Guest guest Posted June 7, 2009 Report Share Posted June 7, 2009 Dear Respected Members, I am student of lal kitab. and very new to this group. Can anyone explain what and which is mahadasha according to lal kitab? What method should be followed to find mahadasha according to lal kitab? In what manner it effects on native chart? Like in Parashari jyotish " Vimshottari Dasha " is followed and it is calculated by the moon's constellation. Is lal kitab mahadasha is different from vimshottari dasha, how it is calculated, is it different from 35 saala chakkar. Is lal kitab mahadasha starts from janam waqt ka griha or it is starts by daurey ka griha? I am confused about this. Please honourable research scholars help me and get me out of this problem. Chetan Sud (Student) c_p_s23 chetansud23 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 7, 2009 Report Share Posted June 7, 2009 Dear Chetan ji, This was one of the controvertial topics in this forum in the past. I would suggest seraching this forum archive for getting more information. Lal Kitab is not very clear on what should be the starting planet in Lal Kitab dasa cycle. Truly speaking I have not seen any successful application of Lal Kitab dasa that starts with janma waqt ka graha/ janma samaya ka graha. There is huge debate on this topic in the past and in absense of any practical example, we were not able to conclude anything. There are various calculation methods suggested. According to one method, the powerful planet among janma waqt ka graha and janma samaya ka graha etc. will be the first starting planet in Lal Kitab dasa. According to another method, the first planet that will come to the lagna according to varshphal table in the upcoming years will be the starting planet for the Lal Kitab dasa. Though I find static Lal Kitab dasa (always starting from Saturn) pretty useful. In Lal Kitab you will get some examples, where event related to a planet happened in the dasa period of the planet. For example the planet is Sun, you will see the happenings related to Sun at the age of 22, or 11 (half of 22), or 44 (double of 22) and so on. Try to use it in conjunction of Lal Kitab varshphal and you will get good result. Also sometimes it is suggested to adjust dasa according to a major event for your life. For example, if somebody married at the at of 23, Venus dasa will be taken starting from that age and next dasa period will be taken according to 35 year cycle. These are few of the methods without and controversy and I would suggest using these methods. Thanks & Regards, Punit Pandey On Sun, Jun 7, 2009 at 9:44 PM, c_p_s23 <c_p_s23 wrote: > > > Dear Respected Members, > > I am student of lal kitab. and very new to this group. Can anyone explain > what and which is mahadasha according to lal kitab? What method should be > followed to find mahadasha according to lal kitab? In what manner it effects > on native chart? Like in Parashari jyotish " Vimshottari Dasha " is followed > and it is calculated by the moon's constellation. > > Is lal kitab mahadasha is different from vimshottari dasha, how it is > calculated, is it different from 35 saala chakkar. Is lal kitab mahadasha > starts from janam waqt ka griha or it is starts by daurey ka griha? I am > confused about this. Please honourable research scholars help me and get me > out of this problem. > > Chetan Sud (Student) > c_p_s23 <c_p_s23%40> > chetansud23 <chetansud23%40gmail.com> > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 8, 2009 Report Share Posted June 8, 2009 Dear Punit Ji, Thanks for your valuable suggestion. I'll keep this in my mind. I also folllow this method. Punit ji one more question. Which remedies should be followed? Whether of Natal Chart or Varshphal chart or both? Please explain that according to red book bhavas have their own aspects & according to mahadasha chapter of red book it says that planets also have their aspects? which aspects is important, aspects of houses or aspects of planets and when these aspect is applicable? Chetan Sud (Student) lalkitab , Punit Pandey <punitp wrote: > > Dear Chetan ji, > > This was one of the controvertial topics in this forum in the past. I would > suggest seraching this forum archive for getting more information. Lal Kitab > is not very clear on what should be the starting planet in Lal Kitab dasa > cycle. Truly speaking I have not seen any successful application of Lal > Kitab dasa that starts with janma waqt ka graha/ janma samaya ka graha. > There is huge debate on this topic in the past and in absense of any > practical example, we were not able to conclude anything. There are various > calculation methods suggested. According to one method, the powerful planet > among janma waqt ka graha and janma samaya ka graha etc. will be the first > starting planet in Lal Kitab dasa. According to another method, the first > planet that will come to the lagna according to varshphal table in the > upcoming years will be the starting planet for the Lal Kitab dasa. > > Though I find static Lal Kitab dasa (always starting from Saturn) pretty > useful. In Lal Kitab you will get some examples, where event related to a > planet happened in the dasa period of the planet. For example the planet is > Sun, you will see the happenings related to Sun at the age of 22, or 11 > (half of 22), or 44 (double of 22) and so on. Try to use it in conjunction > of Lal Kitab varshphal and you will get good result. Also sometimes it is > suggested to adjust dasa according to a major event for your life. For > example, if somebody married at the at of 23, Venus dasa will be taken > starting from that age and next dasa period will be taken according to 35 > year cycle. These are few of the methods without and controversy and I would > suggest using these methods. > > Thanks & Regards, > > Punit Pandey > > > On Sun, Jun 7, 2009 at 9:44 PM, c_p_s23 <c_p_s23 wrote: > > > > > > > Dear Respected Members, > > > > I am student of lal kitab. and very new to this group. Can anyone explain > > what and which is mahadasha according to lal kitab? What method should be > > followed to find mahadasha according to lal kitab? In what manner it effects > > on native chart? Like in Parashari jyotish " Vimshottari Dasha " is followed > > and it is calculated by the moon's constellation. > > > > Is lal kitab mahadasha is different from vimshottari dasha, how it is > > calculated, is it different from 35 saala chakkar. Is lal kitab mahadasha > > starts from janam waqt ka griha or it is starts by daurey ka griha? I am > > confused about this. Please honourable research scholars help me and get me > > out of this problem. > > > > Chetan Sud (Student) > > c_p_s23 <c_p_s23%40> > > chetansud23 <chetansud23%40gmail.com> > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2009 Report Share Posted June 9, 2009 respected punit ji, I think chetan is after " grah ki mahadasha " which gives continous bad effects on the native for a long period of time. actually i was wondering if you can elaborate it as i am little confused too with " mahadasha " in lal kitab. looking forward to learn from you. Sincerely Jitin syallalkitab , " c_p_s23 " <c_p_s23 wrote: > > Dear Punit Ji, > > Thanks for your valuable suggestion. I'll keep this in my mind. I also folllow this method. Punit ji one more question. Which remedies should be followed? Whether of Natal Chart or Varshphal chart or both? Please explain that according to red book bhavas have their own aspects & according to mahadasha chapter of red book it says that planets also have their aspects? which aspects is important, aspects of houses or aspects of planets and when these aspect is applicable? > > Chetan Sud (Student) > > lalkitab , Punit Pandey <punitp@> wrote: > > > > Dear Chetan ji, > > > > This was one of the controvertial topics in this forum in the past. I would > > suggest seraching this forum archive for getting more information. Lal Kitab > > is not very clear on what should be the starting planet in Lal Kitab dasa > > cycle. Truly speaking I have not seen any successful application of Lal > > Kitab dasa that starts with janma waqt ka graha/ janma samaya ka graha. > > There is huge debate on this topic in the past and in absense of any > > practical example, we were not able to conclude anything. There are various > > calculation methods suggested. According to one method, the powerful planet > > among janma waqt ka graha and janma samaya ka graha etc. will be the first > > starting planet in Lal Kitab dasa. According to another method, the first > > planet that will come to the lagna according to varshphal table in the > > upcoming years will be the starting planet for the Lal Kitab dasa. > > > > Though I find static Lal Kitab dasa (always starting from Saturn) pretty > > useful. In Lal Kitab you will get some examples, where event related to a > > planet happened in the dasa period of the planet. For example the planet is > > Sun, you will see the happenings related to Sun at the age of 22, or 11 > > (half of 22), or 44 (double of 22) and so on. Try to use it in conjunction > > of Lal Kitab varshphal and you will get good result. Also sometimes it is > > suggested to adjust dasa according to a major event for your life. For > > example, if somebody married at the at of 23, Venus dasa will be taken > > starting from that age and next dasa period will be taken according to 35 > > year cycle. These are few of the methods without and controversy and I would > > suggest using these methods. > > > > Thanks & Regards, > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > > > On Sun, Jun 7, 2009 at 9:44 PM, c_p_s23 <c_p_s23@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Respected Members, > > > > > > I am student of lal kitab. and very new to this group. Can anyone explain > > > what and which is mahadasha according to lal kitab? What method should be > > > followed to find mahadasha according to lal kitab? In what manner it effects > > > on native chart? Like in Parashari jyotish " Vimshottari Dasha " is followed > > > and it is calculated by the moon's constellation. > > > > > > Is lal kitab mahadasha is different from vimshottari dasha, how it is > > > calculated, is it different from 35 saala chakkar. Is lal kitab mahadasha > > > starts from janam waqt ka griha or it is starts by daurey ka griha? I am > > > confused about this. Please honourable research scholars help me and get me > > > out of this problem. > > > > > > Chetan Sud (Student) > > > c_p_s23@ <c_p_s23%40> > > > chetansud23@ <chetansud23%40gmail.com> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 30, 2009 Report Share Posted June 30, 2009 dear punit, a little which i understand, a) janam waqt ka greh and janamdin ka greh, theory is for the planet of janamdin