directions amiguity?= exercise

[Guest guest]

Nirmal ji; we have 2 options

1. accept makkan kundali as such as varshphal; rashi no ke bolne

wale grah etc i.e. we don't know any logic or base which pt applied

to them, it has not been decoded in any manner. so unless and untill

someone comes with an explanation as to on what basis this kundali

was made by pt ji we cannot discard it just because we are not yet

to comprehend its logics; accept it as such as varshphal etc;

without adulteration of shashtri jyotish.

2. i think prabhakar ji's is right saunth ki dali milne par aadmi

jab pansari ban jata hai to sone ko bhi kasauti par parkhne se nahi

chookta bhale hi uske pass kasauti na ho aur use koi ose khud hi

apni banani pade.

3. enough is enough ; it is simple either explain all the logics of

this book or accept them as such

for a positive approach we can undertake an exercise by identifying

objects of planets khannawise from left to right as per makkan

kundali in our own homes.

kulbirbance

 

, " kulbirbance "

<kulbirbance wrote:

>

> although it apperas ambigious but is actually correct

> according to lalkitab KUNDALI KE KHANA NO. 1 SE CHALKAR AGAR

> NAUVAIN KO JAYAIN YA MAKAAN SE BAAHAR KO NIKALAIN TO JIS TARAF -

> DAYAAN (right) HAATH HOGAA- US TARAF MAKAAN KE TAMAAM GRAH JO

KHANA

> NO. 1 SE 8 TAK HO APNA SABOOT DENGEY, ISI TARAH AGAR 12 NO.

KHAANE

> SE APNE AAPKO KHANA NO. 9 KI TARAF AATEY HUVE GINE YA MAKAAN MAIN

> BAAHAR SE AAKAR DAAKHIL HONE LAGAIN TO KHANA NO. 12 SE 12, 11 10

KE

> GHARON KE GRAH --DAAYEN (right) TARAF MAKAAN KE --SABOOT DENGEY.

> at at the face of it appears ambigious because house no 12

> represents south east direction i.e. left direction in the house

of

> native having east facing house. also at another place shani 12 ki

> andheri kothari is reffered to be on the right side.

> BUT IF CAREFULLY READ THESE LINES IT IS CLEAR THAT LEFT AND RIGHT

> SIDES ARE REFERRED TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT AFTER MARKING A LINE

> BETWEEN THE OBSERVERS POSITION AND HOUSE NO. 9.

> UNLESS AND UNTILL HOUSE 9 POSITION IS NOT TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT WE

> CANNOT JUST DRAW A STRAIGHT LINE FROM THE HOUSE'S MAIN DOOR IN ANY

> DIRECTION AND MARK LEFT AND RIGHT SIDES.

> kulbirbance

>

[Guest guest]

Dear Kulbir ji,

You are right, We first learn the rules apply these rules and see the

results. logic will come side by side. I consider our self kids as

far as the core system of lalkitab is concerned.

we may try to first complete our command on rules of the system then

decide about logics

Regards

Nirmal Kumar Bhardwaj

,

" kulbirbance " <kulbirbance wrote:

>

> Nirmal ji; we have 2 options

> 1. accept makkan kundali as such as varshphal; rashi no ke bolne

> wale grah etc i.e. we don't know any logic or base which pt

applied

> to them, it has not been decoded in any manner. so unless and

untill

> someone comes with an explanation as to on what basis this kundali

> was made by pt ji we cannot discard it just because we are not yet

> to comprehend its logics; accept it as such as varshphal etc;

> without adulteration of shashtri jyotish.

> 2. i think prabhakar ji's is right saunth ki dali milne par aadmi

> jab pansari ban jata hai to sone ko bhi kasauti par parkhne se

nahi

> chookta bhale hi uske pass kasauti na ho aur use koi ose khud hi

> apni banani pade.

> 3. enough is enough ; it is simple either explain all the logics

of

> this book or accept them as such

> for a positive approach we can undertake an exercise by

identifying

> objects of planets khannawise from left to right as per makkan

> kundali in our own homes.

> kulbirbance

>

> , " kulbirbance "

> <kulbirbance@> wrote:

> >

> > although it apperas ambigious but is actually correct

> > according to lalkitab KUNDALI KE KHANA NO. 1 SE CHALKAR AGAR

> > NAUVAIN KO JAYAIN YA MAKAAN SE BAAHAR KO NIKALAIN TO JIS TARAF -

> > DAYAAN (right) HAATH HOGAA- US TARAF MAKAAN KE TAMAAM GRAH JO

> KHANA

> > NO. 1 SE 8 TAK HO APNA SABOOT DENGEY, ISI TARAH AGAR 12 NO.

> KHAANE

> > SE APNE AAPKO KHANA NO. 9 KI TARAF AATEY HUVE GINE YA MAKAAN

MAIN

> > BAAHAR SE AAKAR DAAKHIL HONE LAGAIN TO KHANA NO. 12 SE 12, 11

10

> KE

> > GHARON KE GRAH --DAAYEN (right) TARAF MAKAAN KE --SABOOT DENGEY.

> > at at the face of it appears ambigious because house no 12

> > represents south east direction i.e. left direction in the house

> of

> > native having east facing house. also at another place shani 12

ki

> > andheri kothari is reffered to be on the right side.

> > BUT IF CAREFULLY READ THESE LINES IT IS CLEAR THAT LEFT AND

RIGHT

> > SIDES ARE REFERRED TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT AFTER MARKING A LINE

> > BETWEEN THE OBSERVERS POSITION AND HOUSE NO. 9.

> > UNLESS AND UNTILL HOUSE 9 POSITION IS NOT TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT WE

> > CANNOT JUST DRAW A STRAIGHT LINE FROM THE HOUSE'S MAIN DOOR IN

ANY

> > DIRECTION AND MARK LEFT AND RIGHT SIDES.

> > kulbirbance

> >

>