Guest guest Posted December 19, 2004 Report Share Posted December 19, 2004 Hi Therese, Since 1987 I have been studying western astrology and since a year I have been reading books about Jyotish and joining discussionlists. I must say that most western astrologers I meet work with the geocentric tropical zodiac, so the one that is more or less 23 degrees ahead from the sidereal. I have also met only a few western astrologers who actually use the sidereal positions, like the jyotish do. I must say that they mostly have a broader view, either they are also into jyotish, or astrosophy or even astronomy, because it is hard for traditional western astrologers to let go of the idea that around the 21st of march the sun is in aries. In the Netherlands where I live I only meet western astrologers who want to work with the obsolete tropical calculations of Ptolemy. I am afraid that there aren't many purely western siderealists. Greetings, Anne You wrote: Cynthia and all, When you refer us to a web site, could you please give us the full site address including http?? That way we can just and go there. Otherwise we have to copy, paste and add http//. This will help the more impatient of us move quickly on the web. (All you have to do is go to your recommended site, copy the URL and paste it into your list post.) I'd also like to issue an explanation/apology to those few left who use the pure Fagan-Bradley sidereal system. This list was begun to help others understand that system, but the numbers are against you. There are only a few western siderealists left (all over age 50 or 60?), but the Jyotish people, young and older, are incrasing by the hundreds. We're seeing history in the making as Jyotish concepts become combined with western sidereal tenets. Then we'll have to continue to face the ayanamsa question. This is nothing we can change, just as Jyotish is now absorbing some (correct or incorrect) tropical concepts. Therese Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.