Science of astrology

[Guest guest]

Dear Mark,

Thanks for your intelligent comments diverting the point of issue, which you

your-self referred as my words (as follows). (this point is pending since a

year)

>>>>>>> " FIRST YOUR WORDS....

 

" why don't you enlighten as to how astrological principles were

formulated. Only then it can be ascertained as to whether some

correction is required in the principles it-self or not and which

principle is correct in view of procedure adopted for fixing principles

(whether it may be by Ptolemy or by Indian sages).

 

Thus to move in this direction I put my simple direction as to how sign was

formulated and who (Babylonian, Greek astronomer or Indian sages etc.) find them

with predictive quality.

 

We can only analyze relevancy and correctness of astrology (predictive) if we

analyze it systematically instead of random support or oppose. " <<<<<<<<<<<

I find that as usual you have not replied the point raised but you have came out

with your views which you may like to infuse in the mind. I hope you will share

your views on my points.

Now my observation on your comments

>>>>>#1 THE VEDIC ASTROLOGY'S MAIN PERSPECTIVE IS THAT THESE 'TRUTHS' OF A VEDIC

OR CONSCIOUSNESS NATURE, COME NOT SO MUCH FROM ANALYSIS, OR EXPERIENCE EVEN, BUT

FROM

VEDIC SEERS WHO COGNIZED THE TRUTHS OF THE VED....<<<<<<

 

NO, Ved Vyas, who wrote Ved, has not referred even a single principle of

astrology (predictive), then how you can say that Vedic astrology is truth of

Ved.

 

>>>>BUT, WE ALSO LIVE IN A SCIENTIFIC AGE, WHICH I BELIEVE WAS CREATED, ALSO, BY

GOD, TO HELP US LEARN TO VALIDATE AND VERIFY THE TRUTHS OF LIFE...<<<<

Why God will help us (means astrologers) to earn by disclosing the fate decided

by the God. And how you can say that truth of life may be known by astrology.

 

>>>>>>FOR ME, PERSONALLY, THERE HAVE BEEN 2 WAYS IN WHICH I'VE FOUND THE TRUTHS

OF ASTROLOGY, FOR ME.

 

#1 THE DETAILS, THE RULES AND PRINCIPLES OF MY JYOTISH CHART, REALLY DO FIT M,

PERSONALLY, OR

SUBJECTIVELY, MUCH MORE ACCURATELY THAN THE WESTRN SYSTEM...<<<<<<<

I think you are not aware that many Indians find that Western system is correct

instead of socalled Vedic system. Some one may support Krishnamurty system,

Palmistry, terro card, Vaastu, Nadi etc. etc.. So how you can substantiate that

one system is correct. When another person is having some opposite views. It

means it is only personal psychology, by which you are attached to any one

system.

 

>>>>>>>>AND, THE EVERY DAY MOVEMENTS OF THE STARS, ALSO, CONFIRM THE JYOTISH

SYSTEM.

IN ADDITION TO STUDYING THE PRINCIPLES OF JYOTISH I'VE ALSO STUDIED THE TRANSITS

VERY DEEPLY.

I'VE EVEN BEEN LUCKY TO HAVE MADE A CHART OF EACH DAY FOR OVER 20 YEARS. AND IN

ALL THAT TIME,I'VE FOUND, TIME AND TIME AGAIN, THAT NATURE, HERSELF, IS

LITERALLY, FOLLOWING THE EXACT RULES AND PRINCIPLES OF JYOTISH. <<<<<<

 

Please intimate some principles, which in your opinion is being followed by

astrology. I think you may have collected so many principles during last 20

years.

 

>>>>>>>SO, WHAT WILL BE NEEDED IS EVEN MORE AND MORE CLOSELY SCRUTINY, TO VERIFY

AND VALIDATE THE 'TRUTHS' OF ASTROLOGY, IN THE FUTURE....

 

BUT EVEN MORE IMPORTANTLY, WHAT REALLY NEEDS TO HAPPEN, IS THAT ASTROLOGY NEEDS

TO BE CONNECTED EVEN MORE PROFOUNDLY, TO THE POWERFUL REMEDIES AND REMEDIAL

MEASURES, OF 'LIFE' AND THE REAL PURPOSE AND IMPORTANT RESULT, WILL BE THAT

INDIVIDUALS WILL BE HELPED OUT OF THEIR MISERIES...

SO, THE EMOTIONALLY CRIPPLED PERSON WHO HAS MANY EMOTIONAL PROBLEMS AND

WEAKNESSES, WILL ONLY BE HELPED, IF HE CAN BE TAUGHT LITERALLY, HOW TO IMPROVE

OR STRENGTHEN HIS MOON.

 

THE SATURN IMBALANCED PERSON WITH HEALTH PROBLEMS WILL ONLY BE TRULY HELPED IF

HE LEARNS HOW TO IMPROVE HIS SATURN, CREATING HEALTH, WHERE HIS TENDENCIES

PREVIOUSLY CREATED DIS-EAS AND DISEASE. <<<<<<<<

 

You mean to say that God wants us to find the truth of life through astrology so

that we (astrologer) may try to undermine the destiny of a person, where

miseries have been fixed by the God, with the help of socalled remedy.

 

I hope you will clarify above points alongwith my old querry.

 

Thanks

Yours truly,

Sanat

 

PS: Other members may also take part in this discussion.