RE: TP controversy example (Partha's Accident)

March 23, 2010

Dear Rao Ji,If any prominent event of the life will not be reflected in yearly chart, there is no reason to refer them. These charts are studied along with birth charts.MR. P.S.Iyer of PALGHAT kerla ,explained me in detail in early 80's that the yearly charts based on SOLI-lunar year gives much reliable results.it is my impression that you do not give VIMSOTTARI DASA ITS DUE IMPORTANCE.BPHSwritten many chapter on this dasa alone.I may be wrong. Further , a in depth study is requiredof such karika's as Laghu and Madya Parasari.He met accident in the dasa of Rahu placed in 11H, which is eighth from 11H. Antardasa was of Sunwhich is lord of 9H (6H from 4th) Sun is placed in 12H with Mars karka of accidents.Further,Sun in placed in 2H from Rahu , a marka place from Rahu. Even more Sun is the lord of another Marka house from Rahu. It was writing on the wall that he would certainly met with some serious accident in Rahu/Sun period.BPHS'S CHAPTER 55 ON MAJOR PERIOD OF RAHU SAYS SO.LAGHU PARASARI'S Verses 36 37 ,27 AND 39may be refered:Verse 36-If Rahu is placed in Shubh houses , even benefic planet not having sambandha with noded . will get benefic results according to sub- dasa lord.Verse 37- In the sub-period of benefic lord , the native will get unauspicious results in the dasa of malefic planets.Verse 27 - says MALEFIC PLANET'S DASA MAY ALSO PROBE DEATH INFLICTING.VERSE 39- Even dasa of marka planet does not kill in sub-period of benefic planet/ This is the reason that I slightly rectifird the birth time and accident was self-evident and not the death.Jupiter is 4H lord and on the last degree of sign and in MARKA HOUSE FROM DASA LORD.Jupiter DASA WAS NOT RUNNING . HIS PRYANTAR DASA WAS RUNNING. DASA AND ANTARDASA LORDALWAYS PLANS THE EVENT AND EXCUTION IS ARRANGED IN SUB-SUB PERIOD.There is a dictum that week Lagna lord can give accident.I was giving reply to matured astrological group and was not teaching in the class.Wasit necessary to explain all these details.Surely he must be running . Rahu/Sun / Jup/Jup/Jup.This is the reason that Jupiter could not give protection as per rule given in verse 29 of Laghu Parasari.In chart 20 , given in your book Vedic Astrology , a bad event had occurred in Jupiter/Moon period which is self evident if we follow the rules given in Madya PARASARI. Moon obtainedGemini Navamsa occupied by ketu and placed in 8H.Moon will give set back in marriageaccording to well defined rules in Madhya Parasari.I am a fan of VIMSOTTARI DASA.BESR REGARDS,G. K. Goel

JyotishWritings ; vedic astrology ; From: pvrDate: Fri, 19 Mar 2010 23:10:35 -0400 TP controversy example (Partha's Accident)

Namaste,

Let us look at the Tithi Pravesha chart of 2008-09 for the birthdata given by Partha below. Using standard SJC teachings, annual TP chart is cast for 2008 November 20, 8:24:12 pm (IST), New Delhi. Jupiter's Tithi Ashtottari dasa gave the accident. Jupiter is the 7th and 10th lord in 7th in moolatrikona, joined by the 5th lord and giving a raja yoga. Why did he have a major accident in Jupiter dasa, be bed-ridden for 3 months and why did his career suffer?

Though one can justify any event with any chart or any dasa or any technique by seeing shapes in clouds and beating around the bush, I honestly could not have seen that event in Jupiter dasa in that chart.

* * *

Now, note that Partha was born on *Margasira* Krishna Navami with Sun in Sc. In the TP chart above, Sun is in Sc again, but the tithi is *Karthika* Krishna Navami. Though solar month has been preserved, soli-lunar month (which is the basis for tithis!!!) has not been preserved.

If you make a TP chart strictly using soli-lunar calendar (instead of mixing up soli-lunar days with solar months as taught by Sanjay ji), you will get the annual TP chart on 2008 December 20, 10:02:13 am (IST), New Delhi. That happens to be Margasira Krishna Navami, though Sun is in Sg. In fact, his lunar birthday is celebrated on that day in tradition!

In this chart, Cp rises. Three planets are in the 12th house, whether you use SJC reckoning or the house reckoning I recommend. The 12th lord Jupiter is debilitated and with Rahu. This explains being bed-ridden much better. Saturn is in the 8th house in D-1 and D-30 and the accident occurred in his dasa as per both annual Tithi Ashtottari dasa and annual Vimsottari dasa.

