Guest guest Posted September 7, 2007 Report Share Posted September 7, 2007 Shree Ganeshaya Namaha, Respected Members, I came across an article that says " 3rd-from-Budha is an inauspicious location for matters of mental health. Any planet in 3rd-from-Budha will cause distracted thinking, depressed thinking, compulsive thoughts, etc. according to the nature of that graha in 3rd-from- Budha. The strongest effect of this mental-drain phenomenon occurs during the mahadasha of Budha when the bhukti of the graha(s) which occupy 3rd-from-Budha comes onto the schedule. " I do not know the source but appears to be BPHS (as this article has most of the items referred from BPHS). Kindly comment on the veracity and modifications this rule might undergo under the impact of other factors. Personally I have experienced some effects of the above mentioned in my current Mahadasa of Mercury and antardasa of Rahu. Rahu is placed in Pi (lagna) and Mercury in 11th (cap). Look forward to your respected opinion/s. best regards Hanmant Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 7, 2007 Report Share Posted September 7, 2007 Aadaraniya Hemant Ji, OM Shri Gajaanana Namastuvyam. Can You please cite the reference of that article... Regarding your own instance it is like telling a doctor that you have pain in the left arm possibly because you played Throw Ball a little too much yesterday and probably one of your mussel has strained thereby effecting the entire body....Is not it?? So what has happened?? You actually has assumed the intelligent role of a doctor yourself...you are only seeking confirmation of your view from some doctor....this is what exactly is " self fulfilling Prophecy " ..OK..it happens with all of us as the Self (Ahama), the Supreme Locus Motor, functions like that... " Ahama " ...is the Supreme ..liberator and the Subjugator... OK enough of philosophy.. Now see, what the doctor will need ...he / she will quickly fill thirty forms because you have pain in the arm and after getting all investigative results..the doctor Will make a guess (mind you guess only) what is wrong with you.by that time you down by 200 dollars... In order to be assertive and predictive..one has to be very-very sure and demonstrate to the other guy that you are right and the other is wrong. If you say it is because of the third placement(???) of Mercury..then prove it... It happened with me once and I will never forget it,,when flying to USA..I got badly hurt on my Toes kind courtesy a sweet lady... by the time I reached the destination the foot was badly swollen..And I was going to USA for some intense physical acivity..rigour of the highest order ..and I had to prove my team and myself..so was damn demoralized.. I straight away went to a doctor...we was professional..and rightly asked me for fifty tests...I was flabergasted...damn it such a simple thing...but he said ..give me two hours and every thing will be over... Proudly he came back and said ...your three fingers are broken and three months of hospitalisation...I looked at him got up from the fine bed and started running...I was ahead ..he was after me..there was a lady doctor..she also stated running after me ...after about two miles of running I came back to my assigned bed. I asked the doctor if he really thought my three toes were broken...he she conducted the X-ray again and apologized that it was only stress fracture.... So either you present the case like that or Give all deatails... For example I may say since the Eleventh from the Ascendant causes Counter Argala on the First it may give bad results...so your theory has gone for a fut...daignostic has to be wide..still it could be questined...see how wide is the scope of VEDIC Astrology.... So give complete deatils...Indians are unnecessary secretive where they should not be...and unnecessary open where they should not be.....Aham...Aham...(Do you know these sounds come out of the throat)..Aham..Aham... Wishing you good times.. Om Vidhyutadhamaaa...namaste namo Namaha.... - In vedic astrology , " hmuttagi " <hmuttagi wrote: > > Shree Ganeshaya Namaha, > > Respected Members, > > I came across an article that says " 3rd-from-Budha is an inauspicious > location for matters of mental health. Any planet in 3rd-from- Budha > will cause distracted thinking, depressed thinking, compulsive > thoughts, etc. according to the nature of that graha in 3rd-from- > Budha. The strongest effect of this mental-drain phenomenon occurs > during the mahadasha of Budha when the bhukti of the graha(s) which > occupy 3rd-from-Budha comes onto the schedule. " > > I do not know the source but appears to be BPHS (as this article has > most of the items referred from BPHS). > > Kindly comment on the veracity and modifications this rule might > undergo under the impact of other factors. > > Personally I have experienced some effects of the above mentioned in > my current Mahadasa of Mercury and antardasa of Rahu. Rahu is placed > in Pi (lagna) and Mercury in 11th (cap). > > Look forward to your respected opinion/s. > > best regards > Hanmant > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 10, 2007 Report Share Posted September 10, 2007 Respected Member, The information can be checked on this link http://www.barbarapijan.com/bpa/Topics/Budha_Mercury.htm#graha% 20occupying%203rd-from-Budha My communication has been misintrepreted as confimration of the above. I would have liked some comments on how a graha in 3rd from mercury affect the mind (whether it aspects or not the moon or bhava for thinking). Leraned people may comment on the subject. regards Hanmant vedic astrology , " Shobhana " <bhadrakaali wrote: > > Aadaraniya Hemant Ji, > OM Shri Gajaanana Namastuvyam. > > Can You please cite the reference of that article... > Regarding your own instance it is like telling a doctor that you have > pain in the left arm possibly because you played Throw Ball a little > too much yesterday and probably one of your mussel has strained > thereby effecting the entire body....Is not it?? > > So what has happened?? You actually has assumed the intelligent role > of a doctor yourself...you are only seeking confirmation of your view > from some doctor....this is what exactly is " self fulfilling > Prophecy " ..OK..it happens with all of us as the Self (Ahama), the > Supreme Locus Motor, functions like that... " Ahama " ...is the > Supreme ..liberator and the Subjugator... > OK enough of philosophy.. > > Now see, what the doctor will need ...he / she will quickly fill > thirty forms because you have pain in the arm and after getting all > investigative results..the doctor Will make a guess (mind you guess > only) what is wrong with you.by that time you down by 200 dollars... > > In order to be assertive and predictive..one has to be very-very sure > and demonstrate to the other guy that you are right and the other is > wrong. If you say it is because of the third placement(???) of > Mercury..then prove it... > It happened with me once and I will never forget it,,when flying to > USA..I got badly hurt on my Toes kind courtesy a sweet lady... by the > time I reached the destination the foot was badly swollen..And I was > going to USA for some intense physical acivity..rigour of the highest > order ..and I had to prove my team and myself..so was damn > demoralized.. > > I straight away went to a doctor...we was professional..and rightly > asked me for fifty tests...I was flabergasted...damn it such a simple > thing...but he said ..give me two hours and every thing will be > over... > Proudly he came back and said ...your three fingers are broken and > three months of hospitalisation...I looked at him got up from the > fine bed and started running...I was ahead ..he was after me..there > was a lady doctor..she also stated running after me ...after about > two miles of running I came back to my assigned bed. > I asked the doctor if he really thought my three toes were > broken...he she conducted the X-ray again and apologized that it was > only stress fracture.... > > So either you present the case like that or Give all deatails... > For example I may say since the Eleventh from the Ascendant causes > Counter Argala on the First it may give bad results...so your theory > has gone for a fut...daignostic has to be wide..still it could be > questined...see how wide is the scope of VEDIC Astrology.... > > So give complete deatils...Indians are unnecessary secretive where > they should not be...and unnecessary open where they should not > be.....Aham...Aham...(Do you know these sounds come out of the > throat)..Aham..Aham... > Wishing you good times.. > > Om Vidhyutadhamaaa...namaste namo Namaha.... > > > > - In vedic astrology , " hmuttagi " <hmuttagi@> wrote: > > > > Shree Ganeshaya Namaha, > > > > Respected Members, > > > > I came across an article that says " 3rd-from-Budha is an > inauspicious > > location for matters of mental health. Any planet in 3rd-from- > Budha > > will cause distracted thinking, depressed thinking, compulsive > > thoughts, etc. according to the nature of that graha in 3rd-from- > > Budha. The strongest effect of this mental-drain phenomenon occurs > > during the mahadasha of Budha when the bhukti of the graha(s) which > > occupy 3rd-from-Budha comes onto the schedule. " > > > > I do not know the source but appears to be BPHS (as this article > has > > most of the items referred from BPHS). > > > > Kindly comment on the veracity and modifications this rule might > > undergo under the impact of other factors. > > > > Personally I have experienced some effects of the above mentioned > in > > my current Mahadasa of Mercury and antardasa of Rahu. Rahu is > placed > > in Pi (lagna) and Mercury in 11th (cap). > > > > Look forward to your respected opinion/s. > > > > best regards > > Hanmant > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 10, 2007 Report Share Posted September 10, 2007 Aadaraniya Harmant Jee, Namshkaar to you and Shri Ganesha. First of all my apologies for hurting your sentiments.... The basic rule of astro consultency is that You have to goad the astrologer into correct answer by providing as many detils as will help him in finding a solution..I do understand limitations of an open site web site. But after all it is you who need a correct solution..so help astrologer to help yourself. Secondly, thanks for providing the link. Any planet which is in the eleveth from the one under consideration will provide shubh / Asubha argala depending on other factors. It is well known that Mercury is a hollow but with tremendous power to increase the characterstics of the other planet it get associated with...that is why it is the biggest Maya. Now see if one planet has to offer bad result during its period and Mercury is is in eleveth from it increase the effects of that planets as it is in the eleveth.. So what you said and what the web site essentially is saying what has been simply told by Jaimini. However, the reference is showing it in