ka greh which is of rashi fal, and janam waqt ka greh which is of greh phal wala, this is completly different theory, it is useful when u advice upaya but it doesnot give any good result, how say a person born on sunday (janam din-rashi fal) and the time is 8 to 10 (time of sun-greh phal)but in plantery position the sun is situated in 12 the house or may be somewhere else where it is uapaable. here no upaya is adviceable as this greh greh-phal wala ho gaya and no upaya will work here. but if time is of jupiter then any problem related to sun or jupiter will be covered with the upaya of sun. b)35 sala chakkar, the balance dasha yog (LK has given saturn example) is for calculatig when the 35 sala chakkar will be completed. c) the lal kitab theory(my understanding) says the mahadasha would be of as per ancient theory (vish..dasha wali), but if in between any planets bad effect starts coming in that will be sign of that planets mahadasha.... if cross check few tewa then this theory may also be use full. every palnets effect has been divided into three phases (very starting chepters) where the middle period if of its own effect. if we try to pick that and work reverse the theory will get cleared. one example. shuker maha dasha(3rd year).....a person construct house (sign of saturn)now u check the placement of saturn in the tewa if it is well placed it means its seventh + year of saturn (divide 18 year by 3) lalkitab , " jitinsyal82 " <jitinsyal82 wrote: > > respected punit ji, > I think chetan is after " grah ki mahadasha " which gives continous bad effects on the native for a long period of time. actually i was wondering if you can elaborate it as i am little confused too with " mahadasha " in lal kitab. > looking forward to learn from you. > > Sincerely > Jitin syallalkitab , " c_p_s23 " <c_p_s23@> wrote: > > > > Dear Punit Ji, > > > > Thanks for your valuable suggestion. I'll keep this in my mind. I also folllow this method. Punit ji one more question. Which remedies should be followed? Whether of Natal Chart or Varshphal chart or both? Please explain that according to red book bhavas have their own aspects & according to mahadasha chapter of red book it says that planets also have their aspects? which aspects is important, aspects of houses or aspects of planets and when these aspect is applicable? > > > > Chetan Sud (Student) > > > > lalkitab , Punit Pandey <punitp@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Chetan ji, > > > > > > This was one of the controvertial topics in this forum in the past. I would > > > suggest seraching this forum archive for getting more information. Lal Kitab > > > is not very clear on what should be the starting planet in Lal Kitab dasa > > > cycle. Truly speaking I have not seen any successful application of Lal > > > Kitab dasa that starts with janma waqt ka graha/ janma samaya ka graha. > > > There is huge debate on this topic in the past and in absense of any > > > practical example, we were not able to conclude anything. There are various > > > calculation methods suggested. According to one method, the powerful planet > > > among janma waqt ka graha and janma samaya ka graha etc. will be the first > > > starting planet in Lal Kitab dasa. According to another method, the first > > > planet that will come to the lagna according to varshphal table in the > > > upcoming years will be the starting planet for the Lal Kitab dasa. > > > > > > Though I find static Lal Kitab dasa (always starting from Saturn) pretty > > > useful. In Lal Kitab you will get some examples, where event related to a > > > planet happened in the dasa period of the planet. For example the planet is > > > Sun, you will see the happenings related to Sun at the age of 22, or 11 > > > (half of 22), or 44 (double of 22) and so on. Try to use it in conjunction > > > of Lal Kitab varshphal and you will get good result. Also sometimes it is > > > suggested to adjust dasa according to a major event for your life. For > > > example, if somebody married at the at of 23, Venus dasa will be taken > > > starting from that age and next dasa period will be taken according to 35 > > > year cycle. These are few of the methods without and controversy and I would > > > suggest using these methods. > > > > > > Thanks & Regards, > > > > > > Punit Pandey > > > > > > > > > On Sun, Jun 7, 2009 at 9:44 PM, c_p_s23 <c_p_s23@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dear Respected Members, > > > > > > > > I am student of lal kitab. and very new to this group. Can anyone explain > > > > what and which is mahadasha according to lal kitab? What method should be > > > > followed to find mahadasha according to lal kitab? In what manner it effects > > > > on native chart? Like in Parashari jyotish " Vimshottari Dasha " is followed > > > > and it is calculated by the moon's constellation. > > > > > > > > Is lal kitab mahadasha is different from vimshottari dasha, how it is > > > > calculated, is it different from 35 saala chakkar. Is lal kitab mahadasha > > > > starts from janam waqt ka griha or it is starts by daurey ka griha? I am > > > > confused about this. Please honourable research scholars help me and get me > > > > out of this problem. > > > > > > > > Chetan Sud (Student) > > > > c_p_s23@ <c_p_s23%40> > > > > chetansud23@ <chetansud23%40gmail.com> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.