* * *

There is no comparison. This chart explains the events on the ground much better than the version of TP chart given by Sanjay ji's teachings. If you see a TP chart not explaining events well, please try the TP chart based strictly on soli-lunar months ("Preferences", "Related to calculations", "Tithi Prevesha Calculation Options" in JHora). The default in JHora is Sanjay ji's teaching.

As I mentioned before, Sanjay ji was not sure in 1998-99 whether solar or soli-lunar months should be used in TP. He honestly told that to me and asked me to research. We ended up teaching solar month based TP. The result of my research is that solar months should not be mixed up and soli-lunar months should be used.

Best regards,

Narasimha

-------------------------

Free Jyotish Software, Free Jyotish Lessons, Jyotish Writings,

"Do It Yourself" ritual manuals for short Homam and Pitri Tarpana:

http://www.VedicAstrologer.org

Films that make a difference: http://SaraswatiFilms.org

Spirituality:

Jyotish writings: JyotishWritings

-------------------------

sohamsa , Partha Sarathy <partvinu wrote:

> Hi All,

>

> I had an accident last year because of which was bedridden for three months. You

> can use either Narayana dasa or vimshottari to analyse the event for everybody's

> benefit.

> Transits can also be used.

>

> Event: June 11, 2009, 4:45 AM, chennai

>

> Birth particular

> 15/december/1976

> Time: 8 :30 AM

> PLace: New Delhi,

>

> Regards

> Partha

> Dear Goel Sir,

>

> Thank you. Honestly, i was expecting good last year, but everything

> went from bad to worse, no salary for months, bad treatment at office

> compounded matters.

> Anyways, i am waiting for Jupiter dasa, atleast he should provide some

> relief to the nonsense i am facing since 17 years.

>

> Regards

> Partha

All the latest on four wheels and more Get it now.

March 23, 2010

Namaste Goel ji,

Â

But TP itself can work as a stand alone technique, no?

Â

-Regards

Â Rajarshi

--- On Tue, 23/3/10, gopal krishna goel <g.k.goel wrote:

gopal krishna goel <g.k.goel

RE: TP controversy example (Partha's Accident)

, vedic astrology ,

Tuesday, 23 March, 2010, 3:56 PM

Â

Dear Rao Ji,

If any prominent event of the life will not be reflected in yearly chart, there

is no reason

to refer them. These charts are studied along with birth charts.

MR. P.S.Iyer of PALGHAT kerla ,explained me in detail in early 80's that the

yearly charts based on SOLI-lunar year gives much reliable results.

it is my impression that you do not give VIMSOTTARI DASA ITS DUE IMPORTANCE.BPHS

written many chapter on this dasa alone.I may be wrong. Further , a in depth

study is required

of such karika's as Laghu and Madya Parasari.

He met accident in the dasa of Rahu placed in 11H, which is eighth from 11H.

Antardasa was of Sun

which is lord of 9H (6H from 4th) Sun is placed in 12H with Mars karka of

accidents.Further,

Sun in placed in 2H from Rahu , a marka place from Rahu. Even more Sun is the

lord of another Marka house from Rahu. It was writing on the wall that he would

certainly met with some serious accident

in Rahu/Sun period.BPHS' S CHAPTER 55 ON MAJOR PERIOD OF RAHU SAYS SO.

LAGHU PARASARI'S Verses 36 37 ,27 AND 39may be refered:

Verse 36-If Rahu is placed in Shubh houses , even benefic planet not having

sambandha with noded . will get benefic results according to sub- dasa lord.

Verse 37- In the sub-period of benefic lord , the native will get unauspicious

results in the dasa of

malefic planets.

Verse 27 - says MALEFIC PLANET'S DASA MAY ALSO PROBE DEATH INFLICTING.

VERSE 39- Even dasa of marka planet does not kill in sub-period of benefic

planet/

This is the reason that I slightly rectifird the birth time and accident was

self-evident and not the death.

Jupiter is 4H lord and on the last degree of sign and in MARKA HOUSE FROM DASA

LORD.

Jupiter DASA WAS NOT RUNNING . HIS PRYANTAR DASA WAS RUNNING. DASA AND ANTARDASA

LORD

ALWAYS PLANS THE EVENT AND EXCUTION IS ARRANGED IN SUB-SUB PERIOD.

There is a dictum that week Lagna lord can give accident.