a slighty negetive way and I personally do not feel so..as Mercury will offer its own results too during its atardassa and multitudes of other factors will have to be seen... Please provide basic data... There are some error also in the article, as Mercury does go in the third or eleven of the Sun...Yes, not beyong that in D-1. However, one may find it any where in Divisional charts. I was actually looking for some other principle which is not there on that page. Regards Om Ganeshaya Namaha.. vedic astrology , " hmuttagi " <hmuttagi wrote: > > Respected Member, > > The information can be checked on this link > http://www.barbarapijan.com/bpa/Topics/Budha_Mercury.htm#graha% > 20occupying%203rd-from-Budha > > My communication has been misintrepreted as confimration of the > above. I would have liked some comments on how a graha in 3rd from > mercury affect the mind (whether it aspects or not the moon or bhava > for thinking). > > Leraned people may comment on the subject. > > regards > Hanmant > > > > > vedic astrology , " Shobhana " <bhadrakaali@> > wrote: > > > > Aadaraniya Hemant Ji, > > OM Shri Gajaanana Namastuvyam. > > > > Can You please cite the reference of that article... > > Regarding your own instance it is like telling a doctor that you > have > > pain in the left arm possibly because you played Throw Ball a > little > > too much yesterday and probably one of your mussel has strained > > thereby effecting the entire body....Is not it?? > > > > So what has happened?? You actually has assumed the intelligent > role > > of a doctor yourself...you are only seeking confirmation of your > view > > from some doctor....this is what exactly is " self fulfilling > > Prophecy " ..OK..it happens with all of us as the Self (Ahama), the > > Supreme Locus Motor, functions like that... " Ahama " ...is the > > Supreme ..liberator and the Subjugator... > > OK enough of philosophy.. > > > > Now see, what the doctor will need ...he / she will quickly fill > > thirty forms because you have pain in the arm and after getting all > > investigative results..the doctor Will make a guess (mind you guess > > only) what is wrong with you.by that time you down by 200 dollars... > > > > In order to be assertive and predictive..one has to be very-very > sure > > and demonstrate to the other guy that you are right and the other > is > > wrong. If you say it is because of the third placement(???) of > > Mercury..then prove it... > > It happened with me once and I will never forget it,,when flying to > > USA..I got badly hurt on my Toes kind courtesy a sweet lady... by > the > > time I reached the destination the foot was badly swollen..And I > was > > going to USA for some intense physical acivity..rigour of the > highest > > order ..and I had to prove my team and myself..so was damn > > demoralized.. > > > > I straight away went to a doctor...we was professional..and rightly > > asked me for fifty tests...I was flabergasted...damn it such a > simple > > thing...but he said ..give me two hours and every thing will be > > over... > > Proudly he came back and said ...your three fingers are broken and > > three months of hospitalisation...I looked at him got up from the > > fine bed and started running...I was ahead ..he was after me..there > > was a lady doctor..she also stated running after me ...after about > > two miles of running I came back to my assigned bed. > > I asked the doctor if he really thought my three toes were > > broken...he she conducted the X-ray again and apologized that it > was > > only stress fracture.... > > > > So either you present the case like that or Give all deatails... > > For example I may say since the Eleventh from the Ascendant causes > > Counter Argala on the First it may give bad results...so your > theory > > has gone for a fut...daignostic has to be wide..still it could be > > questined...see how wide is the scope of VEDIC Astrology.... > > > > So give complete deatils...Indians are unnecessary secretive where > > they should not be...and unnecessary open where they should not > > be.....Aham...Aham...(Do you know these sounds come out of the > > throat)..Aham..Aham... > > Wishing you good times.. > > > > Om Vidhyutadhamaaa...namaste namo Namaha.... > > > > > > > > - In vedic astrology , " hmuttagi " <hmuttagi@> wrote: > > > > > > Shree Ganeshaya Namaha, > > > > > > Respected Members, > > > > > > I came across an article that says " 3rd-from-Budha is an > > inauspicious > > > location for matters of mental health. Any planet in 3rd-from- > > Budha > > > will cause distracted thinking, depressed thinking, compulsive > > > thoughts, etc. according to the nature of that graha in 3rd- from- > > > Budha. The strongest effect of this mental-drain phenomenon > occurs > > > during the mahadasha of Budha when the bhukti of the graha(s) > which > > > occupy 3rd-from-Budha comes onto the schedule. " > > > > > > I do not know the source but appears to be BPHS (as this article > > has > > > most of the items referred from BPHS). > > > > > > Kindly comment on the veracity and modifications this rule might > > > undergo under the impact of other factors. > > > > > > Personally I have experienced some effects of the above mentioned > > in > > > my current Mahadasa of Mercury and antardasa of Rahu. Rahu is > > placed > > > in Pi (lagna) and Mercury in 11th (cap). > > > > > > Look forward to your respected opinion/s. > > > > > > best regards > > > Hanmant > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.