Guest guest Posted December 8, 2009 Report Share Posted December 8, 2009 Dear All respected, I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. why is this? Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna is determined by the sunrise? The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage etc.... for the benefit of people like me. What do you think? Thanks MANNI Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2009 Report Share Posted December 8, 2009 sir, pranam to all gurujans, To help new commers start lal kitab ,migrate slowly from parasari system, I wish to suggest that a team or a few seniors should start a small guide to help new students to learn lal kitab and practce for the benefit of all man kind. With best wishes - H Balakrishna Mysore India lalkitab , " Manni " wrote: > > Dear > > All respected, > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. why is this? > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna is determined by the sunrise? > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > What do you think? > > Thanks > > MANNI > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2009 Report Share Posted December 8, 2009 Manni ji; Since it is your first book on lalkitab; follow it in the way that; Just assume all the horoscopes to be of aries lagan; Study further; if and whenever you are confused or have a question; post it here; you will get a ready reply; happy learning; wish you all the best. Regards Kulbir. lalkitab , " Manni " wrote: > > Dear > > All respected, > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. why is this? > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna is determined by the sunrise? > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > What do you think? > > Thanks > > MANNI > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2009 Report Share Posted December 8, 2009 Hello Kulbir Ji and all    Is this the only book, at the time of Ravan it might have written in Sanskrit and each author as its own way of translating it. Can you please refer to a best available book in either in English or Hindi  Thanks RAHULSHARMA Jai Shri Ganesh Gajaananam bhoodha ghanaathi sevitham kabhitha jamboo palasara pakshitham umaasutham sokha vinaasakaranam namaami vigneswara paadha pankajam --- On Tue, 12/8/09, kulbir <kulbirbains wrote: kulbir <kulbirbains [lalkitab] Re: Learning topic suggestions lalkitab Tuesday, December 8, 2009, 9:02 AM  Manni ji; Since it is your first book on lalkitab; follow it in the way that; Just assume all the horoscopes to be of aries lagan; Study further; if and whenever you are confused or have a question; post it here; you will get a ready reply; happy learning; wish you all the best. Regards Kulbir. lalkitab@ s.com, " Manni " <manni7rehal@ ...> wrote: > > Dear > > All respected, > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. why is this? > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna is determined by the sunrise? > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > What do you think? > > Thanks > > MANNI > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2009 Report Share Posted December 8, 2009 That will be great if some one can do it.. RAHULSHARMA Jai Shri Ganesh Gajaananam bhoodha ghanaathi sevitham kabhitha jamboo palasara pakshitham umaasutham sokha vinaasakaranam namaami vigneswara paadha pankajam --- On Tue, 12/8/09, hundraj_balakrishna <hbalakrishna wrote: hundraj_balakrishna <hbalakrishna [lalkitab] Re: Learning topic suggestions lalkitab Tuesday, December 8, 2009, 8:41 AM Â sir, pranam to all gurujans, To help new commers start lal kitab ,migrate slowly from parasari system, I wish to suggest that a team or a few seniors should start a small guide to help new students to learn lal kitab and practce for the benefit of all man kind. With best wishes - H Balakrishna Mysore India lalkitab@ s.com, " Manni " <manni7rehal@ ...> wrote: > > Dear > > All respected, > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. why is this? > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna is determined by the sunrise? > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > What do you think? > > Thanks > > MANNI > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 8, 2009 Report Share Posted December 8, 2009 Hi Kulbir ji,  Many thanks, it quite interesting the chapter on the 35 year cycle is confusing, but what i plan to do is read the book all first, then start reading it again and this time more thorough and also with the help of all learned people here in this forum.  Many thanks  Manni --- On Tue, 8/12/09, kulbir <kulbirbains wrote: kulbir <kulbirbains [lalkitab] Re: Learning topic suggestions lalkitab Tuesday, 8 December, 2009, 17:02  Manni ji; Since it is your first book on lalkitab; follow it in the way that; Just assume all the horoscopes to be of aries lagan; Study further; if and whenever you are confused or have a question; post it here; you will get a ready reply; happy learning; wish you all the best. Regards Kulbir. lalkitab@ s.com, " Manni " <manni7rehal@ ...