I was giving reply to matured astrological group and was not teaching in the

class.Was

it necessary to explain all these details.Surely he must be running . Rahu/Sun /

Jup/Jup/Jup. This is the reason that Jupiter could not give protection as per

rule given in verse 29 of Laghu Parasari.

In chart 20 , given in your book Vedic Astrology , a bad event had occurred in

Jupiter/Moon

period which is self evident if we follow the rules given in Madya PARASARI.

Moon obtained

Gemini Navamsa occupied by ketu and placed in 8H.Moon will give set back in

marriage

according to well defined rules in Madhya Parasari.

I am a fan of VIMSOTTARI DASA.

BESR REGARDS,

G. K. Goel

JyotishWritings; vedic astrology;

pvr (AT) charter (DOT) net

Fri, 19 Mar 2010 23:10:35 -0400

TP controversy example (Partha's Accident)

Namaste,

Let us look at the Tithi Pravesha chart of 2008-09 for the birthdata given by

Partha below. Using standard SJC teachings, annual TP chart is cast for 2008

November 20, 8:24:12 pm (IST), New Delhi. Jupiter's Tithi Ashtottari dasa gave

the accident. Jupiter is the 7th and 10th lord in 7th in moolatrikona, joined by

the 5th lord and giving a raja yoga. Why did he have a major accident in Jupiter

dasa, be bed-ridden for 3 months and why did his career suffer?

Though one can justify any event with any chart or any dasa or any technique by

seeing shapes in clouds and beating around the bush, I honestly could not have

seen that event in Jupiter dasa in that chart.

* * *

Now, note that Partha was born on *Margasira* Krishna Navami with Sun in Sc. In

the TP chart above, Sun is in Sc again, but the tithi is *Karthika* Krishna

Navami. Though solar month has been preserved, soli-lunar month (which is the

basis for tithis!!!) has not been preserved.

If you make a TP chart strictly using soli-lunar calendar (instead of mixing up

soli-lunar days with solar months as taught by Sanjay ji), you will get the

annual TP chart on 2008 December 20, 10:02:13 am (IST), New Delhi. That happens

to be Margasira Krishna Navami, though Sun is in Sg. In fact, his lunar birthday

is celebrated on that day in tradition!

In this chart, Cp rises. Three planets are in the 12th house, whether you use

SJC reckoning or the house reckoning I recommend. The 12th lord Jupiter is

debilitated and with Rahu. This explains being bed-ridden much better. Saturn is

in the 8th house in D-1 and D-30 and the accident occurred in his dasa as per

both annual Tithi Ashtottari dasa and annual Vimsottari dasa.

* * *

There is no comparison. This chart explains the events on the ground much better

than the version of TP chart given by Sanjay ji's teachings. If you see a TP

chart not explaining events well, please try the TP chart based strictly on

soli-lunar months ( " Preferences " , " Related to calculations " , " Tithi Prevesha

Calculation Options " in JHora). The default in JHora is Sanjay ji's teaching.

As I mentioned before, Sanjay ji was not sure in 1998-99 whether solar or

soli-lunar months should be used in TP. He honestly told that to me and asked me

to research. We ended up teaching solar month based TP. The result of my

research is that solar months should not be mixed up and soli-lunar months

should be used.

Best regards,

Narasimha

------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -

Free Jyotish Software, Free Jyotish Lessons, Jyotish Writings,

" Do It Yourself " ritual manuals for short Homam and Pitri Tarpana:

http://www.VedicAst rologer.org

Films that make a difference: http://SaraswatiFil ms.org

Spirituality: http://groups. / group/vedic- wisdom

Jyotish writings: http://groups. / group/JyotishWri tings

------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -

sohamsa@ .com, Partha Sarathy <partvinu@.. .> wrote:

> Hi All,

>

> I had an accident last year because of which was bedridden for three months.

You

> can use either Narayana dasa or vimshottari to analyse the event for

everybody's

> benefit.

> Transits can also be used.

>

> Event: June 11, 2009, 4:45 AM, chennai

>

> Birth particular

> 15/december/ 1976

> Time: 8 :30 AM

> PLace: New Delhi,

>

> Regards

> Partha

> Dear Goel Sir,

>

> Thank you. Honestly, i was expecting good last year, but everything

> went from bad to worse, no salary for months, bad treatment at office

> compounded matters.

> Anyways, i am waiting for Jupiter dasa, atleast he should provide some

> relief to the nonsense i am facing since 17 years.

