Application of Amsas (Divisions) [1 Attachment]

[Guest guest]

Respected Goel ji,Thank you for sharing you views. I think attachments are not accessible through the group.Kindly forward the text with the post or you may upload the file in the files section.Regards

Neelam2009/10/13 gopal krishna goel <g.k.goel

 

 

 

 

 

[Attachment(s) from gopal krishna goel included below]

 

 

Dear Sreenadh , Chakraborty and Dr. Neelam ji, I am one who favor the use of VARGA CHARTS ,AND NOTED DOWN SOME RULES FOR ASSESSMENT OF VARGA CHARTS  " How to judge the effects from divisional charts "

I earnestly hope it will help in the accessment of varga charts.Regards,G. K. Goel

 

From: sreesog

Tue, 13 Oct 2009 08:35:23 +0000 Re: Application of Amsas (Divisions)

 

 

 

 

Dear Chakraborty ji,

Well said! You got is all correct.

//> There is a request to all. If possible, a Blind chart may please be taken up by the forum. And both sides may use different approaches to show what are the additional informations could be gleaned from use of D-9 charts and whether the additional info is correct or not.

> This will help many a forum member to understand the discussion that is going on for few days.//

I agree to this - but would request you to hold it for some time. Let more info gets poured in, clarity come, let the water get settled and become more clean, let consensus sets in and then we will conduct an Amsa centric blind chart reading. If we does it in a hurry, the focus will shift and we will lose a chance for good amount of information exchange.

Love and regards,

Sreenadh

 

, " Chakraborty, PL " <CHAKRABORTYP2 wrote:

>

> Dear Learned Seniors,

>

> The result of this discussion appears to be....(from an engrs point

> of view only) (To be taken on a lighter vein ONLY)

>

> Sreenadh-ji is saying :

>

> 1) Varga Charts are not sanctioned as per codes and standards.

> Hence can not be used as a part of standard design practices.

> 2) There are no precedents or Code cases relating to such practices.

> 3) The Varga charts are not covered in " recommended good practices "

> in the Codes / Standards

> 4) There are few institutes practising such charts. It appears that they

> have 'extrapolated' data to form such practices. However, the basis

> of such extrapolation is not established.

>

> On the other hand, Neelam-ji and others have slightly different take

>

> 1) The codes / standards are have not clearly banned such uses

> 2) There are few code cases which can be interpreted other-wise

> and prima facie, appears to support varga charts

> 3) Irrespective of Codes/standards, few experts are using such charts

> frequently and getting good results / additional benefits. These

> are Company design practices and may supersede international

> codes. (Like Shell Design Practice may supersede ASME codes

> where Shell is the designer).

>

> There is a request to all. If possible, a Blind chart may please be taken

> up by the forum. And both sides may use different approaches to show

> what are the additional informations could be gleaned from use of D-9 charts

> and whether the additional info is correct or not.

>

> This will help many a forum member to understand the discussion that is

> going on for few days.

>

> regards

>

> Chakraborty

 

 

 

Don’t fall behind. Log on to MSN India for a roundup on the world panorama