> wrote: > > Dear > > All respected, > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. why is this? > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna is determined by the sunrise? > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > What do you think? > > Thanks > > MANNI > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2009 Report Share Posted December 9, 2009 Dear seniors I second that too! I am curious to learn about LK but dont know where to start. Even though i can read in hindi i still prefer in english. Where do beginners start? thank you kiran 2009/12/9 hundraj_balakrishna <hbalakrishna > > > > sir, > pranam to all gurujans, > > To help new commers start lal kitab ,migrate slowly from parasari system, I > wish to suggest that a team or a few seniors should start a small guide to > help new students to learn lal kitab and practce for the benefit of all man > kind. > > With best wishes - H Balakrishna Mysore India > > lalkitab <lalkitab%40>, " Manni " > wrote: > > > > Dear > > > > All respected, > > > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you > dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. > why is this? > > > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient > atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna > is determined by the sunrise? > > > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is > that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage > etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > > > What do you think? > > > > Thanks > > > > MANNI > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2009 Report Share Posted December 9, 2009 Rahul ji; Lalkitb comprises of 5 books 1. Samudrik Ki Lalkitab Ke Farmaan, published in 1939 AD; 2. Samudrik Ki Lalkitab Ke Armaan, published in 1940 AD: 3. Lalkitab Teesra Hissa published, in 1941 AD: 4. Lalkitab Tarmeemshuda published, in 1942 AD; 5. Ilm-e Samudrik ki buniyad par jyotish ki Lalkitab published in 1952 AD. The books have photograph of Pt. Sharma Girdhari Lal; resident of Pharwala depicting him as printer and publisher and the name of Shri Aatma Ram Sharma resident of Tehsil Noorpur; District Kangra is mentioned as Katib ( calighrapher, composer script-writter). The books were printed at Jahaazi Press, Lahore and contact address mentioned is of Calcutta Photo Shop; Amritsar; Calcutta Photo Shop; Dharmshala; Kangra. Calcutta Photo Shop. The author of these books is Pt. Rup Chand Joshi son of Shri Jyoti Ram Joshi resident of Village Pharwala, District Jalandhar; Punjab; Date of birth 18-01-1898; or 10-5-1898; Pt. Ji served in Defense accounts and retired as Assistant Accounts officer. He was posted at different places in India e.g Lahore, Dharamshal, Bombay, Madras, Ambala, Shimla. During his service tenure. He expired on 24-12-1982. Pt. Girdhari lal Sharma ji and Pt Rup Chand joshi ji were first cousins. So no connection with Ravana; Could you please translate the shalok that you have written. Regards Kulbir. lalkitab , Rahul Sharma <toneyrahulsharma wrote: > > Hello Kulbir Ji and all > Â > Â Â Is this the only book, at the time of Ravan it might have written in Sanskrit and each author as its own way of translating it. Can you please refer to a best available book in either in English or Hindi > Â > Thanks > > > > RAHULSHARMA > Jai Shri Ganesh > Gajaananam bhoodha ghanaathi sevitham > kabhitha jamboo palasara pakshitham > umaasutham sokha vinaasakaranam > namaami vigneswara paadha pankajam > > --- On Tue, 12/8/09, kulbir <kulbirbains wrote: > > > kulbir <kulbirbains > [lalkitab] Re: Learning topic suggestions > lalkitab > Tuesday, December 8, 2009, 9:02 AM > > > Â > > > > Manni ji; Since it is your first book on lalkitab; > follow it in the way that; > Just assume all the horoscopes to be of aries lagan; > Study further; > if and whenever you are confused or have a question; post it here; you will get a ready reply; > happy learning; > wish you all the best. > Regards > Kulbir. > > lalkitab@ s.com, " Manni " <manni7rehal@ ...> wrote: > > > > Dear > > > > All respected, > > > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. why is this? > > > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna is determined by the sunrise? > > > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > > > What do you think? > > > > Thanks > > > > MANNI > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2009 Report Share Posted December 9, 2009 Balakkrishnaji; Kiran ji; Rahul ji; i too want to learn in a systematic way and have some plans for it; we can form a group of those interested in the study right from beginning, here only; added benefit would be that since all seniors are members of this group; they can monitor or at least send in their inputs; guidance; experiences etc. from time to time. lets hear what Punit ji has to say; if he approves; we can start it shortly. Regards Kulbir. lalkitab , Kiran Akbar <reiki.kiran wrote: > > Dear seniors > I second that too! I am curious to learn about LK but dont know where to > start. Even though