>

> Regards

> Partha

____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _

The latest songs, trailers and more

http://video. in.msn.com/

March 23, 2010

Namaste Goel saab,

The issue is NOT whether natal Vimsottari dasa shows the event or not. The issue

is whether annual TP chart shows it or not.

The native in question had an accident and was bed-ridden for 3 months. The

annual TP chart (using solar months) does not show it at all. If one says, " the

event happened even though annual TP chart does not shows it, because natal

Vimsottari dasa shows it " , what is the point in even using annual TP charts?

I agree that no technique works in a vacuum and with 100% accuracy. But, any

good technique cannot be so badly off. It has to show an event to some degree or

the other. The exact degree to which an event happens is cumulatively decided by

many factors. But each good factor has to show the event to some degree or the

other.

As I showed, by using soli-lunar months to make annual TP chart, you can see

that 12th lord Jupiter was debilitated and with Rahu and there were afflictions

in 12th, explaining the problem with foot. Dasa of a planet in 8th in rasi and

D-30 gave the accident. Annual TP chart explains the event quite well.

If one sticks to a wrong definition of annual TP chart, one will occasionally

have to abandon it and take recourse to Vimsottari dasa.

* * *

As I said earlier, people do celebrate their soli-lunar birthday based on

soli-lunar month. For example, Lord Rama's birthday is celebrated on the Sukla

Navami tithi of *Chaitra* months and not the Sukla Navami tithi of a specific

solar month (Meena or Mesha). Sun may be in Meena sometimes and Mesha sometimes,

on Sri Rama Navami. Same thing with the birthdays of individuals. Same thing

with annual TP chart.

* * *

Even Sanjay ji was not sure in late 1998 whether solar months or soli-lunar

months should be used. He asked me to research. We ended up teaching solar

months. The theorization that Sun, the soul, provides the anchor and hence Sun

should be in the same sign and be the same Aaditya, was popularized. But

deriving methods based on theorization and then trying to justify them

practically is like putting the bullock cart in front of the bullock. Bullock

should drive the cart and not the other way around. Methods should be derived

and confirmed based on practical working. One can after all theorize *anything*.

Principles should never be determined on the basis of theorization alone.

Best regards,

Narasimha

-

Free Jyotish Software, Free Jyotish Lessons, Jyotish Writings,

" Do It Yourself " ritual manuals for short Homam and Pitri Tarpana:

http://www.VedicAstrologer.org

Films that make a difference: http://SaraswatiFilms.org

Spirituality:

Jyotish writings: JyotishWritings

-

, gopal krishna goel <g.k.goel wrote:

> Dear Rao Ji,

> If any prominent event of the life will not be reflected in yearly chart,

there is no reason

> to refer them. These charts are studied along with birth charts.

> MR. P.S.Iyer of PALGHAT kerla ,explained me in detail in early 80's that the

yearly charts based on SOLI-lunar year gives much reliable results.

> it is my impression that you do not give VIMSOTTARI DASA ITS DUE

IMPORTANCE.BPHS

> written many chapter on this dasa alone.I may be wrong. Further , a in depth

study is required

> of such karika's as Laghu and Madya Parasari.

> He met accident in the dasa of Rahu placed in 11H, which is eighth from 11H.

Antardasa was of Sun

> which is lord of 9H (6H from 4th) Sun is placed in 12H with Mars karka of

accidents.Further,

> Sun in placed in 2H from Rahu , a marka place from Rahu. Even more Sun is the

lord of another Marka house from Rahu. It was writing on the wall that he would

certainly met with some serious accident

> in Rahu/Sun period.BPHS'S CHAPTER 55 ON MAJOR PERIOD OF RAHU SAYS SO.

> LAGHU PARASARI'S Verses 36 37 ,27 AND 39may be refered:

> Verse 36-If Rahu is placed in Shubh houses , even benefic planet not having

sambandha with noded . will get benefic results according to sub- dasa lord.

> Verse 37- In the sub-period of benefic lord , the native will get unauspicious

results in the dasa of

> malefic planets.

> Verse 27 - says MALEFIC PLANET'S DASA MAY ALSO PROBE DEATH INFLICTING.

> VERSE 39- Even dasa of marka planet does not kill in sub-period of benefic

planet/

>

> This is the reason that I slightly rectifird the birth time and accident was

self-evident and not the death.

> Jupiter is 4H lord and on the last degree of sign and in MARKA HOUSE FROM DASA

LORD.

> Jupiter DASA WAS NOT RUNNING . HIS PRYANTAR DASA WAS RUNNING. DASA AND

ANTARDASA LORD

> ALWAYS PLANS THE EVENT AND EXCUTION IS ARRANGED IN SUB-SUB PERIOD.

