Any chance of Tests - Nakshatras

[Guest guest]

Shri A. Sharmaji,

 

Jai Shri Ram!

 

<AKKji started this Hindu Calendar Reform movement and advocates a corrected

calendar and according to the rules of the Vedic period. How do we know that

AKKji's theories are correct and true and better and our current Hindu

Calendar is not? >

 

Right now you are discussing nakshatras vis-a-vis the Junction Stars

vis-a-vis the Vedic rituals. As such, pl. do not involve extraneous issues

to obfuscate the matter.

 

Instead of exercising your grey matter just for nit-picking, pl. go through

the correspondence of the Hinducalendar forum assiduously, if you want

really to prove or disprove something there. Obviously, you are still

unaware that I am asking suggestions from " learned " people like you as to

whether Junction Stars of various nakshatra divisions do really have

something to do with their namesake nakshatras or not? If yes, do we treat

the junction stars as the midpoint of that namesake nakshatra or its

starting point or ending point? Why should we do so? I have repeated it

umpteen number of times that about this issue I am still groping in the dark

myself!

 

The crux of the matter is that if the Junction Stars have nothing to do with

the namesake nakshatras, then who coined their names and why? In what way

are they then relevant to the Hindu ethos? For your " ready reference " , the

first time that we find any mention of Junctions Stars vis-a-vis namesake

naksahtras is the Surya Siddhanta of Maya the mlechha! Could it be that he

got the computations of those stars from Hipparchus or some other Greek or

any foreign astronomer and it was only as a ruse that he implanted those

Junction Stars in the Hindu psyche, just as he advised that all the useless,

baseless and fundamentally wrong arguments of his Surya Siddhanta were

" revealed " to him by none other than Surya Bhagwan in the fag end of last

Satya Yuga, which " event " is supposed to have taken place, as per the same

Maya the mleccha, at least 864,000 (Dwapara Yuga) plus 1,296,000 (Treta

Yuga) i.e., 2,160,000 years back!

 

Perhaps you must be aware that we have no evidence of human race, (hope Maya

the mleccha was a human being instead of a " divine " " personality, as is

claimed by " Vedic astrologers " ) going back to even a few hundred thousand

years, leave alone a couple of milli0n years!

 

In the Surya Siddhanta itself, there is a separate chapter “Bha-graha-yuti

adhikara” i.e. “Chapter of the conjunction of asterisms and planets”. In

fact, it is the same chapter that talks of the (Polar) longitudes and

latitudes of Junction Stars and the methodology of calculating timings of

conjunction of planets with those Junction Stars. By implication, even

that methodology was revealed to Maya the mlechha by Sury Bhagwan! Why was

topic of “conjunctions of asterisms and planets” included in that work when

there is already a separate definition of nakshatras, equal divisions,

starting from Ashvini-cum-Mesha, and ironically that Mesha rashis is so

called sayana as per the same Siddhanta!

 

So the discussion about nakshatras vis-à-vis Junction stars is wide open and

once you arrive at some conclusion, if at all you arrive at any, you may

test them in whatever way you want to.

 

< If everything Vedic is so correct and true, then why you Indian Hindus are

running away from Vedic heritage to England's English and America's Dollar

and now the European Union's Euro? Why should non-Indian Hindus blindly

believe what modern Hindus of India say in today's time? >

 

You are contradicting your own statements! It appears you are more confused

than anybody else! On the one hand you say, “If everything Vedic is so

correct and true, then why you Indian Hindus are running away from Vedic

heritage to England’s English and America’s Dollar and now the European

Union’s Euro” and then in the same breath, you are saying, “Why should

non-Indian Hindus blindly believe what modern Hindus of India say in today’s

time”?

 

How is all this haranguing relevant to the discussion at Hindu calendar

forum? In this forum, nobody is asking anybody to start celebrating any

festival or ritual that he/she is not already celebrating or to start

observing any muhurta that he/she is not already observing! All that this

forum is asking is that those who believe in celebrating festivals like

Maha Shivaratri or Navaratras or Dipavali or so called Makar Samkranti etc.,

or observing muhurtas like Dhanurmas, Kharamas, Pitra-paksha etc. must do so

as per the canons of those very works like the Vedanga Jyotisham, the

Bhagavata, the Vishnu-Purana, Shiva Purana etc. etc. which are supposed to

have prescribed those festivals or rituals or muhurtas etc.

 

The efforts of this forum are to also make the entire Hindu community

aware of the fact that we are being fleeced by “Vedic astrologers” in the

name of “moola-nakshatram dosha” etc. when there is no such curse in any of

the shastras!

 

Hope the cobwebs have got cleared now!

 

Jai Shri Ram!

 

A K Kaul

 

 

 

HinduCalendar , A Sharma <asharmanz wrote:

HinduCalendar] Re: Any chance of Tests - Nakshatras

 

 

AKKji, DLji, HMji, and Co.,

 

 

 

Vedic Rituals are material processes yielding material results.

 

 

 

Therefore, why can not they be tested for their efficacy. Just because we do

not know how to test them does not mean they can not be tested.

 

 

 

AKKji started this Hindu Calendar Reform movement and advocates a corrected

calendar and according to the rules of the Vedic period. How do we know that

AKKji's theories are correct and true and better and our current Hindu

Calendar is not?

 

 

 

If AKKji is correct, how is he going to prove to and convince the

non-believers?

 

 

 

Therefore, proper and truth-yielding tests are required to prove either way.

 

 

 

 

If everything Vedic is so correct and true, then why you Indian Hindus are

running away from Vedic heritage to England's English and America's Dollar

and now the European Union's Euro? Why should non-Indian Hindus blindly

believe what modern Hindus of India say in today's time?

 

 

 

Bhupendraji,

 

BTW, who " pooh poohed " Lord Krishna? I recall that a "

<HinduCalendar/post?postID=ZlbxnWFJKDyPY20HIaB

oxqY7KJKLtZmc9C2jscnhG9Y-CZC9F-ocLnX8bULqSDEMbN1Q3ZMMIU2C4WlQg4teKyc>

devisingh.rajput " wrote this:

" you have rights to make choice but no right to have fruit of your

choice...this krushna told to you......nothing deny of prediction.. .. " .

 

If you are referring to this then you are mistaken and are jumping to

conclusions.

 

 

 

Regards,

 

ASharma.

 

 

 

--- On Tue, 3/2/10, Bhupendra Jamnadas <

<HinduCalendar/post?postID=wjA95UkPBQUKZV05jh0

M8ANivFFgSxHzwflX5H5Vaw3zGjFXLBYBIeby5qrg50i2OC7wlvu8yMbs7PLGrg>

b_jamna> wrote:

What kind of replies am I reading in this group. Some days ago, someone was

equating prediction to mathematics and virtually pooh poohed Lord Krishna.

Now I read another member asking for testing of Rituals..

I am speechless. If people are not interested in subjects being discussed in

this group, why pariticipate or even be a member?

Bhupendra.

 

 

 

--- On Tue, 3/1/10, A Sharma <

<HinduCalendar/post?postID=lv5iCjcidKK8qVYtJDq

RrfNsEKIw14VKP9WAD-aOThRlLtcGtSI9OE83eQOZmADXqNuCFBHqf9JoENE1>

asharmanz wrote:

Then how about testing using the Vedic Rituals which use the Nakshatras?

ASharma.