i can read in hindi i still prefer in english. Where do > beginners start? > thank you > kiran > 2009/12/9 hundraj_balakrishna <hbalakrishna > > > > > > > > > sir, > > pranam to all gurujans, > > > > To help new commers start lal kitab ,migrate slowly from parasari system, I > > wish to suggest that a team or a few seniors should start a small guide to > > help new students to learn lal kitab and practce for the benefit of all man > > kind. > > > > With best wishes - H Balakrishna Mysore India > > > > lalkitab <lalkitab%40>, " Manni " > > wrote: > > > > > > Dear > > > > > > All respected, > > > > > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > > > > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you > > dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. > > why is this? > > > > > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient > > atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna > > is determined by the sunrise? > > > > > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is > > that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage > > etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > > > > > What do you think? > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > MANNI > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2009 Report Share Posted December 9, 2009 Dear Rahul ji, As correctly mentioned by Kulbir ji, there is no connection between Ravan Samhita and Lal Kitab. Both are independent texts and only similarity is that both of these cover much more than just birth chart analysis. For more information, read articles on my blog at http://www.lalkitab.in/. Thanks & Regards, Punit Pandey On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 2:52 PM, kulbir <kulbirbains wrote: > > > > Rahul ji; > > Lalkitb comprises of 5 books > 1. Samudrik Ki Lalkitab Ke Farmaan, published in 1939 AD; > 2. Samudrik Ki Lalkitab Ke Armaan, published in 1940 AD: > 3. Lalkitab Teesra Hissa published, in 1941 AD: > 4. Lalkitab Tarmeemshuda published, in 1942 AD; > 5. Ilm-e Samudrik ki buniyad par jyotish ki Lalkitab published in 1952 AD. > The books have photograph of Pt. Sharma Girdhari Lal; resident of Pharwala > depicting him as printer and publisher and the name of Shri Aatma Ram Sharma > resident of Tehsil Noorpur; District Kangra is mentioned as Katib ( > calighrapher, composer script-writter). > The books were printed at Jahaazi Press, Lahore and contact address > mentioned is of Calcutta Photo Shop; Amritsar; Calcutta Photo Shop; > Dharmshala; Kangra. Calcutta Photo Shop. > The author of these books is Pt. Rup Chand Joshi son of Shri Jyoti Ram > Joshi resident of Village Pharwala, District Jalandhar; Punjab; Date of > birth 18-01-1898; or 10-5-1898; Pt. Ji served in Defense accounts and > retired as Assistant Accounts officer. He was posted at different places in > India e.g Lahore, Dharamshal, Bombay, Madras, Ambala, Shimla. During his > service tenure. He expired on 24-12-1982. > > Pt. Girdhari lal Sharma ji and Pt Rup Chand joshi ji were first cousins. > > So no connection with Ravana; > Could you please translate the shalok that you have written. > > Regards > Kulbir. > > > lalkitab <lalkitab%40>, Rahul Sharma > <toneyrahulsharma wrote: > > > > Hello Kulbir Ji and all > > Â > > Â Â Is this the only book, at the time of Ravan it might have written in > Sanskrit and each author as its own way of translating it. Can you please > refer to a best available book in either in English or Hindi > > Â > > > Thanks > > > > > > > > RAHULSHARMA > > Jai Shri Ganesh > > Gajaananam bhoodha ghanaathi sevitham > > kabhitha jamboo palasara pakshitham > > umaasutham sokha vinaasakaranam > > namaami vigneswara paadha pankajam > > > > --- On Tue, 12/8/09, kulbir <kulbirbains wrote: > > > > > > kulbir <kulbirbains > > > [lalkitab] Re: Learning topic suggestions > > lalkitab <lalkitab%40> > > Tuesday, December 8, 2009, 9:02 AM > > > > > > Â > > > > > > > > Manni ji; Since it is your first book on lalkitab; > > follow it in the way that; > > Just assume all the horoscopes to be of aries lagan; > > Study further; > > if and whenever you are confused or have a question; post it here; you > will get a ready reply; > > happy learning; > > wish you all the best. > > Regards > > Kulbir. > > > > lalkitab@ s.com, " Manni " <manni7rehal@ ...