> There is a dictum that week Lagna lord can give accident.

> I was giving reply to matured astrological group and was not teaching in the

class.Was

> it necessary to explain all these details.Surely he must be running . Rahu/Sun

/ Jup/Jup/Jup.This is the reason that Jupiter could not give protection as per

rule given in verse 29 of Laghu Parasari.

>

> In chart 20 , given in your book Vedic Astrology , a bad event had occurred in

Jupiter/Moon

> period which is self evident if we follow the rules given in Madya PARASARI.

Moon obtained

> Gemini Navamsa occupied by ketu and placed in 8H.Moon will give set back in

marriage

> according to well defined rules in Madhya Parasari.

> I am a fan of VIMSOTTARI DASA.

> BESR REGARDS,

>

> G. K. Goel

>

> JyotishWritings ; vedic astrology ;

> pvr

> Fri, 19 Mar 2010 23:10:35 -0400

> TP controversy example (Partha's Accident)

>

> Namaste,

>

> Let us look at the Tithi Pravesha chart of 2008-09 for the birthdata given by

Partha below. Using standard SJC teachings, annual TP chart is cast for 2008

November 20, 8:24:12 pm (IST), New Delhi. Jupiter's Tithi Ashtottari dasa gave

the accident. Jupiter is the 7th and 10th lord in 7th in moolatrikona, joined by

the 5th lord and giving a raja yoga. Why did he have a major accident in Jupiter

dasa, be bed-ridden for 3 months and why did his career suffer?

>

> Though one can justify any event with any chart or any dasa or any technique

by seeing shapes in clouds and beating around the bush, I honestly could not

have seen that event in Jupiter dasa in that chart.

>

> * * *

>

> Now, note that Partha was born on *Margasira* Krishna Navami with Sun in Sc.

In the TP chart above, Sun is in Sc again, but the tithi is *Karthika* Krishna

Navami. Though solar month has been preserved, soli-lunar month (which is the

basis for tithis!!!) has not been preserved.

>

> If you make a TP chart strictly using soli-lunar calendar (instead of mixing

up soli-lunar days with solar months as taught by Sanjay ji), you will get the

annual TP chart on 2008 December 20, 10:02:13 am (IST), New Delhi. That happens

to be Margasira Krishna Navami, though Sun is in Sg. In fact, his lunar birthday

is celebrated on that day in tradition!

>

> In this chart, Cp rises. Three planets are in the 12th house, whether you use

SJC reckoning or the house reckoning I recommend. The 12th lord Jupiter is

debilitated and with Rahu. This explains being bed-ridden much better. Saturn is

in the 8th house in D-1 and D-30 and the accident occurred in his dasa as per

both annual Tithi Ashtottari dasa and annual Vimsottari dasa.

>

> * * *

>

> There is no comparison. This chart explains the events on the ground much

better than the version of TP chart given by Sanjay ji's teachings. If you see a

TP chart not explaining events well, please try the TP chart based strictly on

soli-lunar months ( " Preferences " , " Related to calculations " , " Tithi Prevesha

Calculation Options " in JHora). The default in JHora is Sanjay ji's teaching.

>

> As I mentioned before, Sanjay ji was not sure in 1998-99 whether solar or

soli-lunar months should be used in TP. He honestly told that to me and asked me

to research. We ended up teaching solar month based TP. The result of my

research is that solar months should not be mixed up and soli-lunar months

should be used.

>

> Best regards,

>

> Narasimha

>

> -------------------------

>

> Free Jyotish Software, Free Jyotish Lessons, Jyotish Writings,

>

> " Do It Yourself " ritual manuals for short Homam and Pitri Tarpana:

>

> http://www.VedicAstrologer.org

>

> Films that make a difference: http://SaraswatiFilms.org

>

> Spirituality:

>

> Jyotish writings: JyotishWritings

>

> -------------------------

>

> sohamsa , Partha Sarathy <partvinu@> wrote:

>

> > Hi All,

>

> >

>

> > I had an accident last year because of which was bedridden for three months.

You

>

> > can use either Narayana dasa or vimshottari to analyse the event for

everybody's

>

> > benefit.

>

> > Transits can also be used.

