> London,

> > > we

> > > > should look up the Sarini and say that his Lagna would be

Makar

> at one

> > > > degree [ 1Cp0]

> > > >

> > > > Let us examine your contention through a few examples

> > > >

> > > > Date of birth for all the places : January 13, 1972

> > > > Time of birth for all the places : 7 am [ no DST]

> > > >

> > > > Lagna from the Sarini for all the places should be : Makar

at 1

> degree [

> > > > ayanansha correction not done]

> > > >

> > > > Now let us find out the Lagna through software and see how

> correct the

> > > > Lagna from the Sarini is:

> > > >

> > > > Lagna through the software

> > > >

> > > > Madras : 3 Cp 51 [ Makar at 3d51]

> > > >

> > > > Islamabad : 24 Sg 01 [ Dhanu 24d01 ]

> > > > Moscow : 27 Sc 43 [ Brishchik 27d43 ]

> > > > New York : 22 Sg 22 [ Dhanu 22d22]

> > > > Helsinki : 22 Sc 37 [ Brishchik 22d37]

> > > > Singapore : 24 Sg 52 [ Dhanu 24d52]

> > > > London : 9 Sg 58 [ Dhanu at 9d58]

> > > > Oslo : 23 Sc 40 [ Brishchik 23 d 40 ]

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > Now you see for yourself; forget about the degrees even the

> Lagna

> > > changes

> > > > not by just one Rasi, it changes by two Rasi for a few

places.

> > > >

> > > > This is an answer to your trick. Therefore we once again

> reiterate the

> > > > stand taken by the Lal Kitab Discussion group that :

> > > >

> > > > A Sarini should not be used for places either in India or

> abroad except

> > > > for the place it has been calculated for and the adjoining

> places in

> > > that

> > > > region.

> > > >

> > > > Sincerely,

> > > >

> > > > KP Miglani

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > Chat on a cool, new interface. No download required. Click

here.

> > > >

> > > >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...