> wrote: > > > > > > Dear > > > > > > All respected, > > > > > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > > > > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you > dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. > why is this? > > > > > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient > atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna > is determined by the sunrise? > > > > > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is > that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage > etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > > > > > What do you think? > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > MANNI > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 9, 2009 Report Share Posted December 9, 2009 Thats a great idea, Please lead us in the right direction.. Â Thanks RAHULSHARMA Jai Shri Ganesh Gajaananam bhoodha ghanaathi sevitham kabhitha jamboo palasara pakshitham umaasutham sokha vinaasakaranam namaami vigneswara paadha pankajam --- On Wed, 12/9/09, kulbir <kulbirbains wrote: kulbir <kulbirbains [lalkitab] Re: Learning topic suggestions lalkitab Wednesday, December 9, 2009, 1:41 AM Â Balakkrishnaji; Kiran ji; Rahul ji; i too want to learn in a systematic way and have some plans for it; we can form a group of those interested in the study right from beginning, here only; added benefit would be that since all seniors are members of this group; they can monitor or at least send in their inputs; guidance; experiences etc. from time to time. lets hear what Punit ji has to say; if he approves; we can start it shortly. Regards Kulbir. lalkitab@ s.com, Kiran Akbar <reiki.kiran@ ...> wrote: > > Dear seniors > I second that too! I am curious to learn about LK but dont know where to > start. Even though i can read in hindi i still prefer in english. Where do > beginners start? > thank you > kiran > 2009/12/9 hundraj_balakrishna <hbalakrishna@ ...> > > > > > > > > > sir, > > pranam to all gurujans, > > > > To help new commers start lal kitab ,migrate slowly from parasari system, I > > wish to suggest that a team or a few seniors should start a small guide to > > help new students to learn lal kitab and practce for the benefit of all man > > kind. > > > > With best wishes - H Balakrishna Mysore India > > > > lalkitab@ s.com <lalkitab%40gr oups.com> , " Manni " > > <manni7rehal@ > wrote: > > > > > > Dear > > > > > > All respected, > > > > > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > > > > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you > > dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. > > why is this? > > > > > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient > > atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna > > is determined by the sunrise? > > > > > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is > > that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage > > etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > > > > > What do you think? > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > MANNI > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 10, 2009 Report Share Posted December 10, 2009 Same here. Will be fantastic Sent from BlackBerry® on Airtel Rahul Sharma <toneyrahulsharma Wed, 9 Dec 2009 08:53:33 <lalkitab > Re: [lalkitab] Re: Learning topic suggestions Thats a great idea, Please lead us in the right direction..  Thanks RAHULSHARMA Jai Shri Ganesh Gajaananam bhoodha ghanaathi sevitham kabhitha jamboo palasara pakshitham umaasutham sokha vinaasakaranam namaami vigneswara paadha pankajam --- On Wed, 12/9/09, kulbir <kulbirbains wrote: kulbir <kulbirbains [lalkitab] Re: Learning topic suggestions lalkitab Wednesday, December 9, 2009, 1:41 AM  Balakkrishnaji; Kiran ji; Rahul ji; i too want to learn in a systematic way and have some plans for it; we can form a group of those interested in the study right from beginning, here only; added benefit would be that since all seniors are members of this group; they can monitor or at least send in their inputs; guidance; experiences etc. from time to time. lets hear what Punit ji has to say; if he approves; we can start it shortly. Regards Kulbir. lalkitab@ s.com, Kiran Akbar <reiki.kiran@ ...> wrote: > > Dear seniors > I second that too! I am curious to learn about LK but dont know where to > start. Even though i can read in hindi i still prefer in english. Where do > beginners start? > thank you > kiran > 2009/12/9 hundraj_balakrishna <hbalakrishna@ ...> > > > > > > > > > sir, > > pranam to all gurujans, > > > > To help new commers start lal kitab ,migrate slowly from parasari system, I > > wish to suggest that a team or a few seniors should start a small guide to > > help new students to learn lal kitab and practce for the benefit of all man > > kind. > > > > With best wishes - H Balakrishna Mysore India > > > > lalkitab@ s.com <lalkitab%40gr oups.com> , " Manni " > > <manni7rehal@ > wrote: > > > > > > Dear > > > > > > All respected, > > > > > > I started to read a book by Prof U.C Mahajan - LAL KItab In English. > > > > > > The question I have is that early in the book it states that in LK you > > dont really consider rashi, but the rashi have been mentioned quite a bit. > > why is this? > > > > > > Also it mentions that the first rashi is always aries, as the ancient > > atsrologer used to assign any rashi in the sirt house, but surly the lagna > > is determined by the sunrise? > > > > > > The suggestions I would like to make tour learned respected sir ji, is > > that can we not have small tutorials on say career, education, marriage > > etc.... for the benefit of people like me. > > > > > > What do you think? > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > MANNI > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.