>

> >

>

> > Event: June 11, 2009, 4:45 AM, chennai

>

> >

>

> > Birth particular

>

> > 15/december/1976

>

> > Time: 8 :30 AM

>

> > PLace: New Delhi,

>

> >

>

> > Regards

>

> > Partha

>

> > Dear Goel Sir,

>

> >

>

> > Thank you. Honestly, i was expecting good last year, but everything

>

> > went from bad to worse, no salary for months, bad treatment at office

>

> > compounded matters.

>

> > Anyways, i am waiting for Jupiter dasa, atleast he should provide some

>

> > relief to the nonsense i am facing since 17 years.

>

> >

>

> > Regards

>

> > Partha

March 23, 2010

The Tithi Pravesha Chakra of 2008-09 clearly shows the event if we are prepared

to look for it. All standard jyotish rules must be used in the Tithi Pravesh

charts as taught by me in the past at SJC and in particular to Narasimha.

Rashi TP 2008

Navamsha TP 2008

1.. Natal Chart of Partha Sarathy has Dhanus Lagna while the TP 2008-09 has

Mithuna Lagna which is not only the maraka bhava but also the badhaka bhava for

the chart. Therefore in the year 2008-09 mixed results will prevail with the 7th

house indicating the events to come.

2.. Lagnesha Mercury is in the 6th house of accidents and suffering and is

severely afflicted by two agni tattva planets Mars and Sun. This shows

astra-aghata and will surely bring operation or cutting of the body if other

factors also indicate so.

3.. Jupiter is the badhakesha of the chart and is well placed in own sign in

Hamsa yoga with mantresha Shukra indicating a period when he shall have lot of

time to do mantra japa. However the manner in which this will come about may not

be good as Jupiter is in badhaka sign as badhakesh and is in Ghataka Nakshatra

from Simha rashi [Purva Ashadha is ghataka for Simha]. The Moon is another

maraka and is afflicted by Saturn. Now both Saturn and Jupiter, the two

tormentors of the Moon as 8th lord (Sat) and badhaka in ghataka nakshatra (Jup)

are in Scorpio Navamsha. Thus, Jupiter is in Roga-amsha I.e. navamsha of the

sign in the 6th house of the rashi chart and as per Rasi-Tulya-Amsha, Jupiter

will indicate accidents and such other adverse results.

4.. Further, Jupiter is under severe papa-kartari yoga between Mars and Sun on

the one side and Rahu in the 8th house , on the other side.

5.. There is unbroken Kala Sarpa Yoga working on this chart for the year

2008-09 along the Rudra Axis = 2-8th house axis which is very dangerous. There

is no breakage at all for the KSY and the native will have to suffer it.

Timing of the event

a.. Tithi Ashtottari Dasha: The event happened exactly when the maraka (7th)

bhava functioned in Jupiter dasha-Venus antardasa having the papa-kartari yoga.

b.. Narayana Dasha: Exactly on the date Virgo dasha started with Mandi in it

in Sagittarius antardasha. In the Navamsha, Virgo is 7th house with Mars in MKS

and Sagittarius has Ketu showing accidents. In D1, we have already seen how Sg

is geared for the event due to the Papa kartari Yoga.

c.. Vimsottari dasa: (Personally I like this dasha very much). Jupiter dasha

Saturn antardasha. See the arguments to the Moon affliction. Any affliction to

the Moon will surely bring health related issues.

So how can we say that the TP chart is not right or not working. On the other

hand what is being suggested as a modification is that the Lunar months alone be

used. If that be so, then people born in Adhika/Mala maasa will actually have

birthdays falling in every few years unless we stretch the rules to accommodate

them in the regular Lunar months.

The traditional system, as I have learnt it, requires the Sun to be the same as

*Sarvaatma Divakara - Sun is the representation of the soul and this cannot

change in one body*. This is the Aditya who brings us to this planet and is

responsible for us continued existence. We have to respect its boundaries -

these are of 30 degrees each. So, if I am born with the Sun in Cancer, it must

remain so.

In fact the Greek Astrology [Tajika jyotish] uses this in a very strict manner

in which the (1) Sun is brought back to the exact degree-minute of longitude for

Annual returns.

However, we in Vedic use (1) Sun return to the same sign instead of exact degree

and (2) Sun-Moon angle = Tithi and Karana to be the same.

What Narasimha is suggesting is to drop (1) Sun factor altogether and only use

factor (2).

No harm in testing this, but one must use standard jyotish rules to test the

validity of the traditional system before replacing it with a new one.

Regards

Sanjay Rath

Narasimha PVR Rao

Wednesday, March 24, 2010 3:51 AM

vedic astrology ; ;

JyotishWritings

[vedic astrology] Re: TP controversy example (Partha's Accident)